Media/Website Evaluation

Evaluating Web Sites: A Checklist Fall 2012  University Libraries  www.lib.umd.edu/ues/guides/evaluating-checklist Why evaluate web sites? No one judges the quality or accuracy of information found on the World Wide

Web before it is published, so you must evaluate what you find for yourself. Some sites are created by experts; for example, the University of Maryland Libraries site is authored by librarians who have expertise in the field of information science. However, the vast majority of World Wide Web sites are designed and authored by non-experts.

Directions:

1. Carefully read through and answer each question directly on this form. 2. After filling out the page print it. 3. Attach a printout of the first page of the web site you are evaluating to this checklist and hand the

packet in to your professor.

What is the URL or web address of the web site you are evaluating? http:// What is the title of the web site?

Authority and Accuracy Anyone who knows a little HTML coding and has access to a server can create and load a web page. It is important to find out the author’s identity and his or her qualifications or expertise in order to determine the credibility and reliability of the information.

Who is the author of the web site? I couldn’t tell The author is:

What authorship clues did the URL (web address) provide? Check all that apply: company (.com) non-profit organization (.org) acadmic institution (.edu) country-specific site (e.g., .uk) U.S. government agency (.gov) personal web page (e.g., www.jamieoliver.com) U.S. military site (.mil) other? Please describe: network of computer (.net)

What are the qualifications of the author or group that created the site? I couldn’t find this information. The author’s qualifications are:

File: Evaluating Websites: A Checklist University of Maryland Libraries * UES * 10/2012

Purpose and Content Determine the purpose of the web site by looking closely at the content of the information. Some sites provide links to information (e.g., an About Our Organization or Mission Statement page) detailing the purpose in creating the web site, while the purpose of others might not be obvious at first. Take the time to thoroughly explore a web site to determine if the information is mostly subjective (biased or opinionated), objective (factual), or mixed.

What is the purpose of the web page or site? Check all that apply:

A personal web page A company or organization web site A forum for educational/public service information A forum for scholarly/research information For entertainment An advertisement or electronic commerce A forum for ideas, opinions, or points of view Other – please explain:

In your own words, briefly describe the purpose of the web site:

What does the web site provide? Check one:

Balanced, objective or factual information Biased, subjective or opinionated statements. Are the arguments well supported? Yes No Both objective and subjective information I couldn’t tell Other – please explain:

Does the web site provide any contact information or means of communicating with the author or webmaster?

No Yes, the site provides:

File: Evaluating Websites: A Checklist University of Maryland Libraries * UES * 10/2012

Currency The currency or regularity of updating information is vital for some types of web sites and not so important for others. For example, web sites that provide historical information, such as the presidential papers of George Washington, do not have to be updated as often as sites that provide news stories or stock market information.

When was the web site last revised, modified, or updated? I couldn’t tell It was updated:

Is currency important to the type of information available on this web site? Please explain:

Is the site well maintained?

I couldn’t tell Yes No

Are links broken (do you receive error messages)? I couldn’t tell Yes No

Design, Organization, and Ease of Use

Design, organization, and ease of use are important considerations. Web sites can provide useful sources of information. However, if a web site is slow to load, or difficult to navigate, search, and read, its contribution and usefulness will be lost.

In your opinion, how does the web site appear overall? Check all that apply: Well designed and organized Poorly designed and organized Easy to read and navigate Difficult to read and navigate Help screens are available Help screens are unavailable A search feature/site map is available A search feature/site map is unavailable

1. URL:
2. Site Title:
3. Check Box3: Off
4. Check Box4: Off
5. Site Author:
6. Check Box6: Off
7. Check Box7: Off
8. Check Box8: Off
9. Check Box9: Off
10. Check Box10: Off
11. Check Box11: Off
12. Check Box12: Off
13. Check Box13: Off
14. Other:
15. Check Box15: Off
16. Check Box16: Off
17. Author Qualifications:
18. Check Box18: Off
19. Check Box19: Off
20. Check Box20: Off
21. Check Box21: Off
22. Check Box22: Off
23. Check Box23: Off
24. Check Box24: Off
25. Check Box25: Off
26. Other2:
27. Site Purpose:
28. Check Box28: Off
29. Check Box29: Off
30. Check Box30: Off
31. Check Box31: Off
32. Check Box32: Off
33. Other3:
34. Check Box34: Off
35. Check Box35: Off
36. Text36:
37. Check Box37: Off
38. Check Box38: Off
39. Site Currency:
40. Currency Importance:
41. Check Box41: Off
42. Check Box42: Off
43. Check Box43: Off
44. Check Box44: Off
45. Check Box45: Off
46. Check Box46: Off
47. Check Box47: Off
48. Check Box48: Off
49. Check Box49: Off
50. Check Box50: Off
51. Check Box51: Off
52. Check Box52: Off
53. Check Box53: Off
54. Check Box54: Off
55. Group55: Off