Formal Written Speech
Quincy3900
Cricatindividualgradingrubric201811.rtfName:
Catiline Conspiracy 63 BCE: Game Speeches
Each student is responsible for writing a 600-750 word speech /article . See individual role sheets for more details.
Essay/Article Topic:
Word Count:
Criteria
Description
Excellent
Good
Satisfactory
Needs
Improvement
CONTENT
Argument
Speech/Article has a clear argument or point of view. If speech, it proposes or supports a specific measure, which is explicitly and clearly expressed.
Evidence
Speech/Article makes meaningful use of primary sources; this means not only using quotes and ideas but also explaining how these quotes and ideas support your argument. All evidence is properly cited.
Analysis
The paper shows critical analysis and thoughtful reflection. The paper goes beyond mere summary of the primary sources and role sheets; it shows evidence that you have thought about the topic, considered different viewpoints where appropriate, and created an original and persuasive interpretation of the relevant issue(s).
Historical & Game Context
Paper shows understanding of the overall historical events and game context.
COMPOSITION
S yntax & Punctuation
Paper is written in standard English: sentence-level grammar and punctuation are correct.
Organization
The paper is well-organized, with 1) an introduction that clearly states your thesis; 2) a body where the argument is developed, containing well-structured paragraphs, each with a clear and appropriate topic sentence, linked together with smooth, logical transitions; and 3) and conclusion, which ties together your arguments and restates your thesis.
Proof-read
Paper is free of spelling and other careless errors.
Citations
All ideas and quotes are cited (in the text of the Speech and has a bibliography at the end)
COMMENTS:
