Journalclubtemplate.docx

Journal Club Template

Journal Article Citation

Reference

Introduction:

Background

· Information regarding the topic discussed in the article (medication, treatment, etc.) – why is this relevant?

· Previous relevant trials should be reviewed by presenter to provide greater understanding of the topic being discussed – can summarize previous literature on the topic and point out any gaps in knowledge

· Include any funding disclosures

Objective

· State the article’s main objective for the study

Methods:

Study Methods

· Design of the trial (e.g. prospective/retrospective, RCT, case series, open-label, double-blinded, etc.)

· Setting of the trial: (e.g. multicenter/single center study)

· Time frame of the study conducted

· Method of randomization, if applicable

· Study design - any specifics about the study method (e.g. questionnaires, follow-up time frame, monitoring parameters, etc.)

Patient Population

Inclusion Criteria:

· As stated in the article

Exclusion Criteria:

· As stated in the article

Baseline

Characteristics

· Comparison of the baseline characteristics between the groups

· Explanation of significant differences/similarities between the study groups

Endpoints

Primary Endpoints

· As stated in the article

· As stated in the article

Secondary Endpoints

· As stated in the article

· As stated in the article

Statistical Analysis

· Explain each statistical test used in the analysis

· Determine whether the test is appropriate for the type of data analyzed

(example)

Statistical Analysis

Data

Appropriate?

Results:

Primary

Outcomes

· Utilize graphs/charts to explain the outcomes

· Highlight important outcomes and explain the significance

Secondary Outcomes

· Utilize graphs/charts to explain the outcomes

· Highlight important outcomes and explain the significance

Critique:

Strengths

· Analyze various parts of the article thoughtfully and carefully to establish the article’s strengths

· Explore the article thoroughly and evaluate more persuasively by presenting a balanced view

· Determine whether the study or work discussed the objective/purpose of the research

Limitations

· Same as above

Name & Date (can include APPE or class, if applicable)

1

Conclusions:

Author’s

Conclusion

· Summarize the author’s major findings and conclusions

My

Conclusions

· Incorporate your criticisms of the article to formulate your own conclusion

· Discuss how the findings can be used in clinical practice

References

1.

2.

3.

Appendix:

(can include other tables/charts or background information that can help explain the article)

1