For NJosh ONLY

Lohan says

Hilton says

Lohan had the paper they were working on together, and Hilton grabbed it. The paper tore

Lohan writing gossip about her on a piece of paper, and Hilton tried taking the paper. The paper tore

Conflict: Project information on paper in either or both handwriting

Conflict: gossip on paper in Lohan’s writing

Lohan crumpled her half and threw it at Hilton

No comment on fate of paper

Conflict: crumpled paper

Conflict: no crumpling

Lohan states that Hilton attacked her with pen

Hilton says nothing about attacking Lohan

Conflict: Hilton attacks with pen

Conflict: Hilton would deny it

Lohan says pen broke in her arm

Hilton says nothing

Conflict: pen in Lohan’s arm

Conflict: no pen in arm

Lohan says Hilton broke potted plant over Lohan’s head

Hilton says Lohan struck her with potted plant

Conflict: Hilton broke potted plant on Lohan’s head

Conflict: Lohan struck Hilton with potted plant.

Blood from Hilton on ground/floor of Commons

Shoeprints from Hilton on ground/floor of Commons