URGENT : CHANGE MANAGEMENT - NEED COMPLETED IN 10 HOURS - OFFERING HIGH
Interviewer Respondant Interviewer Respondant Interviewer Respondant Interviewer Respondant Interviewer Respondant
Hi my name is Jessica Sam, a student from Curtin University, and I would like to conduct an interview with you for an assignment I am doing that relates to change in the organisation. Will you allow me to ask you a few questions? Yes of course. That’s great. The purpose of this interview is to allow me to analyse, interpret and evaluate the appropriateness and effectiveness of a change process in an organisation, particularly yours, with the theories I have learnt in my unit. So to start off, please tell me about your work and your position. So I am a casual worker in Myer Perth in the Ladies Footwear Department and I have been working there since 2014. Tell me about the situation in our workplace that involved or required some form of change. Okay, so recently there has been a shake-up which is called “New Myer”, it’s a scheme that affects all levels of the company including management shake-up, admin relocation, changed services for customers and staff. Why did this situation come about? Um, My guess is the economy. Myer is not doing so well as well as a lot of Australian fashion industries at the moment, there’s pressure on stockholders to make more money and in that process they have made some changes that I think did not have enough risk evaluation and therefore has occurred a few problems. What was the change all about? So, they came up with a scheme “New Myer” and this would affect their advertising, the way staff works and the way managers relay that to their staff. It started with incorporating Myer Academy where staff was meant to login to learn about trends and fashion, this kind of thing, it was all about chaining the service for our customers so they have a better connection to our store and loyalty therefore creating more beneficial sales. Um, changes included the admin in all stores, apart from myer city, were dissolved and now managers have to do a lot of admin work therefore taking
managers off the floor. In my department I hardly see my manager which is causing me to think why do we have one [giggles], therefore it makes a bit of miscommunication in tasks. Also, all stores were routed out to an overseas call centre, this was meant to cut costs but has left with a sour reaction from customers as it can take up to 25 minutes to be connected to an area and then due to the language barrier could be connected to the wrong area therefore causing more strife. We were also told we cannot call other stores, we had to just give them the number and let them deal with it, this can cause a bit of tension. I can see it working when we are busy and don't have time but as all of these factors are meant to increase customer loyalty and satisfaction some changes that they made did not see the foresight in losing customers due to this risky change. With these ongoing changes with the “New Myer” they updated systems in my department. We all are allocated an iPad and are responsible in logging into our shoe finder app, a new system where we search for shoes and send them to a runner at the back who deliver them, this was meant to create more faces on the floor for better customer experience and faster service. We do have, well ⅔ of our team is made of permanent part timers in a mature age bracket, so when this rolled around we had a bit of technical difficulties because they weren't as duck-to-water as the younger generation with the technology, so there was a bit of a learning curve there, mostly through it now but it's been about six months. The ipads also are monitored creating a bit of stress for staff members from managers when we don't use them correctly or when they die [battery life] or incorrect stock on the system, there's just another barrier we have to go through now. The entire Myer network is now using an app called Kronos for all time card facilities so we can clockin, clockout, see our hours, update our unavailability. This is good and bad, but this does leave our managers off the floor and in the admin for longer periods of times for changes and schedules. I've had a few problems in the fact that I have updated my unavailability a month in advance and I have seen first hand in the office when they are allocating availability it doesn't show them our preset availability which means they have rostered us on when we cannot do it and we have given them ample time to let them know we can't do it. They have deleted the paper system which was, I think, was a more sustainable communication of hours, it has created tension in the workforce because I have said I am unavailable for a date weeks and weeks in advance and then when I see I have been rostered on I have to tell her [manager] and she almost blames me “oh, why can't you work” kind of thing, but when you look at their screen when they're scheduling it, it does not tell them, that it does not show the blocked out dates and they have to click quite a few buttons to get to the unavailability page. So I think that the navigation of the system needs quite a bit of updating
Interviewer Respondant Interviewer Respondant Interviewer Respondant
which will only come from our feedback of the app which I hope in a few months time things will be smoother and better for the company, Why was it necessary to deal with the change situation? Um, it was necessary because it was from the change of command. Obviously starting from the top to satisfying stockholders and then to our CEO and then down to our regional managers trying to push this “New Myer” agenda. So the particular managers in our stores had a short amount of time to change the attitude of staff and to portray this “New Myer”. We learnt as we went, tried to change our ways, but also had to deal with the repercussions. We have to deal with it because we serve thousands of people a day and if we don't change our ways we get stressed from either end, management and customers, therefore creating a tense working environment. Um, it was necessary to change with the ways to keep our jobs, to keep relevant and yeah. How did you or the others deal with the change? And what did you do? I reevaluated the importance of my job there and the fact that I needed to accept these new changes even though there was little direction, I do think they shouldve have a few store meetings to explain these things, I kind of came to my own outcomes of what was all happening, I think they lacked a bit of communication there so to deal with it I just had to soldier on and know that hopefully they did have bigger plans for us and I was loyal to the team so as long as I put effort into it it would made my working life easier there. I also had to change and deal with it so customer experience was better - the happier the customer, the happier we are. And also the happier the customer is the happier we are so if we are mopey about these changes we are not going to make any sales and therefore will threaten our jobs so we just have to deal with it. Did the others deal with the change the same way you did or? Some people were resistant. There were a lot of behind the scenes kind of chatter and bitchiness and a lot of uncomfortable staff workers knowing that these changes were coming and we were kind of felt a little bit not respected because we have been working there for a long time and things were changing and we didn't really have that respect between managers and staff. So there was a lot of complaining behind the scenes. Some people have left due to it, some people have retired but it is creating a bit of stress around
Interviewer Interviewer Respondant
staff. What changed as a result of your actions? Overall, once we went with the flow with this “New Myer” we kind of agreed to team leaders and managing staff and just tried to help them. Once I realised that it wasn't coming from them and they weren't just being, you know, angry at us for nothing, kind of had an easier time, I kind of realised that all of these changes were coming from higher up and they had the pressure on them, so by just agreeing to it and being more accepting of it, our relationship became easy to work with and everyone just got along abit better. Also learning these new systems, customer experience has become good and bad, on the floor it is faster, but I’m not sure if its better. I am constantly serving many people at once and I kind of lose that personal experience with them unless it's very quiet. The phone issue is a way to work fast but it's also lessening our customer loyalty. Ipads helping us become faster, but again it brings issues with technical difficulties. Result of my actions I have become a better problem solver, I can deal with more things under pressure, I think it's just I've been able to grow with the company and know that I can move on from there with quite a few life lessons. In your view, was the action you have taken successful? And what makes you say so? I think the actions that I have taken will be successful soon, we are still getting used to this “New Myer” so it will take time. Overall, the new actions taken by senior staff were originally not good, there was a lot of confusion, a lot of he said she said, no one really knew what we were doing. I think they went about it the wrong way. They cut hours, we were understaffed, we had sadder staff on the floor because they were complaining about the lack of hours the lack of money, so that resulted in not the best customer relations which then affected their sales, so I feel like they should've changed something else than what they did or at least made the communication better when these changes were happening so we had more team unity instead of division between the hierarchies. Overall, i think it will be a good change after a while, because we will just get used to it but I think the overall change could have been brought out smoother with more conversations about what was happening and why.