Policy evaluation stage 3

Component Subcomponent Component

Grades Total

Stage 1 Content

Details of the policy: What is being proposed, why is it being proposed, who is proposing it, where is it being proposed, who is being targeted, etc.

7

Stage 1 Writing Details

Essay is clear, easy to follow, flows well, with few spelling and grammar errors 3

Stage 2 Content

Economic framework used to describe expected effects and summary of 5 related empirical papers

14

Stage 2 Writing Details

Essay is clear, easy to follow, flows wells, the summary of the papers is well integrated, and there are few spelling and grammar errors

6

Stage 3 Content

Reflection on the policy, including your opinion, whether you think it will be suggessful, whether there are aspects of your setting that imply the expected effects will be different from other settings, would you suggest any improvements for the policy

7

Stage 3 Writing Details

Essay is clear, easy to follow, flows wells, is written in a logical and coherent manner, and there are few spelling and grammar errors

3

Final Version Content

All previous suggestions have been incorporated 7

Final Version Writing Details

Essay is clear, easy to follow, flows wells, is written in a logical and coherent manner, and there are few spelling and grammar errors

3

10

20

10

10