RISK MANAGEMENT
FIN 562 Risk Management
Professor Mark Shore
DePaul University
Week 10 Lecture Notes
Twitter @shorecap
Financial Innovation
• Cash markets to forwards, futures, options, other derivatives for commodities & financial, private equity and public equity = innovation
• Choices of insurance policies = innovation
• Increased choices of credit and lending = innovation
• Information & data transfer from printed books, letters, railroad, telegraph, telephone, radio, airplanes, television to the internet and high-speed digital transfer = innovation ➢Data & information is critical to financial services
• Fintech
The Cycle of Innovation
• Intermediaries = the function between two parties ➢“The middleman”
• Disintermediation = removal of the traditional intermediary ➢Bank Teller
➢Stockbroker
• Reintermediation = new technology intermediaries appear ➢ATM
➢Online trading
Fintech
Machine Learning (page 622-623) • Branch of artificial intelligence that allows
computers to learn without being explicitly programmed ➢Supervised Learning: builds rules to map inputs to
outputs ➢Unsupervised Learning: seeks patterns in the data ➢Reinforcement Learning: Has a goal/ task and learns the
task
• Uses tools to search for patterns. Some are traditional statistical tools such as linear regression, logistic regression and PCA
• An important tools that mirrors the way humans recognize patterns are neural networks
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 5e, Chapter 28, Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Examples of Applications • Translation from one language to another
• Fraud recognition
• Lending decisions
• Driving a car
• Also used for: ➢Market trading patterns
➢Customer behavior
➢Algos for online behavior
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 5e, Chapter 28, Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Blockchain • A distributed ledger (spreadsheet)
• When updated a new block is added = a chain of blocks
• A community of users can update it
• Hacking and fraud are extremely unlikely
• It is the technology behind bitcoin ➢Has other applications in finance, supply chain
management, law (smart contracts), regulation
• Permission = Private blockchains where people tend to know and trust each other
• Permissionless = Non-restrictive on users and people may not know or trust each other
Hashing 1
• Hashing converts text to a 64 string of numbers and letters
• Cannot be reversed
• Hashing is an important part of blockchain security systems
• Blockchain records are made tamper proof with a hash where one of the inputs is the hash of the immediately preceding block
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 5e, Chapter 28, Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Hashing 2
Hashing “Risk Management and Financial Institutions” (without quotation marks) using SHA gives:
1dcc48387a27cd95378b08ab26261b161a97c51a7c9146f3d3f f73710d656a3f
Adding the edition number so that ``Risk Management and Financial Institutions 5'' is input (again without quotation marks) produces a totally different hash:
117e1e23121f8db4b75d3e2a63d37ef052b11a63cf448721825 aadb882492c6b
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 5e, Chapter 28, Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Payment Systems (page 625)
• Many innovations already: credit cards, debit cards, mobile wallets
• Future use of biometric authorization
• Data collection and privacy issues
• Increasing use of digital currencies
• Will central banks use digital currencies?
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 5e, Chapter 28, Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
18000
20000
9/30/2013 9/30/2014 9/30/2015 9/30/2016 9/30/2017 9/30/2018 9/30/2019 9/30/2020
Bitcoin
Source: Coindesk, 11/12/20. Look at www.coinmarketcap.com
Lending Innovations • P2P lending is example of disintermediation
followed by re-intermediation ➢Aka Marketplace Lending
• Lending Club statistics published June 2017:
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 5e, Chapter 28, Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Grade A B C D E F&G
Ave Interest Rate
7.26 10.79 14.01 17.20 19.94 24.04
Ave Net Ann Return
4.86 6.29 6.69 6.32 5.59 4.52
Crowdfunding (page 631)
• Raising funding for projects on line • Donation based
• Debt based
• Equity-based
• Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs) are an alternative to IPOs where a company issues a new digital currency, usually in return for a digital currency such as bitcoin
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 5e, Chapter 28, Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Regulation
• Regulation is a barrier to entry for FinTechs
• Regulators do not want to stifle innovation and have come up with some plans that provide some regulatory relief for innovators
• But regulating FinTechs is a challenge (e.g., HFTs have caused problems for regulators)
• Can a computer program be regulated in the same way as the systems in a large bank?
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 5e, Chapter 28, Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
RegTech
• RegTech is the word used to describe the use of technology to improve compliance with regulations. Examples: • Screen customers and transactions in real time for
money laundering, terrorist financing, and sanctions
• Monitor staff communications using machine learning to determine outliers
• Use a library of global regulatory requirements
Risk Management and Financial Institutions 5e, Chapter 28, Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Risk Management Mistakes to Avoid
Risk Management and Financial
Institutions 5e, Chapter 29,
Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Big Losses (Business Snapshot 29.1, page 644-645) • Allied Irish Bank ($700 million)
• Barings ($1 billion)
• Enron’s Counterparties ($ billions in lawsuits)
• Hammersmith and Fulham ($600 million)
• Kidder Peabody ($350 million)
• LTCM ($4 billion)
• National Westminster Bank ($130 million)
• Orange County ($2 billion)
• Procter and Gamble ($90 million)
• Soc Gen ($7 billion)
• Subprime Mortgage Losses ($ tens of billions)
• UBS (2.3 billion)
Related to a single individual = internal controls
Risk Management and Financial
Institutions 5e, Chapter 29,
Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Risk Limits (page 643-645) • Risk must be quantified, and risk limits set
➢Procedures in places to control the risks
• Exceeding risk limits not acceptable even when profits result
• Do not assume that you can outguess the market
• Be diversified
• Scenario analysis and stress testing is important
Risk Management and Financial
Institutions 5e, Chapter 29,
Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Managing the Trading Room (page 647-649)
• Do not give too much independence to star traders
• Separate the front, middle, and back office
• Do not blindly trust models
• Be conservative in recognizing inception profits
• Do not sell clients inappropriate products
• Beware easy profits ➢Are there potential operational, credit, or market risks?
Risk Management and Financial
Institutions 5e, Chapter 29,
Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Liquidity Risk (page 649-651)
• The credit crisis of 2007 has emphasized the importance of liquidity risk
• Need to ensure that liquidity funding needs can be met in stressed market conditions
• Beware when many are following the same strategy ➢Will slippage occur to enter and exit the positions?
➢Liquidity Black Holes?
• Do not make excessive use of short-term borrowings for long-term needs
• Market transparency is important
Risk Management and Financial
Institutions 5e, Chapter 29,
Copyright © John C. Hull 2018
Lessons for Non-Financial Corporations (page 651-653)
• It is important to fully understand the products you trade
• Beware of hedgers becoming speculators
• It can be dangerous to make the Treasurer’s department a profit center
A Final Point (page 653-654)
• Three types of risk • Known
• Unknown
• Unknowable
• Flexibility is important ➢Avoid excessive leverage
➢Diversify across products and sectors
Risk Management and Financial
Institutions 5e, Chapter 29,
Copyright © John C. Hull 2018 23
Thank You