Question
Literature Search Chart – Quantitative or Qualitative Research Studies
(may also use for Mixed Methods or Outcomes Studies)
Also attach article as PDF to assignment
|
Reference |
1 pt 1 pt |
Reference listed in correct APA format PDF of article uploaded to Canvas assignment |
|
|
Type of Research
|
1 pt |
Accurately identify whether quantitative (non-experimental), quantitative (experimental) or qualitative |
Quantitative: Non-experimental Quantitative - Experimental Qualitative |
|
Design/ Method
|
2 pts
1 pt
1 pt |
· Describe method (e.g., longitudinal, cohort, pre-test/post-test, retrospective chart review, interview, focus group) · Describe whether researcher had comparison groups and how they differed · Describe time frame (e.g. baseline data, follow-up at x months) |
· |
|
Sample & Setting
|
1 pt 1 pt 1 pt 1 pt |
· Population studied: demographic variables · Inclusion criteria · How sample is chosen · Setting of study |
· |
|
Major Variables & Measurements
|
2 pts
2 pts |
· Describe the variables studied ( quantitative) or the general content of questions ( qualitative) · For each variable, list the specific survey/tool/measurement ( quantitative) or how are data collected and analyzed ( qualitative) |
· |
|
Findings
|
1 pt 4 pts |
· In your own words · Describe the key findings of the study, specifically detailing results, such as % of subjects who experienced a certain result; discuss whether results were statistically significant ( quantitative) or describe/define the major themes of the study including details about what the themes mean and any sub-themes ( qualitative) |
· |
|
Appraisal: Applicability to PICOT |
2 pts |
· Describe how and to what extent this study contributes to answering your PICOT question – such as – Does it have a similar population? Does it answer your question? Does it support or not support your intervention? |
· |
|
Appraisal: Study Rigor |
1 pt
1 pt
1 pt |
· Discuss issues related to validity or reliability, including study design, researcher bias, subject selection, etc. · State whether you believe the study was sufficient to answer the researcher’s questions in terms of: Design, number of subjects, variables, etc. ( quantitative) or Your determination of whether the analysis of data and themes was sufficient and whether it aligned with philosophy for this type of study ( qualitative) · Why did you state the study was sufficient or not sufficient? |
· |