Evidence Table Worksheet
Student’s name
Instructor
Course
Date
I. PICOT Question: (P) In patients with risk factors for CAD (I) how does exposure to extreme life stressors (C) vs patients with no known risk factors (I) contribute to the development of an acute STEMI/NSTEMI (T) in a 1-year time frame.
Running head: Evidence Table Worksheet 1
Evidence Table Worksheet 2
1.
Will you have a comparison group or will subjects be their own controls?
I will make my derivations dependent on the comparison group I picked concerning the statistical meaning of the study results procured.
2. Is a ‘time’ appropriate with your question—why or why not?
Yes, for the reason that CAD patient require ample time when educated them about nursing interventions in order to record gradual change in risk factors.
II. Evidence Synthesis
|
(database) ex: Cochran
|
Study #1
|
Study #2
|
Study #3
|
Study #4
|
Study #5
|
Synthesis
|
|
(p) Population
|
Men and women between 25-60 years.
|
Included CAD participants were from all gender and age.
|
CAD participants from all age and gender.
|
90 CAD patients averaged 59.3 years.
|
Adults above or equal to 64 years.
|
Involved CAD participant from all ages and gender.
|
|
(I) Intervention
|
Teaching CAD patients about healthy living lifestyles.
|
Modifying CAD risk factors.
|
Fractional flow reserve – guided strategy
|
Flexible health program
|
Nutritious eating plan
|
Maintaining the selected lifestyle with healthy activities
|
|
(c) Comparison
|
Patients with no risk factors didn’t receive teachings on modifiable risk factors.
|
Improper risk factors modification
|
No use of educational programs
|
Mediations were not used to patients with no known risk factors.
|
Living unhealthy lifestyle.
|
Inactive and unhealthy lifestyle.
|
|
(o) Outcome
|
Estimated 24% decrease of risk for patients to develop CAD
|
CAD patients supported by patient interventions reduced their anxiety feeling, plus the progression of cardiovascular failure reduces with smoking cessation while also maintaining systolic pulse.
|
The fractional flow reserve-guided strategy helped specialists to monitor the health status of CAD patients.
|
participants who used mobile health mediations complied well with medicines intake that significantly reduced coronary heart disease progression.
|
The study showed DASH diets reduces the risk of developing heart failure by 30%
|
Healthy lifestyle reduced the rate of CAD progression
|
|
(t) time
|
7 years
|
1 year
|
5 years
|
30 days
|
over 21.5 years
|
6.9
|
III. Evaluation Table
|
Citation
|
Design
|
Sample size: Adequate?
|
Major Variables:
Independent Dependent
|
Study findings: Strengths and weaknesses
|
Level of evidence
|
Evidence Synthesis
|
|
Fung et al. (2016)
|
Quantitative, a prospective analysis
|
6817, satisfactory
|
CAD prevalence was the dependent variable while lifestyle modification was the independent variable.
|
Specialists have discovered CAD patients given healthy teachings about modifiable risk factors is reducing. Satisfactory research instrument was used to measure the quality. Study’s limitation was lack of accessing confounding factors, for instance utilization of medicines in management approaches, patient’s functional status, and the severity of prevailing concomitant
ailments.
|
Level I
|
The study’s results revealed that reducing CAD stressors improved the quality of life of patients. for example, researchers used an eating pattern as a modifiable appraisal instrument that is set up on the premise that there are inadequate appraisal tools that don’t require extensive time and examination in the forecast of CAD risk. The analysis was therefore projected to control the development of such instrument by showing a dynamically compelling methodology by which to separate CAD risk over dietary supervision.
|
|
Levy et al. (2018).
|
Analysis of literature using quantitative approach.
|
Unsuitable
|
Nutrition program was independent variable while CAD prevalence was dependent variable.
|
Study shows that, CAD patients find it convincing and useful in managing their conditions using phone services. An efficient investigation and meta-survey of 27 novel researches was included in the examination, and the findings revealed that having no distinctions in death rates about the phone plus a control population demonstrating a comparative dimension of sufficiency. The phone provision mediations came with benefits of reduce tension scores, lower systolic pulse, lower depression scores, quitting smoking, and less admissions.
|
Level III
|
The study shows how psychological stressors affected CAD patients exposing them to risk of future illnesses. When the underlying issue become the episodes of heart failure, then it becomes relentless to maintain patient care as an investment, even in circumstances where patient have been diagnosed with an uncommon cardiac arrest.
|
|
Lee et al. (2018).
|
Analysis of literature using quantitative approach
|
Inappropriate
|
The dependent variable was monitoring CAD patient’s status, and the independent variable was fractional flow reserve-guided strategy.
|
The wellbeing results of CAD patients can be easily analyzed with the partial flow reserve-guided technique. Articles beyond 5 years were selected as a way of measuring the quality of this study. The significant limitations are the execution of the faulty real instrument for checking and data examination and moderate headway of prominent obstructive physiology progresses achieving prohibitions in the midst of the data gathering process.
|
Level IV
|
The assessment was completed to make allowances concerning the meaning of standard screening in patients with CAD to screen their prosperity status and offer perfect interventions.
|
|
Giuliano et al. (2017)
|
Quantitative, a randomized controlled trial
|
90, quite adequate
|
Independent – medication reminders and education; Dependent – health status in patients with CAD
|
This examination demonstrated that patients would by and large show higher levels of exactness in their consistency element, suggesting that texts could be a doable methodology for enabling consistency with the dietary changes. The assessment's primary quality is the use of ANOVA in light of the fact that the example size is minimal. The restriction is that the data gathering process required only 30 days, which isn't adequate to consider each possible difference.
|
Level II
|
The overall self-revealed adherence didn't differentiate altogether between social events that got medication refreshes and educational works, educational text messages just or no texts by any means. Thus, content illustrating and phone support may be conceivably beneficial enhancements; notwithstanding, they will likely not be fruitful all alone. Regardless, utilizing the two methods may be considerably stronger than using either procedure uninhibitedly.
|
|
Blaum et al. (2019)
|
Quantitative study, prospective analysis
|
4,490, adequate
|
Dependent- incidence of CAD; Independent dieting approach
|
Coronary disease recorded only a 21% diminishing in risk with modifiable changes. The essential quality is using arranged data gotten in the midst of the hour of over 21 years. The principal impediment is the usage of just a single estimation tool to perform information examination.
|
Level II
|
A successful reduction in various contributing factors to cardiovascular failure may acquire an all the huger decline in the risk of heart failure. Lifestyle modifications are critical while alleviating CAD.
|
References
Blaum, C., Brunner, F. J., Kröger, F., Braetz, J., Lorenz, T., Goßling, A., ... & Waldeyer, C. (2019). Modifiable lifestyle risk factors and C-reactive protein in patients with coronary artery disease: Implications for an anti-inflammatory treatment target population. European journal of preventive cardiology, 2047487319885458.
Fung, T. T., Pan, A., Hou, T., Mozaffarian, D., Rexrode, K. M., Willett, W. C., & Hu, F. B. (2016). Food quality score and the risk of coronary artery disease: A prospective analysis in 3 cohorts. The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 104(1), 65–72. doi: 10.3945/ajcn.116.130393
Giuliano, C., Parmenter, B. J., Baker, M. K., Mitchell, B. L., Williams, A. D., Lyndon, K., ... & Levinger, I. (2017). Cardiac rehabilitation for patients with coronary artery disease: a practical guide to enhance patient outcomes through continuity of care. Clinical Medicine Insights: Cardiology, 11, 1179546817710028.
Lee, J. M., Doh, J. H., Nam, C. W., Shin, E. S., & Koo, B. K. (2018). Functional approach for coronary artery disease: Filling the gap between evidence and practice. Korean Circulation Journal, 48(3), 179-190. Doi: 10.4070/kcj.2017.0393
Levy, A. E., Huang, C., Huang, A., & Ho, P. M. (2018). Recent approaches to improve medication adherence in patients with coronary heart disease: Progress towards a learning healthcare system. Current atherosclerosis reports, 20(1), 1-9.