Reiki

Provides a detailed and clear biomedical overview of the paper topic, including affected population(s), etiology, diagnosis, prognosis, comorbidity.

4points

Provides information on biomedical overview with need for minor improvements or expansion.

3points

Provides information on biomedical overview with great need for improvements, expansion, or correction.

2points

Information is largely undeveloped, or incorrect.

1points

Provides a detailed and clear Chinese Medicine overview of the paper topic, including etiology, common pattern presentation, zang fu pathology and other associated classifications such as six channel or 4 level theory context.

4points

Provides information on Chinese medicine overview with need for minor improvements or expansion.

3points

Provides information on Chinese medicine overview with great need for improvements, expansion, or correction.

2points

Information is largely undeveloped, or incorrect.

1points

Provides detailed overview of treatment interventions from a biomedical and Chinese medicine approach, including cautions, contraindication of treatments.

4points

Provides information on biomedical and Chinese medicine treatment interventions with need for minor improvements or expansion.

3points

Provides information on biomedical and Chinese medicine treatment interventions with great need for improvements, expansion, or correction.

2points

Information is largely undeveloped or incorrect.

1points

Provides detailed overview of impact of lifestyle, diet and other miscellaneous factors in both progression of the disease or practices to support resolution.

4points

Provides information on lifestyle, diet or miscellaneous factors with need for minor improvements or expansion.

3points

Provides information on lifestyle, diet or miscellaneous factors with great need for improvements, expansion, or correction.

2points

Information is largely undeveloped, or incorrect.

1points

Writing is well thought out, detailed, clear, and at a graduate level. Punctuation, grammar and spelling are without mistakes. Accepted biomedical and CM sources are cited using

4points

Writing is at a high level with clarity in development of ideas and organization, with room for minor improvements. Minor punctuation, grammar or spelling mistakes. Minor

3points

Moderate errors in punctuation, grammar, spelling. Writing level, development or expression of ideas needs improvement. Citation incomplete or improper format.

2points

Low level writing that is unclear, disorganized, poorly developed or uncited theories. Many grammatical, spelling or punctuation mistakes. Citation is absent or

1points