Human Resource Management Assignment 2. See Instructions and Build off of assignment 1
Staffing Organizations
Chapter 5:
External Recruitment
Copyright 2022 © McGraw Hill LLC. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw Hill LLC.
External Recruitment 1
Strategic Recruitment Planning
© McGraw Hill LLC
Planning, Communicating, and Implementing Strategic Recruiting
© McGraw Hill LLC
Defining Strategic Recruiting Goals 1
Goal 1: The Right Types of Applicants
Identify needs via organizational compentency and job requirements analysis
What types of applicants are most likely to have the required KSAOs?
Match recruitment messaging to culture, values, and job-spanning competencies
© McGraw Hill LLC
Defining Strategic Recruiting Goals 2
Goal 2: The Right Number of Applicants
Based on planning process
Expanding versus contracting demand
Selectivity of the system
Most applicants to be rejected requires extensive recruiting
Most applicants able to be hired requires less extensive recruiting
Labor market and competition for workers
© McGraw Hill LLC
Defining Strategic Recruiting Goals 3
Goal 3: Applicants at the Right Time
Immediate needs versus long-term needs
Time-to-hire
Degree of focus on a few specific applicants versus sorting through a large number of applicants
© McGraw Hill LLC
Open Versus Targeted Recruiting
Table divided into three columns summarizes choosing between open and targeted recruitment. Column 1 notes open and targeted. The column headers from 2 to 4 are marked as: Technique, advantages, and best when.
| Technique | Advantages | Best When | |
| Open | Advertising position with a message appealing to a wide variety of job seekers in a variety of media outlets that will reach the highest possible audience | Ensures that a diverse set of applicants are contacted and considered | Large numbers of applicants are required Pre-entry qualifications are not as important |
| Targeted | Focusing advertising and recruiting efforts by tailoring message content to attract segments of the labor market with specific KSAOs or demographic characteristics | Narrows the pool of potential applicants, allowing the organization to concentrate efforts on the most qualified Facilitates a more personal approach to each applicant | The organization needs specific skill sets that are in short supply Hiring for high-leverage positions |
© McGraw Hill LLC
Recruitment Planning: Administrative Issues
Incorporating external recruitment agency
Facilitate use of software platforms for applicant tracking
Advertising expertise
Allows organization to focus on core competency in messaging and developing relationships
Specifying timing (applicants at the right time)
Firm deadlines or “always taking applications”
Evaluating selection process timing
Recruitment budge and return on investment
© McGraw Hill LLC
Example Recruitment Budget
Should recruitment expenses be charged to HR or to the business unit using HR services?
Most organizations charge the HR department, possibly to encourage each business unit to use the recruitment services of the HR group
May result in the business unit users not being concerned about minimizing costs.
© McGraw Hill LLC
External Recruitment 2
Applicant Reactions
© McGraw Hill LLC
Applicant Reactions 1
Job and organization characteristics
The most important attraction features
Job characteristics
Wages
Opportunity for growth and development
Interesting characteristics
Organization characteristics
Prestige
Reputation for treating employees well
© McGraw Hill LLC
Applicant Reactions 2
Reactions to recruiters
Influence of recruiter vs. job characteristics
Influence of recruiter on attitudes and behaviors
Demographics of recruiters
Influential recruiter behaviors
Warmth and knowledge of the job
Reactions to recruitment process
Relationship of screening devices to job
Delay times in recruitment process
Funding of recruitment process
Credibility of recruiter during recruitment process
© McGraw Hill LLC
Consideration Related to Recruiters: Selection
Desirable characteristics of recruiters
Strong interpersonal skills
Knowledge about company, jobs, and career-related issues
Technology skills
Enthusiasm
Various sources of recruiters
HR professionals
Line managers
Employees
© McGraw Hill LLC
Diversity and Inclusion
Advertisements should depict diversity, especially among those in positions of authority
Advertising in publications targeted at women and minorities
Target older workers by flexible schedules, health and pension benefits, and part-time opportunities
© McGraw Hill LLC
Discussion Questions 2
List 10 sources of applicants that organizations turn to when recruiting. For each source, identify needs specific to the source, as well as pros and cons of using the source for recruitment.
© McGraw Hill LLC
External Recruitment 3
Communication
© McGraw Hill LLC
Comparing Choice of Messages
Table divided into four columns summarizes comparing choice of messages. Column 1 notes branded, targeted, and realistic. The column headers from 2 to 4 are marked as: Information conveyed, applicant reactions, potential drawback, and best for.
| Information Conveyed | Applicant Reactions | Potential Drawback | Best For | |
| Branded | An appealing description is developed based on marketing principles, emphasizing unique features of the organization | Positive view of the organization, increased intention to apply for jobs, and better prehire information about benefits of the job | Overly positive message may result in employee dissatisfaction after hire | Tight labor markets or higher-value jobs |
| Targeted | Advertising themes are designed to a attract a specific set of employees | Better fit between application message and specific applicant groups | May dissuade applicants who aren’t interested in work attributes featured in the message from applying | Specific KSAOs, or seeking a specific type of applicant |
| Realistic | Both positive and negative aspects of a job and organization are described | Some applicants self-select out; those who remain will have a better understanding of the job and will be less likely to leave | The best potential applicants may be more likely to leave | Loose labor markets or when turnover is costly |
© McGraw Hill LLC
Example Messages
Table divided into two columns summarizes example communication messages. The column headers are marked as: Type of message and example message.
| Branded | Example focus: Tech savvy financial services company Example message: Our organization lives on the cutting edge. We have been developing new methods for meeting client needs, including the most fully featured app-based portfolio management tools on the market. Employees will be part of a culture known for rewarding creativity, initiative, and innovation. |
| Targeted | Example focus: Recruiting new college graduates Example message: We provide the perfect place to start your career. Our training and development programs offer a world of opportunities to try out a variety of roles and functions, building out your skill set with each new assignment. |
| Realistic | Example job requirement: Frequent travel Example message: While working in this organization provides opportunities to do a variety of tasks, it does require extensive travel. New hires can expect to be on the road for at least one week per month, and sometimes more. |
© McGraw Hill LLC
Comparing Communication Media
Table divided into five columns summarizes comparing communication media. The column headers are marked from left to right as: Media type, reach, richness, interactivity, and credibility.
| Media Type | Reach | Richness | Interactivity | Credibility |
| Advertisements | High | Medium | Low | Low |
| Recruitment Brochures | Medium | High | Low | Low |
| Organizational Websites | Medium | High | Medium | Low |
| Videoconferencing | Low | High | High | Medium |
| Direct Contact | Low | High | High | Medium |
| Word of Mouth and Social Media | Medium | High | High | High |
© McGraw Hill LLC
Communication Media
Reach describes how many individuals can learn about a job through the method of delivery.
High: A source that can be seen by nearly anyone across many platforms
Low: A source that needs to be sought out and can be accessed by only a few individuals
Richness describes how media allow for a variety of methods for conveying messages
Interactive media sources can be customized to each respondent’s specific needs
Crediblity describes how messages are seen as honest, accurate, and thorough
High: Messages from employees and friends
Low: Messages just from corporate offices
© McGraw Hill LLC
External Recruitment 4
Applicant Sourcing
© McGraw Hill LLC
Applicant Sourcing
Individual recruiting sources
Target individual job seekers, direct from the organization and its representatives
Applicant initiated, general employment websites, niche employment websites
Social recruiting sources
Rely on relationships that employees have with current employees or those who would endorse the company
Employee referrals, social networking sites, professional associations
Organizational recruiting sources
Access to a large number of similar applicants
Colleges and placement offices, employment agencies, executive search firms, social service agencies
© McGraw Hill LLC
Metrics for Evaluating Recruiting Methods
Quantity
Quality
Cost
Impact on HR Outcomes
Employee satisfaction
Job performance
Diversity
Retention
© McGraw Hill LLC
External Recruitment 5
Legal Issues
© McGraw Hill LLC
Legal Issues
Definition of job applicant
Definition according to EEOC and OFCCP
Importance of establishing written application policies
Affirmative Action Programs
Guidelines of OFCCP for recruitment actions
Electronic recruitment
Usage may create artificial barriers to employment opportunities
Job advertisements
Fraud and misrepresentation
© McGraw Hill LLC
Ethical Issues in Staffing
Issue 1
Many organizations have adopted a targeted recruitment strategy. For example, some organizations target workers 50 years of age and older in their recruitment efforts, which includes advertising specifically in media outlets frequented by older individuals. Other organizations target recruitment messages at women, minorities, or those with the desired skills. Do you think targeted recruitment systems are fair? Why or why not?
Issue 2
Most organizations have in place job boards on their web page where applicants can apply for jobs online. What ethical obligations, if any, do you think organizations have to individuals who apply for jobs online?
© McGraw Hill LLC
End of Main Content
Copyright 2022 © McGraw Hill LLC. All rights reserved. No reproduction or distribution without the prior written consent of McGraw Hill LLC.
Because learning changes everything.®
www.mheducation.com