IT project
9
Unemployment Insurance Tax Modernization
Initiation Date: July 2016 End Date: September 2017
NASCIO Award Category Digital Government: Government to Business State of Illinois
Tom Revane, Chief Information Officer Department of Employment Security [email protected]
1
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Illinois Department of Employment Security (IDES) collects the largest volume of business tax in the State of Illinois:
Unemployment Insurance (UI) Tax. Annually IDES has over 2.4 million “touches” with their taxpaying customers—
employers and third‐party payroll service providers—related to UI wage reporting and payment processing. Yet, the
applications IDES used to administer UI Tax were, in some cases, over 25 years old, costly to maintain, not easy to adapt
to changing statutes and regulations, and were a challenge for customers to navigate. Internally, agency staff had to
interact with multiple applications to administer the UI Tax program and support their customers’ needs. Externally,
customers had limited electronic self‐service options. IDES had entire business processes built around paper and
outdated technology. Change was needed on all levels to improve customer service and the overall customer
experience. IDES needed to move to a 21st century platform.
When exploring solutions, IDES realized the Illinois Department of Revenue (IDOR) already had an application, GenTax,
and the customer facing e‐Services portal, MyTax Illinois, that could achieve IDES's goals while maintaining their
separate legislative and fiduciary responsibilities. Illinois was also embarking on a statewide digital transformation,
which included centralizing IT services and personnel into one agency—Illinois Department of Innovation and
Technology (DoIT)—and encouraging multi‐agency initiatives, an enterprise approach to technology, and improving
efficiencies across state government. This transformation made it possible for IDES, IDOR, and DoIT to launch a unique
collaboration to modernize the UI Tax program into a proven, state‐of‐the‐art application. This modernization project
significantly reduced IDES' costs, risks and timeline to realize results when compared to other options, such as a stand‐
alone implementation or custom development project.
The 14‐month UI Tax modernization project completed on schedule and on budget in September 2017. GenTax and
MyTax Illinois significantly improved IDES' ability to process incoming reports and payments and improve their level of
customer support. Over 50 percent of previous paper filers are now filing electronically. IDES achieved an estimated
savings of over $800,000 annually through the elimination of paper‐based processes and reduced IT support costs.
Customers have one‐stop access to register for and administer all their State of Illinois taxes and numerous new self‐
service features in MyTax Illinois.
Due to this transformative project, the State of Illinois is positioned to enjoy multiple benefits of the IDES and IDOR
partnership, a few of which include:
Consolidated and shared services, including mail and print operations and IT maintenance, which allows both agencies to have reduced operational overhead.
Created a foundation for future modernization and growth opportunities. Services and features created for tax administration by one agency can be easily adapted for the needs of the other agency. For example, IDOR launched a Statewide Tax Lien Registry using GenTax and MyTax Illinois which will save the department $700,000 annually in fees and labor. Pending legislative approval, IDES will join the lien registry for similar benefits.
Increased collections, customer compliance, and fraud prevention efforts. IDES collected over $1 million in new revenues in less than six months with the implementation of the Treasury Offset Program (TOP). IDOR has years of experience in advanced fraud detection and analytics that will assist IDES in their program development.
2
CONCEPT
Adding UI Tax to MyTax Illinois and GenTax was vital to IDES business operations. This project replaced five legacy
applications—three of which were mainframe technologies, some over 25 years old—which were failing and unable to
support current UI Tax administrative processes and state and federal law. These legacy applications were used to
administer UI Tax for over 300,000 businesses in the State of Illinois.
For a number of years, IDES was unable to invest in improving the legacy UI Tax applications and could only perform
minimum maintenance. Resources were occupied in upgrading IDES’ UI Benefits application to provide better customer
experiences and improved staff efficiencies. IDES is still making further investments into the UI Benefits application.
Due to the degrading infrastructure of the UI Tax applications and lack of resources to support them, customers’
experience with the agency suffered.
In 2014, IDES the State of Illinois underwent executive change and the administration made upgrading the technology
that supports UI Tax, one of the agency’s critical business operations, a top priority. IDES began researching options and
started exploring a partnership with IDOR. Through this partnership, IDES leveraged a clause in an existing contract
IDOR had with a vendor—FAST Enterprises, LLC (FAST)—to implement FAST’s UI Tax module into GenTax, a commercial
off‐the‐shelf integrated tax processing software package. IDOR has been using GenTax to administer over 100 taxes and
fees since 2007. This innovative and collaborative approach simplified procurement and brought significant cost savings
to IDES and the State of Illinois. IDES estimates that project costs may have doubled or more if they purchased a stand‐
alone application or embarked on a custom development project. In July 2016, the 14‐month project to implement UI
Tax into GenTax started. This project included a unique collaboration between three state agencies—IDES, IDOR, and
DoIT—and the vendor, FAST. In addition to implementing UI Tax, the project upgraded the existing GenTax installation
at IDOR from version 9 of the software to version 10, the most current version of the software on the market at the
time. By January 2017, IDOR was using GenTax version 10. UI Tax launched in September 2017 in GenTax and MyTax
Illinois—Illinois’ centralized website using the GenTax e‐Services functionality where taxpayers can register with IDOR
and IDES, electronically file tax returns, make payments, and manage their tax accounts. This 14‐month, fixed price
project was completed on schedule and on budget.
The successful execution of the project required close collaboration between IDES, IDOR, DoIT, and the vendor, FAST.
Two teams were created to accommodate the 200+ mile geographic split between Chicago, IL—home of IDES—and
Springfield, IL—home of IDOR. The Chicago team included personnel from IDES, DoIT, and FAST and the Springfield
team included personnel from IDOR, DoIT, and FAST. Clear separation of responsibilities and regular communication
between the teams were critical components to the project’s success. The Springfield Team executed the version 10
GenTax software upgrade, hardware upgrades to the application and database servers, testing of IDOR business
processes, and training of IDOR users. The Chicago Team executed the configuration of UI Tax into the GenTax software,
external communications, testing of IDES business processes, and training of IDES users. IDES and IDOR also partnered
in an extensive data conversion and cleanup effort to merge IDES business demographic data from legacy applications
into GenTax. This effort included review and correction of over 27,000 federal employer identification numbers (FEINs).
To stay connected, the teams frequently engaged in conference calls, video conferencing, webinars, and face‐to‐face
meetings.
A key component of the project’s success was use of an iterative implementation methodology. Using iterative cycles,
project developers involved business users early and often, received feedback, made corrections, and improved the
delivered results. Within only a few weeks, IDES business users were “playing” with a functioning UI Tax application.
3
This approach to software delivery allowed the business to see early and frequent progress from project developers. It
also enabled business users on the project to interact with their emerging application daily and quickly become experts.
The UI Tax modernization project affected internal agency users and external users. To inform and prepare all
stakeholders for the launch of UI Tax in GenTax (internal users) and MyTax Illinois (external users), communication plans
were prepared for both.
Internally, agency staff attended regular “Open House” meetings where project subject matter experts (SMEs)—agency
personnel assigned full‐time to the project—gave demonstrations of application functionality, reviewed business
process changes, and answered questions. SMEs also delivered weekly “take home” briefings to their business units and
management to share regular project updates, decisions, process impacts, and milestones. The project contributed
regular posts to the IDES intranet and leveraged email blasts to share focused messages to agency staff. During the
build up to the application’s Go Live, the project issued bi‐monthly project newsletters with article contributions from
SMEs and IDES’s director. These communications reached over 1,000 agency users spread across over 50 locations
throughout Illinois.
At time of launch, the project team provided “deskside” support services to the agency users. Deskside support was
provided by roaming application experts—a broad network of SMEs, IT staff, and trainers developed throughout the
course of the project—located on‐site with agency users who were dedicated to answering questions and assisting
agency staff. A dedicated “Hotline” support telephone number was established for users to have a support staff
dispatched directly to their location.
Externally, a campaign of “early and often” communication was deployed to notify agency customers of the coming
application changes and agency services. Notices were placed onto the legacy e‐Filing application alerting customers to
the coming changes. These notices were regularly updated with each tax filing and payment due date, so customers
would receive fresh, up‐to‐date information. IDES leveraged several existing mailings and issued several project specific
mailings to include project information—such as the MyTax Illinois Go Live date, instructions on how to transition to
MyTax Illinois, and notices of upcoming process and service changes. IDES conducted a usability study with customers
to receive and apply feedback to ensure MyTax Illinois was customer friendly. IDES also engaged in a word‐of‐mouth
campaign by attending business association chapter meetings, conferences, and fairs to share information with the
business community. This plan ensured customers received information through multiple channels. At Go Live, over
200,000 businesses successfully transitioned from the legacy e‐Filing application into MyTax Illinois. IDES experienced
no decline in e‐Service customer compliance. Rather, e‐Service compliance significantly increased by over 13 percent
within the first quarter. Over 50 percent of customers who were filing by paper in the legacy applications changed to
filing electronically in MyTax Illinois.
SIGNIFICANCE
The UI Tax modernization project brought together three State of Illinois agencies and FAST, for the common goal of
improving the interaction between the State of Illinois and all Illinois businesses. The significance of a project this size
can be measured both in terms of immediate impact and long‐term sustainability.
Once implemented, customers were immediately able to access MyTax Illinois to efficiently and securely exchange
information with IDES. Customers now have one‐stop registration process and access for all State of Illinois taxes in one
application. Correspondence can now be viewed online and customers have other new self‐service options such as
requesting a refund, viewing annual rates, maintaining a power of attorney relationship, and updating the customer’s
4
account information. This project changed IDES’ business model from only providing basic support to providing true
customer self‐sufficiency.
GenTax and MyTax Illinois use best‐practice security designs to protect customer data. Personally identifiable
information (PII) for employees, such as social security numbers (SSNs), is masked when viewed in MyTax Illinois. These
applications transmit data using encrypted communication protocols and network identification security. Additionally,
IDES implemented a “clean desk” policy and eliminated unnecessary use of paper with PII. For example, in the legacy
applications, IDES mailed preprinted paper wage report packets to customers with unmasked SSNs for all their
employees. The UI Tax modernization project eliminated this mailing.
Legacy applications consistently stored old, outdated, or incorrect information. As part of this project, invalid customer
accounts were identified and never transferred into GenTax. Over 27,000 customer UI Tax accounts with missing or
mismatched FEINs were cleansed before conversion into GenTax. Merging IDES and IDOR data proved extremely
beneficial, especially in data cross‐match programs with other state and federal agencies, such as the Internal Revenue
Service (IRS).
The project created a healthy working relationship between the three agencies based on open dialogue, a common goal, and a structured decision‐making process. The relationship and common technology platform created many functional synergies and significant efficiencies including:
One application that processes all tax returns and payments for both agencies. DoIT staff use the same technical skill set and technology platform to support both IDES and IDOR business
operations.
IDES now uses IDOR’s central print and mail operations for faster, less costly correspondence delivery. Better management of application service pack and version upgrades ensures both agencies have access to new
software features.
Ongoing discussions for future opportunities related to shared tax collections, improved cross agency fraud detection and prevention efforts, and IDES joining the Statewide Tax Lien Registry.
Reduced IT related support costs through shared resources and datacenter.
The size and far reaching effects of this project, positively changed the culture of IDES. The notion of “have to do” was
replaced with an attitude of “can do” and “let’s do it better.” Cultural changes may not always be quantifiable, but they
do set the stage for long‐term success. Even now, eight months after implementation, staff from IDOR, IDES, and DoIT
are continuing to reengineer business processes, apply software enhancements, and innovate more e‐Service options
for customers. This new attitude and approach is all based on the ideas, passion, and energy generated from this
project.
Additionally, IDES Hotline staff's ability to support customer questions and concerns has significantly improved.
Previously, Hotline staff had to access multiple legacy applications to understand and address a customer’s situation.
Now, all the customer’s information is contained within GenTax. GenTax also offers staff the ability to view the
customer’s screen in tandem which addresses the age‐old comment from a customer “I’m not sure what I just did.”
5
IMPACT
GenTax and MyTax Illinois have been in production for UI Tax processing since September 2017. New MyTax Illinois
features have improved the overall customer experience by making more content available online and by providing
automated options that simplified previous paper‐based processes.
IDES Benefits IDES is expecting to see savings of over $800,000 annually.
o IDES immediately reduced annual printing and mailing expenses by over $400,000 related to the elimination of the paper wage report packets that were mailed quarterly. Customers can easily file their
wage reports online through MyTax Illinois.
o Reductions of approximately $250,000 annually are expected related to the significant decrease of several manually intensive paper‐based processes. Over 50,000 customers transitioned from filing
paper wage reports to filing online through MyTax Illinois. This represents a 50 percent reduction in the
amount of paper wage reports from 400,000 a year to 200,000 a year. The processing of paper checks
decreased by 60 percent from 525,000 a year to 200,000 a year. This has been offset by an increase in
electronic payment processing through MyTax Illinois.
o Annual savings of over $160,000 are expected from the replacement of the legacy applications. IDES is now participating in the Treasury Offset Program (TOP). TOP is a federal offset program that disburses
federal payments, such as federal tax refunds, to creditor agencies like IDES who are owed monies by delinquent
taxpayers. In less than six months, TOP notice mailings and actual TOP offsets resulted in over $1 million in
collections.
IDES staff have been trained and now have access to the latest software platform replacing multiple legacy applications that were over 25 years old. Workflow processes were re‐engineered to improve staff processing
efficiency.
Customer Benefits The expanded suite of e‐Service options in MyTax Illinois further reduced the number of paper forms submitted
to IDES for manual processing and empowered customers to complete more transactions online.
o Customers can now manage all State of Illinois taxes through one website, MyTax Illinois. Previously, customers had to navigate separate applications for each state agency.
o New Illinois businesses can now register in one location through MyTax Illinois for both IDOR and IDES. Previously, a new business had to work with each agency separately.
o 50,000 customers stopped using paper and now submit their quarterly wage reports and make their payments online through MyTax Illinois reducing the customer’s workload and improving the accuracy
of their reporting.
Customers can now see their correspondence online. Every letter sent to customers was reviewed and either eliminated or rewritten to follow plain language guidelines. IDES had over 300 pieces of correspondence and
consolidated it down to only 115. Agency business, printing, and mailing processes were modernized to
improve the timeliness for generating and mailing correspondence. For example, customers used to receive
their first bill anywhere from 6 to 18 months after payment was originally due. With the new processes,
customers receive their first bill within 45 days.
Other modernized and expanded e‐Services options were offered to customers. MyTax Illinois enabled IDES to offer dozens of self‐service features to administer UI Tax such as one‐stop registration, electronic notifications
and access to e‐Correspondence, filing and paying of UI Tax, request refunds, request extensions, State
6
Information Data Exchange System (SIDES) registration, power of attorney maintenance, and access to up‐to‐
date tax rates and account balances.
MyTax Illinois can be displayed using ADA‐compliant features incorporated into the latest versions of major web browsers.
The UI Tax modernization project produced significant results. In addition to the annual expense savings, IDES changed
its core business model and culture. The effect was immediate. The improved interactions with customers was
substantial. Previously, using the legacy applications, IDES provided only basic levels of support to customers. Entire
business processes were built around outdated technology. It was inefficient and expensive for all involved.
Adding UI Tax to MyTax Illinois created an environment of true self‐sufficiency for customers. Customers now interact
with both IDOR and IDES through one easy‐to‐use application. A customer can register their business, file their wage
reports, pay their taxes, receive and review all correspondence, and interact with both agencies all online. This project
is a significant service delivery accomplishment involving multiple highly matrixed governmental agencies. With the
project’s completion, the State of Illinois has vastly improved the Government to Business working relationship.