Transportation and Distribution Final Assignment

Criteria Unacceptable Minimally Responsive Satisfactory Exemplary Points

Incorporation of

Feedback [Used for

Milestone Assignments]

Little to no attempt was

made to improve upon the

assignment based on prior

feedback.

The incorporation of feedback is

provided, with minor changes made

based on the feedback from previous

milestones, more extensive changes

are expected based on the feedback.

This reflects major misconceptions

and/or incomplete understanding of

the assignment and topic.

The incorporation of feedback is

accurate and generally complete,

though minor portions may be

missing OR the attempt to integrate

the feedback from previous

milestones did not effectively

enhance the current milestone,

overall from the original draft. More

details and clarity of concepts are

needed to effectively enhance the

Final Project.

The incorporation of feedback is

accurate and complete, with feedback

effectively integrated from previous

milestones. The revisions have

enhanced the Final Project.

Score 0 17 21 25 25

Description and

Relevancy of the role

that logistics providers

play with regard to

transportation planning

and execution strategies

for your chosen

product/industry.

A description of the role that

logistics providers play with

regard to transportation

planning and execution

strategies for your chosen

product/industry is not

identified nor described.

A description of the role that

logistics providers play with regard

to transportation planning and

execution strategies for your chosen

product/industry is identified, but

not described appropriately, with

major details missing and evidence

of misconceptions.

The description of the role that

logistics providers play with regard

to transportation planning and

execution strategies for your chosen

product/industry is relevant, and is

described appropriately, though

minor details are missing.

The description of the role that

logistics providers play with regard to

transportation planning and execution

strategies for your chosen

product/industry is relevant, and is

described appropriately and in detail.

Score 0 17 21 25 25

Interpretation and

Analysis of how reverse

logistics impacts

operations within the

supply chain system for

your chosen product.

Interpretations of how

reverse logistics impacts

operations within the supply

chain system for your chosen

product are barely presented,

if at all.

Interpretations of how reverse

logistics impacts operations within

the supply chain system for your

chosen product, and reflect major

misconceptions and/or incomplete

understanding.

Interpretations of how reverse

logistics impacts operations within

the supply chain system for your

chosen product are complete.

Justifications are accurate and

appropriate, identifying sections as

evidence and discussing them, with

some important details missing.

Interpretations of how impact reverse

logistics impacts operations within the

supply chain system for your chosen

product are complete. Justifications

are thorough and accurate, identifying

clearly specific sections as evidence

and discussing them with detail.

Score 0 17 21 25 25

SBT_BUS381_M8A1_FINAL_PROJECT_RUBRIC

Use of Sources as

Evidence

The resources, if any, are not

credible.

Resources are noted in the

bibliography, but are not relevant to

the topic at hand. They may be used

as sources of evidence to support

claims, but are used forcibly, and not

appropriately.

Including additional sources or

information about the sources may

have strengthened the support of

certain claims.

The selected resources noted in the

bibliography are credible and have

relevance with the topic at hand,

and are used as sources of evidence

to support claims made. Some of

these connections, however, may be

a little far-fetched.

Including additional sources or

information about sources may have

strengthened the support of certain

claims.

The selected resources noted in the

bibliography are credible, and have

clear relevance with the topic at hand,

and are used as sources of evidence to

support claims made.

A sufficient number of sources were

used to make strong arguments

for/against claims.

Score 0 7 12 15 15

Writing Quality/APA

Style

Frequent problems with

organization, clarity and/or

conventions make the paper

hard to read. APA style

guidelines are not adhered

to, which increases the risk of

plagiarism.

Numerous mechanical errors are

distracting; and organization of ideas

are lacking, but not enough to

interfere with meaning. APA style

guidelines are attempted, with major

errors.

There are few problems with

organization, clarity or conventions

that should have been fixed. APA

style guidelines are followed, with

only minor errors. Problems and

errors are not serious enough to

distract the reader.

The writing skillfully communicates the

message(s) and the language flows

seamlessly throughout; there are

minimal problems with spelling,

punctuation, and grammar; APA style

guidelines are followed accurately.

Score 0 6 8 10 10

Total Points 100