Health Policy Analysis
Lilstar0207
HealthCarePolicyAnalysisFinalPaperGradingRubric.docx· Health Care Policy Analysis Final Paper Grading Rubric
Health Care Policy Analysis Final Paper Grading Rubric
|
Criteria |
90-100 |
80-89 |
70-79 |
60-69 |
<60 |
|
Problem Statement – Defines the problem addressed in the analysis 20% of assignment grade |
Problem statement is one sentence in the form of a question Problem statement clearly focused Several options identified for solving the problem No grammatical or spelling errors In-line citation provided for sources and reference page is APA formatted |
Problem is in the form of a question but is not clearly focused. Several options identified for solving the problem Some grammatical &/or spelling errors In-line citation provided for resources, reference page contains some APA formatting errors. |
Problem is not in the form of a question or is not clearly focused. Options not related to problem Many grammatical and/or spelling errors. No inline references provided for resources. Many APA formatting errors on reference page |
Problem is not in the form of a question and is not clearly focused Only 1 option offered Grammatical and/or spelling errors throughout. No inline references and/or references not included in an APA formatted reference list.
|
No performance |
|
Background: Provides factual information needed to understand the problem 20% of assignment grade |
Background includes all necessary factual information. Information not directly relevant to the analysis is eliminated Tone of background is appropriate. No grammatical or spelling errors In-line citation provided for sources and reference page is APA formatted |
Background is missing some necessary factual information. Some extraneous information to the topic is included. Tone of background is mostly appropriate. Some grammatical &/or spelling errors In-line citation provided for resources, reference page contains some APA formatting errors
|
Many grammatical and/or spelling errors. No inline references provided for resources. Many APA formatting errors on reference page |
Grammatical and/or spelling errors throughout. No inline references and/or references not included in an APA formatted reference list.
|
No performance |
|
Landscape: Reviews the various stakeholders and their concerns 20% of assignment grade |
The landscape identifies all of the key stakeholders. The stakeholders’ views are described clearly and accurately. The structure of the landscape is consistent and easy to follow. The tone of the landscape is appropriate The reader has all of the information necessary to assess the options No grammatical or spelling errors In-line citation provided for sources and reference page is APA formatted |
The landscape identifies most of the key stakeholders. The stakeholders’ views are mostly described clearly and accurately. The structure of the landscape is fairly consistent and easy to follow. The reader has most of the information necessary to assess the options. Some grammatical &/or spelling errors In-line citation provided for resources, reference page contains some APA formatting errors
|
The landscape identifies some of the key stakeholders. Some of the stakeholders’ views are somewhat described clearly and accurately. The structure of the landscape is inconsistent but relatively easy to follows. The reader has some of the information necessary to assess the options. Many grammatical and/or spelling errors. No inline references provided for resources. Many APA formatting errors on reference page |
The landscape identifies 1-2 of the key stakeholders. Few of the stakeholders’ views are somewhat described in a barely clear or accurate manner. The structure of the landscape is inconsistent and difficult to follow. The reader has little information necessary to assess the options. Grammatical and/or spelling errors throughout. No inline references and/or references not included in an APA formatted reference list.
|
No performance |
|
Options: Describes and analyzes several options to address the problem 20% of assignment grade |
The options directly address the issue identified in the problem statement. The pros and cons of each option are clearly assessed. All of the criteria are applied to each option’s assessment. The options are sufficiently different from each other to give the client a real choice. All of the options are within the power of the client. No grammatical or spelling errors In-line citation provided for sources and reference page is APA formatte |
The options mostly address the issues identified in the problem statement. The pros and cons of each option are fairly clearly assessed. Most of the criteria are applied to each option’s assessment. The options are mostly different from each other to give the client a real choice. Most of the options are within the power of the client. Some grammatical &/or spelling errors In-line citation provided for resources, reference page contains some APA formatting errors
|
The options somewhat address the issues identified in the problem statement. Some of the pros and cons of each option are somewhat assessed. Some of the criteria are applied to each option’s assessment. The options are fairly similar not really giving the client a real choice. Some of the options are within the power of the client. Many grammatical and/or spelling errors. No inline references provided for resources. Many APA formatting errors on reference page |
The options barely or do not address the issues identified in the problem statement. 1-2 of the pros and cons of each option are barely assessed. Few of the criteria are applied to some of the option’s assessment. The options do not give the client a real choice. Most of the options are not within the power of the client. Grammatical and/or spelling errors throughout. No inline references and/or references not included in an APA formatted reference list.
|
No performance |
|
Recommendation: Offers one option as the best action to pursue 20% of assignment grade |
The recommendation offered is one of the options assessed. There is only one option recommended. A clear explanation is offered for the option selected as the best option, despite any of its flaws. No grammatical or spelling errors In-line citation provided for sources and reference page is APA formatted |
The recommendation offered is one of the options assessed. There is only one option recommended. The explanation offered for the option selected as the best option despite any of its flaws is mostly clear. Some grammatical &/or spelling errors In-line citation provided for resources, reference page contains some APA formatting errors
|
The recommendation is one of the options assessed. More than one option is recommended. The explanation offered for the option selected as the best option despite any of its flaws is somewhat unclear Many grammatical and/or spelling errors. No inline references provided for resources. Many APA formatting errors on reference page |
The recommendation is not one of the options assessed and/or more than one option is recommended. The explanation offered for the option selected as the best option despite any of its flaws is unclearly set forth. Grammatical and/or spelling errors throughout. No inline references and/or references not included in an APA formatted reference list.
|
No performance |
