Dell Case study

Level of Achievement

Criteria

Poor

0-20%

Fair

20-45%

Good

45-80%

Excellent

80-100%

Content

25 points

Most questions NOT addressed.

Elaboration and detail are not nominally evident.  Information is not clear and/or developed.  Answers reflect little complexity and critical thinking.  Discussion is difficult to understand with little clarity.  Lacks meaning, applicability.

Some questions are addressed.

Some information relative to the topic but lacking elaboration and detail.  Answers reflect a basic understanding of the material but no critical thinking or complexity is evident.  Discussion is understood but lacks some clarity.  Lacks relevancy, meaning, applicability and is somewhat difficult to understand.

Most questions addressed.

Clear information relative to the topic but lacking elaboration and detail.  Answers reflect some complexity and critical thinking is not fully developed.  Discussion is understood but lacks some clarity.  Mostly relevant, meaningful, applicable and can be understood.

All questions are addressed.

Elaborate and detailed information relative to the topic.  Critical thinking and insight evident in the complexity of answers.  Discussion is articulated in a clear manner. 

Answers are relevant, meaningful, applicable and easily understood.

Grammar

Several spelling, grammar or sentence structure errors.  The structure of the paper has many discrepancies to the requirements of: clear paragraphs for each question, double spacing, 12-point font, and 1-inch margins.  Paper is significantly short of four full pages.

Moderate number of spelling or grammar errors. The requirements for the structure of the paper are lacking: clear paragraphs for each question, double spacing, 12-point font, and 1-inch margins.  Paper is somewhat short of four full pages.

A couple of spelling, grammar or sentence structure errors.  The structure of the paper mostly meets the requirements of: clear paragraphs for each question, double spacing, 12-point font, and 1-inch margins.  Paper is marginally short of four full pages.

No spelling, grammar or sentence structure errors.  The structure of the paper should have clear paragraphs for each question.  Four-page minimum, double spaced, 12-point font, 1-inch margins.

Organization

10 points

Few or no answers are organized, easy to follow and logical. Answers do not include supporting details and/or examples. 

Some answers are organized, easy to follow and logical. Answers do not include supporting details and/or examples.

Most answers are organized, easy to follow and logical. Answers include some supporting details and/or examples.

 All answers are organized, easy to follow and logical. Answers include several supporting details and/or examples.

.

Bibliography

Citation

5 points

 No required citations referenced on last page.

Few required citations referenced on last page.

Some sources referenced are appropriate and applicable to the topic.

 Most required citations clearly referenced on last page.

Most sources referenced are appropriate and applicable to the topic.

All required citations clearly referenced on last page.

All sources referenced are appropriate and applicable to the topic.