Ethics and Politics

Ethics and politics

Review 3 of 900 words

-About 900 words

Analyze and try to solve the following ethical problem by testing two approaches. Then judge the respective effectiveness of each of these two approaches.

Instructions:

-Don't forget to highlight a conflict of values from the dilemma you will analyze.

- Pay attention to the quality of the language and the clarity of your words.

-Write the text to the computer

-Write down the total number of words in your essay at the end of the essay

Question :

From the following article, explain, with the help of relevant theories seen in class, what should be the role of the state?

https://globalnews.ca/news/6757176/montreal-homeless-shelters-coronavirus-covid-19/

Introduction :

SA: Introduce problematic: explain what the article says. It will give you an explanation as to why this article is an issue.

SP: problematic

SD : plan

Author 1:

1- Thesis defended

2- Premises

3- Principles

4- Partial conclusion

5- Situation 2-3

6- Conclusion

Author 2: Ditto

Synthesis : not an opinion piece; concept analysis Recommendation

Conclusion: summary more open

Rawls :

Liberalism: legitimacy state/rights

Contract is fictitious: justifying laws

1. Justice as fairness:

a. Meritocracy: awarded fct for merit

b. Natural inequality

c. Sailing of ignorance

d. Equality before rights

e. Difference: destitute, therefore, just

Nozick :

1. Inviolable rights

2. Status: Night watchman

3. Ownership: product belongs to you

4. Consent

5. Minimal: Police, Courts and Army

6. Repair

Synthesis :