Management Case Analysis
Olk – Strategic Management -- 2012
Industry Analysis Checklist
The purpose of this worksheet is to help you analyze the industry in which your project company operates. The worksheet begins by asking some background information to help identify the boundaries of the analysis. Spend time working on defining the boundaries because this can be challenging and, of course, drive the rest of the analysis. Following, the worksheet goes through each of the 6 forces of an industry before concluding with some general observations. Again, as a reminder, be sure to keep the analysis at the industry level and not a specific company level.
Group Project Company ___________________________
Step 1: Defining the Industry
1. In what industry or industry segment does the company compete?
[If you cannot define the industry or industry segment, then working through the following questions will help. If you can define the industry or industry segment, skip to question 2]
a. What products are substitutable? (Substitution on the supply side)
b. What manufacturers/service providers can easily switch to produce these products/services? (Substitution on the demand side)
c. What are the geographical boundaries to the industry? (i.e., where are there different prices for the same product)]
2. What companies compete in this industry?
3. What kind of companies are likely entrants into this industry? (e.g., From what existing industries might they come? Are there start-up companies that might enter?)
4. What types of companies comprise the suppliers (provide specific names)?
5. What types of companies comprise the buyers (provide specific names)? [If your project company sells directly to consumers, just note this]
6. What are potential substitutes? What are the advantages and disadvantages of each?
Step 2: Analyze the Industry
What are key trends occurring in the macro-environment that affect the industry?
(Be as specific as possible in providing numeric indication of key trends for each category)
a. National/International Economy
b. Technology
c. Political-Legal
d. Natural Environment
e. Demographic Structure
f. Social Culture
Industry Forces
|
Threat of new entrants into an industry is greatest when within the industry the: |
High |
Low |
Conditions forFocal Industry(select High or Low) |
|
Economies of scale are |
|
XX |
|
|
Product differentiation is |
|
XX |
|
|
Capital requirements are |
|
XX |
|
|
Existing companies’ control of distribution channels is |
|
XX |
|
|
Existing companies’ level of proprietary knowledge is |
|
XX |
|
|
Existing companies’ control over access to raw materials is |
|
XX |
|
|
Government and legal barriers are |
|
XX |
|
|
Expected retaliation by established companies is |
|
XX |
|
All conditions are not equal, which conditions significantly affect the threat of new entrants?
Do you consider the threat of new entrants favorable or unfavorable? Why?
What are changes that may affect the threat of new entrants?
|
Power of suppliers is greatest when the: |
High |
Low |
Conditions forFocal Industry(select High or Low) |
|
Size of or concentration of focal industry companies relative to supplier companies is |
|
XX |
|
|
Total volume of or percentage of suppliers’ products purchased by the focal industry companies is |
|
XX |
|
|
Product differentiation of suppliers is |
XX |
|
|
|
Switching costs for focal industry companies are |
XX |
|
|
|
Threat of forward integration by suppliers is |
XX |
|
|
|
Suppliers’ knowledge about focal industry companies’ cost structure is |
XX |
|
|
|
Extent of suppliers’ profits is |
XX |
|
|
|
Cost savings for the focal industry companies from the supplier’s product are |
XX |
|
|
|
Importance of the suppliers’ input to quality of the focal industry’s final product is |
XX |
|
|
|
Cost of suppliers’ product relative to the focal industry companies’ total cost is |
XX |
|
|
All conditions are not equal, which conditions significantly affect the bargaining power of suppliers?
From the perspective of the focal industry, do you consider the bargaining power of the suppliers a favorable or unfavorable condition of the environment? Why?
What are changes that may affect the bargaining power of the suppliers?
|
Power of buyers is greatest when the: |
High |
Low |
Conditions forFocal Industry(select High or Low) |
|
Size of or concentration of buyers relative to focal industry companies is |
XX |
|
|
|
Total volume of or percentage of focal industry companies’ products purchased by the buyers is |
XX |
|
|
|
Product differentiation by focal industry companies is |
|
XX |
|
|
Switching costs for buyers are |
|
XX |
|
|
Threat of backward integration by buyers is |
XX |
|
|
|
Buyers’ knowledge about focal industry companies’ cost structure is |
XX |
|
|
|
Extent of buyers’ profits are |
|
XX |
|
|
Cost savings for the buyers from the focal industry companies’ product are |
|
XX |
|
|
Importance of the focal industry companies’ input to quality of the buyers’ final products is |
|
XX |
|
|
Cost of focal industry companies’ product relative to the buyers’ total cost is |
|
XX |
|
All conditions are not equal, which conditions significantly affect the bargaining power of the buyers?
From the perspective of the focal industry, do you consider the bargaining power of the buyers a favorable or unfavorable condition of the environment? Why?
What are changes that may affect the bargaining power of the buyers?
|
Threat of substitute products is greatest when the: |
High |
Low |
Conditions forFocal Industry(select High or Low) |
|
Buyer propensity to substitute is |
XX |
|
|
|
Relative price-performance relationship of substitutes compared to industry product is |
XX |
|
|
Which of these two conditions significantly affect the threat of a substitute?
From the perspective of the focal industry, is the threat of substitute products a favorable or unfavorable condition of the environment? Why?
What are changes that may affect the threat of substitute products?
|
Intensity of competitive rivalry within the focal industry is greatest when the: |
High |
Low |
Conditions forFocal Industry(select High or Low) |
|
Number of companies or the number of equally balanced companies is |
XX |
|
|
|
Industry growth rate is |
|
XX |
|
|
Fixed or storage costs are |
XX |
|
|
|
Product differentiation is |
|
XX |
|
|
Switching costs for buyers are |
|
XX |
|
|
Diversity among industry companies is |
|
XX |
|
|
Exit barriers are |
XX |
|
|
|
Strategic stakes are |
XX |
|
|
All conditions are not equal, which of the conditions significantly affect the intensity of rivalry?
From the perspective of the focal industry, is the level of rivalry within the industry a favorable or unfavorable condition of the environment? Why?
What are changes that may affect the level of rivalry?
|
Influence of complementary products is greatest when the |
High |
Low |
Conditions forFocal Industry(select High or Low) |
|
Number of or size of the companies producing the complementary product relative to focal industry companies is
|
XX |
|
|
Relative buyer or supplier switching costs for the complementary products is |
XX |
|
|
Ease of unbundling |
|
XX |
|
Rate of growth of the focal industry’s products is |
|
XX |
|
From the perspective of the focal industry, is the influence of complementary products a favorable or unfavorable condition of the environment? Why?
What are changes that may affect the power of complements?
Summary of Analysis
For each of forces in the following figure, circle whether the force has a high, medium or low impact on the industry.
Industry
Rivalry
Threat of Entry
Strength of
Buyers
Strength of
Suppliers
Threat of
Substitutes
Availability of
Complements
Industry Analysis
High
Medium
Low
High
Medium
Low
High
Medium
Low
High
Medium
Low
High
Medium
Low
High
Medium
Low
Step 3: Summarize the Expected Moves by Direct Competitors and Changes in the Industry
Based upon the above, you should have some indication of what significant moves your direct competitors may be considering as well as significant changes that may be occurring in the structure of the industry. What are the top 3-5 moves or changes you anticipate?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Step 4: Clearly State the Key Success Factors
Based upon the above analysis, what are the 3-5 key success factors for companies in the industry?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Step 5: Identify Strategies that Work in Similar Industries
What are similar industries – in terms of lifecycle (e.g., fragmented, emerging, mature, declining), concentration (e.g., competitive, oligopoly, monopoly), technology, product offering, etc. – to the structure of this industry?
What are strategies that appear to be effective in these industries?
Step 6: Develop a plan of action for your company to take
Based upon the above information, what are specific actions your company can take to shape or respond to industry conditions?
� If the buyers are consumers, some of the items may not apply. If an item does not apply, skip it.
PAGE
1
_1168007200.ppt
Industry
Rivalry
Threat of Entry
Strength of
Buyers
Strength of
Suppliers
Threat of
Substitutes
Availability of Complements
Industry Analysis
High
Medium
Low
High
Medium
Low
High
Medium
Low
High
Medium
Low
High
Medium
Low
High
Medium
Low