Network Design Project

Standardized Rubric for Network Design Project

Criteria Levels of Achievement Content Components

70% Advanced Proficient Developing Not present

Network diagram 18 to 20 points

Network diagram completed with all minimum list of components included – including specialty topic.

17 points

Report contains 1-2 major inaccuracies or omissions of the network diagram.

1 to 16 points

Report contains 3 or more major inaccuracies or omissions of the network diagram.

0 points

Missing the network diagram.

Mitigation measures for

security threats in steps

4 and 6

32 to 35 points

Report includes 1 or more paragraphs on each of the five (5) security threats in step 4 and 3 or more paragraphs for the specialty threats in step 6. Includes both their description and how they pose a security threat.

29 to 31 points

Report includes 1 or more paragraphs on only 3-4 security threats, 2 paragraphs on special threats - including both their description and how they pose a security threat.

1 to 28 points

Report includes 1 or more paragraphs on only 1-2 security threats, 1 or more paragraphs on special threats. Report is missing either the threat description or how they pose a security threat.

0 points

Report is missing all threats/ vulnerabilities for steps 4 and 6- as well as their descriptions and security threats.

How network

components / host

measures address

security concerns from

steps 4 and 6

28 to 30 points

• Report includes a discussion of 5 or more network components or host measures and how they address each of the security threats/ vulnerabilities in step 4

• Report includes 3 or more paragraphs describing the security controls addressing the security threats of the chosen specialty in step 6.

25 to 27 points

• Report includes a discussion of 3-4 network components or host measures and how they address the security threats/ vulnerabilities in step 4.

• Report includes 2 paragraphs describing the security controls addressing the security threats of the chosen specialty in step 6.

1 to 24 points

• Report includes a discussion of 1- 2 network components or host measures and how they address the security threats/ vulnerabilities.

• Report includes 1 paragraph describing the security controls addressing the security threats of the chosen specialty.

0 points

• Report is missing a discussion on network or host-based components and how they address the security threats/ vulnerabilities.

• Report is missing a discussion of security controls addressing the security threats of the chosen specialty.

Additional measures to

address security

concerns

18 to 20 points

Report includes a discussion of 1 or more additional security measures that are procedural/ governance related in 2 or more paragraphs. Includes biblical integration supported by scripture.

17 points

Report contains 1-2 inaccuracies or omissions in a discussion of additional security measures. More than one but less than two paragraphs in length.

1 to 16 points

Report contains 3 or more inaccuracies or omissions in a discussion of additional security measures. Only 1 paragraph in length or not completely procedural or governance in nature. Does not include biblical integration supported by scripture.

0 points

Report is missing a discussion of additional security measures that are procedural or governance in nature.

Structural Components

30%

APA format with good

spelling and grammar

18 to 20 points

Proper spelling and grammar are used throughout. Report adheres to current APA format in organization and use of references.

17 points Between 1-2 spelling and grammar errors or minor APA format issues are present.

1 to 16 points Between 3-4 spelling and grammar errors or significant APA formatting issues are present.

0 points

More than 4 spelling and grammar errors or significant APA formatting issues are present.

Report adheres to

minimum number of

pages and references.

23 to 25 points

Report contains ten (10) or more pages of content, title page, and a list of ten (10) or more references beyond the course textbook and Bible.

21 to 22 points Report contains 8-9 pages of content, including a title page and at least of 6-9 references.

1 to 20 points Report contains 5-7 pages of content, including a title page and at least of 3- 5 references.

0 points

Report contains less than 5 pages in total, as well as misses a title page, and does not list any references.