price theory
Price Theory
Lecture 6: Production & Costs
Topics for today’s lecture . . .
1. Production functions
2. Multiple-input production functions
3. Cost minimisation
4. The total cost curve
Production functions
Production as a process of transformation
Factor markets Production technology Product markets
The Firm
Inputs
Labour
Capital
Raw materials
Intermediate goods
Services
Outputs
Goods
Services
Definition: Production technology
The process by which inputs (factors of production), are transformed by a firm into goods
and services.
A firm’s production function describes the maximum quantity of a good or service that can be
produced by a firm, from a given bundle of inputs, given the firm’s production technology.
Production functions
We will typically assume that the inputs into the production process are labour (L) and
capital (K ).
• Labour represents the productive effort of the workers hired by the firm.
• Capital represents the assets used in, but not consumed by, the production process.
We exclude all other inputs from the production function because we only require two inputs
to understand the nature of the trade-offs faced by firms.
The maximum quantity of a good or service that can be produced by a given bundle of inputs
is written Q = f (L,K ).
A production function with one input
00
2
16
3
27
Q = 6L2 − L3
Q
0 L
Consider the production function
Q = 6L2 − L3, in which the only input is labour.
• This is a production function in which the firm’s capital stock is fixed.
If Q represents the number of cars the
firm can service per day then:
• L = 2 workers can service Q = 16 cars.
• L = 3 workers can service Q = 27 cars.
Technical efficiency
00 Technically
efficient
Technically
inefficient
Q = 6L2 − L3
Q
0 L
The production function illustrates the
maximum quantity of output that can be
produced.
If the firm is producing at a point on its
production function we say that it is
technically efficient.
If the firm is producing inside its
production function we say that it is
technically inefficient.
Exercise: Inputs & production
00
25
5
Q
0 L
Using the production function illustrated
in the figure, answer the following
questions:
1. Suppose that this firm hires 5 workers.
If the firm services 25 cars per day, is
it technically efficient? Briefly explain.
2. Would this firm be willing to hire 5
workers? Briefly explain.
Exercise solutions
00
25
5
Q
0 L
1. Using 5 workers to service 25 cars per
day is technically efficient.
The point lies on the production
function, and therefore Q = 25 is the
maximum possible output when L = 5.
2. No. The same level of production can
be achieved with fewer workers (and
therefore lower cost).
Definition: Marginal product
The rate at which total output changes as the usage of an input rises, holding constant the
usage of all other inputs.
The marginal product of an input is the partial derivative (slope) of the production function,
with respect to the input in question.
The marginal product of labour
00
2 3
Q = 6L2 − L3
Q
L
MPL = 12L− 3L2
MPL
0 L
For a single input production function, the
marginal product of labour is written,
MPL = dQ
dL .
Note: You will always be provided with
marginal products in this course.
• When 2 workers are employed, the marginal product (slope) is 12.
• When 3 workers are employed, the marginal product (slope) is 9.
Increasing marginal returns
00
Q
Q
L
MPL
MPL
0 L
Increasing
This example has a number of features
common to many production functions:
• If no labour is employed (L = 0), nothing can be produced (Q = 0).
• Initially, as additional workers are employed, output rises at an
increasing rate.
Increasing marginal returns occur at low
levels of labour usage, as more workers
allows greater specialisation.
Definition: Law of diminishing marginal returns
The principle that as the usage of one input increases, past some point the marginal product
of that input will decrease.
Diminishing marginal returns
00
Diminishing
total returns
Q
Q
L
MPL
MPL
0 L
Increasing Diminishing
Diminishing marginal returns set in once
the gains to specialisation have been
exhausted.
• As workers are added to a fixed capital stock, they begin to get in one
and other’s way, creating congestion.
• With many workers, coordinating their activities also becomes more difficult.
In extreme cases, the production function
may reach a region where there are
diminishing total returns to labour.
Quiz 1
Gregory owns and runs a cafe. When Gregory employs a third staff member he notices that
the cafe is able to serve 100 additional customers each day. When he employs a fourth staff
member the cafe is able to serve a further 80 additional customers each day. From the
information provided, we can conclude that Gregory’s cafe is experiencing,
(a) increasing marginal returns to labour, and increasing total returns.
(b) increasing marginal returns to labour, and decreasing total returns.
(c) decreasing marginal returns to labour, and increasing total returns.
(d) decreasing marginal returns to labour, and decreasing total returns.
Multiple-input production functions
A production function with labour & capital
3
3 L
Q
0
K
The single-input production function is
drawn for a given quantity of capital.
Varying the firm’s capital stock also
affects the quantity of output that can be
produced.
The marginal product of labour is the
slope (partial derivative) of the production
function in the direction of an increase in
labour,
MPL = ∂Q
∂L .
Marginal product of capital
3
3 L
Q
0
K
The marginal product of capital is the
slope (partial derivative) of the production
function in the direction of an increase in
capital,
MPK = ∂Q
∂K .
Past some point, capital experiences
diminishing marginal returns.
In extreme cases the marginal product of
capital may become negative.
Discussion: The marginal product of capital
Consider a firm that services cars. How might we explain the following phenomena? (In each
of the following, the number of mechanics employed by the firm is held fixed.)
• Increasing marginal product of capital, when a firm’s capital stock is relatively low.
• Diminishing marginal returns to capital.
• Diminishing total returns to capital, when a firm’s capital stock is relatively high.
Definition: Isoquant
A curve that shows all combinations of labour and capital that can produce a given level of
output.
Using isoquants we can illustrate the shape of the production function in the input-space.
Isoquants
Q = 5
Q = 16
Q = 27
L
Q
0
K
Isoquants are the contour lines of the
production function; the set of all points
at the same height.
Higher isoquants correspond to larger
quantities of output.
Isoquants illustrate the tradeoff between
labour and capital in the production
function.
Isoquants in labour-capital space
00
53
1
Q = 27
Q = 16
Q = 5 K
0 L
Isoquants illustrate production possibilities
on the space of inputs.
Notice that these isoquants are backward
bending.
This occurs if there is a point beyond
which there are diminishing total returns
to labour.
The economic region of production
00
53
1
Q = 27
Q = 16
Q = 5 K
0 L
economic
region
uneconomic
region
A profit maximising firm never wants to
waste inputs.
This firm will not employ 5 workers if it
can produce the same output with 3.
The economic region is the region in
which isoquants are downward sloping.
A firm will not produce in the uneconomic
region, as the same output can be
produced with fewer inputs in the
economic region.
Definition: Marginal rate of technical substitution
The rate at which a firm can substitute labour for capital, while maintaining a constant level
of output.
The marginal rate of technical substitution of labour for capital (written MRTSL,K ) is the
negative of the slope of an isoquant.
Marginal rate of technical substitution
00
Q = 100
K
0 L
The marginal rate of technical
substitution can be written as the ratio of
marginal products,
MRTSL,K = MPL MPK
.
An isoquant displays a diminishing
marginal rate of technical substitution if it
becomes flatter as we move down along
the curve.
Diminishing MRTSL,K implies that
substituting labour for capital becomes
progressively less effective.
Quiz 2
Winston’s Widgets has the production function Q = 200LK . The associated marginal
products are MPL = 200K and MPK = 200L. For this production function the marginal
returns to labour are,
(a) diminishing.
(b) constant.
(c) increasing.
(d) not possible to assess with the information provided.
Quiz 3
Winston’s Widgets has the production function Q = 200LK . The associated marginal
products are MPL = 200K and MPK = 200L. For this production function, the marginal rate
of technical substitution is,
(a) diminishing.
(b) constant.
(c) increasing.
(d) not possible to assess with the information provided.
Cost minimisation
A firm’s cost minimisation problem
Winston’s Widgets has the production function Q = 200LK . The associated marginal
products are MPL = 200K and MPK = 200L.
Suppose that the wage (the price of labour) is w = $180 per day, and that the rental price of
capital is r = $240 per day.
What is the lowest cost at which Winston’s Widgets can produce Q = 2400 widgets per day?
The cost of a bundle of inputs
00
1 12
8
Q = 2400
K
0 L
A
The bundle A, with LA = 8 workers and
KA = 1.5 units of capital, lies on the
required isoquant as,
200LAKA = 200× 8× 1.5 = 2400.
The total cost of bundle A is,
TCA = wLA + rKA
= 180× 8 + 240× 1.5 = $1800.
Does A minimise the firm’s costs?
Definition: Isocost line
The set of all bundles of inputs with the same total cost.
The slope of an isocost line is the negative of the ratio of input prices (−w/r ).
The isocost line through bundle A
00
1 12
8
Q = 2400
TCA
10
7 12
K
0 L
A
The bundles of inputs with the same total
cost as A are described by the equation,
wL + rK = TCA,
or 180L + 240K = 1800.
The L-intercept of the isocost line is,
TCA w
= 1800
180 = 10.
The K -intercept of the isocost line is,
TCA r
= 1800
240 = 7.5.
Comparing costs
00
1 12
8
Q = 2400
TCA
10
7 12
K
0 L
A
B
C
Bundles lying above the isocost line (such
as B) are more expensive than A.
Bundles lying below the isocost line (such
as C ) are less expensive than A.
A bundle of inputs does not minimise a
firm’s cost if it lies on an isocost line that
crosses the isoquant.
The cost-minimising bundle of inputs
00
Q = 2400
6
8
TCA
K
0 L
A
The cost-minimising bundle lies on the
isocost line that touches the isoquant at a
single point.
Diminishing marginal rate of technical
substitution implies that the isocost line
passing through the cost minimising
bundle A is tangent to the isoquant,
MRTSL,K = w
r .
At most one bundle of inputs can satisfy
these conditions.
Two conditions for (interior) cost minimisation
• The cost minimising bundle of inputs lies on the isoquant corresponding to the required quantity of output. Therefore, the production function must be satisfied for the required
value of Q.
• At the cost minimising bundle of inputs the slope of the isoquant is equal to the slope of the isocost line, therefore,
MPL MPx
= w
r .
Note: These conditions are predicated on a diminishing marginal rate of technical
substitution.
Exercise: Finding the optimal bundle of inputs
Winston’s Widgets has the production function Q = 200LK . The associated marginal
products are MPL = 200K and MPK = 200L. The price of labour is w = $180 per day, and
the rental price of capital is r = $240 per day.
1. Derive the equation for the Q = 2400 isoquant.
2. Find the firm’s marginal rate of technical substitution, and use it to construct the
tangency condition.
3. Solve the two equations simultaneously to find the optimal bundle of inputs.
4. What is the total cost of the optimal bundle?
Exercise solutions
1. The equation of the isoquant is found by substituting for Q in the production function,
200LK = 2400.
2. Winston’s Widgets marginal rate of technical substitution is,
MRTSL,K = MPL MPK
= 200K
200L =
K
L .
The tangency condition equates the marginal rate of technical substitution with the ratio
of input prices, MPL MPK
= w
r ⇒
K
L =
180
240 .
Exercise solutions
3. Rearranging the tangency condition to solve for K gives us,
K
L =
180
240 ⇒ K =
3L
4 .
Substituting for K into the equation of the isoquant,
200L
( 3L
4
) = 2400 ⇒ 150L2 = 2400 ⇒ L2 = 16 ⇒ L = 4.
Substituting for L in the tangency condition,
K = 3× 4
4 = 3.
4. The total cost of bundle A is TCA = wL + rK = 180× 4 + 240× 3 = $1440.
Marginal product per dollar
An alternative way of stating the tangency condition is,
MPL w
= MPK
r .
In words, at an interior optimum the marginal product per dollar must be equal for all inputs.
• This condition must hold for every pair of inputs that a firm utilises, regardless of the number of inputs to the firm’s production process.
Intuitively, if the marginal product per dollar is higher for labour than for capital, the firm can
reduce its costs by reducing usage of capital, and increasing usage of labour.
A change in the price of labour
00
3
4
4
3
Q = 2400
6
8
TCA
8
6
TCB
K
0 L
A
B
How does an increase in the wage, from
w1 = $180 to w2 = $320 per day, alter
the cost-minimising bundle of inputs?
After the increase in the wage, isocost
lines are steeper,
slope = − w2 r
= − 320
240 = −
4
3 .
The firm substitutes capital for labour.
The total cost increases to,
TCB = 320× 3 + 240× 4 = $1920.
Abundant opportunity for substitution
00
Q1
TCA
TCB
K
0 L
A
B
Along the isoquants of this production
function, labour and capital are relatively
interchangeable.
If the MRTSL,K changes gradually, the
production function offers abundant input
substitution opportunities.
The firm responds to an increase in the
wage by significantly increasing the
automation of the production process.
Minimal opportunity for substitution
00
Q1
TCA
TCB
K
0 L
A B
Along the isoquants of this production
function, there is little potential to
substitute labour for capital.
When the MRTSL,K changes rapidly, the
production function offers limited input
substitution opportunities.
The firm is unable to significantly
reorganise production in response to an
increase in the wage.
Fixed proportions production functions
00 fixed
proportions
Q1
TCA
TCB
K
0 L
A
The production function Q = min{L,K} requires inputs to be used in fixed
proportions (the inputs are perfect
complements).
The economic region of production
corresponds to the corners of the
isoquants.
The fixed proportions production function
offers no opportunities to substitute
labour for capital.
The total cost curve
Expanding production
00
3
4
4 12
6
Q = 2400
Q = 5400
6
8
TCA
9
TCB
K
0 L
A
B
In order for a firm to expand production,
it must select a bundle of inputs on a
higher isoquant.
The new cost-minimising bundle B has a
higher total cost than A.
Given that the input prices have not
changed, the isocost line TCB must have
the same slope as TCA.
Definition: Total cost curve
A curve that shows how total cost varies with output, holding input prices fixed and choosing
all inputs to minimise cost.
The total cost curve indicates the lowest cost at which each quantity can be produced.
Plotting the total cost curve
00
QA QB
TCA
TCB K
L
A B
TCA
QA
TCB
QB
TC
TC
0 Q
A
B
The quantity of output produced by
bundle A, can be plotted against the total
cost of the bundle.
Increasing output requires moving to a
higher isocost line.
It follows that the total cost curve must
be upward sloping.
Winston’s Widgets input demands
The first step in constructing a total cost function for a firm is deriving the input demands.
To find Winston’s Widgets input demands we solve the isoquant equation and tangency
conditions simultaneously for unknown quantity Q, and input prices w and r ,
200LK = Q and K
L =
w
r .
Rearranging the tangency condition to solve for K gives us K = wL/r .
Substituting for K into the isoquant equation allows us to derive the labour demand function,
200L
( wL
r
) = Q ⇒ 200
w
r L2 = Q ⇒ L2 =
Qr
200w ⇒ L =
√ Qr
200w .
Winston’s Widgets total cost function
Substituting for L in the tangency condition allows us to derive the capital demand function,
K = w
r
√ Qr
200w ⇒ K =
√ Qrw2
200wr2 ⇒ K =
√ Qw
200r .
The total cost of producing the quantity Q is therefore,
TC (Q) = wL + rK = w
√ Qr
200w + r
√ Qw
200r =
√ Qwr
200 +
√ Qwr
200 =
√ Qwr
50 .
Notice that for given input prices, the total cost function is a function of the quantity
produced only. Optimal use of inputs is implicit in all cost functions.
Questions?
Key concepts from today’s lecture
You can use these concepts (as search terms) to conduct further research into the topics
covered in today’s lecture:
• Inputs (factors of production)
• Production technology
• Production function
• Technical efficiency
• Marginal product
• Isoquant
• Economic region of production
• Marginal rate of technical substitution
• Cost minimisation
• Isocost line
• Total cost curve
• Total cost function
Further reading & exercises
The further readings provide additional context to the lecture material, and reinforce core
concepts. All readings and exercises can be found in Microeconomics 5th edition, by Besanko
and Braeutigam.
• Chapter 6, sections 6.1–6.3. • Chapter 7, sections 7.1–7.3.
Where the readings and lecture materials differ, the lecture materials take precedence.
The following exercises provide you with additional opportunities to apply the skills and
knowledge developed in this topic.
• Melbourne based students: 6.4, 6.5, 6.10, 6.17, 7.4 & 7.13. • Singapore based students: 6.7, 6.15 & 7.6.
The solutions can be found at the back of the textbook.
Quiz solutions
Quiz 1 (c)
Quiz 2 (b)
Quiz 3 (a)
- Production functions
- Multiple-input production functions
- Cost minimisation
- The total cost curve
- Appendix