Ethical Issue in Working Standard and Condition

Criteria

(4) Exceeds Expectations

(3) Meets Expectations

(2) Approaches Expectations

(1) Does Not Meet Expectations

Identifies Ethical

Dilemma

Clearly and objectively details the circumstances that created the ethical problem; identifies the central ethical dilemma and its importance.

Provides an adequate explanation of the circumstances that created the ethical problem; identifies the central ethical dilemma.

Leaves out some important details when explaining the circumstances that led to the ethical problem; describes the central ethical dilemma in vague terms.

Fails to explain the factors that led to the ethical problem and misinterprets the core ethical dilemma.

Considers Stakeholders

Identifies and prioritizes the interests of all relevant stakeholders.

Identifies the interests of most of the relevant stakeholders.

Identifies and prioritizes the interests of a few relevant stakeholders.

Fails to identify any of the relevant stakeholders or interests.

Analyzes Ethical Alternatives

Identifies a number of alternatives and predicts their associated consequences in detail.

Identifies at least two alternatives and predicts their associated consequences in detail.

Identifies only one ethical approach to the ethical dilemma and its associated consequence.

Fails to provide adequate explanation of an ethical approach to the issue.

Chooses an Action and Articulates a Plan of Implementation

Chooses an action that creatively addresses the ethical problem and articulates a skillful plan for implementing it.

Chooses an appropriate action for addressing the ethical problem and articulates a practical plan for implementing it.

Chooses an action that does not directly address the ethical problem and articulates an impractical plan for implementing it.

Does not identify and/or explain appropriate decision for a course of action.