A short form need to fill in 24h
ENG 106 Literature Review Synthesis Matrix
Complete an analysis of each article you plan to use in your literature review. Write relevant information associated with the author(s) and theme in each area. This matrix will help you organize your lit review paper.
Topic: Exploring the Economics of Mass Incarceration
Research question(s): What contributes to the flawed economic nature of the American Justice System?
Take your topic and break it into main ideas or themes. Then, look for information relevant to each theme. Not every box will be filled in. You need to align the themes to the author/source.
|
Author (s), title/year/source |
Theme 1 - Inefficient Spending |
Theme 2 – Low-Risk Offender Alternatives |
Theme 3 - Collateral Damage (Incarcerated Communities) |
|
1. Ferner, New Report Details Devastating Effects Of Mass Incarceration On The U.S. / 2016/ Huffington Post |
The U.S. spends $80 billion on incarceration each year and over $270 billion on the entire criminal justice system at the federal, state and local levels.
United States employs 2.5 times more corrections officers per capita than other nations, but employs 30 percent fewer police officers per capita |
incarcerating more people likely entails jailing offenders who are on average lower-risk, meaning their incarceration will yield even fewer benefits to the public. |
indirect costs to the prisoners themselves, their families and their communities, all collateral damages that can last for generations.
There are roughly 70 million adult Americans — nearly a third of the entire adult population — with some kind of a criminal record can keep ex-offenders from finding a job, not to mention one that is decent, safe and well-paying. |
|
2. Katel, Downsizing Prisons / 2011 / CQ Researcher |
Budget crises are forcing states to re-examine the cost of maintaining their prison and jail systems |
states have been putting too many low-risk offenders in prison. They contend that expanding alternatives to incarceration would reduce prison costs and lower crime rates. |
Diversion also enables offenders to make victim-restitution payments and meet their family responsibilities. “If you want victims to be restored, and to ensure that child-support payments are made, people should be out in the community working, rather than incapacitated” |
|
3. BANKING ON BONDAGE: PRIVATE PRISONS AND MASS INCARCERATION / ACLU |
While the nation's unprecedented rate of imprisonment deprives individuals of freedom, wrests loved ones from their families, and drains the resources of governments, communities, and taxpayers, the private prison industry reaps lucrative rewards |
|
|
|
4. CEA, Economic Perspectives on Incarceration and the Criminal Justice System / 2016/ The White House |
The direct government costs of the criminal justice system are significant
Given the total costs, some criminal justice policies, including increased incarceration, fail a cost-benefit test
|
|
The probability that a family is in poverty increases by nearly 40 percent while a father is incarcerated
Parental incarceration is a strong risk factor for a number of adverse outcomes
Having a criminal record makes it more difficult to find employment |
|
5. Furman and Holtz-Eakin, Why Mass Incarceration Doesn’t Pay / 2016/ NYT |
a general rule in economics — the law of diminishing marginal benefits — applies to incarcerating additional people or adding years to sentences
Finally, more than $80 billion is spent annually on corrections, or over $600 per household
the criminal justice system should be designed to ensure that the benefits of incarceration exceed the costs |
Individuals incarcerated for nonviolent drug crimes — 50 percent of the federal prison population — pose a low risk, and the costs of incarcerating these people outweigh the benefits
There are other tools that can reduce crime more cost-effectively, including promoting employment and wage growth and investing in education |
Time in prison not only means a loss of freedom, but it also means a loss of earnings, risks to the health and safety of the incarcerated, and prolonged absences from family that can strain marriages and increase behavioral problems in children |
|
6. Clear, T. R. (2009). Imprisoning Communities: how mass incarceration makes disadvantaged neighborhoods worse. |
|
|
Imprisonment “raids supplies of local human capital and leaves a gap in employable residents, thus depleting neighborhood economic strength”
Prior to incarceration, most prisoners are an economic resource to their neighborhoods and immediate families |
|
7. Gottschalk, M. (2010). Cell blocks & red ink: mass incarceration, the great recession & penal reform. Daedalus, 139(3), 62-73. |
the country’s extraordinary incarceration rate is “unsustainable economically.”
Dozens of states cut their corrections budgets in 2009, and many proposed closing penal facilities to cover gaping budget gaps |
has begun to investigate alternatives to incarceration, and last October, Congress ordered the Commission to review mandatory minimum sentencing
imprisonment rate tends to rise with the unemployment rate |
Prisons provide few economic benefits to local communities, notably the rural areas that have been the primary sites for new prison construction since the 1980s |
|
8. CBS News, The cost of a nation of incarceration / 2012 |
In a bad economy, just the expense of incarceration is beginning to create converts among state legislators faced with disastrous budget problems |
State of Florida is building a so-called re-entry center for 400 non-violent inmates.
Here they'll cost taxpayers HALF what the state would spend on keeping them in prison. |
In communities of color, you see devastating consequences as a result of our policies. Now, one out of three black men between the ages of 18 and 35 is in jail, in prison, on probation or on parole |
Notes:
· Targets minority neighborhoods removes big part of the workforce thereby stunts economic growth
· Prison system paid for by taxpayers ; private prisons benefit from mass incarceration
· Rehabilitation vs. maintaining a population which makes more economic sense?
· Petty crimes and being able to afford bail
· Costs of mass incarceration
· Collateral damages (costs to prisoners, their families, and their communities)
· putting too many low-risk offenders in prison
· expanding alternatives to incarceration would reduce prison costs and lower crime rates
· financial and social cost and impact it has on our nation
· diverting nonviolent offenders from prison into alternatives such as drug courts, which allow offenders to remain free and work and live under tight supervision while getting treatment
· given the total costs, some criminal justice policies, including increased incarceration, fail a cost-benefit test.