discussion 3
I. J. Computer Network and Information Security, 2019, 1, 62-69 Published Online January 2019 in MECS (http://www.mecs-press.org/)
DOI: 10.5815/ijcnis.2019.01.06
Copyright © 2019 MECS I.J. Computer Network and Information Security, 2019, 1, 62-69
Cyber Security and Analysis of Cyber-Crime
Laws to Restrict Cyber Crime in Pakistan
Qamar Atta Ul Haq Computer Science Department, ISP University 9-KM Bosan Roads, Multan Pakistan +92-61-111-786-477
PAKISTAN
E-mail: [email protected]
Received: 11 November 2018; Accepted: 14 December 2018; Published: 08 January 2019
Abstract—This research report analyses the plebeian
interest and tension hostility between privacy and cyber
security in Pakistan. I explore the areas threaten by
hackers in means of ATM card hacks and social data
sniffing. It explores the challenges for Cyber security
belongs to privacy and data protection.
Index Terms—Cyber security, cyber jihad, hacking
aggression, Intrusion detection system and intrusion
prevention systems, Intellectual property, Computer
security, Cyber terrorism, Security risks, Encryption,
Hacking Vulnerability.
I. INTRODUCTION
The process or steps are adopted to protect the system
against the criminal malefactor or unauthorized access
and the use of data of military, industrial and business is
called cyber security. A criminal way and activity that is
adopted by a person and a group through the use of
computer and internet called cyber crime. Cyber issue is
pulling everyone's attention of World Wide [1].
Charles Babbage was the professor of the Cambridge
University in 1837 build the mechanical, modern
computer called “Analytical Engine” and that work is
surprisingly more than 100 years of future work, it was
an astonishing moment of his work. The united State
military give the official approval in 1943 to first
computer called ENIAC (Electronic Numerical Integrator
and Computer). The ENIAC possess the very large
requirements as a collection of the 18,000 of the vacuum
tubes which designed to give the computation power of
100,000 amounts of pulses in per second, which speed
300,000 more and faster than human power of processing
the information. The prediction of the Gordon more in
1965 that the amount of transistors on a computer chip
will be double in every year. The first Hackers friendly
tool that is OSINT (Open Source Intelligent) and it was
web enabled [1]. The cyberspace (Communication over a
linked billion of computers via the internet) was firstly
occur in 2011.Hacker is the expert person, that expertise
in computer system, the hacker used that knowledge to
access the data in unauthorized and illegal way. The
research group of UK (United Kingdom) IWM
(information warfare monitor) in 2009 tells the existence
of the “Ghost Net" that is a collection of compromised
1000 computers in more than 103 countries, that infected
and victimize the world wide countries [1, 4, 19].
Mafia Boy in 2001 from the Montreal is a student of
15 years age created the DOS (Denial of Services) attack
on the online web based companies that result a financial
damage of $1000000 dollars. Syrian air force defense
system in 20017 sudden disabled by the cyber-attack.
The first worm introduced in 1949 by the John von a
mathematician during proposing the “self-replicating
automata" and that will remain in experimental stage [2].
The annual cost of the global cybercrime is predicted
that it can be extended approximate from 3$ TD (Trillion
Dollars) till 2015 to 6$ in 2021. The cyber security
industry and market in 2015 spending the $75 billion
Dollars which is extended and grow to an unbeatable
record in history in 2018 that is $101 billions of dollars
and the prediction about the cyber security cost that is
growing to $170 billion dollars in 2020. The European
countries, making the directives used to protect the
information in systems from threats, EGDPR (European
General Data Protection Regulations and the Second
directive are NIS (Network Information Security).
Pakistan is currently focusing the national when Pakistan
army facing a threat from terrorists as well as
international cyber security threats coming from the
China and India it is a strategic war for the survival of
Pakistan [2, 13, 21].
Pakistan facing two wars, one against with the
terrorists and second with the issues of cyber security.
The services of internet available since from 1990 in
Pakistan. Pakistan population is 200,813,818 in 2018,
which is 2.97% of the total world population. Pakistan
have 6 th
position in the list of the country by population,
and population density is 250 per km2 and 39.6% of the
population is urban. Pakistan population 200,813,818
and from that there is 44.3424 million of internet users in
Pakistan and also there is mobile subscribers adding
1million a month, approximate 16.5 million users browse
and use internet from there mobiles while others are
broadband subscribers. In Pakistan 80% smart phones
found less than price of the $100 [2, 6, 7, 8].
ICT (Information and Communication Technology)
fastest developing industry in Pakistan. , Corresponding
to the report of ITU (International Telecommunication
Cyber Security and Analysis of Cyber-Crime Laws to Restrict Cyber Crime in Pakistan 63
Copyright © 2019 MECS I.J. Computer Network and Information Security, 2019, 1, 62-69
Union), In 2001 almost 1.3% of population was using
internet and by the end of 2006 that the estimated figure
was increased 6.7% of population, till the end of 2012
this figure increases to 20million. While ISPAK (Internet
Service Provider Association of Pakistan) said that in
2012 the figure is about 10million [3]. Separate from
these reports IT THINK TAMKS asserted that the figure
should be crossed 30million.3G and 4G available in
Pakistan from April 14, 2014.The Government of
Pakistan earned from 3G and 4G from auction is about
$930 million and $210 million. According to PTA
(Pakistan Telecommunication Authority) annual report
2018 shows that 50 million cellular subscribers, 56
million 3G/4G subscribers, 3 million basic telephony
subscribers and 58 million broadband subscribers [3, 7,
16, 20].
A. Identifying The Security Back Holes And Laps In Pakistan Institutions
Russian and Chinese hackers are involved in trying for
breaching the Pakistani bank's security by obtaining the
people ATM card information on the Darknet or a dark
website. According to my Research 2000000 ATM card
information were sold on a Darknet and the price of per
ATM card information that is sold is $150. I am
suggesting the 20000 Pakistani banks to improve security
systems that is used for international transaction through
ATM cards or any other medium. Improve Monitoring
system for employee that is involved in dealing to sale
ATM card information on a dark website
II. LITERATURE RIEW
There are 50 countries who introduced their strategies
for cyberspace and for cyber security. The most vital
infrastructure about protection towards the cyber security,
there are 25 countries who introduced and show the
policies of cyber security, United States of America,
Algeria, United Kingdom, Australia, Switzerland, Brazil,
Sweden, Canada, Spain, Estonia, Singapore, Finland,
Russia, France, Poland, Germany, New Zealand,
Hungary, Norway, India, Netherlands, Italy, Malaysia,
Japan.
The cyber security and the probability appraisal cyber
security threats to the Distributed control system (DCS),
supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA)
networks and Industrial Control Systems (ICS)
introducing organizational and Government groups
1. CSP (Cyber Secure Pakistan) 2. NUST (National University of Sciences &
Technology)
3. CERTs (Computer Emergency Response Teams) 4. EAS (Enterprise Application Systems) 5. EMS (Energy Management Systems) 6. ISO/IEC 17799 (Information Security
Management)
7. PCSRF (Process Control Securities Requirements Forum)
8. SPP-ICS (System Protection Profile for
Industrial Control Systems)
9. ISA-TR99.00.01-2004 (Security Technologies of Manufacturing and Control Systems)
10. NIAC (The National Infrastructure Advisory Council)
11. NCS (The National Communication System) 12. NCSD (National Cyber Security Division) 13. CSSP (Control Systems Security Program) 14. ISA (Instrumentation, Systems, and Automation
Society)
15. NIST (National Institute for Science and Technology)
16. NERC (The North American Electrical Reliability Council)
17. US CERT (The United States Computer Emergency Readiness Team’s)
18. ISACs (Information Sharing and Analysis Centers)
19. CND (The Computer Network Defense) 20. CSIS (Center for Strategic and International
Studies)
21. CERT/CC (Coordination Center) 22. NIST (National Institute for Standards and
Technology)
23. IDS (Intrusion Detection System) 24. CIC (Created by the Cyber Innovating Center) 25. NICERC (The National Integrated Cyber
Educating Research Center)
26. PTA (Pakistan Telecommunication Authority)
III. TYPES OF CYBER CRIMINALS AND ATTACKS
Cyber criminals are those people (programmers) who
use their expertise and skills to commit a crime on
internet and stole someone information or any other
sensitive data for the purpose of blackmailing and for
money called cyber criminals. Usually this are
programmers who used their skills in illegal activities we
know that is a crime [4].
Fig.1. Types of Cyber Criminals [4, 19]
Cyber-attack is any kind of abhorrent actions that is
taken by the cyber-criminal on computer through internet
to stole and get someone sensitive information and data
for illegal purpose. Cyber criminals adopt different
methods and way so that they can force any of computer
user to attract towards bait and catch in a trap. There are
following some types of a programmers possible attacks
through the internet on a computer.
64 Cyber Security and Analysis of Cyber-Crime Laws to Restrict Cyber Crime in Pakistan
Copyright © 2019 MECS I.J. Computer Network and Information Security, 2019, 1, 62-69
Fig.2. Types of Cyber-Attacks [4, 19, 14, 9]
While the Governments of Pakistan emphases on
terrorism war NAP (National Action Plan), at that time
another threat feels to be appearing as purview of visible
horizon that is cyber security. Today modern life
depends on the online services and online shopping
because we are intellectual that is the reason of
information and personal data at risk of stealing our
personal information and data from hacking and others
related to the unauthorized access, that major issue
confronting the Pakistan. Since our cell phones and
computers are victims of more than 8 countries, whose
intelligence agencies are interfering in our personal life
and the aggression of hacking and for money increasing
day by day and we are enduring suffering from that
situation, now Pakistan focusing the cyber security to
protect the rights and personal data from stealing
someone.
The first spam email brought in 1978, when it was
transmitted to the ARPANET (Advanced Research
Project Agency Network). The UK police caught the
student as he hacked FBI email in 2005 and some
documents of NATO are hacked in Afghanistan and
“Mafia Boy” attacks on DOS (Daniel of Services).In
2000 Swedish NORDEA bank victim and about $100000
was stolen.
Cavelty in 2010 prepared annotations about the triune
or multiple interlacing preaching about the domain or
field of cyber security. Cyber is affix predicating the
cyber space and pertains to the ECN (Electronic
Communication Networks) virtual realism by oxford in
2014. Cyberspace destined and contrived as an IE
(Information Environment) by Friedman in 2013. The
present-day cyber security standard is FIRST the Forum
of Incident Response Security Teams and IEEE Institute
of Electrical and Electronics Engineering and NIST
National Institute of Standers and Technology and the
ICANN The internet Corporation for Assigned Names
and Numbers.
HAIMS and CHITTESTER works result that to reduce
the effects of cyber-attacks. HONEY POTS amuse the
attacker from attaining the vital system information.
CORDESMAN works on cyber threats. KLIMBURG
works on cybercrime. MCHUGH examining the dealings
of treble speed of networks. KING ET, he inquire about
the cyber threats. LOPEZ suggest the security services
about smart grid. WHITMAN and MATTORD works on
information protection. MARTIN and RICE their works
about cyber domineering. MILLER trying to secure the
system. NELSON and NASH trying amending to control
system. NISSENBAUM improving the cyber security
schemes. ANSS describe and handle cyber-attacks.
DHILLON who introduced the idea of data security.
ERIKSSON who stops penetration of information.
ARQUILLA introduced the transmutation of war into
cyber war. CLARKE give the concept of cyber warfare.
Pakistan, now starts working about cyber security
because Pakistan facing two wars one about terrorism
and second to protect, secure and protect their people
privacy, data and information from accessing outside the
country intelligence agencies and the most enemy threat
facing Pakistan from India one from India interfering
Karachi and Baluchistan matters to split the Pakistan and
second accessing the digital data from American and
India and others countries intelligence agencies. For that
purpose Pakistan increases his security policy and
starting awareness to the people through the seminars
and through universities.
1. PIPS (Pakistan Institute of Parliamentary Services)
2. PISA (Pakistan Information Security Association)
3. NSA (National Security Agency) 4. Senator Mushahid Hussain particularly
elaborate the cyber security threats.
5. PKCERT (National Emergency Team) 6. NAP consist the cyber security 7. Cyber security taskforce 8. According to SAARC Pakistan should have to
be initiate the steps against cyber security
9. PECO
NSA gives report to Pakistan about the security gaps
in Pakistan and digital data may stole from the terrorists
and use for the terrorism activity. On the behalf of the
NSA report Pakistan senate defense committee and PIPS
AND PISA take charge on the consequence of opposing
Pakistan through cyber security on July8, 2013.Now that
time, Pakistan first time take stand to oppose the cyber
threats belong to Pakistan. Pakistan information security
association hire the experts from NUST, LUMS, RIPHA
University and the internet providers.
The defense committee organized the seminar in
which parliamentarian are invited for awareness and
introduced the seven points of the plan related to the
cyber security and threats by committee chairman
M.Hussain Sayed
1. M\O defence 2. HEC 3. LUMS 4. NUST 5. PISA 6. CSTF 7. Ministries law 8. Ministries interior 9. Foreign affairs 10. FIA 11. NAB
Cyber Security and Analysis of Cyber-Crime Laws to Restrict Cyber Crime in Pakistan 65
Copyright © 2019 MECS I.J. Computer Network and Information Security, 2019, 1, 62-69
IV. CYBER CRIME
In November 2018 due to a cyber-attack 624
customers of different 22 banks are losing their money
which is 11.7 million. A legal report from the FIA is that
the data of 19,865 ATM cards were sold on a dark web.
The action of using computers and networks as an
instrument for the interest of illegal criminal activity.
Cyber-crime in tensest threats are knocking the doors of
Pakistan but regrettably grapevine Pakistan laws are
calm and waiting for execution. ICT seventh exposition
and admitted CONNECT exhibition Karachi and
reported approximate 200 cases of hacking and
blackmailing in 2012. Pakistan facing the following
crimes
1. Physical detrimental a computer system 2. Fiscal crimes 3. Logic dud 4. Cyber smut 5. Virus and worms assail 6. Email burlesquing 7. DSN 8. Cyber calumniation 9. Salami assail 10. Cyber haunting 11. Information diddling 12. Unsanctioned accession to computer systems
and networks
13. Online hazarding 14. Password smashing 15. Blackmailing for stealing electronic information
The situation of cybercrime in Pakistan is very
dangerous but still there is no strict laws. In 2011
approximate 25 instances will occurs and registered with
concerning to cybercrime. Facebook profile and account
information stealing through hacking as the intention of
blackmailing for some benefits and unreal Facebook
accounts of girls is used to necessitate for retaliation
because from the girls side family had refused the
marriage offering, but still there is no cyber laws in
Pakistan.
In 2015 Pakistan originate steps to secure Pakistan
from the cybercrime and threats of cyber security related
issues with the team or organization of PSA and Ultra
Spectra (pvt). April8, 2015 the conference asserted
organized coordinated with the coaction of NUST-
SEECS and more than fifty fence-sitters means
stakeholders on call and this conference become leading
Asian consequence for all fence-sitters admitting
Government, data protection professed means
professionals, data security enterprisers,
telecommunication sector security steering plus
administrators, trusting sector and information
technology sector to contribution perceptivity into the
most recent demonstrated creations and concepts. The
schedule discussion for cyber security of Pakistan is to
search as entirely the interior or internal and extraneous
or international community of interests admitting
ICANN, APNIC, Internet social club, Google, territorial
CERTs, world-wide investigators on the issue to arrive
and contribution of their undergoes as substantially. The
canonic intention and causative posterior this conference
is too conscious the people of Pakistan about the
cybercrime and cyber terrorism, for that purpose cyber
invulnerable Pakistan comprising a chain of building
training, workplaces, cognizance sittings, contenders,
keynote oratory, panel conversation, security discussion
by illustrious internal and external industry professionals.
Proficient awareness sittings and holding the succeeding
training sittings, CHFI (Computer Hacking Forensic
Investigation), mobile diligence incursion testing,
contrary engineering malevolent program, Linux origin
instruments workplace by Pakistan, system protection
workplace through ICANN and APNIC. LEA workplace
in Pakistan, kid security through the internet society.
Cyber-crime arises quickly in Pakistan. Concording to
the cyber-crime wing (CCU), furcate of FIA Federal
Investigation Agency, exclusively events and exclusively
are notifiable and reported in the unit, in 2007 cyber-
crime related events reported to CCU is 62 and in 2008
the events rapidly increases to 287 and after passing laws
from the parliament of Pakistan the ration of cyber-
crimes were deteriorated from 2009 117 events and 2010
and half exclusively 73. Later on the ratio increases again
and rapidly from the previous and antecedently ration of
events that is 2011 to 2012 is 411 events , 2013 is
290,2014 320 with tiny blackmailing,2015 is about 345,
in the start of 2016 there were 89 till march events are
reported to FIA.[7, 8]
Fig.3. Hackers Attack in Pakistan
Edward Snowden a brave man scrupulous to disclose,
reveal and fetched out how the USAs NSA National
Security Agency spotting on majority countries in the
world. Such spotting evidently constituted by USAs
political, economic and combatant or military
international vantage. The fifth nearly and most spotted
on country is India, straight a lot than Russia and China.
Conceiving the India is the USAs momentous
collaborator, spotting on the India that is infract of trust
for USA, therefor USA spotting all the countries except
India. Iran in the crowning list 14 billion sets up of the
USA intelligence and administrative unit, the second
number of Pakistan is came approximate 13.5 billion, the
third number of the Jordan is about 12.7 billion, in fourth
position Egypt comes estimated figure is 7.6 billion and
66 Cyber Security and Analysis of Cyber-Crime Laws to Restrict Cyber Crime in Pakistan
Copyright © 2019 MECS I.J. Computer Network and Information Security, 2019, 1, 62-69
the fifth number come of the be loving country of USAs
India approximate is 6.3 billion.
Cyber-crime as well intromit directing viruses on
distinct systems, sending calumniation contents. Pakistan
committee of the cyber-crime is following features can
be
1. Computer territory direct approaches attacking to the others computer systems
2. Computer districted used as a tool to confide imposter and the banned hazarding or gaming
3. Computer are used as a supportive for storage felonious and purloining of data or
information.
V. CYBER LAWS IN PAKISTAN
Cyber laws or the inferior conversationally and
national laws of Pakistan is a consideration that capsulate
the effectual consequences associated to the
manipulation and the use of communicatory, relations
and the disseminative expressions of electronic network
entropy gimmicks or devices and engineering’s. The
following Pakistan cyber laws for criminals
1. ETA The Electronic Transaction Act (1996). 2. ETO The Electronic Transaction Ordinance
(2002)
3. PACCA Perspective analysis of Cyber-crime act (2006)
4. EFTA The Electronic Funds Transfer Act (2007) 5. PECOP The Prevention of Electronic Crime
Ordinance Pakistan (2007)
6. PECOA Prevention of Electronic Crime Ordinance Act (2008)
7. PCCCOA Prevention and Control Cyber Crime Ordinance act (2009)
8. FTOA The Fair and Trial Ordinance Act (2012) 9. PECOA Prevention of E Crimes ordinance Act
(2013)
10. PPOA Protection of Pakistan Ordinance Act (2014)
11. EDPCCOA The Electronic Documents and Prevention of Cyber Crime Ordinance Act
(2014)
12. PECOA Prevention of Electronic Crimes Ordinance Act (2015)
13. AECOA Amendment Electronic Crimes Ordinance Act (2016)
There are five primary points of 2016 cyber-crime act
is the following
a. First, it is a crime or illegal activity to transmit or send a messages or pictures to any persons e-mail
address.
b. Second, the constabulary and the police force, Federal investigation agency and any other
agency will not necessitate the inquiry
endorsement and warrant to search.
c. Subordinate incision or section 17 and 18 political critique and the political manifestation should be
criminalized and illegitimate.
d. Subordinate incision or section 31, Government can Barricade and take accession to some internet
site online or current informant.
e. Subordinate incision or section 26, ISP’S, eateries, promenades, buildings, offices airports and the
bus stations anyplace with the internet adroitness
should be required to accommodate and hold
information and data for three months.
Table 1. Cyber-crime Punishments in Pakistan [7, 8]
Crime Immurement/imp
risonment
Penalization/pen
alty
Data damage 3 3-Lac
Criminal data access 3 3-Lac
Criminal access 3 3-Lac
System damage 3 3-Lac
Electronic forgery 7 7-Lac
Electronic fraud 7 7-Lac
Misuse of devices 3 3-Lac
Unauthorized access to
code 3 3-Lac
Malicious code 5 5-Lac
Defamation 5 5-Lac
Cyber stalking 3 3-Lac
Cyber spamming 6-months 50,000
Spoofing 3 3-Lac
Pornography 10 10-Lac
Cyber terrorism life
10-million
VI. CONSCIOUSNESS CURRICULUM
Pakistan organizing the awareness seminar for their
people and the main purpose to aware the people of
government and private sectors to secure their
information and important personal data.
Cyber Security and Analysis of Cyber-Crime Laws to Restrict Cyber Crime in Pakistan 67
Copyright © 2019 MECS I.J. Computer Network and Information Security, 2019, 1, 62-69
Table 2. Cyber-crime Conferences in Pakistan [7, 8, 9]
ISSUES/CONSEQUENCES Involvement
Cyber Security Conference 2015 in Multan many
Lecture about superior menace of Cyber
offenses and Cyber Terrorism 80
Cyber Security and protection disputes and
suffices answer (intervening Level
Management)
200
Cyber Security and protection disputes and
suffices answer (grayer or old Level
Management)
85
predilection about Cyber offenses (secondary
Level Management) 40
Equal crusades and exploits to fighting
Banking associated Cyber offenses and
currency Laundering (precedential
administrators of Banking Sector)
200
Cyber Security and protection disputes and
suffices answer (at Karachi) 200
Cyber Security and protection disputes and
suffices solutions (at Lahore) 20
Litigating or Processing of beginning Cyber
offense event and case by NR3C 30
Satisfactory standard Efforts to fighting ISP’s
associated and corresponding to the Cyber
Crimes
20
Cyber offenses or crime For SIG, at FIA
Academy and pedantic 200
Cyber offenses challenges situation and
Solution at Islamabad 200
Entropy or information Security and Cyber
offenses at Islamabad 250
Information protection security and Cyber
offenses at Islamabad 200
Conference on Cyber Security at Karachi 300
One day workshop on Cyber Security and
protection Challenges and disputes &
Solutions
52
Lecture on the origination of Introduction to
Cyber Crimes
60 Trainee
and beginner
Judges of
Punjab
Training and educating Polices of Agency
officers in the area or field of Digital
Evidence and manifest Islamabad, Peshawar,
Lahore, Karachi, Quetta and Muzafrabad
35
Lecture about the Cyber Security and
protection to beginner and trainee NAB
Officers
35
One day conference on the Cyber Security
and protection 37
Lecture about the data and Information
Security demonstrating in NAB 60
Lecture on the data and Information Security
delivering in NAB 50
Four Days conditioning or Training
Workshop for subordinate training ASPs at
federal Police Academy
45
VII. PAKISTAN STRUGGLING AND EXERTION AGAINST THE CYBER WAR
PISA Pakistan Information Security Association, the
CSP Cyber Secure Pakistan, Pakistan interior ministry
and defense ministry, ICANN, APNIC and the
Engineering school of NUST is SEECS (School of
Electrical Engineering and Computer Science) working
collaborating and cooperating to each other for technical
awareness and the cyber security of Pakistan, all of these
working unitedly and organizing seminars training
sessions and workshops and for technical awareness is
follows [10]
DNSSEC (Domain Name and System securities)
workshops, Mobile applications and Penetration and
incursion testing training sessions, REM (Reverse
Engineering Malware) workshops, LINUX supported
public and open Source tools, Computer hacking forensic
or practical investigation and probe, Women centric
cyber security and protection seminar, Child online
security and protection workshop and ceremony cyber
secure Pakistan 2015. In 2018 a hope to protect the
information may take government steps
VIII. SUGGESTED SECURITY TOOLS BY PROFESSIONALS
According to the APSCC (Asia Pacific Satellite
Communication Council more than 9 billion records are
lost or stole per year [9]
Fig.4. Technical Awareness [10, 13, 21]
Fig.5. PSCC Report [9, 11, 10]
68 Cyber Security and Analysis of Cyber-Crime Laws to Restrict Cyber Crime in Pakistan
Copyright © 2019 MECS I.J. Computer Network and Information Security, 2019, 1, 62-69
1. Sysinternals and Windows Godmode suggested by the RON WOERNER the director of cyber
security studies at Bellevue University.
2. Microsoft EMET suggested by the YIER JIN the assistant professor of computer sciences and
EE (Electrical Engineering) at the University of
Central Florida.
3. Secure@source, Q-Radar, ArcSighr and Splunk suggested by the JEEF NORTHROP the CTO at
international association of secrecy or privacy
professionals and experts.
4. Insider thread protection suggested by the MIKE PAPAY the VP and CISO at Northrop
Grumman.
5. Privileged identity management suggested by the ANDRAS CSER the security analyst and
expert at Forrester.
6. Patch management suggested by the GARY HAYSLIP the Deputy Director for CISO in the
city of San Diego.
7. Blue box suggested by the DR.JOHN D. JOHNSON the global security strategian and
security architect and designer for John Deere.
8. Endpoint detection and response suggested by the NEIL MACDONALD the VP and
distinguish or discern analyst at the Gartner.
9. Fire Eye suggested by the RANDY MARCHANY the information technology
security lab director and the security officer in
the Virginia.
10. Advanced security analytics suggested by the JOHNA TILL JOHNSON the CEO at Nemertes
Research.
IX. CONCLUSION
This article has presented and confronted inspection or
review of the scientific literature about the cyber security,
protections, awareness and consciousness, security
disruptions and laps, cyber security situations, cyber-
crimes, cyber laws and punishments, cyber terrorism and
for cyber security suggested security tools by
professionals in Pakistan. For this purpose and
determination 42 articles were read, collective and
gregarious, compactly and succinctly delineate or
describe.
REFERENCES
[1] Seminar, “Security in Cyber Space: Implications and Challenges,” Center for International Strategic Studies
(CISS), Islamabad Marriot Hotel, September 30, 2014.
[2] Deibert, Ron. Distributed Security as Cyber Strategy: Outlining a Comprehensive Approach for Canada in
Cyberspace. Prepared for the Canadian Defense &
Foreign Affairs Institute, August 2012.
[3] Oona A. Hathaway, Rebecca Crootof, Philip Levitz, Haley Nix, Aileen, Nowlan, William Perdue, Julia
Spiegel; “The Law of Cyber Attack”; Forthcoming in
the California Law Review, 2012.
[4] WSIS Thematic Meeting on Cyber security Geneva, 10 June 2005 A Comparative Analysis Cyber security
Initiative Worldwide Page 3-4.
[5] The art of ensuring the existence and continuity of the information society of a nation, guaranteeing and
protecting, in Cyberspace, its information, assets and
critical infrastructure.” (Canongia & Mandarino, 2014).
[6] Dr. Sadiq Ali Khan Department of Computer Science National University of Computer and Emerging
Sciences FAST.
[7] FIA, NAB, SEECS, PISA, CSP and NUST researches documents.
[8] APSCC. (2018, 11 10). step1.php. Retrieved from online.fpsc.gov.pk:online.fpsc.gov.pk/fpsc/gr/step1.php
[9] Brahima Sanou (Director, T. D. (2017). Global Cybersecurity Index (GCI). Global Cybersecurity Index
(GCI), 65.
[10] J. Blackburn and G. Waters. Optimising Australia’s Response to the Cyber Challenge. Kokoda Foundation,
2011.
[11] M. Qiu, L. Zhang, Z. Ming, Z. Chen, X. Qin, and L. Yang. Securityaware optimization for ubiquitous
computing systems with SEAT graph approach. J. of
Computer and Syst. Sci., 79(5):518–529, 2013.
[12] M. Gallaher, A. Link, and B. Rowe. Cyber Security: Economic Strategies and Public Policy Alternatives.
Edward Elgar Publishing, 2008.
[13] F. Pasqualetti, F. Dorfler, and F. Bullo. Attack detection and identification in cyber-physical systems.
IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control,
58(11):2715–2729, 2013.
[14] Y. Yan, Y. Qian, H. Sharif, and D. Tipper. A survey on cyber security for smart grid communications. IEEE
Communications Surveys & Tutorials, 14(4):998–1010,
2012.
[15] S. Subashini and V. Kavitha. A survey on security issues in service delivery models of cloud computing.
Journal of network and computer applications, 34(1):1–
11, 2011.
[16] M. Qiu, H. Su, M. Chen, Z. Ming, and L. Yang. Balance of security strength and energy for a PMU
monitoring system in smart grid. IEEE
Communications Magazine, 50(5):142–149, 2012.
[17] F. Hu, M. Qiu, J. Li, T. Grant, D. Taylor, and S. McCaleb et al. A review on cloud computing: Design
challenges in architecture and security. J. of Computing
and Info. Tech., 19(1):25–55, 2011.
[18] F. Liu, H. Lo, L. Chen, and W. Lee. Comprehensive security integrated model and ontology within cloud
computing. J. of Internet Technology, 14(6):935–946,
2013.
[19] N. Rani, A. Satyanarayana, and P. Bhaskaran. Coastal vulnerability assessment studies over india: a review.
Natural Hazards, 77(1):405– 428, 2015.
[20] K. Gai, M. Qiu, L. Tao, and Y. Zhu. Intrusion detection techniques for mobile cloud computing in
heterogeneous 5G. Security and Communication
Networks, pages 1–10, 2015.
Authors’ Profiles
Qamar atta ul haq was born on Nov 9, 1993
in Multan .He completed his Higher
Secondary School and college from the
hometown Multan. He completed his
graduation degree from the Institute of
Southern Punjab Multan Pakistan and then he
Cyber Security and Analysis of Cyber-Crime Laws to Restrict Cyber Crime in Pakistan 69
Copyright © 2019 MECS I.J. Computer Network and Information Security, 2019, 1, 62-69
completed his master degree from ISP Multan and got Gold
medal for his work. After that he goes to the IUB University for
MSCS with the specialization in Artificial Intelligence and
carry on his research to facilitate the Nation from his research
and work.
How to cite this paper: Qamar Atta Ul Haq,"Cyber Security and Analysis of Cyber-Crime Laws to Restrict Cyber
Crime in Pakistan", International Journal of Computer Network and Information Security(IJCNIS), Vol.11, No.1,
pp.62-69, 2019.DOI: 10.5815/ijcnis.2019.01.06
© 2019. Notwithstanding the ProQuest Terms and Conditions, you may use this content in accordance with the associated terms available at
http://www.mecs-press.org/ijcnis/terms.html