Journal #1 HBSE
Chapter 2: Theoretical Perspectives on Human Behavior
DIMENSIONS OF
Person and Environment
HUMAN BEHAVIOR
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Chapter Outline
Multiple perspectives for a multidimensional approach
Systems perspective
Conflict perspective
Exchange and choice perspective
Social constructionist perspective
Psychodynamic perspective
Developmental perspective
Social behavioral perspective
Humanistic perspective
The merits of multiple perspectives
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Multiple Perspectives for a Multidimensional Approach
Theories
Are useful for thinking about changing configurations of persons and environments
Are not mutually exclusive but overlapping and intersecting
Differ by focus and perspective
Evolve as world views expand and change to accommodate diversity and inequality
Used to guide practice interventions
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Systems Perspective
Sees human behavior as the outcome of interaction within and among systems of interrelated parts
Systems are made up of interrelated members (parts) that constitute an ordered whole
Each part of the system impacts all other parts and the system as a whole
All systems are subsystems of other larger systems
Systems maintain boundaries that give them their identities
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Systems Perspective Cont.
Examples of systems perspectives:
General systems theory
Ecological theory
Risk and resiliency theory
Complex systems theory
Chaos theory
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Systems Perspective Cont.
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Applications of the Systems Perspective
Identify and discuss the recent role transitions that may be affecting the McKinley family
How can a social worker assist the family to renegotiate changing or unsatisfactory role structures?
What types of networks might members of the McKinley family develop for support as they face their challenging role transitions?
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Conflict Perspective
Emphasizes that conflicts arise because of inequalities in the distribution of resources
Groups and individuals try to advance their own interests over the interests of others
Power is unequally divided, and some social groups dominate others
Social order is based on the manipulation and control of non-dominant groups by dominant groups
Lack of open conflict is a sign of exploitation
Members of non-dominant groups become alienated from society
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Conflict Perspective Cont.
Social change is driven by conflict, with periods of change interrupting long periods of stability
Examples of conflict perspectives:
Critical race theory
Intersectionality theory
Empowerment theories
Feminist theories
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Conflict Perspective Cont.
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Applications of the Conflict Perspective
Are there power arrangements or forces of oppression and the alienation that emanates from them that you can identify in the McKinley family?
What types of advocacy efforts might challenge the patterns of dominance in this family?
What are some techniques that social workers can use in their practice to heighten awareness of the power dynamics in relationships with the McKinleys and other clients?
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Exchange and Choice Perspective
Focus on the processes whereby individual and collective actors seek and exchange resources and the choices made in pursuit of those resources
People are rational and goal-directed
Try to maximize rewards / minimize cost
Values, standards, expectations, and alternatives influence the assessment of rewards and costs
Reciprocity of exchange is essential to social life
Power comes from unequal resources in an exchange
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Exchange and Choice Perspective Cont.
Examples of exchange and choice perspectives:
Social exchange theory
Rational choice theory
Social network theory
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Exchange and Choice Perspective Cont.
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Applications of the Rational Choice Perspective
Using Exhibit 2.5, describe the resources sought and exchanged within the McKinley family
How can a social worker help members of the McKinley family to renegotiate unsatisfactory patterns of exchange?
What social policy can increase the rewards for prosocial behavior in families like the McKinleys?
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Social Constructionist Perspective
Focuses on how people construct meaning, a sense of self, and a social world through their interactions with each other
Learn through interactions to classify the world and their place in it
Reality is shaped through interaction and is continuously reshaped
People perform for their social audiences, but they are also free, active, and creative
Social interaction is grounded in language customs, as well as cultural and historical contexts
Society consists of social processes, not social structures
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Social Constructionist Perspective Cont.
Examples of social constructionist perspectives:
Symbolic interaction theory
Postmodern theories
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Social Constructionist Perspective Cont.
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Applications of the Social Constructionist Perspective
What are the different ways that members of the McKinley family understand their situation?
How can a social worker engage the McKinleys in thinking about the environments in which their constructions of situations have developed?
How can a social worker be involved in the discussion with Ruth McKinley and her family to negotiate lines of action?
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Psychodynamic Perspective
Concerned with how internal processes such as needs, drives, and emotions motivate human behavior
Emotions have a central place in human behavior
Unconscious, as well as conscious, mental activity serves as the motivating force in human behavior
Early childhood experiences are central in the patterning of an individual’s emotions and, therefore, central to problems of living throughout life
Individuals may become overwhelmed by internal and/or external demands
Individuals frequently use ego defense mechanisms to avoid becoming overwhelmed by internal and/or external demands
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Psychodynamic Perspective Cont.
Examples of psychodynamic perspectives:
Drive or instinct theory
Topographical theory of the mind
Structural model of the mind
Psychosexual stage theory
Ego psychology
Object relations theory
Self psychology
Relational-cultural theory
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Psychodynamic Perspective Cont.
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Applications of the Psychodynamic Perspective
Discuss the emotional conflicts that Bethany McKinley might be experiencing as a result of her family situation
How can a social worker help the member of McKinley family develop self-awareness and self-control?
What does a social worker need to know about the family history to help Ruth McKinley resolve her issues with her daughter?
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Developmental Perspective
Focus is on how human behavior unfolds across the life course, how people change and stay the same over time
Human development occurs in clearly defined stages
Human development is a complex interaction of biological, psychological, and social factors
Each stage of life is qualitatively different from all other stages and builds on earlier stages
Moving from one stage to the next involves new tasks and changes in statuses and roles
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Developmental Perspective Cont.
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Developmental Perspective Cont.
Examples of developmental perspectives:
Life span or life cycle theory
Epigenetic model of human development
Life course perspective
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Applications of the Developmental Perspective
Identify some of the key developmental transitions of Bethany McKinley
How have the familial, cultural, and historical contexts in the timing and experience of developmental transitions impacted her situation?
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Social Behavioral Perspective
Human behavior is learned as individuals interact with their environment
Similar learning processes taking place in different environments produce differences in human behavior
All human problems can be formulated as undesirable behavior
All behavior can be defined and changed
Human behavior is learned by association of environmental stimuli, by reinforcement, by imitation, and by personal expectations and meanings
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Social Behavioral Perspective Cont
Examples of social behavioral perspectives:
Classical conditioning theory
Operant conditioning theory
Cognitive social learning theory
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Social Behavior Perspective Cont.
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Applications of the Social Behavioral Perspective
Consider the variety of learning processes by which Stanley and his mother have learned behavior
Is there any reason to consider the possibility of learned helplessness and the lack motivation for change in working with the McKinleys?
Are there social justice and fairness issues that a social worker should be aware of before engaging in behavior modification with any member of this family?
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Humanistic Perspective
Emphasizes individual’s freedom of action and search for meaning
Each person is unique and valuable
People always have the capacity to change themselves, even to make radical change
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Humanistic Perspective Cont.
Human behavior can be understood only from the vantage point of the phenomenal self—from the internal frame of reference of the individual
People make psychologically destructive demands on each other, and attempts to meet those demands produce anxiety
Human behavior is driven by a desire for growth, personal meaning, and competence, and by a need to experience a bond with others
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Humanistic Perspective Cont.
Examples of humanistic perspectives:
Carl Rogers and core conditions of therapeutic process: empathy, warmth, genuineness
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs
Transpersonal psychology
Existential psychology
Positive psychology
Capabilities approach
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Humanistic Perspective Cont.
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Applications of the Humanistic Perspective
What might be some differences between your assessment of the McKinley situation and Ruth or Stanley’s own assessment?
What are the strengths of each member of the McKinley family?
How does a focus on the strengths differ from a focus on the pathology in this family?
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Merits of Multiple Perspectives
All the theories seek to understand human behavior, but different phenomena are emphasized in each
Theories guide social work practice
Use multiple perspectives in integrated fashion to see many dimensions
Flexible and reflecting in thinking and “doing”
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.
Questions to Consider about the Theories:
What is the evidence for this statement?
Is this true for all people (for me, for my client, for other people I know)?
How can I use this information in my practice?
Is there anything left out of this argument?
What is the main point of this section?
Can I summarize the argument?
How does this relate to other evidence about this topic?
Hutchison, Dimensions of Human Behavior: Person and Environment, Fifth Edition. © 2015 SAGE Publications.