Schizophrenia

profileelidash
FormalPaperDirectionsandRubricSpring220252.docx

2

NUR 210 Formal Paper Direction and Rubric for Students

DESCRIPTION: Consistent with the philosophy and organizing framework of the nursing program, this assignment is designed to promote written communication skills as well as self-reflection as it relates to caring for patients or family members who have an identified mental health disorder. Using evidence-based nursing journal articles, students will write a formal paper describing a specific mental health disorder, their interaction with someone that has this disorder, and reflect on this interaction and how they communicated with the individual. This project is worth 14% of the final course grade. The points on the Formal Paper assignment will be added to the theory grade if the minimum of 59.93 points is achieved.

1. The student will write a paper referencing at least two (2) evidence-based and peer-reviewed nursing journal articles that are no more than five (5) years old. The paper will be written in American Psychological Association (APA) format (7th edition) and should use professional language. The paper should include the following:

· Introduction (15 points):

Use the title of the paper as the level one header for the first paragraph.

Identify a mental health disorder from the list below:

· Anorexia

· Depression (may include post-partum depression)

· Anxiety

· PTSD

· Bipolar 1

· Schizophrenia

· Bipolar 2

· Substance abuse (emphasis on addiction disorder, not withdrawal)

Describe the characteristics/manifestations of the selected disorder.

Identify specific risk factors that may lead to the selected disorder.

Cite Boyd & Luebbert within the introduction if information on manifestations and risk factors is summarized from that textbook.

· Analysis (this is the next Level 1 header) (35 points):

Give an example of an individual (patient, family member, friend, peer) who has the mental health disorder identified in the introduction. Please do not use the real name of this individual or explain their relation to you (ex. use Mr. C. instead of Charlie).

Self-reflect on your initial thoughts/feelings when engaging with the individual. Include your emotional reaction to the experience.

This may be told from the first person and may include the use of “I”.

Compare the two (2) manifestations this individual has that correspond with the manifestations noted in the introduction of this paper.

What are two (2) stressors/triggers that worsened the identified mental health disorder for this individual?

Discuss specific interventions were used in this individual’s treatment plan?

Discuss two (2) additional interventions would you recommend for this individual’s treatment plan? If listing medications, list specific classes of medications for this disorder.

Analysis section must include one (1) citation from a peer-reviewed nursing journal article related to the above analysis criteria.

· Reflection (this is the next Level 1 header) (35 points):

Specifically identify one of these three stigmas; public, self, label avoidance (p. 4 of Boyd & Luebbert), associated with this mental health disorder and how others reacted to this individual’s disorder (labeling).

Discuss at least two (2) verbal therapeutic communication techniques that were used when interacting with this individual. MUST use the therapeutic communication techniques listed below (on page 10-11 of this document) and provide an example of how this communication technique was demonstrated.

Identify an adaptive and a maladaptive defense mechanism (see p. 7 below).

Describe one (1) maladaptive defense mechanism ( see p.7 below) and how it is used while in an acute exacerbation of the disorder. 5 pts

Describe one (1) adaptive defense mechanism or coping style ( see p. 7 below) that this individual may use and how it is used while in an acute exacerbation of the disorder. 5 pts.

Reflection must include one (1) citation from a peer-reviewed nursing journal article related to the above reflection criteria.

2. The paper will be three (3) pages maximum in length (not counting title or reference pages). Any additional pages will not be read, and the additional content will not be graded.

3. APA format is required for the paper including a title page, reference page, and in-text citations. The paper should be in

narrative form. This may be told from the first person and may include the use of “I”. Do not include tables, tabulated lists or bullet points. Use complete sentences. Level 1 headers must be used throughout paper. Use the title as the initial header, then Analysis, and Reflection APA 7th edition is now required. There is an APA 7th edition checklist in d2l and more information is available in the Student Nurse Resources manual.

4. Refer to the Student Nurse Handbook regarding point deductions for late submissions. Point deductions will be implemented for all and any missing components.

5. Refer to the Student Nurse Handbook regarding the Policy for Writing Assignments. Note that any re-admitted students must submit a new writing assignment when the course is repeated. Duplication of content from previous assignments is self-plagiarism.

6. Papers and articles must be uploaded into the designated Formal Paper assignment area in the main d2L shell. Articles should be submitted

as PDF (.pdf format) documents in the Article assignment area.

7. Papers must be submitted as a Microsoft Word document (.docx format) for instructors to be able to review them and make grading notations. Papers submitted as PDFs or other formats will result in point deductions.

8. Refer to Boyd: Essentials of psychiatric nursing, 3rd edition and the Student Nurse Resources manual for detailed information on defense mechanisms, therapeutic communication, and stigmas. Use this format for the mental health text:

Boyd, M. A. & Luebbert, R. (2023). Essentials of psychiatric nursing (3rd ed.). Wolters Kluwer. https://coursepoint.vitalsource.com/books/9781975154028

9. All sources for citations/quotes in the paper must be on the reference page. All references must be cited in the paper. Once your paper is submitted into the Formal Paper assignment box, you will be able to see your Turn-It-In score next to your paper. Turn-It-In scores above 30% will require extra scrutiny and will result in a minimum of five (5) point deduction.

10. Separate articles must be cited for both the Analysis and Reflection sections of the paper.

Print this rubric when writing the formal paper

2

Revised 10.14.24

Exceeds Expectations

Meets Expectations

Minimally Meets Expectations

Introduction (15 points)- do not use Introduction as level 1 header, use title of paper

15-11 pts

10-6 pts

< 6 pts

· Identifies a mental health disorder from the list provided. 2 pts

· Provides a complete description of the characteristics/manifestations of the disorder.

7 pts

· Describes the known risk factors that lead to the disorder.

6 pts

· Vague identification of the mental health disorder. 1 pt

· Minimal description of the characteristics/manifestations of the disorder. 2-5 pts

· Minimal description of known risk factors. 2-4 pts

· Lacks specific identification of mental health disorder.

· Lacks description of characteristics or manifestations of the disorder.

· Lacks any known risk factors.

Analysis (35 points)

35-24 pts

23-12 pts

< 12

· Gives a complete description of an individual who has the mental health disorder discussed in introduction. Does not name individual. 2 pts

· Describes student’s awareness of the mental health disorder and student’s initial thoughts/feelings when interacting with the individual. 8 pts

· Compare two (2) manifestations that this individual has that correspond with manifestations in introduction of paper. 5 pts

· Discuss two (2) stressors/triggers that worsened the disorder for this individual. 5 pts

· Discuss two (2) interventions used in individual’s treatment plan. 3 pts

· Recommends two (2) additional interventions.

3 pts

· Cites one (1) EBP peer-reviewed nursing journal (1 point) article less than five (5) years old (1 point). 2 pts total

· Information from the article is included in the analysis. 5 pts

· Citation matches the reference listed on the reference page. 2 pts

· Provides minimal description of an individual with the mental health disorder. Names individual identified or relationship to author. 1 pt

· Provides minimal description of awareness of the mental health disorder and initial thoughts/feelings when interacting with the individual. 3-5 pts

· Compares only one (1) manifestation that this individual has that corresponds with manifestations in introduction of paper. 1-3 pts

· Describes one (1) stressor/trigger that worsened the disorder for this individual. 1-3 pts

· Minimal discussion of interventions used in individual’s treatment plan. 1-2 pts

· Recommends one (1) additional intervention. 1-2 pts

· Minimal information from the article is included in the analysis. 2-4 pts

· Article cited is not a nursing journal or is more than five (5) years old. 1-2 pts

· Lacks identification of a specific individual with this disorder.

· Does not describe interaction with individual.

· No manifestations of the disorder are compared.

· No stressors or triggers are identified.

· No interventions or recommendations are discussed.

· Does not cite an EBP peer-reviewed nursing journal article less than five (5) years old.

· Information from the article is not included in the analysis.

· Citation does not match the reference listed on the reference page.

· Article cited is not a nursing journal and is more than five (5) years old.

Reflection (35 points)

35-24 pts

23-12 pts

< 12

· Identifies at least one (1) type of stigma ( Boyd & Luebbert, 2023, p. 4) associated with this disorder. 6 pts

· Discusses at least two (2) verbal therapeutic communication techniques that were used when interacting with this individual with an example of each (see Student Nurse Resources or pg. 10-12 below), 10 pts

· Describe one (1) maladaptive defense mechanism and how it is used while in an acute exacerbation of the disorder. Use list below (pg. 7-9). 5 pts

· Describe one (1) adaptive defense mechanism or coping style and how it is used while in an acute exacerbation of the disorder. Use list below (pg. 7-9). 5 pts

· Cites one (1) EBP peer-reviewed nursing journal article less than five (5) years old. 2 pts

· Information from the article is included in the reflection. 5 pts

· Citation matches the reference listed on the reference page. 2 pts 

· Minimal discussion on the stigma associated with the disorder. 1-3 pts

· Discusses one (1) therapeutic communication technique with one example that was used when interacting with this individual.

3-5 pts

· Minimal description of one (1) maladaptive defense mechanism that would assist this individual while in an acute exacerbation of the disorder. 2-4 pts

· Minimal description of one (1) adaptive defense mechanism or coping style that this individual may use while in an acute exacerbation of the disorder. 2-4 pts

· Minimal information from the article is included in the reflection. 2-4 pts

· Article cited is not a nursing journal or is more than five (5) years old. 1-2 pts

· No discussion of the stigma associated with the disorder.

· No therapeutic communication techniques and examples identified.

· Does not identify defense mechanisms.

· Does not cite an EBP peer-reviewed nursing journal article less than five (5) years old.

· Information from the article is not included in the reflection.

· Citation does not match the reference listed on the reference page.

Turn It In (5 points) The percentage for the most recently submitted paper will be utilized.

5

N/A

0

· < 30%

· N/A

· >30 %

· Citations are accurate but paper contains excessive quotes/citations

APA Format (5 points) These are not the entirety of the named errors-consult the APA manual, 7th edition.

5

4-3

2-0

· No errors

1-2 errors

· Spacing

· Title page

· Reference page

· Running head

· Pagination

· Abbreviations

· Citations

· Quotations

· Font size

· Sizing/Format

· Capitalizing common nouns

· 3 errors

· Spacing

· Title page

· Reference page

· Running head

· Pagination

· Abbreviations

· Citations

· Quotations

· Font size

· Sizing/Format

· Capitalizing common nouns

Writing Style, Grammar, Spelling, Punctuation (5 points) These are not the entirety of named errors-review with the Writing Center.

5

4-3

2-0

· No errors

1-2 errors

· Vernacular/colloquial or jargon use

· Run-on sentences

· Wrong synonym use

· Incorrect spelling of word

· Tense change within a sentence

· Awkward sentence structure

· Quotation use

· 3 errors

· Vernacular/colloquial or jargon use

· Run-on sentences

· Wrong synonym use

· Incorrect spelling of word

· Tense change within a sentence

· Awkward sentence structure

· Quotation use

Defense Mechanisms/Coping Styles

Defense mechanisms, also known as coping styles, are psychological mechanisms that help a person respond to difficult, emotional, or stressful situations. A person may use defense/coping mechanisms knowingly or unwittingly. Many defense mechanisms are maladaptive, such as splitting, projection, or acting out. Any defense mechanism may become a problem when used persistently and interferes with the person’s ability to interact with themselves and others.

Type of Mechanism

Defense Mechanisms

Definition

Example

Maladaptive

Acting out

Using actions rather than reflections or feelings during periods of emotional conflict.

A teenager gets mad at his parents and begins staying out late at night.

Adaptive

Affiliation

Turning to others for help or support (sharing problems with others without implying that someone else is responsible for them)

An individual has a fight with her spouse and turns to her best friend for emotional support.

Adaptive but can become pathological and maladaptive

Altruism

Dedicating life to meeting others (receives gratification either vicariously or from the response of others).

After being rejected by her boyfriend, a young girl joins the Peace Corps.

Maladaptive

Anticipation

Experiencing emotional reactions in advance or anticipating consequences of potential future events and considering realistic, alternative responses or solutions.

A parent cries for 3 weeks before her last child leaves for college. On the day of the separation, the parent spends the day with friends.

Maladaptive

Autistic Fantasy

Excessive daydreaming as a substitute for human relationships, more effective action or problem solving.

A young man sits in his room all day and dreams about being a rock star instead of attending a baseball game with a friend.

Adaptive

Compensation

Overemphasizing a characteristic to make up for a real or imagined failure or handicap.

I do not have time for dates, I am too busy with my ceramics.

Maladaptive

Conversions Reaction

Going to the opposite extreme to avoid carrying out an unacceptable or inappropriate impulse.

I am blind, I just suddenly went blind. The doctors can’t find out why.

Maladaptive

Denial

An attempt is made by persons to screen or ignore unacceptable realities by refusing to acknowledge them.

A woman, though told her father has metastatic cancer, continues to plan a family reunion 18 months in advance.

Maladaptive

Devaluation

Attributing exaggerated negative qualities to self or others.

A boy has been rejected by his long-time girlfriend. He tells his friends that he realizes that she is stupid and ugly.

Maladaptive

Displacement

Shifting the emotional component from one object, idea, or situation to another.

How many times have I told you to keep that bike out of the driveway!

Maladaptive

Dissociation

Experiencing a breakdown in the usually integrated functions of consciousness, memory, perceptions of self or the environment, or sensory and motor behavior.

An adult relates severe sexual abuse experienced as a child but does it without feeling. She says that the experience was as if she were outside her body watching the abuse.

Type of Mechanism

Defense Mechanisms

Definition

Example

Maladaptive

Help-rejecting Complaining

Complaining or making repetitive requests for help that disguise covert feelings of hostility or reproach towards others, which are then expressed by rejecting the suggestions, advice or help that others offer.

A college student asks a teacher for help after receiving a bad grade on a test. Every suggestion the teacher has is rejected by the student.

Adaptive

Humor

Emphasizing the amusing or ironic aspects of the conflicts or stressor.

A person makes a joke right after experiencing an embarrassing situation.

Maladaptive

Identification

Unconsciously modeling oneself after another person or group.

I have decided which shirt I want you to buy me. It’s that one.

Maladaptive

Idealization

Attributing exaggerated positive qualities to others.

An adult falls in love and fails to see the negative qualities in the other person.

Adaptive and can be maladaptive when used to often

Intellectualization

A mechanism by which an emotional response that normally would accompany an uncomfortable or painful incident is evaded using rational explanations that remove any personal feelings or personal significance from the incident.

The hurt over a parent’s sudden death is reduced by saying “They wouldn’t have wanted to live disabled.”

Adaptive and can become maladaptive if it keeps the person from critically assessing life choices.

Introjection

Form of identification that allows for the acceptance of others’ norms and values into oneself, even when contrary to one’s previous assumptions.

A seven-year-old-boy tells his little sister, “Don’t talk to strangers.” He has introjected this value into his self from the instructions of parents and teachers.

Adaptive and can become maladaptive if suppressing emotional awareness and increase the risk of medical conditions

Isolation of affect (AKA Isolation)

Separating emotional components of a thought, which may be temporary or long term.

A second-year medical student dissects a cadaver for her anatomy course without being disturbed by thoughts of death.

Maladaptive

Omnipotence

Feeling or acting as if one possesses special powers or abilities and is superior to others.

An individual tells a friend about personal expertise in the stock market and the ability to predict the best stocks.

Maladaptive

Passive aggression

Indirectly and unassertively expressing aggression toward others. There is a façade of overt compliance masking convert resistance, resentment, or hostility.

One employee doesn’t like another, so he secretly steals her milk from the office refrigerator. She is unaware of his hostile feelings.

Maladaptive

Projection

Attributing one’s own thoughts or impulses to another as if they originated in the other person.

It’s all your fault that I did not win in the contest.

Type of Mechanism

Defense Mechanisms

Definition

Example

Maladaptive

Projection Identification

Falsely attributing to another one’s own unacceptable feelings, impulses, or thoughts. Unlike projection, the individual does not fully disavow what is projected. Instead, the person remains aware of their own affect or impulses but misattributes them as justifiable reactions to the other person. Frequently, the individual induces the very feelings in others that were first mistakenly believed to be there, making it difficult to clarify who did what to whom first.

A child is angry at a parent, who in turn becomes angry at the child but may be unsure of cause of the anger. The child then feels justified in being angry at the parent.

Maladaptive

Rationalization

Offering a socially acceptable and logical explanation for an act or decision produced by unconscious factors.

I’m going to die of something, anyway, so why quit smoking?

Maladaptive

Reaction Formation

A mechanism that allows persons to act exactly opposite to the way they feel.

An executive resents his bosses for calling in a consulting firm to make recommendations for changes in his department but verbalizes complete support of the idea and its exceedingly polite and cooperative.

Maladaptive

Regression

A return to an earlier, more primitive form of behavior.

Since Jenny has been sick, she constantly cries for her mother.

Maladaptive

Repression

The involuntary exclusion of emotionally painful material from awareness.

I can’t seem to remember my supervisor’s name.

Adaptive

Self-assertion

Expressing feelings and thoughts directly in a way that is not coercive or manipulative.

An individual reaffirms that going to a ball game is not what she wants to do.

Adaptive

Self-observation

Reflecting feelings, thoughts, motivation, and behavior and responding to them appropriately.

A person notices an irritation at his friend’s late arrival and decides to tell his friend of his irritation.

Maladaptive

Splitting

Compartmentalizing opposite affect states and failing to integrate the positive and negative qualities of the self or others into cohesive images.

One friend is wonderful and another former friend, who was at one time viewed as being perfect, is now believed to be an evil person.

Adaptive

Sublimation

Channeling potentially maladaptive feelings or impulses into socially acceptable behavior.

An adolescent boy is angry with his parents. On the football field, he tackles someone very forcefully.

Adaptive and can be maladaptive depending on how it is used

Suppression

The intentional exclusion of material from consciousness.

I’m sorry I forgot. Now that you mention it, I do recall.

Maladaptive

Undoing

An action or words designed to annul disapproved thoughts, impulses, or acts in which the person relieves guilt by making reparation.

A father spanks his child, and the next evening brings home a present for him. A teacher spent only a little time writing an exam and then curved it beyond what was usual.

.

THERAPEUTIC COMMUNICATION TECHNIQUES

Technique

Definition

Example

Offering Self

Make yourself available to the patient.

“I’ll stay with you if you would like to talk.”

Open-ended Questions

Ask neutral questions, using when, where, how, and what, that encourage the patient to discuss concerns

“What makes the pain worse?”

Broad Openings

Allow the patient to take the initiative in introducing the topic using a specific open-ended question.

“What would you like to discuss?”

Offering General Leads

General leads let the patient know you are listening, engaged in the conversation and prompt the patient to continue.

“Go on…”, “I see.”

Verbalizing the Implied

Put into words what the patient has only implied or indirectly stated.

Pt: “It’s a waste of time to talk to my doctor.” Nurse: “Are you feeling that no one understands?”

Placing an Event in Time or Sequence

Clarify the relationship of events in time to view them in perspective

“When did your symptoms become worse in relationship to beginning your exercise program?”

Encouraging Comparison

Ask the patient to compare similarities and differences in ideas, experiences, or interpersonal relationships.

“Tell me how your blood sugar levels compared to when you were on the diet and when you were not.”

Opening Remarks

Use general statements based on observations and assessments of the patient to initiate discussion.

“I noticed that you seemed sad after speaking with the doctor.”

Restatement

Repeat to the patient the various content of his or her conversation typically using the same words. Restatement communicates that the nurse is listening but it also communicates that the nurse is playing an active role. Pick out the primary thought or feeling to restate. Overuse of this technique produces a “mimic effect”.

Pt: “I’m worried about my potential disability.” Nurse: “You’re worried about your ability to function.”

Acceptance

Encouraging and receiving information in a non-judgmental and interested manner. A nurse would use this to establish trust and develop a rapport with the patient.

Patient: “I have done something terrible.” Nurse: “I would like to hear about it. It is all right to discuss this with me.”

Reflection

Identify the various emotional themes in a conversation and direct these back to the patient.

Pt: “My husband may look at me differently after the surgery.” Nurse: “You’re anxious about how this surgery may affect your relationship with your husband.”

Focusing

Guide the patient to narrow in on key concerns. Can be termed “Exploring” when delving further into a subject, idea, experience, or relationship without probing.

“You’ve told me about your support system; tell me more about who will assist you when you first get home from the hospital?”

Seeking Clarification

Assist the patient to put into words unclear thoughts or feelings. Seeking clarification decreases the potential for the nurse to guess and/or assume incorrectly. The nurse can clarify the patient’s words or can clarify assumptions about the patient’s non-verbal behaviors.

“Help me to understand your expectations of the treatment.”

Giving Information

Share with the patient relevant information about his or her healthcare and well-being. Provide patient education.

“I’m going to review the side effects of this new medication.”

Looking at Alternatives

Help the patient see options and participate in the decision-making process.

“How do you think you can best stay on your diabetic diet?”

Silence

Allow for a pause in the conversation that permits the nurse and patient time to think about what has taken place. Non-verbal behaviors can communicate caring during silence. Silence can also focus the patient and call attention to what the patient has just verbalized. Time is bought to allow the patient to reevaluate or absorb the impact of a verbalization. Silence is also used when words are not an adequate response.

(No verbalization)

Summarizing

Highlight the importance of a conversation by condensing what was said. Can be used to evaluate learning. Summarizing represents a set of feelings that might have been communicated over a period of minutes. It is a paraphrase that pulls together several feelings.

“We have reviewed the side effects of this medication; how to take it, and how to store it.”

Confrontation

Presenting the patient with a different reality of the situation. If using this a nonjudgmental attitude is imperative as this technique may alienate the patient.

Patient: “My provider won’t talk to me.” Nurse: “I was in the room yesterday when you refused to speak to the provider”

Doubt

Expressing or voicing doubt when a patient relates a situation. A nurse uses this to guide the patient towards other explanations. This is used carefully only when the nurse is certain of the facts/details.

Patient: “My best friend hates me. She never calls me.” Nurse: “From what you have told me that doesn’t sound like you friend. When did your friend last call you?”

Interpretation

Putting into words what the patient is implying or feeling. This technique is used to help the patient identify underlying thoughts.

Patient: “I could not sleep because someone would come in and rape me.” Nurse: “It sounds like you were scared last night. “

Observation

Stating to the patient what the nurse is observing. This is used to point out to the patient that their behavior and actions are unusual for the patient.

Nurse: “You are trembling and perspiring. When did this start?”

Validation

Clarifies understanding of the situation and is used when a nurse is trying to understand a situation a patient tries to describe.

Nurse: “Let me see if I understand what you are saying.”