Obstacles to Strategic Financial and Fiscal Planning for the Environmental Protection Agency
Lionhead102
CreatingaPerformance-DrivenFederalGovernment..pdf
!"!"#$%&'()*$+,-,.#/$$$!$$0)-!#/$1231
#$#%&'(%')*(+%)*,',$*-$.&
!"#$%&'()$)*#"+,"-$'.#/0"&1#')) 2#3#"$4)5,1#"'-#'% 45$6789:;$%<$+758=>98
! "#$%&'(%&)*++*,%&-.&'(%&/-0%1#2%#'&3%1.-14 2*#$%&*#5&6%+78'+&9$'&:/369;&"#&<==>?&'(%& .%5%1*8&,-0%1#2%#'&(*+&,1*57*88@&%A)*#5%5& '(%&7+%&-.&)%1.-12*#$%&2*#*,%2%#'&'%$(4 #"B7%+?&$782"#*'"#,&C"'(&'(%&/369&D-54
%1#"E*'"-#&9$'&-.&FG<GH& I-1&*#@&*52"#"+'1*'"-#&'(*'&"+&+%1"-7+&*J-7'&"2)1-04
"#,&.%5%1*8&,-0%1#2%#'&)%1.-12*#$%?&'(%&*$'&)1-0"5%+&*& C-1K*J8%&.1*2%C-1KH&L%&)1"2*1@&2*#*,%2%#'&$(*84 8%#,%&.*$%5&J@&'(%&M("'%&N-7+%&C"88&#-'&J%&'-&%+'*J8"+(&*& #%C&1%.-12&*,%#5*H&O#+'%*5?&"'&C"88&J%&'-&$1%*'%&'(%&$-#5"4 '"-#+&#%$%++*1@&.-1&'(%&+7$$%++&-.&'(%&D-5%1#"E*'"-#&9$'H&
!"#$"%#&"'"()*#+"(,-(.)/0"# 1)/)2"."/3#4563".# L%&D-5%1#"E*'"-#&9$'&"#$875%+&2*#@&#%C&1%B7"1%2%#'+& '(*'&'(%&)1%+"5%#'&+(-785&7+%H&D-1%&5%'*"8&$*#&J%&.-7#5& "#&3*1'&P&-.&'(%&QR$%&-.&D*#*,%2%#'&*#5&S75,%'T+& :QDST+;&1%$%#'8@&1%0"+%5&U"1$78*1&94<<H&&
!" # $%& '() *+ $(*$, (-+ '$.//$01 # + L%&)1%+"5%#'&C"88&#%%5&'-&*))-"#'&'(%&.-88-C"#,&K%@&-R4 $"*8+&B7"$K8@&'-&%V%$'"0%8@&"2)8%2%#'&'(%&2*#@&'"2%4$1"'"4 $*8&1%B7"1%2%#'+&"#&'(%&D-5%1#"E*'"-#&9$'H &� L%&5%)7'@&5"1%$'-1&.-1&2*#*,%2%#'&"#&QDS&(*+& *&$1"'"$*8&1-8%&"#&'(%&*$'T+&"2)8%2%#'*'"-#&*#5&"#&'(%& 8%*5%1+(")&-.&'(%&%#'"1%&)%1.-12*#$%&+@+'%2H& &� L%&5%)7'@&+%$1%'*1"%+&'@)"$*88@&+%10%&*+&'(%"1&5%)*1'4 2%#'+T&$("%.&-)%1*'"#,&-R$%1+H&37'&2*#*,%1+?&#-'& )-8"$@&%A)%1'+?&"#&'(%+%&1-8%+H &� 9,%#$"%+&27+'&5%+",#*'%&)%1.-12*#$%&"2)1-0%2%#'& -R$%1+H&L%@&*1%&'(%&$("%.&-)%1*'"#,&-R$%1T+&1",('& (*#5H&L%+%&-R$"*8+&$*#&J%&*))-"#'%%+&-1&$*1%%1& %A%$7'"0%+?&J7'&".&*#&*))-"#'%%&"+&+%8%$'%5&'(%@&+(-785& (*0%&*&$*1%%1&J*$K7)H& &� 9,%#$"%+&*81%*5@&(*0%&"#&)8*$%&2-1%&'(*#&<GG&W)1"-14 "'@&,-*8+HX&S@&8*C?&%*$(&27+'&(*0%&*&5%+",#*'%5&,-*8& 8%*5%1H&L%+%&-R$"*8+&*1%&1%+)-#+"J8%&.-1&-0%1+%%"#,&
'(%&*$("%0%2%#'&-.&*&+)%$"Y$&,-*8?&*#5&8%*5"#,&5"+$7+4 +"-#&-#&'(%+%&,-*8+&"#&B7*1'%18@&1%0"%C+H&L%1%&*1%& *8+-&<Z&$1-++4*,%#$@&)1"-1"'@&,-*8+H&[*$(&27+'&(*0%&*& 5%+",#*'%5&W+%#"-1&*$$-7#'*J8%&-R$"*8X&"5%#'"Y%5&J@& QDSH&
I-1&*88&-.&'(%+%&)-+"'"-#+&'(*'&C"88&J%&Y88%5&J@&*&)-8"'"4 $*8&*))-"#'%%?&'(%&QR$%&-.&31%+"5%#'"*8&3%1+-##%8&27+'& )7'&*&#%C&%2)(*+"+&-#&)%1.-12*#$%&2*#*,%2%#'&*#5& *#*8@'"$*8&+K"88+\&,-*8&+%''"#,?&2%*+71%2%#'?&*#*8@+"+?&*#5& %0*87*'"-#H&I-1&'(%&D-5%1#"E*'"-#&9$'&'-&+7$$%%5?&'(%+%& *))-"#'%%+&*#5&-'(%1&K%@&$*1%%1&-R$"*8+&C"88&#%%5&'-&2%%'& *&+%1"%+&-.&"2)-1'*#'&%A)%$'*'"-#+?&C("$(&*1%&5%'*"8%5& 8*'%1&"#&'("+&*1'"$8%H&
7"5#8039-/6#9/#3:"#&9(63#;")( L%&#%C&8*C&(*+&*HJ%1&-.&1%B7"1%2%#'+&'(*'&27+'&J%& $-2)8%'%5&J@&'(%&%#5&-.&'(%&*52"#"+'1*'"-#T+&Y1+'&@%*1H& 92-#,&'(%2\& &� 9,%#$"%+&27+'&5%0%8-)&*&.-714@%*1&+'1*'%,"$&)8*#&*#5& *#&*##7*8&)%1.-12*#$%&)8*#&C"'(&+)%$"Y$&"#5"$*'-1+H& ]#5%1&'(%&#%C&8*C?&'(%+%&)8*#+&*1%&#-C&$-4'%12"#7+& C"'(&)1%+"5%#'"*8&'%12+H&L"+&)1-0"5%+&*&2%$(*#"+2& .-1&*&)1%+"5%#'&'-&5%Y#%&*#5&2%*+71%&)1-,1%++&'-C*15& J1-*5&)-8"$@&,-*8+H&9,%#$"%+&*8+-&27+'&$-#+78'&C"'(& U-#,1%++&-#&'(%&$-#'%#'&-.&'(%"1&)8*#+̂ '("+&C"88& 1%B7"1%&*$'"#,&+--#%1&1*'(%1&'(*#&8*'%1H &� 9,%#$"%+&27+'&1%)-1'&)%1.-12*#$%&5*'*&-#&*&B7*14 '%18@&J*+"+?&*#5&(-85&5*'*451"0%#&B7*1'%18@&1%0"%C+& -.&*,%#$@&)1"-1"'@&,-*8+H&[*$(&*,%#$@&*81%*5@&(*+&*& +2*88HJ%1&-.&5%+",#*'%5&*,%#$@&)1"-1"'@&,-*8+H& L%+%&,-*8+&+%%K&"2)1-0%2%#'&-#&K%@&"'%2+&C"'("#&*& FZ42-#'(&'"2%.1*2%H&3*@&$*1%.78&*''%#'"-#&'-&'("+&+%'& -.&,-*8+H& &� QDS&27+'&)1-57$%&'(%&Y1+'4%0%1&.%5%1*8&,-0%1#2%#'& )%1.-12*#$%&)8*#&.%*'71"#,&$1-++4*,%#$@&)1"-1"'@&,-*8+& *#5&'*1,%'+&.-1&"2)1-0%5&,-0%1#2%#'&)%1.-12*#$%?& 1%)-1'%5&*##7*88@&C"'(&B7*1'%18@&1%0"%C+H&
000<!"#%&'()*+,-,.#/<?/.!/
0%.1#2'
&�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� O2)1-0%&)%1.-12*#$%&J@&"#$1%*+"#,&'(%&7+%&-.&)%1.-14 2*#$%&5*'*H&O#&)71+7"#,&'(%&$(*#,%+&#-'%5&*J-0%&"'& "+&"2)-1'*#'&'-&5%Y#%&*&1%*8"+'"$&2%*+71%&.-1&+7$$%++H& M("8%&'(%&78'"2*'%&,-*8&-.&)%1.-12*#$%&+@+'%2+&"+&'-& "2)1-0%&,-0%1#2%#'*8&)%1.-12*#$%?&'(%&.%5%1*8&,-04 %1#2%#'&,%#%1*88@&7#5%1'*K%+&$-2)8%A&'*+K+&C(%1%& "'&"+&5"R$78'&'-&"+-8*'%&'(%&1%8*'"0%&"2)*$'&-.&,-0%1#4 2%#'&"'+%8.&-#&'(%+%&-7'$-2%+̂ .*1&8%++&'(%&1-8%&-.&*& )%1.-12*#$%&2*#*,%2%#'&+@+'%2H& &� 9#&"#'%12%5"*'%&2%*+71%&-.&+7$$%++&"+&C(%'(%1& .%5%1*8&*$'-1+&*1%&2*K"#,&+@+'%2*'"$&7+%&-.&)%1.-14 2*#$%&5*'*H&]8'"2*'%8@?&+7$$%++&C"88&J%&1%̀ %$'%5&"#&
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� ]+%&*52"#"+'1*'"0%&̀ %A"J"8"'"%+&'-&1%57$%&J715%#+& -#&+'*'%&*#5&8-$*8&,-0%1#2%#'+&*#5&%#$-71*,%& "##-0*'"-#H&O#&*55"'"-#&'-&'(%&D-5%1#"E*'"-#&9$'?& '(%&QJ*2*&*52"#"+'1*'"-#&1%8%*+%5&,7"5*#$%&-#& %A)*#5"#,&*52"#"+'1*'"0%&̀ %A"J"8"'@&*+&*&2%$(*#"+2& '-&"5%#'".@&*#5&1%57$%&J715%#+&-#&+'*'%&*#5&8-$*8& ,-0%1#2%#'+H&L%&7+%&-.&+7$(&̀ %A"J"8"'"%+&$*#&.71'(%1& )%1.-12*#$%&"2)1-0%2%#'&,-*8+H&L%&.%5%1*8&,-0%1#4 2%#'&$*#&)8*@&*&1-8%&"#&%#$-71*,"#,&+'*'%&"##-0*'"-#?& %#+71"#,&'(%&$-88%$'"-#&-.&$-2)*1*J8%&+'*'"+'"$+?&*#5& "5%#'".@"#,&%0"5%#$%4J*+%5&)1*$'"$%+&'(*'&C-1K&C%88H &� a%0%8-)&2%$(*#"+2+&*#5&+'1*'%,"%+&'-&"2)1-0%&$-84 8*J-1*'"-#&*$1-++&*,%#$"%+H&L%&%2)(*+"+&'(*'&'(%& D-5%1#"E*'"-#&9$'&)8*$%+&-#&$1-++4$7''"#,&,-*8+& 7#5%18"#%+&'(%&.*$'&'(*'&2*#@&.%5%1*8&,-0%1#2%#'& '*+K+&1%B7"1%&$--15"#*'"-#&*$1-++&278'")8%&*,%#$"%+H& U*88+&.-1&,1%*'%1&$-88*J-1*'"-#&*$1-++&J71%*7$1*'"$& +'-0%4)")%+&*1%&#-'&#%C?&J7'&'(%&$1-++4$7''"#,&,-*8& 2%$(*#"+2&)1-0"5%+&*&+'1-#,%1&2%*#+&'-&.-+'%1&+7$(& $-88*J-1*'"-#&'(*#&%0%1&J%.-1%H&& & b-&$--15"#*'%&278'")8%&*,%#$"%+&C-1K"#,& '-C*15&-0%18*))"#,&,-*8+&1%B7"1%+&'1%*'"#,&'(%+%& $-88*J-1*'"-#+&*+&"#'%14-1,*#"E*'"-#*8&#%'C-1K+H& c%'C-1K+&+7$(&*+&'(%+%&#%%5&J*+"$&,-0%1#*#$%&2%$(4 *#"+2+&'-&5%'%12"#%&(-C&"#.-12*'"-#&"+&%A$(*#,%5?& *#5&(-C&5%$"+"-#+&*1%&2*5%H&L%&*52"#"+'1*'"-#& +(-785&+%%K&%A*2)8%+&-.&C(%1%&$-88*J-1*'"-#+& J%'C%%#&278'")8%&*,%#$"%+&*1%&C-1K"#,&C%88H& &� D*K%&5*'*451"0%#&1%0"%C+&*&+",#*'71%&2*#*,%2%#'& "#"'"*'"0%H&S@&1%B7"1"#,&B7*1'%18@&1%0"%C&-.&,-*8+?&'(%& 9$'&$1%*'%+&*&1-7'"#%&-.&5*'*&7+%&C"'("#&*,%#$"%+&.-1& 2-#"'-1"#,&*$("%0%2%#'&-#&)1-,1*22*'"$&,-*8+H& b-,%'(%1&C"'(&'(%&*##7*8&+'1*'%,"$&1%0"%C+&QDS&C"88& $-#57$'&C"'(&*,%#$"%+?&'(%+%&1%0"%C+&*1%&'(%&2-+'& )-C%1.78&1%0"+"-#&'-&2*#*,%2%#'&)1*$'"$%&)1-0"5%5& J@&'(%&D-5%1#"E*'"-#&9$'H&
2 " 1 3" -+ 4(5$& ) 66('6" *'$6" 1 *+ $6) -" $'41 *$ '1 78 (*9$1 :) ;'$5" -<) -61 *& " =$>657) # " " + $ ?(77$*) '(& " $(<$?) -3+ $1 -" $*) '$1 & & ) 651 *(" 3$ :# $'4" $& ) 66('6" *'$) <$7" 1 3" -+ 4(5$'(6" $1 *3$ ) -91 *(@ 1 '() *1 7$-" + ) ;-& " + $') $5" -<) -61 *& " $ 61 *1 9" 6" *'$" <<) -'+ =
!3!"#$%&'()*$+,-,.#/$$$!$$0)-!#/$1231
#$#%&'(%')*(+%)*,',$*-$.&
&� a%2-#+'1*'%&8%*5%1+(")&$-22"'2%#'&'-&)%1.-14 2*#$%H&Q#%&-.&'(%&$8%*1%+'&1%+%*1$(&Y#5"#,+&*J-7'& )%1.-12*#$%&2*#*,%2%#'&"+&'(*'&+7$(&+@+'%2+&*1%& 2-1%&8"K%8@&'-&+7$$%%5&C(%#&'(%@&(*0%&'(%&C"5%8@4 )%1$%"0%5&+7))-1'&-.&*,%#$@&8%*5%1+H&d%*5%1+(")& $-22"'2%#'&2%*#+&2-1%&'(*#&'*8K"#,&*J-7'&)%14 .-12*#$%H&[2)8-@%%+&C"88&#-'"$%&".&C-15+&*1%&#-'& *$$-2)*#"%5&J@&'(%&$-22"'2%#'&-.&8%*5%1+(")&'"2%& *#5&-1,*#"E*'"-#*8&1%+-71$%+&'-&)%1.-12*#$%&2*#*,%4 2%#'&%V-1'+H&M"'(-7'&+7$(&$-22"'2%#'?&%2)8-@%%+& C"88&#-'&$-22"'&%"'(%1H& &� S7"85&*&1%+78'+4-1"%#'%5&8%*1#"#,&$78'71%H&d%*5%1+&#-'& -#8@&$-22"'&'-&)%1.-12*#$%&2*#*,%2%#'&)1-$%++%+?& '(%@&*8+-&+%'&'(%&$78'71*8&'-#%&.-1&(-C&+7$(&)1-$%++%+& *1%&7+%5H&d%*5%1+&+(-785&)1"2*1"8@&)71+7%&*&8%*1#"#,& *))1-*$(&'-&'(%&7+%&-.&)%1.-12*#$%&2%*+71%+?&C("$(& $*88+&.-1&%2)8-@%%+&'-&*$K#-C8%5,%&)1-J8%2+?&B7%+4 '"-#&J*+"$&*++72)'"-#+?&*#5&"#0%+'&'(%"1&"#,%#7"'@&'-& +-80%&)1-J8%2+H&O.&)%1.-12*#$%&2%*+71%+&*1%&+%%#&*+&*& )7#"'"0%&'--8&'-&'*1,%'&)--1&)%1.-12*#$%?&%2)8-@%%+& C"88&1%+)-#5&5%.%#+"0%8@&*#5&8"2"'&'(%"1&$--)%1*'"-#H& L%&5*'*451"0%#&1%0"%C+&C"88&J%&K%@&0%#7%+&C(%1%&'(%& $78'71*8&'-#%&-.&'(%&)%1.-12*#$%&2*#*,%2%#'&+@+'%2& C"88&J%&%+'*J8"+(%5H& &� ]+%&J%#$(2*1K"#,&'-&.-+'%1&"2)1-0%2%#'H&S%#$(4 2*1K"#,&2%*#+&"5%#'".@"#,&J%+'4"#4$8*++&"#&*#& "#57+'1@&-1&.7#$'"-#?&*#5&$-2)*1"#,&K%@&)%1.-14 2*#$%&2%'1"$+&*,*"#+'&'(%+%&(",(&)%1.-12%1+H&O'& (*+&J%%#&7#5%17'"8"E%5&"#&'(%&.%5%1*8&,-0%1#2%#'H& O.&*,%#$"%+&7+%&"'&C%88?&"'&C"88&%#$-71*,%&,1%*'%1&7+%& -.&)%1.-12*#$%&5*'*&'-&5%Y#%&+'1%'$(&'*1,%'+?&8%*1#& C(*'&.*$'-1+&$1%*'%&+7$$%++?&*#5&2-'"0*'%&%2)8-@%%+H& 6%̀ %$'"#,&*&8%*1#"#,&$78'71%?&'(%&,-*8&+(-785&J%&'-& 8--K&.-1&)-+"'"0%&-7'8"%1+&*#5&J%+'&)1*$'"$%+&'(*'&$*#& "#.-12&'(%&%V-1'+&-.&-'(%1+H& &�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e&1%+-71$%+&'-&+$*8%47)&"##-0*'"-#+&C(%1%&'(%1%& (*+&J%%#&+",#"Y$*#'&%0"5%#$%&-.&"'+&+7$$%++e&-1&'(%&7+%& -.&%0"5%#$%&'-&*5_7+'&.-1278*+&"#&.%5%1*8&,1*#'+H&
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� L%&M("'%&N-7+%&+(-785&%#$-71*,%&*,%#$"%+&*#5& QDS&'-&)1-*$'"0%8@&$-#+78'&C"'(&U-#,1%++&%*18@& "#&'(%&,-*84+%''"#,&)1-$%++?&*#5&5%2-#+'1*'%&*& C"88"#,#%++&'-&1%̀ %$'&$-#,1%++"-#*8&)1"-1"'"%+H&L%& D-5%1#"E*'"-#&9$'&1%B7"1%+&*,%#$"%+&*#5&QDS& '-&*$'"0%8@&$-#+78'&C"'(&U-#,1%++&*#5&+'*K%(-85%1+& "#&+%''"#,&*88&'@)%&-.&)%1.-12*#$%&,-*8+H&9,%#$"%+& *1%&1%B7"1%5&J@&8*C&'-&1%*$(&-7'&'-&U-#,1%++&-#& '(%&*,%#$@&)1"-1"'@&,-*8+?&*#5&'(%&*52"#"+'1*'"-#&"+& 1%B7"1%5&'-&5-&'(%&+*2%&-#&'(%&.%5%1*8&)1"-1"'@&,-*8+H& &� L%&M("'%&N-7+%&+(-785&+%'&*#&%A)%$'*'"-#&-.&"'+& )%1.-12*#$%&8%*5%1+&'-&2*K%&)%1.-12*#$%&"#.-14 2*'"-#&2-1%&7+%.78&'-&U-#,1%++H&U-#,1%++"-#*8& 2%2J%1+&*#5&+'*V&*1%&7+%5&'-&1%$%"0"#,&"#.-12*4 '"-#&'(*'&(*+&J%%#&$*1%.788@&5%+",#%5&'-&2%%'&'(%"1& "#'%1%+'+H&L"+&"+&,%#%1*88@&#-'&'(%"1&%A)%1"%#$%&C"'(& )%1.-12*#$%&5*'*&)1-57$%5&J@&'(%&%A%$7'"0%&J1*#$(H&
000<!"#%&'()*+,-,.#/<?/.!!
0%.1#2'
9,%#$@&$("%.&-)%1*'"#,&-R$%1+&+(-785&J%&%A)%$'%5&'-& )1-*$'"0%8@&1%*$(&-7'&'-&'(%"1&$-#,1%++"-#*8&$-22"'4 '%%+&'-&Y#5&-7'&C(*'&)%1.-12*#$%&"#.-12*'"-#&"+&-.& )*1'"$78*1&"#'%1%+'&'-&'(%2H&L%+%&2*@&J%&,-*8+&'(*'& 1%̀ %$'&$-#+'"'7%#'&"#'%1%+'+?&J7'&$-22"''%%+&*8+-&2*@& J%&%#,*,%5&J@&$-#+"5%1*'"-#&-.&(",(4)1"-1"'@&,-*8+?&-1& -.&#-#42"++"-#4J*+%5&,-*8+&'(*'&1%̀ %$'&$-#,1%++"-#*8& 5"1%$'"0%+&:.-1&%A*2)8%?&I1%%5-2&-.&O#.-12*'"-#&9$'& 1%B7%+'+&'(*'&$*)'71%&'1*#+)*1%#$@&,-*8+;H& &�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
9,%#$@&-R$"*8+&+(-785&$-2%&'-&$-#,1%++"-#*8&(%*14 "#,+&%A)%$'"#,&'-&J%&B7%1"%5&*J-7'&)%1.-12*#$%&5*'*H&& & U-#,1%++&*8+-&$*#&$1%*'%&"#$%#'"0%+&'-&"2)1-0%& "##-0*'"-#&J@&-V%1"#,&'(%&%A%$7'"0%&J1*#$(&̀ %A"J"8"'@& '-&2-0%&.7#5"#,&*1-7#5&)1-,1*2+&C(%1%&'(%+%&)1-4 ,1*2+&+(*1%&*&+%'&-.&,-*8+H&!7$(&̀ %A"J"8"'@&+(-785&J%& $-#5"'"-#%5&-#&$8%*1&*#5&*,1%%547)-#&,-*8+?&.1%B7%#'& 1%)-1'"#,?&*#5&'(%&7+%&-.&%0"5%#$%4J*+%5&+'1*'%,"%+H&
Copyright of Public Manager is the property of American Society for Training & Development and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.
