OT Theory comparison paper
bron_s
IMG_20180521_0001.pdf
'lepou pue acueJaloJ Jo elueJJ e 'fuoeql e aqucsap puB ouueG 'e
:uorlBuuolu! ounolpl oql a$AoJd llutlt noA leuroJ pequcseld eq1 6unrollo; 'se6ed e U uer{l.ra6uq ou sr lBr{l.reded e u;
'rN'aJBlororll '(pe qlg) sertbtuqcqpue 'sanssr eulcad 'seldoultd :1ue1ssse idaory puaqednccg
s,ueig '(StOd'3'g 'uely ? 'y ll(pqs p /.re1deq3 u! €ouoJeJil Jo seuel; (Se-fS d) uo4qlqeqou o^uu6o3 aql pue (g/-qz d) uoplUqeqeu aqt lnoqe peeu '2,
6u1n11 Agpp Jo saltr^llce - IOV
sllurll leulJou ultlllrirr oq ol prBs si l! uaql 'pslrrxrl Apq0rp fuen 1sn[lo ;1O s! uor]oru ;o e6uel I - s]lrxll leuuou u!r+!rn - INM
'apls u{6U or{l uo sseulee A opsnu ol onp lrue sn] salou prderaq oql uor{l,t ueq} u/rr\o srr{ uo e}enrur ueo
eq let;; uollotu ssol seq IUBJJ 'uue srq selou 'prde.leql eql aM 'esle euoeuos uor.{/r^ slupls!r{ }B seq IUEJJ leq; uo[oru - uoqou 1o e6uel erussed - H{OUd
so^otu aq ueq/n lurot fue lB ser4 IUBJJ leql uotlou - uolloru 1o e0uel olqce - yIOUV
saol at4 ol (lels!p) ufi\op dtrt ot{l urorJ - rQruerye Je ^o!
- 3l sra0url aql ol (telslp) u/nop leplnoqs aqt uoJJ - l(1!r.ue4xe laddn - 3p
aloJls e JoJ uuel Jaqoue fl wlr{ fr 'luepErse JelncsB^oJqoJec - vn3
:ueou Aeq leqru pue esBc aql u! pssn suoqeneJqqe eql lo otuos aJB aJoH
'Epgep pue saryyqe fiereno s)luetJ uo sneo! pnf luoqces uogeryenCI tdaeql puoqedncco eqy
u s4lnsou qse1rcqo ltue ro sgnsru uqpw lo e6uet aqy fiupue1staryn fioqe fuion l,uoe 'fN :ereloJoqt'('pe p"Z)'yepn$
Adaetll puoryedncco eWJol\ooqpoilte:wnnuryuac eJecqileeq eW q6nory7 sa/pn s eseC 'G107) 'p 'uplsue/nol ? 'd 'uerolleH oql urrcldeqc s!r{l pug llf^ no1 'pal6aN Uel 'erOegdruag Uol 'lueplccv Jelnose^orqaJoC lq6rg :1ue.ll :gtSg seOed 'g .re1deq3 pBeU 'l
lueuu6lssy
apel6 lelol Jo ologl lslurod gt r{Uo/n lueulu6rssy eoedglqEug uo JoploJ uorssruqns e!^ (BLge '09 dBW rtepseupeffi g leo/n uo sse/c arcpq one
(eLlZOlSo) g IooM uo ue^re l_o ol uoBsnporlul t00t vlo
Jaded (uos;reduo3 froeqflooncerd Jol soullaplnC IO
uer6oJd luelsrssv Ideraql leuoqedmcg
inort {uBqI 'solpuodde Jo saouaroJoJ ,{uB JaSB - JdEd JnoA Jo pue fua aql oN! cpqnu aJlluo eql elsed pue'e6ed 1xau oql uo punoJ'cyqng uollEnte^I eql Adoc oseeld :IION
asJuoJolal p aueJl e uo luorulee4luerp o1 qceoddB Jraql aseq sJeuogpcerd tO 1eql luelrodul l! s! /(r{ A 'rl
'Adereql ;euoqedncoo ur luarJ qyrn Ourryom ol qceo;dde lueqeor; rnod aseq ol rplLpv\ uo $ilo/u\auell eleudo.rdde ele sJuoJalad
Jo saual uolle1lqeqeg encru0oC eql pue uoqeltllqBqeu eql {ryr equcse6 '6
cJorllo qree uo{ JeJIp auaJeJsJ lo seuerl orq lnod op /noH 'J
eeouoJoleJ Jo seue4 or*I lnof ueatqaq so[ueltuts oq] eJe lEqM 'o
'eouarsJou lo suerl uollB1llqeqey er4lu6oC aql oqucssp pue fypepg 'p
'eoueJeleu Jo oueJl uopelllrqeqay aql oqucsep pue f,11uep1 'c
eecuaJelal lo saueJJ 6urure;dxe uoq/u\ poullep Jo opeu suorldunsse e.re {q1tr 'q
ureJ6o;d luelsrssy Ade:aq1 leuotiedrcsO
'lI33,lr € $I rtElsJs q1gu4 P+$3dxa s!H-'ifulqd'{qd pue
{rs1"lp'6*p.rau rlq u*as 4 oql U$a 3$ 'Cde"uql fBsot]€ -*rtra, ptrr'td*aql q:*ds 'J.A ?C,{q ue*t 3E llldi +H
'e:qeq s'a E ll *i:l sI eE oli ll!;q Ia8 ot se{etr ti '!*i's -1tqi,r op l5in prls sgro8 xeqtgo e.quoddns
q ;J!&r s.q$?r$ 'vjr nir iq pi{n.ri1p sun. lt }roJaq }*}1 l! araq,n a311 qq da EitIq:d al $errrry sqoal;H '$er$pq srq *rr'ns*r Frs
*tuoq
&$tpr 6I {rqq rq ug psg 4aq1 1e*$scq H6rre$$q"qsr "t{1 urc4 a&aqxlp *!,g.aq" surcq trr$la: qt1 uc *r4trreqd *re
.{aqa'e8qr.leut &rsr$ e ;A?q 3}!rl stEl PUE 3H '}ttfir!e;413r
r:rys rrrrl{t t{ll*t ${gi$ Sulpaoq dqaa,u slq pa$1elulellr tet{ aq ptrt 'erg;n pod xql ruo4 spuap; {uar trq 4ucr4
.&rr$rl $ laE 31 3Jlllr $lr{ JI rptrt:l p$s }sE4E*.Iq u"{ao slq *t{:ui ti{ 'pusJr? s!E$ u$a;l*i slq qipr cfi "ta 8u$doqs {.raxu8 }q1 sp eau4}e{no$
Elr* :ltreJg ',{:pune1 pllr uqprcda:* 1l}uE aql caop eJEst
s.qsul 'rEl*q slr{ us $l5El e3s"ue}lllE1l, el{tr [" auop s'{urup $sq $r?rJ 'lFel rx:sql rrro!'q loE ep d*qt yut po*ry*qqs-rar: ,rg s{ ,ffi33r ars s.Ist{3* grq 's:*qqBgati ipq} }s *tt'os q}!i{
{pr:a;:; alt rteq;'e$n*I{ }ql sI P?I{3"1t? pr: q e8arr$l ag1
pua 'rsop l$sr; ai{}sllt} rdera*g e:s aleqJ p*cq-leqqft*a rreqlrqtrs E u1 auraq q,{p-qf,usr s r! erqi {:iri s1qpue4$sJd 'dlqsrqrpr paulx;l* u Es{ aq taoqA{ q1r* pur iq.leau aa11 *ss sasp sqa a3suru$l *rsueld ? ffe$ ilss ? s"q {us'I{
ipaqsuag* crotu #,qQor{ ort: slq 8u3ic{ua *ard -!3t1l,? pris lc{rsjlrp$srr,t pur l}urpr*s F}nr E? 5l aH "mp:us
*1q oi 8o1p*r p!:E 33pr slq t{}l*+ fugpau.g er p.ls&rcJ *$I -{sa! sI p$e nt:lrora 1t}sod t s* qt{ sg uroq parl},r dllua:e"l *H 'irEul aalpt {ra* s ffiaq p*r{ 4EB;C'VJt3 $Iq ;J€$Jg .uq!rl{!qGq3r ?tlsu3lxa 3ld}Ir rq ie$*rq U{}1rE}!Fq"q*} sql ot p}IjaFtrs.rl ssl'A eq t{"p s rsrJE iPszlFqEls su'n put pgd -ssrl }Jg} ?}a}3 eql o: pel4Brpe tBra +I 'spF lJ;l 8!q {I$ E$'j} -r!oi ro sso1 piIE qxads pilltq€ q1r'1
{?qf,Bptaq elqe.ruequft
u,e 3o Brpt-alducr {!ir $iq Iq ru*urred*p drua6rau* *ql or lq$narq sua:6rerg 'o8* *1*a.*r e!trL'salsqtlp Fus *rsa*tP
l.:a:ir;fuaryoro] stq 3q "uo$lppz *l 'l: IS"$ gq qq'ta drarre pliort] Frr"lalul 3E: je {Y;t3} rrcppre JeIa}ssaerqarar q3p
!r *pau8e;p s gllni ueur egt{Jtl pp-:el&39 s $ {usr*
"{-anlfy,55tt4O&;-lr d.l fEa#fi;t-r,.s tuu w*to to $ qq 7 qaqJtJdFH4prqldg,6el ,ds.SqlfrH'rqsryt
-gt-
?/uJo'gyry'o1zyt6 udrqlsr
w#&ffisffi B$#? 'ufaldlureH UeT }*rPt3f,V
J?Ims;rrorqart} lq$lu qur{fr
31lJotrd luffsllvdfi}}*|
E n
g
E € E
E
$
&
urp iErlruarlrtrr rlq &r pr nolpprornffoq pus lrsn asf pfmf, mfUqrre rc$naraurlJo {& rrqrf, flgv Eq Sspnp tae&u geJ 3i:{sard erappt tol trm* rnog
"l' 'i itr4qil$ffi{ Enoa p{rpl rlrtsi p1rlor no(31 floq.{Wr- ro 4qx1 ifgV ${ rq rArtdrpc fuug a^p rq[ pnog '11
aq ars*q$u Bo,( * **rffi ffiffi;tr rdtrlil aluF eql r3 €qlq or {uag dn r*nq( Hmr /roH'01
Irro!lualr -:a1u;8u;.rnp pe4nil aq rrp*llns a:ap rr$Iur rmH *qrtna4s are l:ql qlqe amrurq.ad & Ot {nryt T
'y6r srd{r}I3 lqparry {*t$8ilr arE 1rqt qpry aanrnroyad lrol Ot rrrrnpl .8
qffiStluprytqad 'situt$fi efa|nJoatme flul
-Etrfiil u!)tu*rdslr*Izru g6 g4qlr ugefr*rr$rlag'L ,seu$Dor asll
uo Suprq vA) Erl s $oI op 1rtduq SqiA yA3 rq irqFq prq luerd tcrlt rrupilff *r{ IflSreH 9
'EEcr tmqrJo aalor ag iu; -srrra, m +p.rrl rprelmr l6qnqrr q*trar rgJ3E (I
:rapr eeeql uoiupryy43 sgqa*no[op rsduq rqif yA, E { arryq ?Eq :Frsq eqr rqqt lq,gpuryt
su/F,llw azuawa$w
gqt qu d no[ gnon +op1 FryFsoB nqruar.rarrn rml oq oraryyolm orqq? aq nol mno.rr treraul 6rE santpq 3.)tuard tupou; '€
i{Ilsrf JsJ slpul*qo a*aql sre.tq61 ;Eurssarp puu SulgttqJo t rc nq, q! E$Ilqluqs{1a.r *1q ro :redul s" arrsE <it,ip4g1 rmw rrlessp *Js3-j:!ac ary *u,!puap1 no,t plnax pgr,11
eI$* qr$ {rE ssrpl*i q)fil"r* rdpf$$er nod p1g ;asaql azp-uopd nod ppox *rog ;r{r:s uo*?llflquqeJ $,{uslil tu;rnp issipp* n*i p;anr* uoptdm:o;o sEiJ? teqia
'ssfirer"ris r**E$ -:o+d yc rsrtrreq *apn* pgreri +1ar*pon, pris rq$sr ufiriu -r!4ur qtl'rl srq,sue;l alt 'r3uqeq raqd s:q Ja esnr*g ;sl$sg tllnrlrlultil p$t Je{l?rtl Iureq E q4irt salslngsI alt
'q*'*} a6 a4dwm 4 a:uepgn$ ;r=.rs{qd pu* tuqm} fsqirrr}olmp }**rS a pspalr pu? qqs alttJc;Hs rJq eqr ue *5xfuq el Sma$s 1crr p1f *ptr t;31sgg p;ra1E*r aFI "4uts x{r rs Supltr *pq,tr paqd -uro, !3r{ *sFt?s6 -egxe.rdu Sulsrarp s ,AEr1 ol s"ruadde :gq "sqs'rr Su6sa:p 6E rlll*r axrels"rs{i" u${Eliru{.r spr*u pss alsq qle* ryl q$,s etroq er}}F *r$ ro {3Eq fi$ urss :uo.ry *qr lno s:a$g *l qqurrn *1 ag 'Sqq*op rrq Sufuu*lrl 6{nq3i1p r* g*p rx:f; E seq aH 'u$F?rrt{sprs1p Sq*lqt5r E;;r* &lrr:g JIp rels.tl$ilor$ep {ruxC 'uo}1*ntrE a ?$V ?i* Ba1.rn4
:rolcru s$o,r3
F{rs a*{, qrcq lq pr;rdurl st }jal sq3 ils uollvnlprao} 'eucl fs*arlrq qrr{ }a 6a"pq p:rec} Eupq ieu q q18a*rr* sIH '*pefu**ae;*ro1qqerm $IeH ?ffi*rs! E&!$ut lxale*ug qg "e8uz.r leuuae JFg :Esr"eg .latug :raa:8au g? *, g xralxq, lsurrn lsaer8ap 0I ol 0 :uolBual*a lsilAr l'JNt't,\ :uopeuord :r*r**p gg q 6 :aolpt4dns :S!gr ol $ :{1r}r6:!r}:rrlusfeg i&$qF sa*r*:p SI ot $ :BsrytrlrlJ laur*3xa :*aa:**p g $l S :usilc*sr rgluirtul :raa:&p 51 0t $ xaa:E S sg
rlers aqlq,r { r?qr pue irtrl sq or PePJerr flI pl?s rqrop a$ lsql ul.&l Ppl tJ.la$ qH :ptgsoq uops{Equrpr eqr u1 aq gr srq ag lq,n ro,(dw:qr qttrur o* rp*E aq lqr* pe1uapun pu srop eH .rra{ro lfl1rr euopxrapl rr! Joufiq iu-r,qcru1 ru pooE q put rrnqr te8B4 aH 'srr$raErnElf ary $ery prrE elqErrm E {uBrJ
ci s :ut:sEelxrluoIxalJ.I3Ffr!fitr:s4&ryI$j sE ]-tisEY $?1t al} $rl Efi'3'1 s$ trI
"lExs iltJs,tilq*Y qqr :Io I plrE '{unx} puB
liE*tr.gn *qr;a6q*E*rqr alErs {ilrojltqrY 3gi uo AJo eI}6i rygr*. *1ux*r* ?N T*i;{a prr sr*&43 slq rrI e1es5 quoier? eql l}s ZJo eaq apgtln $rq eq l{!q t?hllt) slrErtr fEEI:6r, {Ilq**l Ft{}Ed $,,!s{ Fsq prr? istr&r sg1-1 "*3:&g ssI 6r nWil trsqp FuB 's:a:fap 0, si sclrnpqr 'saa:tap SB oI uolxag rrp{rroqs sI fi61 tJrl *lq $, ftl6l1d esq 'a:uqeg Bq1 -t1$ 41sI' pac8 q4x ;IE sI ffisElsq tr4puels 4rsI3 csq F$D '*:r:*pq 8qpuul* puu 8uplp a*e@:cod sq{ ig'I pu* f;1 t3al s.rq {* s$tr,rIuera tg.t:t1 r*ra*rd *g'ppaeq-qfp q aH "Aft rygu srq * slpgcp drorq* * Wry :1T t:rri*'*s!$ Pal3r#i? slq uo sge*u8aa:le paa*du4 sa ge,n su'gap*d;eqs pue gxr*i rq*if !€J u$llsfl{ar p*qdury epug ffuper ul}Senre5 "epl* €pI }q1 ea #tr1qi ap"r Sqrduttlq dpur$uor sI Ftrc tualll:rcr;*re 1e+ *rds*g lqr pua ta&o: s1q punsre Suue***uarr dtfr4i:fp s*q aH 's$err?rE !s,tt+*s pur ,luac€p:r{ 14spfi1 "ued$ uor$r3t}? ro*d Eu;pn1:u; '$pgap t *Id8o: paimt[s arr![troJ dlt*p gtl galpldmoe
$rErs Js rrc{1B*"!3*qs ?f,aFa{r g*g pnao3ald p p{Ee rrs.}&"rqrsJ $stjqgg ifis:tsrr*tuap "H
'$$o!rEFJ IE r -eds par pxna:3-*xtfu $i ,fuf$*U3lp qpx 'uagd*rad u1 srpgsp a.!Eq saop iI{ '};rrrl$Ip *q sa*sq8 3q"rra** lrpq erlsE 'uolol^ Jo tsulreaq *;q u1 sryrrjsp o$ ssq eH ?a#I SI e ptsrsls $rp.r{ qslqrli rrs "{ggdl 'teqiJe* 6,{arroqe6; ry6y j$ xsplrl prllJr{ ;t{t pue €u1lsar.&osa*s pue pnldarrad €uJpat ai:*tiru [g$t siu ,*4ilJ*lul tu$I}3rr-rs{p q*ac.rqt suslfgas nottueijals! c,q:eao areld {oo} $cl}Et1l8&e l*
3]r{YrsH*iuSd rvruslrvd f}}}*
5*eliad{r].i|}
i# SrsArvruv SDtdtqJ 9t
8i...; H:.
5h*oEls3fit
&= ffi... ffi=
Fa *:r'.t- 1. %j
(stutod O)
UPJP
lsJ$ e alll speeJ Jo luapna pu (1ueae;e.r
J) ot,qs VdV pue Buqeuuol parnbag
islr.tici r)
poq6norql dpualssuocul
pue dpcarocur parpde (penap.r
I) ep(ls VdV pue bugeutrol palrnbag
(prod e)
poqOnolql fguaprsuocur
peldde [q par:oc st parpde (perrager
#) otlls VdV puP 6urpeuro; pelrnbag
(slurod g)
poq6norql
{pagssuoc pue {;peloc
patpde (luerrapl
1;) etlls VdV pue Ougeulol perrnbeg
(sp;od 9)
eLqs't
(stutod l-O)
uerp lsJu E eltl speal l{pa.uocur payoddns
rc pepoddnsun sl /AsrA ;o lurod :lcaloout Jo
realcun sr ocuoJaloJ lo saue4lo uo4ducse6
(sUrod u-Z)
iuorsnluoc ol speal /r1og Jo l9el
:ocuepna luatcuJnsur pue Ouruosea:
pa ^eB
{q peyoddns ,lI€lA lo lurod iacrpe.rd
IO SEerP pue ASeC o1 ureyed acuelaler
,o saue4 iAoq lnoqe uogeuxolur porgadng
(iutod Z-g)
i/lo[ pJPrl I/IAE qya uoqezruefuo
alqss;Jaur lacrperd
lo se€Je pue esec o1 ureped acuarelel
lo seue4 i oq noqe pap;rrold sllelap auos
(qutod 61-g)
uorlezue6ro eA[caJJa lacrpeld
lo sBaJB pue esEc o1 urepad acuoJoler
,o seue4 i oq lnoqe papp fueap qlepp
puE uorlEurrolur pauuad 'lequelsqnS
(slurod Ot.)
1uq:odur sr 1eq1 {qr* pue acrperd
aprn6 ecuele;a.r
lo saue{ qsqrn u! s{em
1o uor$ucsa6 'g
(sprod t-O)
uEJp lsru e el[ speal llpcerocur payoddns
.lo peyoddnsun sr /\ arn p prod lce.uocur ro
Jealcun sr esuerelsjlo satxe4lo uoBducsag
(prod rz)
/v\ollOl
ol Incgp luoqezue6to e^nceJleur
lacuepne luerlulnsur pue Euruoseel
polt^ef {q peyoddns
^^e!Alo tulod lpepnoid sile}ep leulurur
luo[euro;ur ;eng:adng
(slurod Z*)
i og pJelqrl e qU/\ uorlezue6lo elqoe$eur
laldurexa ue Iq payoddns leLpueuios
men;o prod iacuaregp euo pue
Ipre;ru.ls auo 6upnpur 'ecuajeJaj Jo aure4
qcea 1noqe pepnold qlelsp auos pue
uorpuuolur alenbepy
(sturod Ot,-g)
uollptluolul lo rrlou poo6 luoqezuefuo
altlcalla lse;durexa puB acuapr^a
Aq payoddns rvren
;o lurod isacuaragp oi l pue se0Ielrurs
orl l FBel le 6urpnpur 'acueJeleJ
Jo atrle4 qcee
lnoqe papho:d qrepp pue uoq.euJolur
lueuped 'leltuPlsqns
(slurod g;)
sasuere$p
8 Sanuelrufls ]o uorlE u4uapl
:ocualaral
Jo suJE4 qcee
;o uo4ducseg :lualuoc
1o adocg '7
(sUrtod O)
ueJp lsiu e aI[ speej i paplto"rd uoqpuuolul
snoauerxe ipe.uocur ro reeloun
ale suorlducsap pue suoriluueo
(rurod Z-l)
pap;rro.rd
uoqeuuolur ;engadns pue ;eurrurttr lstural
1o uorlducsap pue
uoruu[ep appurocul
(slurod g-e)
papnord uoqerrxolu! apnbape lsu.ueglo uorlducsap pue uouusep |eued
(sprod 9 = E&)
papnod uollpuxolur ap;dtuoc )eep ere
suusllo suoqducsep puB suorluueo
(sturod g)
suoBdunsse pu" lopotx
pue acusJejoJ
Jo aue4 'fuoeq1 lo uoruuueo '!
us;puo;ssalord sIsB-l
egeldacoeug
s11;1s puo;ssalord u! lus|cueo
e6e.enynqag
urs!lBuolssirlord luapFuocul
agqd*roy lBuo!3s3Jold
afieraay aAoqy
sluld 9g
rade6 acuara;ag lo euBrl
rotvtufltuc
urEJSoJd ]ueisrssv Adetaql leuotledrcog
