INTRODUCTION TO CRITICAL THEORIES AND CONCEPTS IN THE CREATIVE AND CULTURAL INDUSTRIES (CCI)
Festivals and Art Events
Introduction……..
Now, it’s festivals, festivals everywhere. Big ones, small ones, wild ones, silly ones, dutiful ones, pretentious ones, phony ones. Many have lost purpose and direction, not to mention individual profile. Place a potted palm near the box office, double the ticket prices and – whoopee – we have a festival!" (Bernheimer, 2003, Financial Times, W21)
Definition of events
‘…a special event is a one off happening designed to meet specific needs at any given time….local community events may be defined as an activity designed to involve the local population in a shared experience to their mutual benefit’
Wilkinson (1998)
Why events?
Events have always existed but the number of events declined:
Industrialisation and fixed timetables
Impact of religion
Growth of events as a result of the need to ‘escape’ the routines of daily life and to find meaning to existence – postmodern issues
Why have festivals?
“A festival was traditionally a time of celebration, relaxation and recuperation which often followed a period of hard physical labour, sowing or harvesting of crops, for example. The essential feature of these festivals was the celebration of reaffirmation of community or culture.” (Policy Studies Institute cited in Bowdin et al: 2001:3).
Why Festivals and Events: Some Conceptual Considerations
Social habitus (Bourdieu)
Time out of daily life
Tribalism (gatherings of like minded people - music festival, opera)
Signals a cultured people- city spaces
Art is a currency in society
Art spaces have high social standing.
Festivals and Events as Rupture
‘Building on Erwin Goffman… (1974) Festive frames…describe a kind of socially constructed ‘recipe’ for people to deal with the smaller and larger life crises they face in their daily lives, both by giving these meaning and by leading people through an embodied process that eventually allows them to go on with their lives’. (Picard, 2015, 2)
Festivals necessary
Not just different from day to day work life
Also necessary to help us cope with the stresses in our lives as human beings – remind us what it is to be human in the company of other humans mediators of social change?
‘This can include anything from the readjustments required through pivotal points in the life cycle, to the shock of migration, environmental disaster, or revolution’.(Picard 2015, 2)
How?
Definitions vary according to context
‘A special event is a one time or infrequently occurring event outside normal programmes or activities of the sponsoring or organizing body.’ (Getz (1997)
‘There is no festival, even on a sad occasion, that does not imply at least a tendency towards excess and good cheer.’ (Callois 2001:97)
Reflective Exercise
Think about a festival or event that you attended in the last five years?
What were the reasons why you attended the event by considering some the criteria already mentioned?
Special Events
‘a unique moment in time celebrated with ceremony and ritual to satisfy specific needs’
Gold Platt (1997): 3
‘special uniqueness…which differentiated them from fixed attractions, and their ‘ambience’, which elevates them from ordinary life’
Getz, D (1989): 126
Growth in festivals and events reflects the following
Potential impacts: economic, social, environmental
Community
Diasporas
Visitors /tourism
Believe in the need to add value to visits
Special events then…..
They must be of limited and fixed duration, typically hours or days at most.
They must be a one-off or infrequent occurrence, typically monthly or annually at most.
If they are part of a regular series, they must be an unusual component of the series.
They must be unique.
They must require one or more organizers.
Their execution must be planned and controlled.
They must conform to the definition of a special event.
There must be a live audience other than the organizers present at the physical event location
(Doug Matthews http://specialeventguru.blogspot.co.uk/2007/11/seeking-definition-of-special-events.html)
Therefore…
Certain events are there:
To showcase cultures
As a show of ‘here we are’
As a way of ‘owning’ space
“A special event is a gathering of human beings, generally lasting from a few hours to a few days, designed to celebrate, honour, discuss, sell, teach about, encourage, observe, or influence human endeavours.”
Regardless of size or scope
‘an event will not succeed unless it can meet the motivations, expectations and needs of the participants, which will often be the local community, and the visitors.’
Hall (1992)
Reflective Exercise
‘an event will not succeed unless it can meet the motivations, expectations and needs of the participants, which will often be the local community, and the visitors.’ Hall (1992)
Can you think of a festival or event that you attended and how it impacted on your motivations, expectations or needs?
Consumption
‘To the customer or guest, a special event in an opportunity for a leisure social or cultural experience outside the normal range of choices or beyond everyday experience.’
Getz (1997)
Diversity of Events
Artistic performances
Festivals
Carnivals
Trade exhibitions
Sporting competitions and displays
Firework displays
Environmental days
Garden displays
Historic tours
Music festivals
Highland games
Sponsored Walks
Dog shows
Round the world Races
Pageants
Car boot sales
Parades
Royal Performances
Typology of Events
CULTURAL
CELEBRATIONS
Festivals
Carnivals
Religious Events
Parades
Heritage
Commemorations
ART &
ENTERTAINMENT
Concerts
Other Performances
Exhibits
Award Ceremonies
BUSINESS & TRADE
Fairs, Markets, Sales
Consumer/ Trade Shows
Expositions
Meetings and Conventions
Publicity Events
Fund-raising Events
SPORT
COMPETITIONS
Professional
Amateur
EDUCATIONAL &
SCIENTIFIC
Seminars, Workshops. Clinics
Congresses
Interpretive Events
RECREATIONAL
Games and Sports for Fun
Amusement Events
POLITICAL & STATE
Inaugurations
Investitures
VIP Visits
Rallies
(Getz 2003)
PRIVATE EVENTS
a) Personal Celebrations
Anniversaries
Family Holidays
Rites de Passage
b) Social Events
Parties, Galas
Reunions
Reflective Exercise
Consider the previous typology. Make a list of the events that you most commonly attend or would like to attend.
Analyse the differences and similarities between them by looking at how they impacted on your motivations, expectations or needs?
Festival and Events: Some further classifications
Hallmark, mega, major, local, community
What do organisations, places aspire to?
What the social purpose of the event
Economic purpose
Tourism
Unity/community
Showcase cultures- Mela/ carnival
Movement of peoples, ideas, events?
Hallmark Events: Edinburgh festival
Mardi Gras
Octoberfest
Scottish Pavilion Venice Biennale
Sheffield in Venice
Venice Biennale – Art in a political context
Frieze Art fair
Basel- ‘the world’s best art fair’ (the Telegraph)
Opera seasons
Orchestral seasons
Mega Events: Olympics games
The Sochi 2014 Winter Olympics
2012 opening ceremony London
Beijing
Wizard World Comic Con
Star trek
Cultural events: Tomantina
Local and Diasporic
Mela in Edinburgh
Harvest festival: local event
Trick or treat
Clown pilgrims
Day of the Dead Mexico
Chinese New Year
Reflective Exercise
Consider the previous list of events.
Could you see yourself working for one of them? If yes, why and what would you like to do?
Impacts of festivals and events
Psychological impacts
How residents and businesses feel about their locations before, during and after the event
Prestige and hospitality
Political/administrative impacts
Political aims of mega-events
Strenghtening of ideologies
Promotion of individual interests
Economic impact
Businesses
Cities
Regions
Nations
Tourism impacts
Visitor expenditure
Publicity, leading to heightened awareness and more positive image
Image is affected not only by the event period but since the bidding process
Tourist volumes
Infrastructural developments
Organisational developments
Tourism impacts
Tourism gives tribalism and colonialism a second life by bringing them back as representations of themselves and circulating them within an economy of performance. Bruner and (Kirshenblatt-Gimblett 1994)
National impact
Political stability
Soft power
Need for an economic boost
Move from industrial to service economy
Enhance ‘proud’ and confidence levels
Negative affects on communities
Can alienate community
Manipulation of community
Can create negative or false community image
Bad behaviour
Substance abuse
Loss of or restricted access to amenities for host community (adapted from Hall 1989)
Exoticised ‘other’
‘all but extinct cultures are exoticised and felt to contain people with ‘ancient’ or ‘original’ sacred knowledge that can be taught transferred and experienced.’ (Schechner (1993)
Exoticised ‘other’
Defined as ‘transient consumption of aesthetic difference in the search for the sincere and authentic’ (McCannell, Urry)
Authentic if you think it is as you create in your mind? (Chhabra et all 2003)
Reflective Exercise
Consider the previous list of positive and negative outcomes and apply them to the events and festivals that you have attended.
Make pros and cons list about their potential impact.
Inclusivity and Diversity of Art Events