marketing communication
Lecture Week 5 Creative Strategy
© Rustic Look Pencils by Anderson Mancini
UTS 24736 Marketing Communications
SPRING 2019
Subject Coordinator: Dr. Valeria Noguti
1
Early Feedback Survey
Thank you all who sent feedback!
Generally good, most people are happy with the subject
On the improvements:
Couple of comments on being similar to buyer behavior
Second class was to set the concepts we need to discuss marcomms
Format with 1hr workshops
Workshops being spent working in groups
Too fast/feeling unclear: we will spend more time discussing (addresses point above too)
Any other feedback? Please send at any time or come for a chat!
2
Copyright © UTS
2
Subject Structure
MC Strategy
Integrated MC and Budgeting
Creative Strategy
Media Strategy
Evaluation and Metrics
Introduction to MC
MC Industry
Buyers
#1: Advertising, sponsorship
#2: Direct marketing, personal selling, sale promotion, field and experiential marketing, placement, exhibitions, packaging, licensing
#3: Digital, PR
3
Copyright © UTS
Foundations
Managing Marketing Communications
Marketing Communications Mix
Advertising Creativity
The ability to generate fresh, unique, and appropriate ideas that can be used as solutions to communications problems
Determining what the advertising message will say or communicate
Creative
Strategy
Creative
Tactics
Determining how the message strategy will be executed
Copyright © UTS
4
Marcomms Campaigns
Set of interrelated and coordinated marketing communications activities that center on a single theme or idea
Appear in different media across a specified time period
Campaign theme
Central message communicated in all the advertising and promotional activities
Expressed through a slogan or tagline
Slogan
Summation line that briefly expresses the company or brand’s positioning and the message it is trying to deliver to the target audience
Copyright © UTS
Successful, Long-Running Campaigns
Nike Just do it
Qantas The Spirit of Australia
Avis We try harder
Yellow Pages Let your fingers do the walking
L’Oréal Because I am worth it
Carlton United Made from beer
Twisties Life’s pretty straight without Twisties
Company or Brand
Campaign Theme
Copyright © UTS
Creative Brief Outline
Basic problem or issue the advertising must address
Advertising and communications objectives
Target audience
Major selling idea or key benefits/thoughts to communicate
Relevant brand values and suggested tone of voice
Supporting information and requirements
Copyright © UTS
7
Example of Creative Brief: This Girl Can (Sport England)
Basic problem: to get more women from the age of 14-40 regularly active and into sport and to keep them playing
Communication objective: to liberate women from the judgements that hold them back.
Target audience: women aged 14-40 who are currently inactive. They know that they should be exercising and say they want to do more, but aren't. We know that there are many barriers stopping women from exercising, but underlying them all is a single, unifying barrier: a fear of judgement. Women worry about being judged on their appearance, during and after exercise; on their ability, whether they are a beginner or 'too good'; or for spending time exercising instead of prioritising their children or studying.
Key thoughts: it doesn't matter how you do it; the brilliant thing is that you are doing it.
Relevant brand values and suggested tone of voice: empowering, inclusive & authentic with a 'don't give a damn' attitude
(Baskin & Waters WARC 2017)
8
Copyright © UTS
Appeals and Execution Style
Communication Appeals
The approach used to attract the attention of consumers and/or to influence consumer feelings toward the product, service or cause
E.g., rational vs emotional
Execution Style
The way a particular appeal is turned into a communications message
The way the message is presented to the consumer
E.g., specifically what will be said, what images will be included, etc
Copyright © UTS
Rational Appeals
Focus on the consumer’s practical, functional, or utilitarian need for the product or service
Emphasise:
Features of a product or service and/or the benefits
Reasons for owning or using a particular brand
Copyright © UTS
Emotional Appeals
Relate to the customers’ social and psychological needs for purchasing a product or service
Create favourable effect on consumers’ evaluations of a brand
Personal states or feelings: achievement/accomplishment, actualisation, affection, ambition, arousal/stimulation, comfort, excitement, fear, happiness, joy, love, nostalgia, pleasure, pride, safety, security, self-esteem, sentiment, sorrow/grief
Social-based feelings: acceptance, approval, affiliation/belonging, embarrassment, involvement, recognition, rejection, respect, status
Copyright © UTS
Executional techniques: Rational/Information-based appeals
Factual
Feature appeals: Focus on the dominant traits of the product
Favourable price appeals: Makes price offer the dominant point
News appeals: News or announcement about the product
Product/service popularity appeals: Stresses the brand’s popularity
Slice of life
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4tf0-WV8TBs
Demonstration
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_fvk2cbnlJY
Comparative advertising, e.g., Clorox vs Lysol
12
Copyright © UTS
Executional techniques: Emotions/feelings-based appeals
Fear
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=2&v=6vlFFIVxpFM
Humour
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=1&v=fHH3QfBSs7I
Shock (deliberately offends the audience)
Sex (good for ad, not so much for brands in unrelated categories)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W93AiQkgZa4
Music: great to connect emotionally, works as a cue resulting in several memory, perceptual, and attitudinal effects, works in conditioning, etc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BYLD6kXHjgk
Fantasy and surrealism
13
Copyright © UTS
Shock ad example
14
Copyright © UTS
Fantasy and Surrealism example
15
Risk of rejection
Socially disconcerting
“what’s going on here?” leads to high involvement processing
Copyright © UTS
When to use rational vs emotional appeals?
16
Copyright © UTS
For Message Tactics: Informational Motives and Emotions
Copyright © UTS
For Message Tactics: Transformational Motives and Emotions
Copyright © UTS
Example: Is the ad appealing to an emotional state?
Barbara Bank Manager Ad
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vC58URpEqn4
19
Copyright © UTS
Example: Is the ad appealing to an emotional state?
20
Copyright © UTS
Advertising/message Tactics: High involvement
Informational Motives Transformational Motives
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VohEkWMkbsI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Td3OJGfRYv4
https://www.ispot.tv/ad/w3oT/amica-mutual-insurance-company-let-the-block-find-you
Copyright © UTS
High involvement tactics: examples
Transformational overstating benefits, plus additional information
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nXQgcOhzal8
22
Informational; effective when initial positive or neutral brand attitude
Copyright © UTS
Advertising/message Tactics: Low involvement
Informational Motives Transformational Motives
Example: Clorox Ads prior to 2016
Example: Clorox Ads after 2016
Copyright © UTS
Exercise
Ad1: Coke Energy
Ad2: Coke Taste the Feeling – “Friends”
Ad3: ANZ Barbara
Ad4: TipTop bread
Ad5: Wells Fargo bank https://www.ispot.tv/ad/dVfX/wells-fargo-earning-back-your-trust-song-by-black-keys
Where do they sit on the grid (don’t forget to look at message tactics)?
24
| Informational Motives | Transformational Motives | |
| Low Involvement | ||
| High Involvement |
Copyright © UTS
Using the above tactics
Pre-creative strategy
Use grid to set parameters in the creative brief
Be careful not to stifle creativity
Post-creative strategy
Use specific creative tactics within the classification to screen the resulting communications
This is a disciplined way to check creative tactics
25
Copyright © UTS
Elements of Storytelling
Stories are used to frame understanding, to encourage individuals to want to be part of the story, and to identify with the characters. Stories consist of a theme and a plot. The most common ones are:
https://www.campaignlive.co.uk/article/arla-skyr-the-messenger-wieden-kennedy-london/1344352
Copyright © UTS
Is the creative execution consistent with the brand's marketing and advertising objectives?
Is the creative execution consistent with the creative strategy and objectives? Does it communicate what it is supposed to?
Is the creative execution appropriate for the target audience?
Does the creative execution communicate a clear and convincing message to the customer?
Does the creative execution overwhelm the message?
Is the creative execution appropriate for the media environment in which it is likely to be seen?
Is the advertisement truthful and tasteful?
Criteria for Evaluating Creative Executions
Copyright © UTS
Completing Assignment #1
Read the whole brief again to make sure you are not missing anything
Check report contains all elements specified in assignment brief
A good format is to be more descriptive in each heading and include the positive/negatives in a final section (or long paragraph), with your judgement about the campaign (how successful it is and why), together with suggestion of one thing that you would change and why
Check how you would score on the marking criteria:
Check body word count =< 800 words
Submit online
Bring hard copy to hand-in in class
28
Copyright © UTS
Subject Structure
MC Strategy
Integrated MC and Budgeting
Creative Strategy
Media Strategy
Evaluation and Metrics
Introduction to MC
MC Industry
Buyers
#1: Advertising, sponsorship
#2: Direct marketing, personal selling, sale promotion, field and experiential marketing, placement, exhibitions, packaging, licensing
#3: Digital, PR
29
Copyright © UTS
Foundations
Managing Marketing Communications
Marketing Communications Mix
Wrapping up
Creative Strategy discussed
Next week: * Media Planning and Strategy
* Assignment # 1 due
* GUEST: KATRINA ALVAREZ-JARRATT
(CREATIVE DIRECTOR AT TBWA)
30
Copyright © UTS
Conviction (50%) Quality of the argument: strong, sensible, deep, focused, conclusive
Completeness (40%) How well the topic/issue is covered; both positive and negative aspects are covered; supported by reliable sources/material
Presentation (10%) How well the paper is presented; written-expression; proper referencing
Conviction (50%)
Quality of the argument: strong,
sensible, deep, focused, conclusive
Completeness (40%) How well the topic/issue is covered;
both positive and negative aspects are
covered; supported by reliable
sources/material
Presentation (10%) How well the paper is presented;
written-expression; proper referencing
|
Conviction (50%) |
Quality of the argument: strong, sensible, deep, focused, conclusive |
|
Completeness (40%) |
How well the topic/issue is covered; both positive and negative aspects are covered; supported by reliable sources/material |
|
Presentation (10%) |
How well the paper is presented; written-expression; proper referencing |