help

Essay #2 Peer Review Questions

Your Name:

Writer you are reviewing:

1) In the box below, copy and paste what you believe the thesis statement to be.

Rate the strength of the thesis from 1-10 (ten being the highest rating) and share with him or her why the rating was given.

Points to think about:

· Does the thesis discuss how the ad delivers it’s point of view (the rhetorical strategy)?

· Does the author not only mention what the ad is selling but what idea the ad is selling?

My Response:

2) Rate the description of the image on a scale from 1-10.

Consider these questions in your rating:

· Are the descriptions useful to the analysis?

· Are the descriptions specific and use creative language?

· Are the descriptions easy to follow and organized?

My Response:

3) Rate the analysis of the image on a scale from 1-10.

Consider these questions in your rating:

· Does the author analyze specific components (rhetorical strategies) of the advertisement?

· Does the author speculate as to why the ad used this rhetorical strategy?

My Response:

4) Copy and paste or specifically indicate at least one sentence that is confusing to you because of its grammar and flow – even if you aren’t sure what the error is. Please explain why you have marked this sentence as one that needs improvement.

My Response:

5) Ask your classmate one question you have about the essay.

My Response:

Save this document with the following naming convention:

FirstName LastName PR2 Reviewed Name

For example: Megan Howard PR2 John Smith