Arts 205

Discussion Thread: Ancient Religion

MANAGE DISCUSSION

This is a graded discussion: 100 points possible

due Nov 3

11 unread reply.11 reply.

In Chapters 1-3 of the course textbook, you have been studying the role that religion played in ancient civilizations. In this discussion, you will choose two primary source documents and consider the similarities and differences between the religion of the Hebrews (which has greatly influenced Western Civilization), and another ancient religion.  Choose One of the Following to compare with Psalm 8: (See the  Discussion Resources section for links).

Either: Egyptian Book of the Dead: Hymns of Praise to Ra Or: Incantation to Ishtar (from Mesopotamian Civilization) Compare and contrast one of the above documents with: Hymns of Praise to Yahweh - Psalm 8

As you read, look for points of comparison and contrast. Our textbook editors suggest that the Hebrews drew from both Mesopotamian and Egyptian civilizations (2-1), not only practices of law and society, but also in terms of religious beliefs, going as far as to suggest that the Hebrew people were not truly monotheistic until Moses introduced that idea (2-2). Your initial thread should have a clear thesis statement and should respond to the following questions:

Comparison/Contrast: What are the most telling similarities and differences between the two documents?

Basic analysis: What do you think of the textbook editors' conclusions regarding Hebrew monotheism? (Use Genesis to support your arguments)

Biblical Evaluation: Based on your own understanding of the Bible, Christianity, and the nature of man, what reasons do you think might account for the similarities within the texts? (Provide specific Scriptural support)

Draw from the primary source documents and Scripture for the majority of support. Use textbook and lectures for background info only. No outside sources allowed.

Discussion Resources

· Egyptian Book of the Dead: Hymns of Praise to Ra Links to an external site.

· Incantation to Ishtar Links to an external site.

· Psalm 8 Links to an external site.

· Strong's Concordance Links to an external site.

Please review the  Discussion Assignment Instructions Download Discussion Assignment Instructions

Minimize File Preview