Education j jordan Annotated Bibliography Qualitative Research Assignment

profileJordanjameire
JJordanModule2AssignmentAnnotated_Bibliography_CBT_Youth_Violence1.docx

1

An Annotated Bibliography of Quantitative Research

Cognitive Behavioral Programming to Reduce Youth Violence:

Jameire Jordan

Liberty University

HSCI701 D01 202640

Melanie Tidman

November 8, 2026

Cognitive Behavioral Programming to Reduce Youth Violence: An Annotated Bibliography of Quantitative Research Comment by Melanie Tidman: Incorrect title page

Youth violence affects people, schools, and communities, and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) is one of the major tools being used to prevent youth violence, using a structured approach to teach an individual to interrupt their impulsive thoughts and reactions. Some randomized trials in Chicago and El Salvador indicate that programs based on CBT can decrease violence and school issues (Bhatt et al., 2024; Dinarte-Diaz & Egaña-delSol, 2024), though results differ with according to population and intervention implementation. The evidence is not consistent among adolescents, and there is a lack of clarity for organizations on which designs are effective. The aim of this annotated bibliography is to assess five peer-reviewed quantitative studies published between 2023 and 2026 for which CBT-informed programs for violence-prone youth and young adults were tested. Comment by Melanie Tidman: “School issues” try to be more defined in your wording. What kinds of school issues?Issues for the teachers? For the school? For the students? Comment by Melanie Tidman: What kind of implementation? Comment by Melanie Tidman: Were tested or were effective in achieving outcomes?

Annotated Bibliography Comment by Melanie Tidman: Good! It looks like you reviewed the template!

Bhatt, M. P., Heller, S. B., Kapustin, M., Bertrand, M., & Blattman, C. (2024). Predicting and preventing gun violence: An experimental evaluation of READI Chicago. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 139(1), 1–56. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjad031

The researchers were Bhatt, Heller, Kapustin, Bertrand, and Blattman of the University of Chicago, the University of Michigan, and Cornell University and published this randomized trial in a top peer-reviewed economics journal. The sample was comprised of 2,456 men at the highest risk of gun violence in Chicago. Randomly assigning 18 months of supported employment to either supported employment and CBT or to the control group, researchers found significant reductions in arrests and victimizations at 20 months for the supported employment and CBT group compared to the control group after adjusting for multiple testing. There was no significant change in the primary indicator of seriousness of violence, but there was a 65% reduction in the number of people arrested for shooting and homicide offencesoffenses, with estimated benefit-cost ratios ranging from 4:1 to 18:1. Strengths are the large randomized design, and the prespecified primary outcome measure; weaknesses are the bundled job and CBT components, and the lack of generalizability to adolescents. The authors proposed a combination of outreach referrals and algorithmic targeting is best. Results of the study suggest this, but don't prove that, violence prevention with CBT. Comment by Melanie Tidman: I would present the study sequentially. Jumping to results before you explained the data collection strategy, tools used etc makes this section a bit hard to follow. Comment by Melanie Tidman: Multiple testing using what? Comment by Melanie Tidman: Not sure what this means Comment by Melanie Tidman: Awkward sentence. So there is not enough detail in this summary I provided the elements I needed to see on the template: Who did the study? How credible is the study? What population or topic did the study investigate? What were the methods of the study? What was the statistical analysis performed? What were the results? What are the strengths of the study? What are the weaknesses of the study? What were the recommendations? How does this study relate to your selected topic?

Blattman, C., Chaskel, S., Jamison, J. C., & Sheridan, M. (2023). Cognitive behavioral therapy reduces crime and violence over ten years: Experimental evidence. American Economic Review: Insights, 5(4), 527–545. https://doi.org/10.1257/aeri.20220427

This study was published in a peer-reviewed American Economic Association journal and was researched conducted by Blattman, Chaskel, Jamison, and Sheridan from the University of Chicago, Instiglio, the University of Exeter, and the University of North Carolina, respectively. Participants consisted of 999 high-risk men in Liberia randomly allocated to receive 8 weeks of nonspecialist-led CBT, a $200 cash grant, both or neither. The team compared standardized antisocial behavior indices in the four arms 10 years after the study began. The combined therapy and cash treatment led to a 0.25 standard deviation decrease in antisocial behavior, and a 50% decrease in self-reported drug selling, thefts, and robberies, with the greatest effects among men at greatest risk. The strengths of the study are the use of a randomized design and a long term follow-up of 10 years; the weaknesses are that the study was conducted in Liberia and data was collected using self-reports. The authors found that targeted CBT with economic support is an affordable method of preventing violence. The study provides causal evidence for CBT in the long-term. Comment by Melanie Tidman: How did they collect this data? How can you “compare” and what were the standardized social behavioral indices? Comment by Melanie Tidman: I don’t understand your use of standard deviations here. Comment by Melanie Tidman: This is more descriptive Comment by Melanie Tidman: Oh did they us a survey? How did they recruit? How did they disseminate the survey? Not enough detail

Dinarte-Diaz, L. (2025). Understanding the effects of group composition by risk for violence: Experimental evidence from El Salvador. Journal of Development Economics, 175, Article 103480. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdeveco.2025.103480

This study was published by World Bank economist Dinarte-Diaz in the peer-reviewed Journal of Development Economics. Sample The sample consisted of 1,056 students between the ages of 10 and 16 from five public schools in violent communities in El Salvador. The study used randomization inference to analyze intent-to-treat effects from one 20-week after-school program that included social skills development, as well as randomly assigning students to a control group, a homogeneous group of similarly risky peers, and a heterogeneous group of peers. There were small average differences between group types, but mixed groups did the most for the most vulnerable children and did less harm to the least vulnerable; higher average levels of peer risk had a negative impact and greater variation had a positive impact. Strengths: Random assignment of peers; weaknesses: self-reported outcomes, no long-term follow up. The author suggested that consideration be given to the composition of the groups when developing violence considering group composition when developing violence-reduction programs. The study provides guidance for the organization to create cognitive behaviouorganizations to create cognitive behavioral groups. Comment by Melanie Tidman: What does this mean? Comment by Melanie Tidman: So there were 3 groups? unclear Comment by Melanie Tidman: Did the most? What does this mean? Comment by Melanie Tidman: How did they determine “peer risk”? and the impacts? What tools did they use? Comment by Melanie Tidman: Extranneous wording makes the sentence hard to follow

Dinarte-Diaz, L., & Egaña-delSol, P. (2024). Preventing violence in the most violent contexts: Behavioral and neurophysiological evidence from El Salvador. Journal of the European Economic Association, 22(3), 1367–1406. https://doi.org/10.1093/jeea/jvad068

This is a randomized experiment published in one of the top peer-reviewed journals in economics by two World Bank economists and a Chilean university, Dinarte-Diaz and Egaña-delSol. A total of 1056 children ages 10 to 16 attended five public schools in El Salvador. Students were randomly assigned to a 20-week after-school program that consisted of social skills training based on CBT principles and extracurricular activities, and outcomes were measured using surveys, school records and biomarkers called electroencephalograms (EEG). Dat was collected……..Data was analyzed using……….. The program resulted in a meaningful decrease in violent and delinquent behaviors, increased school attitudes, decreased absenteeism, and a small increase in the likelihood of passing courses. Randomization is a strength, as is the fact that multiple data sources were used; a weakness is that program components were bundled, and the follow-up time was brief, but the evidence from exploratory EEG was significant and contained enough data. The authors hypothesized that improving emotion regulation is a likely mechanism, and recommended that programs should focus on self-regulation. The study provides first-hand evidence for school based cognitive behavioral programming of adolescents. Comment by Melanie Tidman: Is this the name of the university? I thought it was the name of the author? Comment by Melanie Tidman: Good this is the kind of detail I am looking for Comment by Melanie Tidman: Why did they use EEGs? What was the connection? EEGs typically show seizure activity. Comment by Melanie Tidman: Increased negative school attitudes? Increased positive school attitudes? Comment by Melanie Tidman: 20 weeks does not seem brief. Comment by Melanie Tidman: Contained enough data? What is enough? Comment by Melanie Tidman: A likely mechanism for what?

Meulen, P., Koning, N., Assink, M., van Hooren, S., Kolthoff, E., & Heynen, E. (2026). Letting work what works—Effectively preventing juvenile delinquency in the Netherlands: A meta-analysis of the evidence. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 70(5). https://doi.org/10.1177/0306624X251344620 Comment by Melanie Tidman: I am sorry but this article is not eligible for this assignment per the instructions, my announcements, and the template.

The authors of this meta-analysis, Meulen and colleagues, published it in a peer-reviewed criminology journal and adhered to PRISMA reporting guidelines, which have been registered. Ten (quasi-)experimental research studies of six interventions in the field of juvenile delinquency in The Netherlands were summarized in the review, resulting in 65 (quasi-)experimental effect sizes from six separate samples. The authors used a three-level meta-analysis with Hedges' g. The overall effect was small but significant (g = 0.22, 95% CI [0.02, 0.42]) and equal to about a 12% reduction in delinquency, whereas the effects of social skills training alone and family-based interventions were not statistically significant. Larger effects were related to longer treatment length and more program integrity. Few papers found and one country only, this is a strength; potential publication bias is a weakness; one formal bias test found. The authors suggested that there is need to have a more robust evidence based practice based on the risk-need-responsivity model. The study is based on CBT elements and faithful implementation.

Biblical Perspectives on the Topic

Proverbs 13:20 reminds us that scripture says that companions form character. There is evidence that peer composition affects violence outcomes (Dinarte-Diaz, 2025) and so does Proverbs 13:20 say, “whoever walks with the wise becomes wise, but the companion of fools will suffer harm” (English Standard Version Bible, 2001). Similarly, Proverbs 27:17 says “Iron sharpens iron, and one man sharpens another” (English Standard Version Bible, 2001) reinforces mentor groups that have members practicing, “Iron sharpens iron, and one man sharpens another” (English Standard Version Bible, 2001), reinforcing mentor groups in which members practice new behaviors together. This is a biblical model of discipleship and restoration that is reflected in programs that foster wise relationships and self-control. Comment by Melanie Tidman: Peer composition?

Conclusion

The five studies reported a positive impact of CBT-informed programs on reducing violent or delinquent outcomes in a variety of settings, with results varying from a null primary index. (Bhatt et al., 2024) to a decrease in violent or delinquent outcomes after 10 years. s (Blattman et al., 2023). Outcomes were influenced by group composition, length of treatment, and implementation integrity. (Dinarte-Diaz, 2025; Meulen et al., 2026). CBT programming with trained facilitators, mixed-risk groups, and fidelity monitoring is recommended for use with youth-serving systems, and should be evaluated with adolescents in randomized trials. This investment is for the benefit of students and acts as a boost to school communities. Comment by Melanie Tidman: Comment by Melanie Tidman: I did not see anything about fidelity monitoring. Comment by Melanie Tidman: Acts as a boost? Comment by Melanie Tidman: The assignment is well organized. Details are missing. I cannot tell what you found as 4 summaries are missing major details from the studies and 1 summary is over an article that is ineligible for this assignment This is well organized so you follow the format. Who did the study? How credible is the study? What population or topic did the study investigate? What were the methods of the study? What was the statistical analysis performed? What were the results? What are the strengths of the study? What are the weaknesses of the study? What were the recommendations? How does this study relate to your selected topic The title page is incorrect. Awkward or unclear wording throughout, no citations are needed in the conclusion. See feedback attached in the grading area Dr. Tidman

References

Bhatt, M. P., Heller, S. B., Kapustin, M., Bertrand, M., & Blattman, C. (2024). Predicting and preventing gun violence: An experimental evaluation of READI Chicago. The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 139(1), 1–56. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjad031 Comment by Melanie Tidman: Activate your hyperlinks so all I need to do is click on them and they take me to the article (should appear in Blue)

Blattman, C., Chaskel, S., Jamison, J. C., & Sheridan, M. (2023). Cognitive behavioral therapy reduces crime and violence over ten years: Experimental evidence. American Economic Review: Insights, 5(4), 527–545. https://doi.org/10.1257/aeri.20220427

Dinarte-Diaz, L. (2025). Understanding the effects of group composition by risk for violence: Experimental evidence from El Salvador. Journal of Development Economics, 175, Article 103480. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jdeveco.2025.103480

Dinarte-Diaz, L., & Egaña-delSol, P. (2024). Preventing violence in the most violent contexts: Behavioral and neurophysiological evidence from El Salvador. Journal of the European Economic Association, 22(3), 1367–1406. https://doi.org/10.1093/jeea/jvad068

English Standard Version Bible. (2001). Crossway. https://www.esv.org

Meulen, P., Koning, N., Assink, M., van Hooren, S., Kolthoff, E., & Heynen, E. (2026). Letting work what works—Effectively preventing juvenile delinquency in the Netherlands: A meta-analysis of the evidence. International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology, 70(5). https://doi.org/10.1177/0306624X251344620 Comment by Melanie Tidman: Per the announcements, instructions, this article is not eligible for this assignment: Instructions Be sure to investigate 5 scholarly peer- reviewed articles covering quantitative primary research studies (excluding literature reviews, Meta-Analyses, or systematic reviews)