Clinical Practice Question and Literature Review

Presentation and Content

44-40 Points

43-30 Points

29-0 Points

Score

Includes all required elements:

· Introduction to Clinical Question

· Identification of theoretical framework and/or model

· Type of Study You Will Conduct (Evidence-Based or Quality Improvement) & Notable Characteristics of the Study Type

· Type of Research Design (Qualitative, Quantitative, Mixed-Methods) & Notable Characteristics of the Design

· Independent & Dependent Variables, & Outcome Measures

· Project Idea, Population & Setting

· Possible Sampling Methods

*Appropriate explanation of the bullet points is included in the VoiceOver power point. Adheres to the 20-minute limit voice presentation.

Errors noted in the information about the theoretical framework, research design, study type, some required elements and explanations are missing.

Missing many of the required elements for the presentation; information presented is incorrect. Does not adhere to the 20-minute voice presentation time limit.

Discussion Board Question

32-30 Points

29-24 Points

23-0 Points

Score

Poses two thoughtful questions about the presentation in the discussion board upon posting of the power point presentation; responds to peers within 24-48 hours and throughout the week. Responses demonstrate understanding of advanced theoretical and research foundations content.

Poses question 1 day late; Responses to peers are after 48 hours and incomplete

Question posed on discussion board lacks depth; delayed response to peers greater than 72 hours; inaccurate information provided to peers

Points

/75

Points

4

Points

3

Points

2

Points

1

Points

0

Score

Critical Thinking/Synthesis

Thoughtfully and accurately interprets results, shows in-depth under-standing of major ideas

Identifies relevant arguments, justifies results, offers reasons

Usually justifies results and offers reasons

Misinterprets data, gives unjustified arguments

Not present

Quality of Information

Covers topic thoroughly, includes details that support the topic in audio/video presentation

Includes essential information, includes some supporting details

Includes most essential information, details are somewhat sketchy

Lacks essential information

Not present

Organization

Well organized and coherent, topics are in logical sequence, includes clear introduction and conclusions

Organized, some topics are out of logical order, conclusions are generally clear

Some organization, topics jump around, conclusions are unclear

Not organized, topics make no sense

Not present

Grammar, Spelling and Visual Design

All grammar and spelling are correct; Slides are visually appealing, clean simple layout, text is limited to main bullet points & easy to read, graphics enhance under-standing of ideas; good use of color and space

One or two errors; Visually attractive, text is easy to read, colors enhance readability, graphics and special effects do not distract from under-standing

One or two errors; Text wordy & is sometimes hard to read, sometimes graphics or special effects distract from under-standing

Very frequent grammar and/or spelling errors; Text is very wordy & very difficult to read, layout is cluttered and confusing

Not present

Oral Presentation

Well prepared, speaks clearly, makes eye contact with audience, as appropriate if on video, delivers with ease, audio/speech is understandable; details bullet/main points

Engages audience, fluid delivery, uses different approach other than simply reading screen,

Clear and understandable, uses limited delivery techniques

Not clear, not understand-able

Not present

APA/

References

APA format, grammar, spelling, and/or punctuation are accurate, or with zero errors. Information is referenced as appropriate on slides

APA format, grammar, spelling, and/or punctuation are accurate, or with one to two errors.

Three errors in APA format, grammar, spelling, and syntax noted.

Four or greater errors in APA format, grammar, spelling, and/or punctuation.

Not present

Points

/24

TOTAL SCORE AND COMMENTS: /100