CJUS 300 Article Review

Criteria

Levels of Achievement

Content

(70%)

Advanced

90-100%

Proficient

70-89%

Developing

1-69%

Not Present

Total

Structure

11.25 to 12.5 points:

Student provides a meaningful and very thorough introduction, thoughtful summation, and a conclusion to the paper.

8.75 to 11 points:

Student provides a meaningful and sufficient introduction, thoughtful summation, and a conclusion to the paper.

1 to 8.5 points:

Student provides a minimal introduction, thoughtful summation, and a conclusion to the paper.

0 points

Not present

Ethical Dilemmas

11.25 to 12.5 points:

Ethical dilemmas are thoroughly presented from the article.

8.75 to 11 points:

Ethical dilemmas are adequately presented from the article.

1 to 8.5 points:

Ethical dilemmas are minimally presented from the article.

0 points

Not present

Analysis

4.5 to 5 points:

Student effectively analyzes and evaluates the central theme, thoughts, and ideas presented in the peer-reviewed article.

3.5 to 4.25 points:

Student adequately analyzes and evaluates the central theme, thoughts, and ideas presented in the peer-reviewed article.

1 to 3.25 points:

Student minimally analyzes and evaluates the central theme, thoughts, and ideas presented in the peer-reviewed article.

0 points

Not present

Biblical Worldview

4.5 to 5 points:

Student effectively relates the article review to a biblical worldview.

3.5 to 4.25 points:

Student adequately relates the article review to a biblical worldview.

1 to 3.25 points:

Student minimally relates the article review to a biblical worldview.

0 points

Not present

Structure (30%)

Advanced

90-100%

Proficient

70-89%

Developing

1-69%

Not present

Total

Spelling and Grammar

4.5 to 5 points:

Proper spelling and grammar are used.

3.5 to 4.25 points:

Proper spelling and grammar are used with minimal errors.

1 to 3.25 points:

Proper spelling and grammar are not used.

0 points

Not present

Length and Format

4.5 to 5 points:

The paper is 2–3 pages.

The paper follows current APA format.

3.5 to 4.25 points:

The paper is not 2–3 pages.

The paper follows current APA format.

1 to 3.25 points:

The paper is not 2–3 pages and the paper does not follow current APA format.

0 points

Not present

Sources

4.5 to 5 points:

All criteria must be met:

· The article is a peer-reviewed article appearing in a scholarly journal.

· The article is less than 5 years old.

· At least 2 Bible verses are given as support.

· A working weblink to the article is provided.

3.5 to 4.25 points:

Most criteria is met:

· The article is a peer-reviewed article appearing in a scholarly journal.

· The article is less than 5 years old.

· At least 2 Bible verses are given as support.

· A working weblink to the article is provided.

1 to 3.25 points:

Minimal criteria is met:

· The article is a peer-reviewed article appearing in a scholarly journal.

· The article is less than 5 years old.

· At least 2 Bible verses are given as support.

· A working weblink to the article is provided.

0 points

Not present

Professor Comments:

Total:

/50