Care plan and concept map
Keiser University College of Nursing (CAMPUS)
Comprehensive Care Plan Rubric
Course:_______________________ Topic:__________________________________ Date:__________________________
Student Name:___________________________________________ Evaluator:________________________________________
RR: 12/2023 Page 2
Student Learning Outcomes
1-Inter/Intra Disciplinary Collaboration and Care Coordination
2-Professionalism and Advocacy & Policy
3-Technology Integration and Information Management
4-Judgement/Reasoning and Research & Translation
Proficiency
5 Excellent - consistently or always performs at desired level.
4 Good – almost always performs at desired level.
3 Adequate – usually performs at the desired level.
2 Developing – seldom performs at the desired level.
1 Unsatisfactory – does not perform at the desired level.
|
Assessment |
|||||||
|
Performance Element |
Student Learning Outcome |
Unsatisfactory 1 |
Developing 2 |
Adequate 3 |
Good 4 |
Excellent 5 |
Comments |
|
Recognizing and Analyzing Cues |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Introduction: 5 elements · Summary of patient’s profile. · History of present illness · Signs and symptoms · Past medical/surgical history. · Head to Toe complete and attached.
|
1,3 |
One or none of the five elements are completed and thorough.
|
Two out of five elements are completed and thorough.
|
Three out of five elements are completed and thorough.
|
Four out of five elements are completed and thorough.
|
All five elements are completed and thorough |
|
|
Pathophysiology presented in the form of a concept map to include these four elements: medical diagnosis, signs and symptoms, potential complications, and expected treatment (with references) |
1,3 |
Missing and/or no references provided. |
Limited description of the four elements. |
Partially and accurately described all four elements |
Adequately and accurately described all four elements |
Thoroughly and accurately described all four elements |
|
|
Laboratory findings to include the following: Normal value, client’s value, and clinical significance of abnormal values (with references). |
1,3 |
Four or more elements missing or inaccurate |
Three elements missing or inaccurate |
Two elements missing or inaccurate |
One element missing or inaccurate |
All elements are accurate and completed |
|
|
Medication list to include the following: Order, dose range, mechanism of action, indication, side effects, and nursing considerations (with references and rationales) |
1,3 |
Four or more elements missing or inaccurate OR no references provided |
Three elements missing or inaccurate.
|
Two elements missing or inaccurate.
|
One element missing or inaccurate.
|
All elements are accurate and completed |
|
|
Problem Statements |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Formation of first/ priority problem statement from assessment data. (Elements to include problem/diagnostic label, “related to,” and “as evidenced by”) |
4 |
No elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as primary problem.
|
One out of three elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as primary problem |
Two out of three elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as primary problem |
All elements completed accurately but NOT correct prioritization as primary problem |
All elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as primary problem |
|
|
Formation of second nursing problem statement from assessment data. (Elements to include problem/diagnostic label, “related to,” and “as evidenced by”) |
4 |
No elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as secondary problem.
|
One out of three elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as secondary problem |
Two out of three elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as secondary problem |
All elements completed accurately but NOT correct prioritization as secondary problem.
|
All elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as secondary problem.
|
|
|
Formation of third nursing problem statement from assessment data. (Elements to include problem/diagnostic label, “related to,” and “as evidenced by”) |
4 |
No elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as tertiary problem.
|
One out of three elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as tertiary problem |
Two out of three elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as tertiary problem |
All elements completed accurately but NOT correct prioritization as tertiary problem.
|
All elements completed accurately with correct prioritization as tertiary problem.
|
|
|
Generate Solutions 3 total goals: 2 short term, 1 long term per problem |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Specific goals that are behavioral, measurable, and time specific as to what the patient will accomplish |
4 |
10+ errors in/omission of elements addressed for each goal throughout care plan |
7-9 errors in/omission of elements addressed for each goal throughout care plan |
4-6 errors in/omission of elements addressed for each goal throughout care plan.
|
1-3 errors in/omission of elements addressed for each goal throughout care plan. |
All 3 elements addressed accurately for each goal throughout care plan |
|
|
Specific goals that are realistic, attainable, and appropriate for patient’s needs |
4 |
10+ errors in/omission of elements addressed for each goal throughout care plan |
7-9 errors in/omission of elements addressed for each goal throughout care plan |
4-6 errors in/omission of elements addressed for each goal throughout care plan |
1-3 errors in/omission of elements addressed for each goal throughout care plan |
All 3 elements addressed accurately for each goal throughout care plan.
|
|
|
Prioritized goals based on Maslow’s or Erikson’s Theory. |
4 |
Goals are not prioritized, and/or the student does not list the Maslow’s or Erikson’s Theory in any goals |
1 out of 3 goals are prioritized and correct using Maslow’s or Erikson’s Theory |
2 out of 3 goals are prioritized and correct using Maslow’s or Erikson’s Theory |
All 3 goals are prioritized in the correct order; however, 1 or more Maslow’s or Erikson’s Theory is not chosen appropriately.
|
All 3 goals are prioritized in the correct order and accurate Maslow’s or Erikson’s Theory chosen |
|
|
Take Action |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Related to the goal/outcome. |
4 |
8 or less nursing interventions are related to the goal stated |
9-14 nursing interventions are related to the goal stated |
15-20 nursing interventions are related to the goal stated |
21-26 nursing interventions are related to the goal stated |
All 27 nursing interventions are related to the goal stated |
|
|
Specific and include frequency. |
4 |
8 or less nursing interventions are specific and include frequency |
9-14 nursing interventions are specific and include frequency |
15-20 nursing interventions are specific and include frequency |
21-26 nursing interventions are specific and include frequency |
All 27 nursing interventions are specific and include frequency |
|
|
Prioritized in order of performance. |
4 |
More than 3 errors in prioritizing nursing intervention or student chose nonpriority nursing interventions |
3 errors in prioritizing nursing interventions |
2 errors in prioritizing nursing interventions |
1 error in prioritizing nursing interventions |
All nursing interventions for each goal are correctly prioritized in order of performance and are appropriate for patient problem |
|
|
Includes 3 interventions per goal, 2 of 3 interventions must be independent nursing actions. |
4 |
Less than 9 nursing interventions given, at least less than 6 are independent nursing actions |
9-14 nursing interventions given, at least 6-9 are independent nursing actions |
15-20 nursing interventions given, at least 10-13 are independent nursing actions |
21-26 nursing interventions given, at least 14-17 are independent nursing actions |
27 nursing interventions given, at least 18 of which are independent nursing actions |
|
|
Rationales |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Rationales (one per intervention) are specific to the goals and interventions stated. |
4 |
Less than 9 nursing interventions provides specific rationales |
9-14 of the nursing interventions provide specific rationales |
15-20 of the nursing interventions provide specific rationales |
21-26 of the nursing interventions provide specific rationales |
All nursing interventions provide specific rationales |
|
|
Rationales are accurate and reflect evidence-based practice, referenced from textbook, including page numbers. |
4 |
Less than 9 rationales are accurate and reflect evidence-based practice and include reference with page number |
9-14 of the rationales are accurate and reflect evidence-based practice and include reference with page number |
15-20 of the rationales are accurate and reflect evidence-based practice and include reference with page number |
21-26 of the rationales are accurate and reflect evidence-based practice and include reference with page number |
All rationales are accurate and reflect evidence-based practice and include reference with page number |
|
|
Evaluate Outcomes |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Each goal evaluated to include two elements: · Nursing care provided (narrative documentation of interventions) · Patient’s response/Expected response to interventions. |
4 |
Student did not evaluate any of the goals |
Missing a total of 3 evaluation elements across all goals |
Missing a total of 2 evaluation elements across all goals |
Missing a total of 1evaluation element across all goals |
Complete evaluation of each listed element for all goals |
|
|
Presentation |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Appropriate use of medical terminology, grammar, spelling, neatness, and APA formatted reference page included |
2 |
9 or more errors or reference page not included |
7-8 errors in presentation |
5-6 errors in presentation |
3-4 errors in presentation |
0-2 errors in presentation |
|
|
Final Grade |
|
|
|
|
|
|
_______ |
*First semester must achieve an average of 3 or greater on the Likert Scale to constitute a passing grade*
*Second semester must achieve an average of 3.5 or greater on the Likert Scale to constitute a passing grade*
*Third and fourth (if applicable) semester must achieve an average of 4 or greater on the Likert Scale to constitute a passing grade*