Issue Identification

CRITERIA 

NON-PERFORMANCE 

BASIC 

PROFICIENT 

DISTINGUISHED 

Describe an ethical issue that can be resolved by an organizational policy.

Does not identify an ethical issue that can be resolved by an organizational policy. 

Identifies, but does not describe, an ethical issue that can be resolved by an organizational policy. 

Describes an ethical issue that can be resolved by an organizational policy. 

Describes an ethical issue that can be resolved by an organizational policy, and provides examples of the ethical issue. 

Evaluate why an organizational policy would be needed to resolve an ethical issue.

Does not describe why an organizational policy would be needed to resolve an ethical issue. 

Describes, but does not evaluate, why an organizational policy would be needed to resolve an ethical issue. 

Evaluates why an organizational policy would be needed to resolve an ethical issue. 

Evaluates why an organizational policy would be needed to resolve an ethical issue, and explains the repercussions of the issue occurring. 

Examine the current relevance of an ethical issue.

Does not describe the current relevance of an ethical issue. 

Describes, but does not examine, the current relevance of an ethical issue. 

Examines the current relevance of an ethical issue. 

Examines the current relevance of an ethical issue, and provides examples of the relevancy. 

Evaluate the importance of resolving an ethical issue.

Does not describe the importance of resolving an ethical issue. 

Describes, but does not evaluate, the importance of resolving an ethical issue. 

Evaluates the importance of resolving an ethical issue. 

Evaluates the importance of resolving an ethical issue, and provides examples of how to resolve it.