HIM 6522 Unit 6 Outcome 4

profileGENUINE EXPERTS
HIM6522ePortfolioPeerReviewRubric.docx

HIM 6522 – Final Applied Project

ePortfolio Peer Review Rubric

Use the rubric below to assess your classmate’s ePortfolio. Provide specific examples/feedback for each criteria.

Peer Reviewer:

ePortfolio being reviewed:

Criteria

Needs Improvement

Acceptable

Exemplary

Provide Specific Examples/Feedback

Artifacts & Layout

Artifacts do not relate to the outcome. The ePortfolio is difficult to read, unprofessional, and the design does not enhance the presentation.

Artifacts relate to the outcome. The ePortfolio is generally easy to read, professional, and appropriate colors and design utilized.

All artifacts are clearly related to the outcome. The ePortfolio is easy to read, professional, and colors and design enhance the presentation.

Integration & Application

Little or no evidence of integration of new learning and its application to an activity/skill/situation is provided. Additional research does not indicate understanding of the industry and professional changes that may occur.

Some integration of new learning and its application to an activity/skill/situation is described. Additional research indicates understanding of the industry and professional changes that may occur.

Integration of new learning and its application to an activity/skill/situation is described and examples provided. Additional research indicates thorough understanding of the industry and professional changes that may occur.

Self-Awareness, Insights & Growth

Little or no evidence of reflection or critical thinking, reference to self-awareness, insights or growth, and/or identification of areas for future professional development.

Reflection and critical thinking demonstrate self-awareness, insights and/or growth. Areas for future professional development are identified.

Shared insights and growth demonstrate deep reflection, critical thinking, and indicate transformational learning. Reflection articulates changes in thinking, beliefs, attitudes, behaviors, etc. and identifies areas for future professional development.

Organization & Comprehension

ePortfolio is not logical and clear, does not demonstrate comprehension of the purpose of the ePortfolio, and exhibits unacceptable writing quality.

ePortfolio is generally logical and clear, demonstrates comprehension of the purpose of the ePortfolio and exhibits acceptable writing quality.

ePortfolio is logical and clear, demonstrates thorough comprehension of the purpose of the ePortfolio, and exhibits writing quality that is clear, well organized and accurate.

To be completed by the Reviewer after peer review and synchronous meeting is complete:

Write a short, one paragraph reflection below on the peer review process. What method was used to conduct your synchronous meeting? What is your impression of the peer review process (i.e. what you learned, challenges encountered, etc.)? How does the process of conducting a peer review contribute to your personal/professional development?