Order 1968796: Evaluating sources

profiletutorthammy
EvaluatingSourcesinstructions.docx

Evaluating Sources                                                              

 

Practically, you already have considerable experience evaluating sources: you instinctively draw on this experience when you choose a well-established website over an unfamiliar one, or an article by an expert instead of a brief essay in a popular magazine.  But to fully evaluate sources, you need to consider other issues as well.

 

For this assignment find 10 sources related to your research question. Choose 5 that are ONLY WEBSITES and 5 that are ONLY ACADEMIC SOURCES. Use the CRAP test described below to evaluate them in the provided chart.

 

The CRAP Test

To evaluate sources more effectively, ask yourself the following questions:

 

Currency

How recent is the information?

How recently has the website been updated (if website)?

Is it current enough for your topic?

 

Reliability

What kind of information is included in the resource?

Is content of the resource primarily opinion?

Does the creator provide references or sources for data or quotations?

If a website, what is the URL (.gov, .com, .biz, .edu, .org, .net)?  What does this tell you?

What does the design of the source tell you? Is it full of errors, disorganized, or is the writing of poor quality?

 

Authority

Who is the creator or author?

What are the credentials? Is she/he a recognized expert in the topic?

Have other authors referred to this work (positive citations)?

Who is the publisher or sponsor? Are they reputable?

What is the publisher’s interest (if any) in this information?

Are there advertisements on the website?

 

Purpose

Is the source trying to persuade you to do something or think in a certain way?

If so, does it include factual information to back up its opinions?

What might be the potential biases of the source? 

Why was the document or website created, and who is its intended audience?

Is the creator/author trying to sell you something?

 

Use these questions to evaluate your chosen sources and fill in the charts provided