Short informative report
COMN 220/COMM 1070 Final Report Rubric
|
Excellent (E) All the criteria are fully followed. Work meets/exceeds professional expectations. |
Good (G) Criteria are mostly followed with minor errors or omissions. |
Needs Improvement (NI) Most criteria are present but there are substantial errors or omissions negatively impacting the quality of the work and professionalism of the document. |
Unacceptable (U) Criteria are missing and/or have significant errors or omissions . Work does not meet professional expectations. |
||
|
Content |
Expectations |
SCORE |
|||
|
|
|
E |
G |
NI |
U |
|
Front Matter
/6 points
|
Cover Page (outer) · descriptive report title · graphic or image (sourced on back) · writers’ names Title Page (inner) · descriptive report title · receiver’s name · writers’ names · course code and section · date of submission Executive Summary · informative style · complete summary of report · one page or less Table of Contents · proper headings with page numbers aligned · lower case Roman numeral List of figures and list of tables: · all of the report’s visuals · correct numbers, titles · corresponding page numbers aligned · lower case Roman numeral |
6 |
5-4 |
3-2 |
1-0 |
|
Introduction
/5 points
|
· general introduction · purpose · background · methods of research · scope and limitations · preview |
5 |
4-3 |
2 |
1-0 |
|
Research Findings
/20 points
|
· provides accurate, relevant, and detailed analysis using specific evidence from research · uses logical organization for topics/subtopics · fulfills purpose |
20-18 |
17-14 |
13-10 |
9-0 |
|
Conclusion /3 points
|
· summarizes research findings · draws conclusions out of findings · no new information presented |
3 |
2 |
1 |
0 |
|
Back Matter
/3 points |
Appendix (ex. interview transcript) · includes relevant info(i.e. interviewee name and date of interview) · proper page numbers, titles · professionally formatted |
3 |
2 |
1 |
0 |
|
Organization |
Expectations |
E |
G |
NI |
U |
|
/3 points |
· sections of document ordered according to Business Report Writing Guidelines · proper paragraph structure |
3 |
2 |
1 |
0 |
|
Research & Documentation |
Expectations |
E |
G |
NI |
U |
|
APA In-text references & Reference list
/20 points
|
· at least 3 credible sources · proper in-text citations in APA · complete References page entries in APA · properly ordered References page · appropriate conventions for incorporating paraphrases and direct quotations · in-text citations and Reference page entries align |
20-18 |
17-14 |
13-10 |
9-0 |
|
Style/Tone |
Expectations |
E |
G |
NI |
U |
|
Business Style Professional Tone
/10 points
|
· precise and concise writing style · parallel structure · 3rd person (no 1st/2nd person pronouns) · uniform style throughout · consistent terms · language is objective · clear audience analysis · professional and consistent tone |
10-9 |
8-7 |
6-4 |
3-0 |
|
Format |
Expectations |
E |
G |
NI |
U |
|
Font & Headings
/5 points
|
· text aligned & spaced appropriately · headings applied correctly · font is consistent and professional · correct pagination |
5-4 |
3 |
2 |
1-0 |
|
Figures, Tables, & Lists
/5 points |
Figures and Tables · introductory content · explanation of figure/table · figure/table # · descriptive title in title case · labels · professional figure or table · in-text citation when required · white space Lists · introductory sentence · professional bullets · parallel structure |
5-4 |
3 |
2 |
1-0 |
|
Mechanics |
Expectations |
E |
G |
NI |
U |
|
Writing Mechanics (points will be deducted ½ for each error up to 20)
/20 points
|
· complete and varied sentences · well-structured sentences · correct grammar · correct punctuation · correct spelling |
20-18 |
17--14 |
13-10 |
9-0 |
|
Total
/100 points |
|
100-80 |
79-70 |
69-60 |
59-0 |
COMN 220/
COM
M
1070
Final Report Rubric
Excellent (E)
All the criteria are
fully
followed. Work
meets/exceeds
professional
expectations.
Good (G)
Criteria are
mostly
followed
with mino
r
errors or omissions.
Needs Improvement (NI)
Most criteria are present
but there are
substantial
errors or omissions
negatively
impacting the
quality
of the work and
professionalism of the
document.
Unacceptable (U)
Criteria are
missing and/or
have
significant errors or
omissions
.
Work does not
meet professional
expectations.
C
ontent
E
xpectations
SCORE
E
G
NI
U
Front M
atter
/6
points
Cover Page (outer)
o
d
escriptive
report
title
o
graphic or image
(sourced on back)
o
writers’ names
Title Page (inner)
o
descriptive report
title
o
receiver’s name
o
writer
s
’
name
s
o
course code and section
o
date
of submission
Executive Summary
o
informative style
o
complete
summary
of report
o
one page or less
Table of Contents
o
proper
headings with page numbers
aligned
o
lower case R
oman numeral
List
of figure
s
and list of tables:
o
all of the report’s visuals
o
correct
numbers, titles
o
corresponding page numbers
aligned
o
lower case Roman numeral
6
5
-
4
3
-
2
1
-
0
Introduction
/5
points
o
general introduction
o
purpose
o
background
o
method
s of research
o
scope
and limitations
o
preview
5
4
-
3
2
1
-
0
Research Findings
/
20
points
o
provides accurate, relevant, and
detailed analysis using specific
evidence from research
o
uses logical organization
for
topics/subtopics
o
fulfills purpose
20
-
18
17
-
14
13
-
10
9
-
0
Conclusion
/3
points
o
summarizes
research findings
o
draws conclusions out of findings
o
no new information
presented
3
2
1
0
Back Matter
/3
points
Appendix
(
ex.
interview transcript)
o
includes
relevant info(i.e. interviewee
name and date of interview
)
o
proper page numbers, titles
o
professionally formatted
3
2
1
0
COMN 220/COMM 1070 Final Report Rubric
Excellent (E)
All the criteria are fully
followed. Work
meets/exceeds
professional
expectations.
Good (G)
Criteria are mostly
followed with minor
errors or omissions.
Needs Improvement (NI)
Most criteria are present
but there are substantial
errors or omissions
negatively impacting the
quality of the work and
professionalism of the
document.
Unacceptable (U)
Criteria are missing and/or
have significant errors or
omissions. Work does not
meet professional
expectations.
Content Expectations
SCORE
E G NI U
Front Matter
/6 points
Cover Page (outer)
o descriptive report title
o graphic or image (sourced on back)
o writers’ names
Title Page (inner)
o descriptive report title
o receiver’s name
o writers’ names
o course code and section
o date of submission
Executive Summary
o informative style
o complete summary of report
o one page or less
Table of Contents
o proper headings with page numbers
aligned
o lower case Roman numeral
List of figures and list of tables:
o all of the report’s visuals
o correct numbers, titles
o corresponding page numbers aligned
o lower case Roman numeral
6 5-4 3-2 1-0
Introduction
/5 points
o general introduction
o purpose
o background
o methods of research
o scope and limitations
o preview
5 4-3 2 1-0
Research Findings
/20 points
o provides accurate, relevant, and
detailed analysis using specific
evidence from research
o uses logical organization for
topics/subtopics
o fulfills purpose
20-18 17-
14
13-
10
9-0
Conclusion
/3 points
o summarizes research findings
o draws conclusions out of findings
o no new information presented
3 2 1 0
Back Matter
/3 points
Appendix (ex. interview transcript)
o includes relevant info(i.e. interviewee
name and date of interview)
o proper page numbers, titles
o professionally formatted
3 2 1 0