Assessment 4

1/10/2020 Health Information System Cost-Benefit Analysis Scoring Guide

https://courserooma.capella.edu/bbcswebdav/institution/MHA-FP/MHA-FP5064/180700/Scoring_Guides/a04_scoring_guide.html 1/2

Health Information System Cost-Benefit Analysis Scoring Guide

CRITERIA NON-PERFORMANCE BASIC PROFICIENT DISTINGUISHED

Identify the components of a health information system.

Does not identify the components of a health information system.

Overlooks components of a health information system important to an accurate cost- benefit analysis.

Identifies the components of a health information system.

Identifies the components of a health information system. Provides a complete and accurate inventory of all key components.

Identify gaps between current health information technology and future needs.

Does not identify gaps between current health information technology and future needs.

Identifies gaps between current health information technology and future needs that are unclear or unlikely.

Identifies gaps between current health information technology and future needs.

Identifies gaps between current health information technology and future needs. Makes astute inferences from a rational assessment of future needs.

Analyze the costs of implementing an upgraded system.

Does not analyze the costs of implementing an upgraded system.

Provides an incomplete cost analysis that overlooks key considerations.

Analyzes the costs of implementing an upgraded system.

Analyzes the short- and long-term costs of implementing an upgraded system. Provides a detailed and insightful analysis, and articulates uncertainties or knowledge gaps that could affect investment decisions.

Analyze the benefits of implementing an upgraded system.

Does not analyze the benefits of implementing an upgraded system.

Provides an incomplete benefit analysis that overlooks key considerations.

Analyzes the benefits of implementing an upgraded system.

Analyzes the short- and long-term benefits of implementing an upgraded system. Provides a detailed and insightful analysis, and articulates uncertainties or knowledge gaps that could affect investment decisions.

Analyze the costs and benefits of not implementing an upgraded system.

Does not analyze the costs and benefits of not implementing an upgraded system.

Analyzes some of the costs and benefits of not implementing an upgraded system, but omits significant items that should have been understood through study activities.

Analyzes the costs and benefits of not implementing an upgraded system.

Analyzes the costs and benefits of not implementing an upgraded system. Also identifies knowledge gaps, unknowns, missing information, unanswered questions, or areas of uncertainty, where further information could improve the analysis.

1/10/2020 Health Information System Cost-Benefit Analysis Scoring Guide

https://courserooma.capella.edu/bbcswebdav/institution/MHA-FP/MHA-FP5064/180700/Scoring_Guides/a04_scoring_guide.html 2/2

CRITERIA NON-PERFORMANCE BASIC PROFICIENT DISTINGUISHED

Determine the impact of evolving business trends on system upgrade decisions.

Does not describe evolving business trends.

Describes evolving business trends.

Determines the impact of evolving business trends on system upgrade decisions.

Determines the impact of evolving business trends on system upgrade decisions. Explicitly identifies logical implications and consequence based on an insightful interpretation and synthesis of business trends; draws well- reasoned, logical conclusions supported by relevant and credible evidence.

Make implementation recommendations based on a cost- benefit analysis.

Does not make implementation recommendations based on a cost- benefit analysis.

Makes implementation recommendations, but the links to the cost-benefit analysis are unclear, questionable, or not well-documented.

Makes implementation recommendations based on a cost- benefit analysis.

Makes implementation recommendations based on a cost-benefit analysis. Draws rational, fully-justified conclusions from an insightful assessment of long-and short-term project costs, benefits, and risks.

Write clearly and concisely, using correct grammar, mechanics, and APA formatting.

Does not write clearly and concisely, using correct grammar, mechanics, and APA formatting.

Writing is unclear and disorganized, includes errors in grammar and mechanics that inhibit effective communication, or contains incorrect or improperly formatted source citations and references.

Writes clearly and concisely, using correct grammar, mechanics, and APA formatting.

Writes clearly and concisely. Grammar, mechanics, and APA formatting are error- free.