Annotated Bibliography Assignment - Due in 9 Hours. Need A+ Work

profilejhayes
ENGL603_Annotated_Bibliography_Grading_Rubric.docx

ENGL 603

Annotated Bibliography Grading Rubric

Criteria

Levels of Achievement

Content 70%

Advanced

Proficient

Developing

Not Present

Quality of Articles

18 to 20 points

Has 6 professional articles from a broad range of dates and a variety of critical approaches

13 to 17 points

Has 6 professional articles; date range might be a little narrow or have little variety of critical approaches

1 to 12 points

Either fewer than 6 professional articles (but more than 3), very limited date range, or no variety in critical approaches

0 points

3 or fewer professional articles

Argument Summaries

14 to 15 points

Thorough and sophisticated summaries; helpfully and clearly lay out the articles’ arguments

6 to 13 points

Good summaries of articles and evaluation; one or two summaries might be a little short or a little unclear

1 to 5 points

One of the following: missing a summary of one or more of the articles; most summaries are too short; three or more summaries are unclear

0 points

Missing or confusing summaries

Evaluation

7 to 7 points

Incisive evaluation of all articles explaining how they might contribute to final research paper product

4 to 6 points

Good evaluation of most articles (might miss one) that gestures toward how article might contribute to final research product

1 to 3 points

One of the following: missing three or more evaluations of articles; unclear or confusing evaluation; little to nothing to say about how articles might contribute to final research product

0 points

No evaluations included

Criteria

Levels of Achievement

Structure 30%

Advanced

Proficient

Developing

Not Present

Grammar and Mechanics

8 to 10 points

Rare grammar errors or stylistic flaws

5 to 7 points

Some minor grammar issues

1 to 4 points

A range from minor grammar errors that occur throughout paper to major errors (score depends on level of grammar errors present)

0 points

Egregious grammar errors that mar most sentences

Documentation

7 to 8 points

Perfectly cited material (both in-text documentation and bibliography entry)

5 to 6 points

Mostly correct citations (in-text documentation and bibliography entry); may have some minor errors

1 to 4 points

Poor citations (citations are attempted, but major errors in either punctuation or format)

0 points

No documentation (in-text citations or bibliography)

Page 1 of 2