SOC assignment
Editorials
Juvenile Victimization
Problems of Crime Victims
- Victimization costs include: damaged property, pain and suffering, and the involvement of police and other agencies of the justice system
The Emergence of Victimology
For every criminal act, there is at least one victim.
Victimology: A subfield of criminology that specializes in studying the victims of crime.
*
Who Gets Victimized
Victimization is not a random process; it is a process encompassing a host of systematic environmental, demographic, and personal characteristics.
Victim characteristics differ according to the type of crime.
*
Violence: What do we mean?
- violent crime (homicide, etc.)
- suicide
- fighting
- bullying
- sexual harassment
- child/adolescent abuse
- date/relationship violence
- gang-related violence
Status Offenses
- truancy from school
- underage drinking
- buying cigarettes
- running away
Violent Crime Index Offenses
- murder
- rape
- aggravated assault
- armed robbery
- arson
Data Sources
- Youth Risk Behavior Survey
- National Youth Gang Survey
- Uniform Crime Reports (UCR), FBI
- National Crime Victimization Survey, DOJ
- Health Behavior of School-aged Children Survey, National Institute for Child Health & Development & WHO (bullying)
- National School Climate Survey, since 2001
Problems of Crime Victims
- Economic Loss:
- Problems of Crime Victims
- Violent crime by juveniles costs $158 billion per year
- Total economic costs of crime amounts to $450 billion annually
- The costs of crime for each U.S. citizen is $1,800 annually
- Victims suffer long term losses in earnings and occupational attainment
- Research suggests crime victims during adolescence earn about $82,000 less than nonvictims
Problems of Crime Victims
- System Abuse
- Callous handling of victims by police
- Holding of personal property for evidence
- Rape victims report feeling “re-raped”
- Economic hardships due to trials
Problems of Crime Victims
- Long Term Stress
- Posttraumatic stress disorders (PTSD)
- Lowering of self-esteem
- Increased risk of suicide
- Eating disorders
- Obsessive-Compulsive Disorders
- Victimization lead to some people feeling timid and cautious
- Fear of a repeat attack
- Suffer psychological stress for longer periods of time
The Nature of Victimization
- Crime rates have been declining
- The violent victimization rate decreased 54 percent
- The property crime victimization rate decreased 50 percent
Figure 3.1 Declining Crime Rates, 1973-2003
Figure 3.2 Violent Crime Victimization Rates, 1973-2003
Figure 3.3 Property Crime Victimization Rates, 1973-2003
Victimization in the Workplace and School
On average, over two million incidents take place in the workplace annually.
The three occupations most at risk are: police officers, correction officers, and taxi drivers.
Schools are some of the safest places we can be.
Teachers get victimized by both theft and violence at school.
*
Violent Schools: Myth or Reality?
- schools among the safest places for children
- homicides in school rare: of 2,000 killings of children/year, 10 in or near schools
- 300 youth killed by guns elsewhere for one killed by gun at school
- % carrying gun/weapon to school declined 1996-2001
- most school crime is theft, not violent: 1% report being victim of a “serious” school crime
*
Dating Violence
the perpetration or threat of an act of violence by at least one member of an unmarried couple on the other member within the context of dating. This violence encompasses any form of sexual assault, physical violence, and verbal or emotional abuse.
Dating Violence
- Estimated prevalence of nonsexual dating violence:
- 22% among male & female h.s. students
- 32% among college students
- females more likely victims
- 80-90% of rapes on college campuses committed by someone victim knows
- characteristics of perpetrators: sexually aggressive male peers, heavy alcohol or drug use, dating violence normative, traditional sex roles, rape myths, family history of observing or experiencing abuse
Safe Dates
Foshee etal, AJPH 1998
- primary & secondary prevention
- 8th & 9th graders in rural North Carolina
- school: student theater; 10 session curriculum; poster contest to:
- change dating violence norms
- teach conflict management skills
- normalize seeking help
- community: train professionals, crisis lines, support groups
- outcomes:
- program students report less verbal, psychological, physical abuse than controls
- program students more likely to endorse non-violence norms, have better communication skills & more favorable attitude towards seeking help
Number of Homicides and Suicides of Youth Ages 15-19 at
and Away from School: 1999-2000
Source: DeVoe et al., Indicators of school crime and safety: 2003 (2003). U.S. Departments of Education and Justice.
*
Bullying - A specific type of aggressive behavior:
- intended to harm or disturb
- occurring repeatedly, over time
- powerful attacking less powerful
Takes many forms:
- threats
- physical harm
- rejection
- name calling
- teasing
- rumors
- take belongings
Percentage of Students ages 12-18 who Reported being Bullied During Previous Six Months, by Grade: 1999 and 2001 – first major study of Bullying
Source: DeVoe et al., Indicators of school crime and safety: 2003 (2003). U.S. Departments of Education and Justice.
*
- 30% US middle school students “involved”:
- 13% bullying
- 11% being bullied
- 6% both bullying & being bullied
- males bully/bullied more than females
- peaks in middle school
- bullying/being bullied associated with adjustment problems
- differences between those bullying & bullied
- successful interventions in Norway, England, South Carolina
Bullying
The Nature of Victimization
- The social ecology of victimization
- Violent crimes are more likely to occur in open public areas during daytime or early evening hours
- Almost two-thirds of more serious crimes such as rape occur after 6 P.M.
- Inner-city inhabitants have a greater chance of being victimized than suburbanites
The Nature of Victimization
- The Victim’s Household
- Larger, African American, Western, and urban homes are the most vulnerable to crime
- Recent declines in victimization may be explained by smaller households in less populated areas due to movement from urban areas
The Nature of Victimization
- Victim Characteristics
- Gender:
- Males are more likely to be victims of violent crime than females, except for rape and sexual assault
- Females are more likely to be victimized by someone they know, whereas males are more likely to be victimized by strangers
- Age:
- Young people are more at risk of victimization than older people
- People over 65 only account for 1 percent of violent victimizations (most being frauds and scams)
Violent Crime Rates by Age of Victim
The Nature of Victimization
- Social Status
- Poor people are more likely to experience violent and property crime
- The wealthy are more likely to be targets of personal theft crimes
The Nature of Victimization
- Marital Status
- Never-married people are more likely to be victimized than married people
- Widows and widowers have the lowest victimization rate
The Nature of Victimization
- Race and Ethnicity
- African Americans more likely to be victims of violent crime than European Americans
- Minorities experience income inequality in greater number than European Americans
The Nature of Victimization
- Repeat Victimization
- Individuals who have been a crime victim have a significantly higher chance of future victimization
- Characteristics which increase potential for victimization
- Target vulnerability
- Target gratifiability
- Target antagonism
The Nature of Victimization
- The Victims and Their Criminals
- Males are more likely to be violently victimized by a stranger
- Females are more likely to be victimized by a friend or intimate
- Crime is intraracial: Blacks victimize Blacks and Whites victimize Whites
- Substance abuse is involved in about one-third of violent crime incidents
- Women are more likely to be both robbed and raped by known acquaintances
Theories of Victimization
- Victim Precipitation Theory – some people may actually initiate the confrontation that leads to their injury or death.
- Active precipitation – victim acts provocatively (Menachem Amir 1971)
- Passive precipitation – occurs when victim exhibits some personal characteristics that unknowingly either threatens or encourages the attacker.
Theories of Victimization
- Lifestyle Theory – certain lifestyles increase exposure to criminal offenders.
- Being in a public place late at night
- Living in an urban area
- High-risk lifestyles (i.e. drinking, drug using)
- Criminal lifestyle such as carrying weapons and belonging to gangs
Theories of Victimization
- Deviant Place Theory
- Victim prone to victimization because one resides in a socially disorganized high-crime area
- The more often victims visit dangerous places, the more likely they will be exposed to crime and violence
- Deviant places include: poor densely populated areas, highly transient neighborhoods and commercial areas with residential property in close proximity
- William Julius Wilson suggests White residents flee high-crime areas, leaving racial minorities behind to suffer high victimization rates
Theories of Victimization
- Routine Activity Theory
- Victimization results from the interaction of everyday factors
- Availability of suitable targets
- Absence of capable guardians
- Presence of motivated offenders
- People who live in “hot spots” elevate their chances of victimization
- Some criminologists suggest moral guardianship might cause some people to refrain from crime if they are bonded with conventional attitudes (peer rejection)
- Ronald Clarke contends the relationship among opportunity, routine activities, and environmental factors increases victimization potential
Routine Activities Theory
The Opportunity Structure of Crime
Victimization and the Criminal & Juvenile Justice Systems
Advocates for victims’ rights began agitating for some of the same kinds of due process rights for victims that are enjoyed by their victimizers in the late 1960s, but it was not until 1982 that a federal task force was set up to examine the treatment of victims by the criminal justice system. A few years later a parallel task force examined the juvenile justice system.
The fair and decent treatment of victims by the system can help them to some extent to get over their victimization.
*
Caring for the Victim
- Victimization surveys indicate almost every American will become a victim of a common law crime
- Helping the victim cope is the responsibility of all of society
Caring for the Victim
- The Government’s Response
- Task Force on Victim’s of Crime created in 1982 to provide recommendations for victim assistance
- In 1984 The Comprehensive Crime Control Act and the Victims of Crime Act authorized federal funding for state victim compensation
Caring for the Victim
- Victim Service Programs
- An estimated 2,000 victim-witness assistance programs have been developed
- Victim compensation: to pay for damages associated with crime ($100 to $15,000)
- Court services: to help prepare victims and witnesses for court testimony
- Public education: to familiarize the general public with primary prevention programs
- Crisis intervention: Networks of social service agencies to provide emergency and long term assistance
- Victim-offender reconciliation programs: use of mediators for face-to-face encounters between victims and perpetrators
- Victim impact statements: allows victims the opportunity to describe their ordeal
Caring for the Victim
- Victims’ Rights
- Legal scholars have suggested crime victims have legal rights and society is obliged to ensure basic rights for law-abiding citizens
- Thirty-three states have added victim’s rights amendments to their constitutions
- A national Constitutional Amendment has been debated but has not yet passed Congress
- In 2004, the Senate passed S.2329 a bill to provide rights to federal victims of crime, which does not change the Constitution
Caring for the Victim
- Victim Advocacy
- Advocates provide assistance to crime victims by interacting with police, courts, and legal aid
- Advocates may assist in the writing of victim statements for various legal proceedings such as sentencing and probation/parole hearings.
- Advocates may interact with media trying to ensure reporting is accurate and that privacy is not violated
Caring for the Victim
- Self-Protection
- Target hardening involves making one’s home and business crime proof
- Use of fences, guards, surveillance cameras, window bars, warning signs, and dogs
- Gary Kleck suggests armed victims kill between 1,500 and 2,800 potential felons each year
Caring for the Victim
- Community Organization
- Neighborhood watch programs
- Community newsletters
- Home security surveys
- Lighting projects
Victim Compensation and Restitution
Victims of crime are eligible for partial compensation from the states to cover medical and living expenses incurred as a result of their victimization.
Victim compensation in the form of direct payments from the offenders in the form of restitution is increasingly ordered by the courts.
*
Victim-Offender Reconciliation Programs (VORPs)
VORPs are an integral component of restorative justice philosophy.
Central to the VORP process is the bringing together of victim and offender in face-to-face meetings mediated by a person trained in mediation theory and practice.
VORPs are used most often in the juvenile system but rarely used for personal violent crimes in juvenile or adult systems.
*