DW5
CHAPTER 8
I npatient Faci l ities and Services
LEARN I NG OBJECTIVES
• Get a fu nctiona l perspective on the evol ution of h ospita l s. • Su rvey the factors that contri buted to the g rowth of hospita ls pr ior to the 1 980s. • U ndersta nd the reasons for the s u bseq uent decl i n e of hospita l s a n d the i r uti l ization . • Descri be some key measures perta i n i n g to hospita l operations a nd i n patient
uti l ization . • Com pa re uti l ization measures i n U.S. hospita l s to those i n other cou ntries. • Differentiate a mong va rious types of hospita l s. • Eva l u ate the controversy s u rro u n d ing physicia n-owned specia lty hos pita ls . • Com prehend some basic concepts i n hospita l governance. • U ndersta nd and d ifferentiate between l icens u re, certification, a nd accred itation a n d
t h e Magnet Recog n ition Progra m of t h e America n N u rses Credentia l i ng Center. • Get a perspective on some key eth ica l issues.
· OIATf'ATI ENT
''We have the inpatient sector under control."
349
I ..
I
350 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
� Introduction The term inpatient is used in conjunc tion with an overnight stay in a health care facility, such as a hospital, whereas out patient refers to services provided while the patient is not lodged in a health care facility. Although the primary function of hospitals is to deliver inpatient acute care services, many hospitals have expanded their scope of services to include nonacute and outpatient care.
According to the American Hospital Association (AHA), a hospital is an insti tution with at least six beds whose primary function is "to deliver patient services, diag nostic and therapeutic, for particular or general medical conditions" (AHA, 1994). In addition, a hospital must be licensed, have an organized physician staff, and pro vide continuous nursing services under the supervision of registered nurses (RNs). Other characteristics of a hospital include an identifiable governing body that is legally responsible for the conduct of the hospital, a chief executive with continuous responsibil ity for the operation of the hospital, main tenance of medical records on each patient, pharmacy services maintained in the institution and supervised by a registered pharmacist, and food service operations that meet the nutritional and therapeu tic requirements of the patients (Health Forum, 2001). The construction and opera tion of the modern hospital are governed by federal laws; state health department regula tions; city ordinances; standards of the Joint Commission; and national codes for build ing, fire protection, and sanitation.
In the past 200 years or so, hospitals have gradually evolved from ordinary institutions of refuge for the homeless and poor to ultramodern facilities that provide
technologically advanced services to the critically ill and injured. The term "medi cal center" is used by some hospitals, reflecting their high level of specialization and wide scope of services, which may include teaching and research. Growth of multihospital chains, especially those pro viding a variety of health care services in addition to acute care, has also introduced the nomenclature "hospital system'' or ''health system:'
This chapter describes institutional care delivery with specific reference to acute care-mostly characterized by sec ondary and tertiary levels of care-in com munity hospitals. It also discusses various ways to classify hospitals and points out important trends and critical issues that will continue to shape the delivery of inpa tient services.
� Hospital Transformation in the United States
From about 1840 to 1900, hospitals under went a drastic change in purpose, func tion, and number. From supplying merely food, shelter, and meager medical care to the pauper sick, armies, persons infected with contagious diseases, the insane, and individuals requiring emergency treat ment, they began to provide skilled medi cal and surgical attention and nursing care to all classes of people (Raffel, 1980). Subsequently, hospitals became centers of medical training and research. More recent transformations have been mainly organizational in nature, as hospitals have consolidated ·into medical systems, deliv ering a broad range of health care services.
1hese transformations can be neatly cate gorized according to five significant func tions in the evolution of hospitals:
1. Primitive institutions of social welfare
2. Distinct institutions of care for the sick
3. Organized institutions of medi cal practice
4. Advanced institutions of medi cal training and research
5. Consolidated systems of health services delivery
Primitive Institutions of Social Welfare Except for a few hospitals that were located in some of the major U.S. cities, during the 1800s, most regions in the country had municipal almshouses (or poorhouses) and pesthouses. Financed through chari table gifts and local government funds, these institutions essentially performed a social welfare function. Almshouses served primarily the destitute of society who needed food and shelter. They also took care of the sick, who received limited nursing care as needed. People generally stayed in these institutions for months, rather than days. Pesthouses were used to quarantine people who were sick with contagious diseases, such as smallpox and yellow fever, so the rest of the community would be protected.
Distinct Institutions of Care for the Sick Not until the late 1800s did infirmaries or hospital departments of city poorhouses break away to become independent medical
Hospital Transformation in the United States 351
care institutions. These were the first pub lic (government) hospitals (Haglund and Dowling, 1993), in this case operated by local governments. For example, the Kings County Almshouse and Infirmary, orga nized in Brooklyn in 1830, later became the Kings County Hospital (Raff el, 1980). Nevertheless, these first public hospitals still served mainly the indigent. Hospitals at this stage often had poor hygiene, inad equate ventilation, and care provided by untrained nurses.
In Europe, the first hospitals were established predominantly by religious orders. Nurses, who were primarily monks and nuns, attended to both the physi cal and spiritual needs of the patients. Later, many of these hospitals became tax -financed public institutions as less church money became available for hospi tals and monasteries. In England, private donations and taxes supported the "royal hospitals:' Other British hospitals were nonprofit (or voluntary) hospitals, which served as a model for such hospitals in the United States (Raffel and Raffel, 1994). Later, creation of the National Health Ser vice in 1948 brought the British nonprofit hospitals under government ownership.
In the United States, the founding of voluntary hospitals-nonprofit com-
_ munity hospitals financed through local philanthropy as opposed to taxes-was often inspired by influential physi cians, with the financial backing of local donors and philanthropists. These hos pitals accepted both indigent and pay ing patients, but to cover their operating expenses, they required charitable contri butions from private citizens.
The first voluntary hospital in the United States established specifically to care for the sick was the Pennsylvania
352 Chapt r I Inpatient Facilities and Services
Hospital in Philadelphia, which opened in 1752. At the time, the city already had an
_almshouse. However, Dr. Thomas Bond, a London-trained physician, brought to prominence the need for a hospital to care for the sick poor of the city. Benjamin Franklin, who was a friend and advisor of Dr. Bond, was instrumental in promoting the idea and in raising voluntary contribu tions to finance the hospital. According to the Pennsylvania Hospital's charter, the contributors had the right to make all laws and regulations relating to the hospital's operation. The contributors also elected members to form the governing board, or the board of trustees. Thus, the control of voluntary hospitals was in the hands of influential community laypeople rather than physicians (Raffel and Raffel, 1994).
Other prominent voluntary hospitals included the New York Hospital in New York, which was completed in 1775 but, due to the Revolutionary War, was not opened to civilian patients until 1791. The Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston was incorporated in 1812 and opened in 1821. During this period, the almshouses continued to serve an important function by receiving overflow patients who could not be admitted to the hospitals because of the unavailability of beds or who had to be discharged from hospitals because they were declared incurable (Raffel and Raffel, 1994). Later hospitals in the United States were modeled after the Pennsylvania, New York, and Massachusetts General hospitals.
Organized Institutions of Medical Practice Social and demographic change, but above all advances in medical science and technol ogy, transformed hospitals into institutions
of medical practice. Beginning in the latter half of the 19th century, new medical tech nology, facilities, and personnel training all became centered in the hospital.
Over time, improvements in hygiene, advanced medical care, and surgical ser vices made hospitals more acceptable to the middle and upper classes. Indeed, hospitals began to attract affluent patients who could afford to pay privately. Thus, the hospital was transformed from a charitable institu tion into one that could generate a profit. In many instances, physicians started opening small hospitals, financed by wealthy and influential sponsors. These facilities were the first proprietary (for-profit) hospitals.
In the early 20th century, the field of hospital administration became a disci pline in its own right. Hospitals needed administrators with expertise in financial management and organizational skills to manage them. The administrative structure of the hospital was organized into depart ments, such as food service, pharmacy, x-ray, and laboratory. In turn, it became necessary to employ professional staff to manage the delivery of services. Efficiency began to emerge as an important element in the management of hospitals. This early emphasis on efficiency foreshadowed two main issues that continue to affect health policy and hospital management: the pressure on hospitals to introduce new technology while containing costs and the assumption that hospitals should oper ate like businesses (Arndt and Bigelow, 2006). Pressure to control costs, along with the availability of advanced medical care in outpatient settings, forced hospitals to limit care to more acute periods of illness rather than the full course of a disease.
Hospital accreditation was another notable development in the early 20th
century. The American College of Surgeons (ACS) began inspecting hospitals in 1918 and developed standards for hospital equip ment and hospital wards. Until 1951, the ACS single-handedly took responsibility for improving hospital-based medical practice. In 19 51, this effort evolved into the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Hospitals, a private nonprofit body formed through the joint efforts of the ACS, the American College of Physicians, the AHA, and the American Medical Association (AMA). The organization changed its name in 1987 to the Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations, which more accurately describes the variety of health facilities it accredits. Since 2007, its official name has been the Joint Commission.
Advanced Institutions of Medical Training and Research Advances in biomedical knowledge made it necessary for physicians to receive most of their training in hospitals, which in turn led to collaborations between hospitals and universities. Pennsylvania Hospital, for example, taught courses required by the College of Philadelphia's medical school, which later became the University of Penn sylvania School of Medicine. Similarly, New York Hospital served as a teaching hospital for medical students of Columbia Medical School, and Massachusetts General Hospi tal provided practical clinical instruction for students of Harvard Medical School (Raffel and Raffel, 1994). To complete phy sicians' medical training, internships and residencies became necessary.
The Johns Hopkins Hospital (opened in 1889), with its adjoining medical school (opened in 1893), inaugurated a new era during which teaching was combined with
Hospital Transformation in the United States 353
clinical practice and scientific inquiry in medicine. In affiliation with university-based medical schools, many hospitals became centers of medical research. The vast number of clinical records and large array of medical conditions among hospital patients provided a wealth of data that informed investigative studies to advance medical knowledge. Even today, large hospitals play an important role in clinical studies. To a lesser extent, some aspects of medical training have shifted to other settings, such as nursing homes, hos pices, and community health centers.
Consolidated Systems of Health Services Delivery Hospitals have been the major cost centers in the health care delivery system. During the 1980s and 1990s, concerns over rising costs prompted the introduction of prospective and capitated payment methods and aggres sive utilization review practices that brought about drastic reductions in the length of inpatient stays. The declining utilization of acute care beds had left most hospitals with excess capacity in the form of empty beds. As the acute inpatient care sector of health care delivery became less profitable, hos pitals adopted a number of consolidation strategies. Multihospital systems formed through mergers and acquisitions; hospital systems diversified into nonacute services, such as outpatient centers, home health care, long-term care, and subacute care; and some hospitals affiliated with networks through contractual arrangements.
Intense consolidation in certain hos pital markets diluted competition, which benefited hospitals. Research suggests that hospital consolidation in the 1990s raised prices by at least 5% as competition eroded (Vogt and Town, 2006).
354 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
� The Expansion Phase: Late 1800s to Mid-1980s
Hospitals grew in numbers when they became a necessary local adjunct of medi cal practice. Growth in medical technology increased the volume of surgical proce dures, almost all of which were performed in hospitals. The number of U.S. hospitals grew from 178 (35,604 beds) in 1872 to 4,359 (421,065 beds) in 1909. By 1929, 6,665 hospitals provided 907,133 beds in the United States (Haglund and Dowling, 1993). As new beds were built, their avail ability almost ensured that they would be used. This phenomenon led Milton Roemer ( 1916-2001) to proclaim, "a built bed is a filled bed"-an affirmation known popularly as Roemer's law (Roemer, 1961).
Haglund and Dowling (1993) identified six significant factors in the growth of hos pitals: advances in medical science, devel opment of specialized technology, advances in medical education, development of pro fessional nursing, growth of health insur ance, and the role of government. The first three factors were discussed in the previous section; this section covers the last three.
Development of Professional Nursing During the latter half of the 19th century, Florence Nightingale was instrumental in transforming nursing into a recognized profession in Great Britain. Following the founding of the Nightingale School of Nursing in England, nursing schools in the United States were established at Bellevue Hospital (New York City), New Haven Hospital (New Haven, Connecticut), and
Massachusetts General Hospital (Boston). The benefits of having trained nurses in hospitals became apparent as the increased efficacy of treatment and hygiene asso ciated with such care improved patient recovery (Haglund and Dowling, 1993). Thus, professional nursing was instrumen tal in transforming hospitals, which to an increasing extent came to be regarded as places of healing, and found acceptance with the middle and upper classes.
Growth of Private Health Insurance Private health insurance in the United States first began as a hospital insurance plan to protect both patients and hospitals against financial instability. During and after the Great Depression of the 1930s, many hospitals were forced to close, and the financial solvency of many more was threatened. Consequently, the number of hospitals in the United States dropped from 6,852 in 1928 to 6,189 in 1937. The growth of private health insurance subsequently became a vehicle for enabling people to pay for hospital services, and the flow of insur ance money helped revive the financial stability of hospitals. Historically, insur ance plans provided generous coverage for inpatient care, placing few restrictions on patients and physicians (Feldstein, 1971).
Role of Government Government funding for hospital con - struction perhaps played the most impor tant role in the expansion of hospitals in the 20th century. Subsequently, Medicare and Medicaid provided indirect funding to the hospital industry by vastly expand ing public-sector health insurance.
The ill-8 o A
Relatively little hospital construction took place during the Great Depression and World War II, so, by the end of the war, there was a severe shortage of hospital beds in the United States. The Hospital Survey and Con struction Act of 1946, commonly referred to as the Hill-Burton Act, provided federal grants to states for the construction of new community hospitals ( nonfederal, short stay hospitals) that would be operated on a nonprofit basis. This legislation required that each state develop and upgrade, annually, a plan for health facility construction based on bed-to-population ratios, which became the basis for the allocation of federal construc tion grants to the states (Raffel, 1980).
In 1946, after World War II ended, 3.2 community hospital beds were available per 1,000 civilian population in the United States. The objective of the Hill-Burton Act was to reach 4.5 beds per 1,000 population (Teisberg et al., 1991). The Hill-Burton pro gram assisted in the construction of nearly 40% of the beds in the nation's short-stay general hospitals and was the single great est factor that increased the U.S. bed supply during the 1950s and 1960s (Haglund and Dowling, 1993). Indeed, the Hill-Burton Act made it possible for even small, remote communities to have their own hospitals (Wolfson and Hopes, 1994). By 1980, the United States had reached its goal of 4.5 community hospital beds per 1,000 civil ian population (National Center for Health Statistics [NCHS], 2002) even though the Hill-Burton program ended in 1974.
Thanks to the Hill-Burton Act, non profit community hospitals in the United States far outnumber all other types of hos pitals even today. Competition from the new hospitals led to the closure of many smaller proprietary, for-profit hospitals.
The Expansion Phase: Late 7 BOOs to Mid- 7 980s 355
Public ealth Insurance The creation of the Medicare and Med icaid programs in 1965 also had a sig nificant-albeit indirect-impact on the increased number of hospital beds and their utilization (Feldstein, 1993), as gov ernment-funded health insurance became available to a large number of elderly and poor Americans. Between 1965 and 1980, the number of community hospitals in the United States increased from 5,736 (741,000 beds) to 5,830 (988,000 beds); total admissions per 1,000 population increased from 130 to 154; and total inpa tient days per 1,000 population increased from 1,007 to 1,159. The percentage of occupied beds also remained relatively stable at around 76% (AHA, 1990). FIGURE8·1 shows trends from 1940 to 2015 in the number of beds per 1,000 resident population.
5 4.5
4 3.6
3 2.9 2.6 2.4
2
1
FIGURE8-1 Trends in t he num ber of U.S. community
hospital beds per 1,000 resident population.
Data from National Center for Health Statistics. 2002. Health, United
States, 2002. Hyattsville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human
Services. p. 281; National Center for Health Statistics. 2018. Health,
United States, 207 7. Hyattsville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and
Human Services. Table 41.
356 Chapt r 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
� The Downsizing Phase: Mid-1980s Onward
The mid-1980s marked a turning point in the growth and utilization of hospital beds. After a sharp decline in 1985, the number of community hospitals and the total number of beds continued to decline until 2005 (FIGURE 8-2). The main reasons for the decline in hospital capacity and utilization were a shift from inpatient to outpatient care driven by changes in reim bursement and the impact of managed care. Consequently, a number of hospitals had to either close down or repurpose the use of acute care beds for other types of services, such as nursing home care.
In 2015, the average occupancy rate (percentage of beds occupied) in commu nity hospitals was 63.6%, and the average
5,900
5,800
5,700
5,600
(/) � 5,500 ·a. (/) � 5,400
0 Ci> 5,300
.0 E ::J
z 5,200
5,100
5,000
4,900
length of stay was 5.5 days (NCHS, 2018). Hospital utilization has remained rela tively stable in recent years. The COVID- 19 pandemic that hit the United States in 2020, however, had a significant effect on hospital utilization.
Changes in Reimbursement The Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act (TEFRA) of 1982 required the conver sion of hospital Medieare reimbursement from cost-plus to a prospective payment system (PPS) based on diagnosis-related groups (DRGs). Under PPS, hospitals are paid a fixed amount per admission accord ing to the patient's principal diagnosis, regardless of how long the patient stays in the hospital. To make a profit, the hos pital must keep its costs below the fixed reimbursement amount, which creates an
- Hospitals (Y1)
- - - Beds (Y2) 1,000,000
950,000 (/) -c Q) co
900,000 0 Ci>
.0 E ::J
z
850,000
800,000
4,800 -+---..-------------�-----------1
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2018
FIGURE 8·2 T he decline in the num ber of U.S . community hospitals and beds .
Data from National Center for Health Statistics. 2002. Health, United States, 2002. Hyattsville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. p. 279;
Health, United States, 207 7, Table 89; Health Forum. 2020. Fast facts on U.S. hospitals. Available at: https://www.aha.org/statistics/fast-facts-us-hospitals.
Accessed August 2020.
Some Key Utilization Measures and Operational Concepts 357
incentive to minimize the patient's length of stay. Following Medicare's lead, other payers soon adopted prospective methods to reimburse hospitals. Private insurers also resorted to competitive pricing and dis counted fees and closely monitored when patients would be hospitalized and for how long. As PPS reimbursement exerted pres sure on hospitals to reduce the length of stay after admission, early discharge from hospitals became practical only as alterna tive services, such as home health care and subacute long-term care, were developed to deliver postacute continuity of care.
The effect of PPS reimbursement on hospitals was dramatic. In the 1980s, 550 hospitals closed and 159 mergers and acquisitions occurred (Balotsky, 2005). Since then, the number of community hospital beds per 1,000 resident popula tion has continued to decline, reaching 2.4 per 1,000 in 2015 (see Figure 8-1). Notably, since 1998, the U.S. hospital capacity per 1 ,000 resident population has remained less than the level in 1946, when the Hill Burton Act was passed. In those days, the additional hospital bed capacity may have been necessary because the settings for postdischarge continuity of care were not well developed. Subsequently, technologi cal advances enabled the development and use of these alternative delivery settings. Hence, technology has played a major role in the tremendous advances in efficiency within the health care system.
Impact of Managed Care In the 1990s, managed care became a growing force that transformed the delivery of health services in the United States. Managed care has emphasized cost containment and the efficient delivery of services by stressing the use of alternative
delivery settings whenever appropri ate. Notably, greater market penetration by health maintenance organizations (HMOs) played a significant role in low ering hospital utilization and profitability (Clement and Grazier, 2001).
Hospital Closures Between 1990 and 2000, more than 200 rural hospitals ( 8% of all rural hospitals) and nearly 300 urban hospitals ( 11 % of all urban hospitals) closed for economic rea sons (Office of Inspector General, 2003). Declining utilization was the main factor underlying this trend. Overall, the total number of community hospitals declined by 9% during the 1990s; the total number of beds in community hospitals declined by 11 % (N CHS, 2013). Hospitals of all sizes throughout the United States either closed entire wings or converted those beds to alternative uses, such as outpatient care, long-term care, or rehabilitation services.
Since 2000, many government -run hospitals, at both the federal and local lev els, have closed. For example, the number of hospitals operated by state and local gov ernments declined from l, 163 in 2000 to 965 in 2018 (Health Forum, 2020; NCHS, 2016) because those facilities could not compete with private community hospitals.
� Some·Key Utilization Measures and Operational Concepts
Discharges The total number of patient discharges per 1,000 population (hospitalization rate) is one indicator of access to hospital inpatient
358 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
services and of the extent of utilization. Because babies born in the hospital are not included in admissions, discharges provide a more accurate count of inpatients served by a hospital. Discharge data for a hos pital indicate the total number of patients discharged from the hospital's acute care beds during a given period. Deaths in hos pitals are counted as discharges.
In general, hospitalization rates and lengths of stay increase with age (except for infants). Females have a higher rate of hospitalization compared to males but incur shorter lengths of stay. This holds true even when data are adjusted to account for pregnancy-related hospitaliza tions. Other details on hospitalizations in the United States are given in TABLE 8·1.
TABLE 8·1 Discharges, Average Length of Stay, and Average Cost per Stay in U.S.
Community Hospitals, 2016
< 1 year 4,200 210.8 3.9
1-17years 1,300 17.1 4.2 12,500
18-44 years 8,700 75. 4 3.8 8,600
45-64 years 8,800 104.3 5.1 14,500
65-84 years 9,900 232.5 5.2 14,500
� 85 years 2,800 455.7 5.1 11,300
Gender
Male 15,400 91.3 5.0 13,300
Female 20,200
Primary Payer
Medicare 14, 100 13,600
Some Key Utilization Measures and Operational Concepts 359
Medicaid 8,200 4.6 9,800
Private insurance 10,700 3.9 10,900
Uninsured 1,500 4.1 9,300
Community Income in the Area of Residence
Lowest 10,800 122.7 4.8 1 1,000
Hig hest 7,000 82.5 4.5 12,900
Weiss, A. J., and A. Elixhauser. 2014. Overview of hospital stays in the United States, 2012 (Statistical Brief #180). Rockville, MD: Agencyfor
Healthcare Research and Quality. Available at: http://www.hcup-us.ahrq.gov/reports/statbriefs/sb 180-Hospitalizations-United-States-2012.pdf.
Accessed May 2017.
In 2016, Medicare paid for the largest number of hospitalizations, followed by private insurance and Medicaid. More than 6 million inpatient days were attributed to patients without insurance. Relative to the U.S. population, the East South Central area (Mississippi, Alabama, Tennessee, and Kentucky) had a disproportionately higher share of hospital stays; the Pacific and Mountain divisions in the western United States had a disproportionately lower share of hospital stays (Freeman et al., 2018).
People living in low-income commu nities-a proxy for socioeconomic sta tus-have higher hospitalization rates and longer lengths of stay compared to those living in higher-income communities. Poorer population groups are generally in poorer health and have less access to routine primary care. These patients also have higher levels of trust in the technical quality of hospital services compared to primary care (Kangovi et al., 2013).
Inpatient Days An inpatient day (also called a patient day) is a night spent in the hospital by a patient. The cumulative number of patient
days over a certain period is known as days of care. Days of care per 1,000 pop ulation over the course of one year reflect utilization of inpatient services.
Average Length of Stay Average length of stay (ALOS) is cal culated by dividing the total days of care by the total number of discharges. Note that the ALOS is overstated when using admissions rather than discharges as the divisor. ALOS measures the number of days a patient, on average, spends in the hospital. Hence, this measure, when applied to individuals or specific groups of patients, is an indicator of sever ity of illness and resource use. In addi tion, ALOS has cost implications. Other things being equal, short hospital stays reduce the cost per discharge. FIGURE 8·3 illustrates ALOS trends in community hospitals.
FIGURE 8·4 shows trends in ALOS by type of hospital ownership. Government owned hospitals have longer lengths of stay, compared to private hospitals. Federal hospitals mainly include those in the Veterans Health Administration
360 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
system, which serve an aging popula tion. State and local government hospitals disproportionately serve the poor and uninsured.
8
7.6
7
6
5
1980 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015
FIGURE 8-3 Trends in average lengt h of stay in
nonfederal s hort-stay hospitals , selected years .
Note: Lengths of stay have been somewhat overstated because
they are calculated by dividing total inpatient days by admissions,
instead of discharges.
Data from National Center for Health Statistics. 2018. Health, United States,
2017. Hyattsville, MD: Department of Health and Human Services. Table 82.
16
en 14
>- 12 as
� � 10
- (f) 8 - 0
6 .c - C> 4 c Q)
_J 2
0
Federal State/Local Govt.
Hospital Access and Utilization: Comparative Data There has been increasing interest in comparing the U.S. health system to the health systems of other countries. For this purpose, the Organization for Eco nomic Cooperation and Development ( 0 ECD) is a reliable source of compara tive health care data. TABLE 8-2 provides hospital utilization data for selected OECD members. Note that the data for the United States in this table include all hospitals, not just community hospitals (as in Table 8-1).
Japan is clearly an outlier in hos pital capacity and utilization. Because a greater supply of hospital beds gener ally leads to higher utilization (Roemer's law), policymakers around the world have adopted the policy of reducing the number of hospital beds. Since 2000, the number of beds per capita has decrease,d in nearly all OECD countries. Part of the decrease can be attributed to advances in medical technology. Between 2000 and 2017, the number of discharges fell
5.4 5.3 5.4
Nonprofit For profit
• 2000 • 2010 • 2015
FIGURE 8-4 Average lengt hs of stay by U.S. hospital owners hip , selected years.
Data from National Center for Health Statistics. 2018. Health, United States, 2071. Hyattsville, MD: Department of Health and Human Services. Table 82.
Some Key Utilization Measures and Operational Concepts 361
TABLE 8-2 Inpatient Hospital Utilization: Comparative Data for Selected OECD Countries, 2017
Hospital Beds
per 1,000 Population
Discharges
per 1,000 Population
Average
Length of
Stay (Days)
Occupancy
Rate
(O/o)
Australia 3.8 18 11 5.6 NA
Canada 2.5 841,2 7.4 9 1.6
France 6.0 1821 9.9 75.6
Germany 8.0 255 8.9 79.8
Japan 13.1 128 16.2 75.5
United Kingdom 2.5 131 6.9 84.3
United States 2.8 125 6.1 64.0
OECD3 average 4.7 154 7.7 75.2
1 Newborns are not included.
2 Data are not comparable to other countries.
3 All OECD countries, not just the ones shown in the table.
Data from Organization for Economic Cooperatio� and Development (OECD). 2019. Health at a glance, 2019: OECD indicators. Available at: https://www.
oecd-ilibrary.org/docserver /4dd50c09-en.pdf?expires= 159778431?&id=id&accname=guest&checksum=17 AOC 45135450B1OB4E8B80741 OCC683.
Accessed August 2020.
in the majority of OECD countries, with some of the largest reductions observed in countries where there were also large decreases in the number of beds. High occupancy rates of curative (acute) care beds can be symptomatic of a health sys tem under pressure and may lead to bed shortages and higher rates of infection (OECD, 2019).
Capacity The number of beds set up and staffed for inpatient use determines the size or capac ity of a hospital. Among all community hos pitals in the United States, 84% have fewer
Total number of community hos pitals = 4,862 Total number of beds= 782, 188
300-499 beds 10%
;:::SO� o �eds
6-24 beds
FIGURE 8-5 Breakdown of U.S. community hospitals
by size , 20 15.
Data from National Center for Health Statistics. 2018. Health, United States,
2077. Hyattsville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Table 89.
362 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
than 300 beds (FIGURE 8·5). The average size of a community hospital was approxi mately 16 1 beds in 2015. Between 2000 and 2010, the number of hospitals with fewer than 50 beds increased by 33% (from 1,198 to 1 ,591) (NCHS, 2018), primarily because of a dramatic rise in the number of physi cian-owned specialty hospitals (discussed later in the section "Specialty Hospitals"). However, regulations under the Afford able Care Act (ACA) put a squeeze on the growth of these hospitals. Consequently, between 2010 and 2015, the growth trick led down to 3 .4% (NCHS, 2018).
Average Daily Census The average number of inpatients receiving care each day in a hospital is called the average daily census. This measure is often used to define occu pancy of inpatient beds in hospitals and other inpatient facilities. The total inpa tient days during a given period (days of care) is divided by the number of days in that period to arrive at the average daily census. For example, if the number
"O Q) ·c..
80
B 75 (.) 0 en
"O Q)
c:o 70 - 0 Q) C> ct! c 65 Q) � cf
60
78.0
64.8
of total inpatient days for July is 3, 1 62, then the average daily census for July is 102 (3, 1 62/3 1 ).
Occupancy Rate The occupancy rate for a given period is derived by dividing the average daily cen sus for that period by the average number of beds (capacity). The resulting fraction is then expressed as a percentage (percent of beds occupied); it indicates the propor tion of a hospital's total inpatient capacity actually utilized. Occupancy rates are also calculated for other types of inpatient facilities, such as nursing homes, and often used as a measure of performance when compared with competitors or with statewide or nationwide data.
FIGURE 8·6 shows the change in aggregate occupancy rates for U.S. community hospi tals from 1960 to 2015. Individual hospitals can compare their own occupancy rates against industry benchmarks. In a competi tive environ�ent, facilities with higher occu pancy rates are considered more successful than those with lower occupancy rates.
1960 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015
FIGURE 8·6 Change in occupancy rates in U.S. community hospitals, 1960-2015 (selected years).
Data from National Center for Health Statistics. 2013. Health, United States, 2012. Hyattsville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. p. 314;
Health, United States, 2017. Table 89.
Hospital Demand, Employment, Expenditures, and Profitability 363
Hospital Demand, Employment, Expenditures, and Profitability
Increases in demand for hospital services and expenditures are driven by demographic trends such as aging of the population and overall population growth; advances in medical technology; health insurance status of the population; and health status of the population, such as the prevalence of chronic conditions. The COVID-19 pandemic, however, was an outlier. As the nation was gripped by the pandemic, the number of hospitalizations mounted, but many routine as well as critical services were cancelled. Projecting the demand for intensive care became a major challenge because the forecasting models turned out to be misleading (Chin et al., 2020).
Pharmaceutical care in hospitals by clinical pharmacists who can address med ication-related issues can shorten hospital stays (Lin et al. , 2020). Similarly, phar maceutical care delivered by community pharmacists can prevent hospitalizations (Pai et al., 2009). Hospital utilization is also significantly reduced for patients with human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)/ acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS) who adhere to their antiretroviral therapy regimens (Nachega et al. , 2010).
Demand for services is the most important factor that affects hospital employment. Hospitals are the largest employers in the health care industry, and hospitals and medical systems are among the largest employers in several states. Health care in general is a growth indus try. Even during the Great Recession of
2007-2009, employment in the health care sector continued to increase even when the rate of unemployment had reached 10% in the general economy (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2018).
Other factors have had a downward influence on hospital demand and jobs. For example, a shift away from treatment on an inpatient basis and toward treatment in outpatient settings has increased demand for outpatient services. Along with the growth of outpatient centers, employment in the outpatient sector has more than dou bled since 2003 (Kacik, 2018a). This trend is expected to continue in the future.
Hospital Expenditures Along with the shift in utilization of hospital services, the share of personal health expenditures for hospital care had declined until 2005, but it has slowly crept up since then (TABLE 8·3).
Inpatient hospital services constitute the largest share (about one-third) of total health care expenditures in the United States. FIGURE 8-7 shows the aggregate costs and hospital stays by payer type. Most of the hospital utilization is incurred by Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries; hence, most of the inpatient expenditures are borne by the government. Even though Medicare is the single largest payer for hospital services, the program's inpatient costs as a proportion of total costs actually declined from 36.9% in 2007 to 32.6% in 2017 (Sanofi-Aventis/Forte Information Resources, 2019). Overall, hospital expen ditures have risen faster than total personal health care expenditures (Table 8-3), so the year-to-year rise in hospital-related expenses remains a central concern among policymakers (Liang et al., 2020).
364 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
TABLE 8-3 Share of Personal Health Expenditures Used for Hospital Care
1980
1990
2000
2005
2010
2015
2018
Increase over
2010-2018
1 Expenditures are in billions of dollars.
Personal Health Expenditures1
217.0
615 .3
1,161.5
1,695 .7
2,191.4
2,710.2
3,075.5
40.3%
Hospital Expenditures 1
100.5
415.5
608.6
822.3
1,034.6
1,191.8
Percentage Share
46.3%
35 .8%
37.5%
38.8%
Data from Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). National health expenditure data. NHE tables (historical). Available at: https://www.cms.gov
/Resea rch-S tatisti cs-Data-and-Systems/Statistics-Trends-a nd-Reports/Nationa I Health Expend Data/National HealthAccountsHistorica I. Accessed July 2020.
Profitability Research shows that hospital revenues are declining as expenses keep rising, thus squeezing hospital operating margins (profitability). Between 2015 and 2016, expenses for nonprofit hospitals grew by 7.5% while revenue grew by 6.6% (Burrill and Kane, 201 7). The transition from vol ume-based reimbursement to value-based payments has presented a major challenge to hospitals' profitability, along with the shift from inpatient to outpatient care.
Even as hospital admissions have fallen, overall hospital employment has risen. Labor is the largest single com - ponent of hospital costs, accounting for roughly 50% of most hospitals' total oper ating costs (Burrill and Kane, 201 7).
Profitability has implications for hos pital survival. Hospitals with a higher ratio of RN s per bed (which translates into improved quality of care), higher operat ing margin, lower percentage of revenues from Medicare and Medicaid, and lower competition are less likely to suffer adverse financial consequences (Pai et al., 201 7). It is also noteworthy that hospitals located in states that implemented Medicaid expansion (an option left up to each state after the 2012 Supreme Court decision on the ACA) have significantly increased Medicaid revenues, decreased uncom pensated care costs, and improvements in profit margins compared with hospitals located in states that did not expand their Medicaid programs (Blavin, 201 6).
Hospital Demand, Employment, Expenditures, and Profitability 365
120%
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0% Aggregate costs
$434.2 billion
Other
Hospital stays 35.8 million
•Medicaid
•Private insurance •Medicare
FIGUREB-7 Aggregate hospital costs and hospital
stays by payer type, 2017. Data from Liang, L., et al., 2020. National inpatient hospital costs: The most
expen-sive conditions by payer, 2017. Statistical Brief #261. Agency for Healthcare
Research and Quality. Available at: https://hcup-us.ahrq.gov/reports/statbriefs
/sb261-Most-Expensive-Hospital-Conditions-2017 .jsp. Accessed August 2020.
250
213
137 132
lnternationa Cost Comparisons To compare the relative price differ ences in various national currencies, the OECD converts the prices into a common currency using purchasing power parities (PPP). In economics, PPPs are conversion rates that show the ratio of prices for a basket of goods in one currency to the same goods in another currency. Hence, PPPs mea sure differences in price levels between countries. FIGURE 8-8 shows uniform hospital prices in selected countries. In 20 1 7, hospital services in Switzerland were priced at 2 1 3% (more than twice) of the OECD average. In the United States, the same services cost 3 7% more than the OECD average. In the United Kingdom, the same hospital services were priced at 7 1 % (29% less) of the OECD average.
OECD average: 100
116 96
87 82 71 66
FICiUREB-8 International comparative hospital prices, 2017. Data from Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). 2020. Focus on health care prices. Available at: http://www.oecd.org/health/
health-systems/Health-Care-Prices-Brief-May-2020.pdf. Accessed August 2020.
366 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
� Types of Hospitals The U.S. hospital market includes a vari ety of institutional forms, including both private and government-owned hos pitals. Most hospitals are private, non - profit, short-stay, community hospitals (FIGURE 8-9). Private, for-profit (investor owned) community hospitals are next in predominance; then come the state and local government-owned community hos pitals and, finally, federal hospitals, which are not community hospitals.
The endless variations in hospital char acteristics defy any simple classification. The classification arrangements described in this section have been commonly used to differentiate among the various types of hospitals. Keep in mind, however, that these classifications are not mutually exclusive.
Psychiatric Other* (nonfederal) 2%
10%
Federal
All hospitals = 6, 146
*Long-term hospitals and hospital units in institutions such as prisons, college campuses, etc.
FIGURE 8-9 Proportion of total U.S. hospitals by type
of hospital, 2018. Data from Health Forum. 2020. Fast facts on US hospitals. AHA hospital
statistics, 2020 edition. Available at: https://www.aha.org/system/files/
media/ti le/2020/01 /2020-a ha-hospital-fast-facts-new-Ja n-2020. pdf.
Accessed August 2020.
Classification by Ownership
Public Hospitals Public hospitals are owned by agencies of federal, state, or local governments. Note that the word "public" does not have its ordinary meaning in this context. A public hospital, for instance, is not necessarily a hospital that is open to the general public. For example, federal hospitals serve spe cial groups of federal beneficiaries, such as Native Americans, military personnel, and veterans, rather than the general population. Veterans Affairs (VA) hospitals constitute the largest group among federal hospitals.
Local governments, such as counties and cities, operate hospitals to serve the general population. Many of these hospi tals are located in large urban areas, where they function as an important safety net for the inner-city indigent and disad vantaged populations. Hence, Medicare, Medicaid, and state and local tax dollars pay for a large portion of the services these hospitals provide. Because of increasing financial pressures, many public hospitals have had to privatize or close in recent years. Out of the 1 ,444 state and local gov ernment-owned hospitals operating in the United States in 1990, only 965 remained in operation in 201 8 (Health Forum, 2020). Most hospitals operated by city and county governments are small to moder ate in size. Some large public hospitals are affiliated with medical schools; they play a significant role in training physicians and other health care professionals.
Compared to private hospitals, public hospitals incur higher utilization, at least in terms of ALOS (see Figure 8-4). ALOS is the highest in federal hospitals ( 10.5 days in 2015), and veterans are the biggest users of these hospitals.
Private Nonprofit Hospitals Nonprofit hospitals are owned and oper
ated by community associations or other
nongovernment organizations. Their pri mary mission is to benefit the community
in which they are located. Patient fees,
third-party reimbursement, donations,
and endowments cover their operating expenses. The private nonprofit sector constitutes the largest group of hospitals (see Figure 8-9), accounting for 48% of all U.S. hospitals. In a managed care envi ronment, nonprofit hospitals have been found to be more efficient than for-profit hospitals. Efficiency is determined by the amount of inputs (e.g., medical supplies, labor) utilized to generate hospital outputs (e.g., discharges, visits, medical training) (Keon-Hyung et al., 2009).
Private For-Profit Hospitals For-profit proprietary hospitals-also referred to as investor-owned hospi tals -are owned by individuals, partner ships, or corporations. They are operated for the financial benefit of the entity that owns the institution; in other words, they are accountable to their stockholders.
At the beginning of the 20th century, more than half of all U.S. hospitals were proprietary institutions. Most of these hos pitals were small and were established by physicians who wanted to hospitalize their own patients (Stewart, 1973). Later, most of these institutions were dosed or acquired by community organizations or hospital corpo rations due to population shifts, increased costs, and the necessities of modern clinical practice (Raffel and Raffel, 1994).
Even though nonprofit hospitals have maintained their overall dominance in the U.S. hospital market, closures have
Types of Hospitals 367
reduced the number of these hospitals and their bed numbers. Conversely, the num bers of for-profit hospitals and beds have increased quite substantially (TABLE 8-4).
The greater increase in the number of hospitals compared to the number of beds and the significant reduction in the aver age size of U.S. hospitals reflect the growth of physician-owned specialty hospitals (discussed later in the section "Specialty Hospitals"), which are smaller in size than other community hospitals. However, pri vate nonprofit hospitals continue to boast higher occupancy rates than for-profit hospitals.
Classification by Public Access Almost 85% of all U.S. hospitals are clas sified as community hospitals (Health Forum, 2020). A community hospi tal is a nonfederal, short-stay hospital whose primary mission is to serve the general community. It may be a private for-profit facility or a private nonprofit facility, or it may be owned by the state or local government, but not by the federal government ( · GU E ·10). A community hospital can also be a general hospital or a specialty hospital. Noncommunity hos pitals include hospitals operated by the federal government, such as VA hospitals to serve veterans; hospital units of insti tutions, such as prisons and infirmaries in colleges and universities; and long-stay hospitals.
Classification by Multiunit Affiliation ·
Hospitals are considered to be part of a multihospital chain-also referred to as
I
I
368 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities a nd Services
2000
Private Nonprofit
Number of hospitals 3,003
Number of beds 582,988
Average size 194
Occupancy rate 65.5 %
Private For-Profit
Number of hospitals 749
Number of beds 109,883
Average size 147
Occupancy rate 55 .9%
2015 Change
2,845 -5.3%
5 30,579 -9.0%
186.5 -3.9%
65.3% -0.2%
1,034 38.1%
135,569 23.4%
131.1 -10.8%
5 7.5 % 1.6%
Data from National Center for Health Statistics. 2018. Health, United States, 2017. Hyattsville, MD: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Table 89.
a multihospital system (MHS)-when two or more hospitals are owned, leased, sponsored, or contractually managed by a central organization (Health Forum, 2020). MHSs are predominant in the private sec tor-including both nonprofit and for profit institutions. In the public sector, the Veterans Health Administration (VHA) operates the single largest MHS in the United States, with more than 145 medical centers operated by the federal government.
The number of hospitals in MHSs has grown annually since 2004, and the pace of consolidation that contributes to their forma tion has accelerated and is likely to continue. In 2018, 3,491 community hospitals (67% of all community hospitals) were affiliated with MHSs (Health Forum, 2020). The pace of
All community hospitals = 5, 198
FIGURE 8-10 Breakdown of U.S. community
hospitals by type of ownership, 2018. Data from Health Forum. 2020. Fast facts on US hospitals. AHA hospital
statistics, 2020 edition. Available at: https://www.aha.org/system/files/
media/fi le/2020/01 /2020-aha-hospital-fast-facts-new-Ja n-2020 .pdf.
Accessed August 2020.
consolidation (i.e., hospitals acquiring phy sician clinics, and hospitals in turn merging into larger systems) has been accelerating for some time. Not only have hospitals and phy sicians been joining MHSs, but the systems themselves have been merging to form even larger systems (Burns et al., 2015).
It is generally believed that larger health systems create better efficiencies,
Types of Hospitals 369
but this does not appear to be happening on a widespread scale. To the contrary, health system consolidation has been found to limit competition, which results in higher prices. This outcome occurs despite the fact that the vast majority of these consolidated health systems are nonprofit entities (TABLE 8·5). MHSs have used various tactics to undermine health
TABLE 8-5 The Largest U.S. Multihospital Chains, 2019
Name of Hospital System {Location)
Nonprofit Chains
Ascension Health (St. Louis, MO)
CommonSpirit Health (Chicago, IL)
Trinity Health (Livonia, Ml)
Providence St. Joseph Health (Renton, WA)
AdventHealth ( Altamonte Springs, FL)
Atrium Health (Charlotte, NC)
Providence Health and Services (Renton, WA)
For-Profit Chains
HCA (Nashville, TN)
Community Health Systems (Franklin, TN)
LifePoint Health (Brentwood, TN)
Tenet Health System (Dallas, TX)
Vibra Healthcare (Mechanicsburg, PA)
Number of Hospitals
151
142
92
51
50
50
26
185
105
86
65
65
Data from Dyrda, L. 2019. 100 of the largest hospitals and health systems in America, 2019. Becker� Hospital Review. Available at: https://www
.beckershospital review.com/largest-hospitals-a nd-health-systems-in-america-2019. htm I. Accessed August 2020.
370 Chapter & Inpatient Facilities and Services
insurers' ability to negotiate lower prices (Bindman, 2020).
Classification by Type of Service
General Hospitals A general hospital provides a variety of services, including general and specialized medicine, general and specialized surgery, and obstetrics, to meet almost all medi cal needs of the community it serves. It provides diagnostic, treatment, and surgi cal services for patients with a variety of medical conditions. Most hospitals in the United States are general hospitals.
The term "general hospital" does not imply that these hospitals are less special ized or that their care is inferior to that of specialty hospitals. The difference lies in the nature of services, not their qual ity. General hospitals provide a broader range of services for a larger variety of conditions, whereas specialty hospitals provide a narrow range of services for specific medical conditions or patient populations.
Specialty Hospitals According to the North American Indus try Classification System developed by the U.S. Census Bureau, specialty hospitals are establishments that primarily engage in providing diagnostic and medical treat ment to inpatients with a specific type of disease or medical condition (but not services for psychiatric care or substance abuse). Specialty hospitals forge their own distinct service niches. Traditionally, the two most common types of specialty hospi tals have been rehabilitation hospitals and children's hospitals. With increasing com petition, however, other types of specialty
hospitals have emerged to provide treat ments that are also available in many gen eral hospitals. Examples include orthopedic hospitals, cardiac hospitals, cancer ( oncol ogy) hospitals, and women's hospitals.
Physicians find such specialized hospi tals more efficient, and in many instances, physicians are full or part owners of these hospitals. Affiliation with such hospitals gives physicians control over hospital operations, flexibility with their time, and an opportunity to enhance their incomes.
Physician-Owned Specialty Hospitals. In the past, critics of physician-owned hospitals (PO Hs) have argued that physi cians' ownership stakes in hospitals cre ate a conflict of interest that could lead to increased utilization and health care costs (Hollingsworth et al., 2010). In a report to Congress, the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC, 2006) pointed out that POHs ( 1) have lower proportions of Medicaid-covered patients than commu nity general hospitals in the same markets; (2) admit less severe, more profitable cases;· (3) draw patients away from community general hospitals, although general hos pitals are typically able to compensate for the revenue loss; and ( 4) do not have lower costs per severity-adjusted discharge than competing general hospitals in the same markets. Hence, administrators of general hospitals have argued that specialty hospi tals engage in "cream-skimming" insured patients, thereby leaving costly emergency and uncompensated cases to general hos pitals. Despite such allegations, however, the presence of specialty hospitals in the acute-care markets do not financially harm general hospitals (Schneider et al., 2007). Nevertheless, the ACA closed the door on future physician-owned hospitals effective
January l, 201 1 , by mandating that hos pitals could not be owned by physicians if those facilities wanted to receive Medi care payments. Existing POHs also faced restrictions on their expansion, except for facilities that treat large numbers of Med icaid patients. The ACA-mandated limita tions have remained controversial.
The previously mentioned concerns arose based on studies that included only a small number of hospitals. A more recent large study found that PO Hs performed only 1 .2% of all procedures done in U.S. hospitals. More specifically, concerns about overutilization of surgeries at PO Hs may be unfounded (Chen et al., 2017; Schroeder et al., 201 8). However, there appears to be overselection of profitable and less disadvantaged patients by POHs. On the plus side, patient outcomes are generally superior at PO Hs compared to other hospitals after adjusting for patient demographics and case complexity. POHs achieve shorter lengths of stay, fewer com plications, and lower readmission rates at a lower cost (Bae et al., 2020). Although some concerns remain, the quality ben - efits afforded by such facilities should not be ignored.
Psychiatric Hospitals The primary function of a psychiatric inpa tient facility is to provide diagnostic and treatment services for a variety of severe mental conditions, such as bipolar disor der, schizophrenia, severe depression, dual diagnosis (mental illness compounded by chemical dependency), and serious emo tional disturbances in children and ado lescents. The main services offered in such a hospital inclll:de psychiatric, psychologi cal, and social work programs. A psychi atric hospital must also have a written
Types of Hospitals 371
agreement with a general hospital for the transfer of patients who may require med ical, obstetric, or surgical services (Health Forum, 2001). Inpatient psychiatric facili ties can be either freestanding hospitals or specialized psychiatric units in a general hospital. In 2018, there were almost 700 psychiatric hospitals in the United States, 45% of which were private for-profit facili ties, and slightly more than 200 were oper ated by public agencies ( Statista, 2020).
State Mental Health Institutions. At one time, mental health institutions oper ated by state governments played a pri mary role in treating people with mental health conditions. Over time, various policy efforts focused on deinstitutional izing people whose needs could be ade quately met in community-based settings. Consequently, many of these institutions were closed or some of their beds were taken out of service. The length of hos pitalizations and the number of inpatient stays have decreased, however. Accord ing to one national study, the ALOS in these hospitals is 106 days, indicating the patients admitted tend to have complex psychiatric/behavioral conditions. Never theless, the number of readmissions after discharge have increased, indicating that many patients may be prematurely dis charged (Ortiz, 2019).
Rehabilitation Hospitals Rehabilitation hospitals specialize in therapeutic services to restore the maxi mum level of functioning in patients who have suffered recent disability due to an episode of illness or an accident. Accord ing to Medicare rules, to be classified as a rehabilitation hospital, at least 60% of the hospital's inpatients must require intensive
372 Chapter I Inpatient Faci l ities and Services
rehabilitation for one or more of 1 3 speci fied conditions, such as stroke, spinal cord injury, major multiple trauma, and brain injury (Centers for Medicare and Med icaid Services [CMS], 2018). Intensive rehabilitation refers to provision of at least 3 hours of therapy per day. Rehabilitation hospitals also serve amputees, victims of accident or sports injuries, and individu als needing intensive cardiac rehabilita tion. Facilities and staff are available to provide physical therapy, occupational therapy, and speech-language pathol ogy. Most rehabilitation hospitals have special arrangements for psychological, social work, and vocational services and are required to have written arrangements with a general hospital for the transfer of patients who need medical, obstetric, or surgical care not available at the institu tion (Health Forum, 2001).
Inpatient rehabilitation facilities (IRF s) can be either freestanding hospitals or spe cialized rehabilitation units in a general hospital. In 2017, approximately 1 , 180 IRFs were Medicare certified (MedPAC, 2019c).
Children1s Hospitals Children's hospitals are community hospi tals that typically have specialized facilities to deal mainly with complex, severe, or chronic illnesses among children. Nearly all children's hospitals provide neonatal intensive care units, pediatric intensive care units, trauma centers, and transplant services. Thus, these hospitals provide a wide range of high-intensity services for children, such as pediatric surgery, cardiology, orthopedic surgery, cancer treatment, HIV I AIDS treatment, and rehabilitation services (DelliFraine, 2006). Some specialize in services such as ortho pedics or cancer treatment.
Children's hospitals can be freestand ing or they can be pediatric centers located in major hospitals. Most pediatric in ten - sive care units are found in large hospitals identified as tertiary centers or academic centers. These hospitals (a total of 63 in 2016) house almost half of all U.S . pediat ric intensive care beds (Horak et al. , 201 9). In most communities, no specialty chil dren's hospitals exist; hence, general acute care hospitals serve as de facto children's hospitals (DelliFraine, 2006).
Classification by Length of Stay
Short-Stay Hospitals A short-stay hospital is one in which the average length of stay is 25 days or less. Most hospitals fall into this category. Patients admitted to these hospitals suf fer from acute conditions. Hospitals with average stays of more than 25 days are considered long-stay hospitals; they include psychiatric hospitals, long-term care hospitals providing subacute care, and chronic disease hospitals.
Long-Term Care Hospitals The majority of long-stay hospitals in the United States are long-term care hos pitals {LTCHs). A long-term care hospi tal is a special type of long-stay hospital described in section 1 886(d)(l)(B)(iv) of the Social Security Act. LTCHs must meet Medicare's conditions of participation for acute care hospitals and must have an ALOS greater than 25 days. LTCHs serve patients who need postacute care, but have complex medical needs and may have multiple chronic problems requiring long term hospitalization. Many patients are admitted to LTCHs from short-stay hos pital intensive care units with respiratory/
ventilator-dependent or other complex medical conditions. Reflecting the higher patient complexity in these facilities, in 2017, the LTCH average length of stay was 26.2 days (AHA, 2019).
Classification by Location Hospitals can be classified based on their location-that is, they can be either urban or rural. Urban hospitals are located in a county that is part of a metropolitan statis tical area (MSA). The U.S. Census Bureau has defined an MSA as a geographic area that includes at least ( 1) one city with a pop ulation of 50,000 or more or (2) an urban ized area of at least 50,000 inhabitants and a total MSA population of at least 100,000. Rural hospitals are located in a county that is not part of an MSA. In 2018, 3 5 % of all U.S. community hospitals were located in rural areas (Health Forum, 2020).
Rural hospitals provide care to approximately 60 million people in the United States (Weil, 2020), but face sev eral challenges. They disproportionately rely on government payments because they serve a higher proportion of elderly and poor patients compared to urban hospitals. Government payments-for example, Medicaid reimbursement-do not cover the full cost of services. The financial viability of these hospitals is further put at risk because of their com munities' low population density, which tends to keep hospital size small and patient volume low (AHA, 201 1). Rural hospitals also face a sustained workforce shortage. The continued urbanization of American surgery-referring to growing surgeon shortages-is a bad omen for rural hospitals and is expected to lead to additional closures and worsen the issue of access (Ellison et al. , 2020).
Types of Hospitals 373
Swing Bed Hospitals The swing bed program for rural hospitals was authorized under the Omnibus Rec onciliation Act of 1980. A hospital swing bed can be used for acute care or skilled nursing care as needed. The swing bed program enabled many rural hospitals to survive during a period of declining occu pancy rates. It also enabled rural residents to access postacute nursing care services, which were not otherwise available in many rural communities.
Under Medicare, the swing bed pro gram operates under two distinct payment systems, for acute hospital stays and skilled nursing facility (SNF) stays, which compli cates financial management. To overcome this drawback, many rural hospitals have switched to critical access hospital status.
Critical Access Hospitals In an attempt to save some of the very small rural hospitals, the Balanced Budget Act of 1997 created the Medicare Rural Hospital Flexibility Program (MRHFP). Under this program, a rural hospital, upon meeting certain conditions, can file an application with Medicare to be classified as a criti cal access hospital (CAH). To qualify as a CAH, the hospital should have no more than 25 acute care and/ or swing beds and must provide 24-hour emergency medical services. It must also meet a distance test in relation to· other hospitals.
CAHs are not subject to the pro spective payment systems applicable to other health care providers; they receive cost-plus reimbursement for inpatient, outpatient, laboratory, therapy, and most postacute services in swing beds. Total payment to the hospital is fixed at 10 1 % of reasonable costs. Because of their many financial advantages, the number of CAHs
374 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
has jumped from 850 in 2003 (Mantone, 2005) to more than 1 ,300 today, represent ing 64% of all rural hospitals (MedPAC, 201 9a).
Other Rural Designations To improve access in some remote loca tions, Congress created two additional rural hospital designations: sole commu - nity hospital and Medicare-dependent hospital.
Sole Community Hospitals. If, because of its remote location, a rural hospital is the sole source of hospital services in a wide geographic area, it may qualify for sole community hospital (SCH) status. SCHs are important safety net provid ers. Approximately 17% of rural hospitals are classified as SCHs (MedPAC, 201 9a). These hospitals benefit from certain pay ment adjustments from Medicare.
Medicare-Dependent Hospitals. Small rural hospitals that may not qualify for the SCH designation may be classified as Medicare-dependent hospitals (MDHs) if at least 60% of their discharges are Medi care beneficiaries. In addition to PPS reimbursement, these hospitals receive payments that are partially based on their costs. Approximately 6% of rural hospitals are classified as MDHs (MedPAC, 201 9a).
Classification by Size There is no standard way to classify hos pitals by size. According to one classifica tion scheme, hospitals with fewer than 100 beds would be classified as small, those with 100 to 500 beds as medium, and those with 500-plus beds as large. Others may classify by size a little differently. Fewer
than half ( 4 7%) of all community hospitals in the United States have 1 00 beds or more (see Figure 8-5).
Experience in the manufacturing and retail sectors of the economy suggests that large enterprises can often realize econo mies of scale. This benefit arises because of their purchasing power for resource inputs and their ability to spread overhead costs over a larger volume of sales. In the hospital industry, several factors influ ence economic efficiency. For example, cost structures differ according to services offered (e.g., specialty care, emergency services), academic and teaching activi ties, and location (rural versus urban). Hence, it is not always feasible to assess economies of scale for hospitals. Never theless, in a comprehensive review of the literature, Giancotti and colleagues (2017) found consistent evidence of economies of scale for hospitals with 200-300 beds; dis economies of scale could be expected to occur with fewer than 200 beds and more than 600 beds.
Other Types of Hospitals
Teaching Hospitals To be designated as a teaching hospital, a hospital must have one or more gradu ate residency programs approved by the AMA. The mere presence of nursing pro grams or training affiliations for other health professionals, such as therapists and dietitians, does not make an institu tion a teaching hospital.
The term academic medical cen ter is commonly used when one or more hospitals, with or without affiliated out patient clinics, are organized around a medical school. Apart from the train ing of physicians, research activities and
clinical investigations become an impor
tant undertaking in such a center. Among the largest and most prestigious
teaching hospitals are the members of the Council of Teaching Hospitals and Health Systems (COTH), which has approximately 400 members in the United States (includ ing 62 VA medical centers) and Canada (Association of American Medical Colleges [AAMC], n.d.). These hospitals usually have substantial teaching and research pro grams and are affiliated with the medical schools of large universities.
Three main traits separate teaching and nonteaching hospitals. First, teaching hospitals provide medical training to phy sicians, research opportunities to health services researchers, and specialized care to patients. These hospitals receive add on payments from Medicare to reflect the additional costs of patient care associated with resident training, based on the num - ber of residents per inpatient bed. Medi care also pays separately for the direct costs of operating approved training pro grams for medical, osteopathic, dental, or podiatric residents (MedPAC, 201 9b).
Second, teaching hospitals have a broader and more complex scope of ser vices than nonteaching hospitals. These hospitals often operate several intensive care units, possess the latest medical tech nologies, and attract a diverse group of physicians representing most specialties and many subspecialties. Major teaching hospitals also offer many unique tertiary care services not generally found in other institutions, such as burn care, trauma care, and organ transplantation. Hence, teaching hospitals attract patients who frequently have more complicated diag noses or need more complex procedures. Because of the greater case-mix complexity
Types of Hospitals 375
of teaching hospitals, greater resources are required for the treatment of their patients.
Third, many of the major teaching hospitals are located in economically depressed, older inner-city areas and are owned by state or local governments. Consequently, these hospitals provide a significant amount of charity care to unin sured patients.
Church-Affiliated Hospitals During the latter half of the 19th cen - tury and the early 20th century, various churches established their own hospi tals. For example, Catholic sisterhoods established the first church-sponsored hospitals in the United States. Later, Prot estant denominations organized hospitals in accord with their missions of service, and Jewish philanthropic organizations opened hospitals so that Jewish patients could observe their dietary laws more faithfully and Jewish physicians could more easily find sites for training and work opportunities (Raff el, 1980).
Most church-affiliated hospitals are community general hospitals. They may be large or small, teaching or nonteaching. Affiliation with a medical school may also vary. Church-affiliated hospitals do not discriminate in rendering care; however, they are generally sensitive to the sponsor ing denomination's special spiritual and/ or dietary emphasis (Raffel and Raffel, 1 994).
Osteopathic Hospitals In 1 970, osteopathic hospitals became eligible to apply for registration with the AHA ( 1 994). For many years after osteopathy was established as a sepa rate branch of medicine in 1 8 7 4, osteo paths had to develop their own hospitals
376 Chapter & Inpatient Facilities and Services
because of the antagonism they faced from the established allopathic medical practitioners. Since then, both groups have inspected each other's medical schools and satisfied themselves that each is worth associating with and that each could serve on the other's faculties and practice side by side in the same hos pitals (Raffel and Raffel, 1 994).
Many osteopathic hospitals today are part of hospital systems and main tain their osteopathic identity within the context of these larger systems. An inde pendent osteopathic hospital is no longer a necessity and seems to be economically out of place in today's market (Hilsenrath, 2006). Also, the operation of osteopathic hospitals has been found to be more costly and less productive in comparison to their counterparts (Sinay, 2005). Consequently, a number of these hospitals have closed.
� Expectations for Nonprofit Hospitals
Laypeople often assume that nonprofit (sometimes called not-for-profit) health care corporations do not make a profit. In fact, every corporation-regardless of whether it is for profit or nonprofit-must make a profit (surplus of revenues over expenses) if it is to survive over the long term. No business can survive for long if it continually spends more than it takes in. That rule of economics holds true for both the nonprofit and for-profit sectors (Nudelman and Andrews, 1996).
The Internal Revenue Code, Section 501 (c)(3), grants tax-exempt status to nonprofit organizations. As such, these institutions are exempt from federal, state, and local taxes, such as income taxes, sales taxes, and property taxes. In general,
nonprofit organizations must ( 1) provide some defined public good, such as service, education, or community welfare; and ( 2) not distribute profits to any individu - als. In contrast, a major goal for a for-profit corporation is to provide its sharehold ers with a return on their investment, although it achieves this goal primarily by excelling at its basic mission. For any health services provider, the basic mission is to deliver the highest-quality care at the most reasonable price possible.
Since 1969, a community-benefit stan dard has been applied to nonprofit hospitals. It broadly refers to services that the govern ment would otherwise have to undertake (Owens, 2005). In 1 983, this standard was modified to include specific criteria that hos pitals must meet to qualify for tax exemp tion: a 24-hour emergency department, policy guidelines for treating the uninsured, and health promotion in the community (Alexander et al., 2009).
The ACA included four new require ments related to community benefits, which were promulgated by adding sec tion 501 (r) to the Internal Revenue Code. Nonprofit hospitals must ( 1 ) establish written financial assistance and emer gency care policies, (2) limit charges for individuals who are eligible for assistance under the hospital's financial assistance policy, ( 3) limit certain billing and collec tion actions against those who fall within the guidelines of financial assistance, and ( 4) conduct a community health needs assessment and adopt an implementation strategy at least once every 3 years. Hos pitals that fail to comply with the com munity health needs assessment mandate are subject to an excise tax (Betbeze, 201 1 ; Internal Revenue Service [IRS], 201 6).
Section 4958 of the IRS code pro hibits executive compensation that may
be deemed unreasonable for tax-exempt
organizations. Nonprofit hospitals must
be prepared to demonstrate not only
that they are paying salaries within some
reasonable range of industry standards,
but also that executives are bringing measurable value in key areas of opera
tions, including community benefits (Appleby, 2004) .
In many communities, nonprofit hospitals compete head-to-head with for profit hospitals. For example, nonprofit hospitals frequently engage in the same kinds of aggressive marketplace behaviors that for-profit hospitals pursue. Generally, nonprofit hospitals operate in locations with higher average incomes, lower pov erty rates, and lower rates of uninsurance than for-profit hospitals (Congressional Budget Office [CBO] , 2006) . In 201 3, 7 of the 10 most profitable hospitals in the United States were nonprofit organiza tions (Ge and Anderson, 2016) .
Institutional theory actually predicts such behavior. When for-profit and non profit organizations face similar regula tory, legal, and professional constraints, they often imitate each other (O'Connell and Brown, 2003) . In the hospital indus try, competition commonly occurs in the same communities for the same patients, with revenues coming from the same pub lic and private third-party sources, and often involving the same physician pro viders who have admitting privileges at more than one hospital.
Recent studies show that vague regu latory language, extensive restrictions, and burdensome documentation requirements for reporting financial assistance contrib ute to significant variations in how hospi tals deliver charity care (Goodman et al., 2020) . Hence, significant gaps exist in the delivery of community benefit services by
Some Management Concepts 377
nonprofit hospitals (Worthy et al., 201 6) . A Modern Healthcare analysis of about 100 Illinois hospitals' tax forms revealed that measuring community benefit spend ing can provide an inconsistent and dis torted view of a hospital's level of charity care (Kacik, 2018b) . Furthermore, hospi tals routinely report different amounts of charity care to the IRS and CMS (Gaskin et al., 201 9) .
As just discussed, legislation over time and reporting by hospitals have tainted the evaluation of what constitutes charity or community benefit. In turn, the measure ment of these constructs has proved chal lenging. Even though for-profit hospitals in the United States have been known to deliver services to those who cannot afford to pay, an objective comparison of the charitable services provided by for-profit hospitals versus those provided by non profit hospitals has not been forthcoming. Hence, the debate continues over what is and what is not a community benefit, and whether giving tax-exempt status to cer tain hospitals has created an unequal and unfair system.
� Some Management Concepts
From a management standpoint, hospitals are complex· organizations. Compared to other business enterprises of similar size, both the external and internal environ ments of hospitals are more complex. A hospital is responsible to numerous stakeholders in its external environment, including the community, the govern ment, insurers, managed care organiza tions (MCOs), and accreditation agencies. A hospital's organizational structure also
I I
I
378 Chapter 8 I npatient Facilities a nd Services
differs substantially from that of other large organizations in the business world.
Hospital Governance Hospital governance has traditionally assumed a tripartite structure, in which the three major sources of authority are the chief executive officer (CEO), the board of trustees, and the chief of staff (FIGURE 8·11 ) . In earlier periods, when physicians operated their own hospitals, trustees dominated the hospitals. Trustees were often the source of capital investment, and their influence in the community brought prestige to the hospital. Later, as voluntary hospitals increased in number, the balance of power shifted, with physi cians gaining the upper hand because they played a critical role in bringing patients to the hospitals . As changes in the health care environment made the management of hospitals more complex, considerable
Board of trustees
Tripartite structure of hospital
governance
Chief of staff CEO ------
(Medical director)
Dual operational
structure
ADM I N I STRATION
Senior vice president
Vice president
Department heads
Supervisors
MEDICAL STAFF
Service chiefs
Committee chairs
FIGURE S .. 1 1 Hospital governance and operational
structures.
power then passed from physicians to senior managers.
The medical staff constitute a separate organizational structure that operates in parallel to the administrative structure. Such a dual structure is rarely seen in other businesses and presents numerous opportu nities for conflicts to arise between the CEO and the medical staff. Physicians account for approximately 85% of hospital spend ing without necessarily being employees (Burns et al., 2020). Matters become even more complicated when the lines of author ity cross between the two structures. For example, nursing services, pharmacists, diagnostic technicians, and dietitians are administratively accountable to the CEO (via the vertical chain of command) but pro fessionally accountable to the medical staff (Raffel and Raffel, 1994). Although most of the medical staff are not paid employees of the hospital, physicians' interest in employ ment has been growing as they seek ways to stabilize their incomes and achieve a better work-life balance in a changing health care landscape (Shoger, 201 1).
Regardless of whether the physicians are independent practitioners or con tracted employees of the hospital, they play a significant role in the hospital's ·success. It requires special skills on the part of the CEO to manage the dual struc ture to achieve the organization's overall objectives.
ar of r s The board of trustees (also referred to as the governing body or board of directors) of a hospital consists of influential busi ness and community leaders. The board is legally responsible for the hospital's operations. It has specific responsibilities for defining the hospital's mission and
long-range direction. The board is also responsible for evaluating, from a strategic standpoint, major decisions such as incur ring capital expenditures for building and equipment, approving annual budgets, and monitoring performance against plans and budgets. The CEO is a member of the board, and one or more physicians also sit on the board as voting members.
One of the most important respon sibilities of the board is to appoint the CEO, evaluate his or her performance, and remove the CEO if necessary. The CEO is charged with providing the board with timely reports on the institution's progress toward achieving its mission and objectives. In most hospitals, the board also approves the appointment of physicians and other professionals to the hospital's medical staff.
Boards often function through commit tees. Standing committees usually include executive, medical staff, human resources, finance, planning, quality improvement, and ethics. Special, or ad hoc, committees are established as needed. The two most important committees, from a governance standpoint, are the executive commit tee and the medical staff committee. The executive committee has continuing monitoring responsibility and author ity over the hospital. Usually, it receives reports from other committees, moni tors policy implementation, and makes recommendations. The medical staff committee is charged with managing medical staff relations. For example, this committee reviews admitting privileges and the performance of the medical staff and must take into account the legal and ethical obligations of the hospital regard ing patient safety, quality improvement, and patient satisfaction.
Some Management Concepts 379
Chief Executive Officer In the past, the titles of ((superintendent" and later ((administrator" were commonly used for a hospital's chief executive. Today, the most commonly encountered titles are "chief executive officer" and ((president:' The CEO's job is to accomplish the orga nization's mission and objectives by exhib iting leadership within the organization. The CEO has the ultimate responsibility for the hospital's day-to-day operations.
The CEO receives delegated author ity from the board and is responsible for managing the organization with the help of senior managers. In large hospitals, these senior managers often carry the title of senior vice president or vice presi dent for various key service areas, such as nursing services, rehabilitation services, human resources, and finance.
Medica l Staff The hospital's medical staff is an organized body of physicians who provide medi cal services to the hospital's patients and perform related clinical duties. Most phy sicians are in private practice outside the hospital. The hospital grants them admit ting privileges, which enable the physi cians to admit and care for their patients in the hospital. Other clinicians, such as den tists and podiatrists, may also be granted admitting . privileges. Appointment to the medical staff is a formal process outlined in the hospital's medical staff bylaws. The medical staff use a framework of self-gov ernance, which upholds the strong tradi tion of physician independence, but are formally accountable to the board of trust ees. Lines of communication to the CEO and the board are established through various committee representations.
380 Chapter 8 I n patient Faci l it ies and Services
A medical director, or chief of staff, heads the medical staff. In all but the smallest hospitals, the medical staff are organizationally divided by major special ties into departments, such as anesthesi ology, internal medicine, obstetrics and gynecology, orthopedic surgery, pathol ogy, cardiology, and radiology. A chief of service, such as chief of cardiology, heads each specialty.
The medical staff generally have their own executive committee that sets general policies and serves as the main decision making body in medical matters. Most hospitals have additional committees. The credentials committee grants and reviews admitting privileges for those already credentialed and for new doctors whose skills are yet untested. The medical records committee ensures that accurate documentation is maintained on the entire regimen of care given to each patient. This committee also oversees confidential ity issues related to medical records. The utilization review committee performs routine checks to ensure that inpatient placements, as well as the lengths of stay, are clinically appropriate. The infection control committee reviews policies and procedures for minimizing infections in the hospital. The quality improvement committee oversees the program for con tinual quality improvement.
� Licensure, Certification, and Accreditation
A license to operate a certain number of hospital beds is a basic regulatory requirement. State governments oversee
the licensure of health care facilities, and each state sets its own standards for licensure. The state's department of health has licensure-related responsibilities. State licensure standards strongly emphasize the physical plant's compliance with building codes, fire safety, climate control, space allocations, and sanitation. Minimum standards are also established for equip ment and personnel. State licensure, however, is not directly tied to the quality of care that a health care facility actually delivers.
All facilities are legally required to be licensed to operate, but they do not have to be certified or accredited. Certi fication gives a hospital the authority to participate in the Medicare and Medicaid programs. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) has devel oped a body of health, safety, and quality standards referred to as conditions of participation and has the authority to enforce those standards for hospitals that participate in the Medicare or Medicaid program. The currently defined condi tions focus primarily on the actual qual ity of care furnished to patients and the outcomes of that care. Each state's depart ment of health verifies the actual compli ance with the standards through periodic inspections.
In contrast to licensure and certifica tion, which are government regulatory mechanisms, accreditation is a private undertaking designed to assure that accredited health care facilities meet cer tain basic standards. Seeking accreditation is voluntary, but the passage of Medicare in 1 965 specified that accredited facilities were eligible for purposes of Medicare reimbursement. Accreditation of a hos pital by the Joint Commission confers
deemed status on the hospital, meaning
the hospital is deemed to have met Medi
care and Medicaid certification standards. Thus, an accredited hospital does not
need to go through the certification pro
cess. Private organizations that have been
approved by the CMS to confer deemed
status are said to have "deeming authoritY:'
In addition to the Joint Commission, the American Osteopathic Association has
deeming authority to accredit hospitals. The Joint Commission also sets stan
dards for and accredits long-term care facilities, psychiatric hospitals, substance abuse programs, outpatient surgery cen ters, urgent care clinics, group practices, community health centers, hospices, and home health agencies. Different sets of standards apply to each category of health care organization. Some facilities, such as nursing homes, do not receive deemed status as a result of accreditation and must also be certified by DHHS to receive Medi care and Medicaid reimbursement.
Over the years, the Joint Commission has refined its accreditation standards and process of verifying compliance. Since 2006, this organization has moved from scheduled to unannounced inspections, with the intention that hospitals should attempt to comply with all the standards all the time.
� Magnet Recognition Program1
Magnet hospital is a special designa tion conferred by the American Nurses
Magnet Recognition Program 38 1
Credentialing Center, an affiliate of the American Nurses Association, that rec ognizes quality patient care, nursing excellence, and innovations in profes sional nursing practice in hospitals. This designation was created after a study of 1 63 hospitals was undertaken in 1 983 by the American Academy of Nursing's Task Force on Nursing Practice in Hospitals. The study found that 4 1 of these hospitals had an environment that attracted and retained well-qualified nurses and pro moted quality patient care. These hospitals were labeled ''Magnet hospitals" because of their ability to attract and retain pro fessional nurses. The characteristics that seemed to distinguish "Magnet" orga nizations from others became known as the Forces of Magnetism. The Forces of Magnetism have since been incorporated into quality indicators and standards of nursing practice as defined in ANA Nurs ing Administration: Scope & Standards of Practice. The Magnet designation is granted after a thorough and lengthy pro cess that includes review of data on quality indicators.
Magnet recognition has been shown to be associated with better job satisfac tion, nursing empowerment, and less turnover, but also with better outcomes for patients, more research and evidence based practice, a superior reputation for the organization, and an easier time recruiting for the organization (Harolds and Miller, 2020). Notably, Magnet and non -Magnet hospitals do not appear to show any meaningful differences in staff ing levels (de Cordova et al., 2020).
1 The Magnet Recognition Program is a registered trademark of the American Nurses Credentialing Center.
382 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
� Ethical and Legal Issues in Patient Care
Ethical issues arise in all types of health services organizations, but the most sig nificant ones occur in acute care hospitals. Increasing levels of technology create situ ations requiring decision making under complex circumstances. For example, life sustaining therapies in intensive care and dealing with life and death issues com monly raise ethical concerns. Likewise, ethical issues arise in health care research and in experimental medicine. The Joint Commission requires accredited institu tions to establish mechanisms that allow patients, families, and employees to obtain resolution of ethical issues or issues that may present a conflict of interest (Hamric and Wocial, 20 16).
Principles of Ethics Ethics requires judgment. Because clear cut rules are often not available in the health care environment, medical practi tioners and managers must rely on certain well-established principles as guides to ethical decision making. Four important principles of ethics are respect for others, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice.
The principle of respect for others has four elements: autonomy, truth-telling, confidentiality, and fidelity. Autonomy allows people to govern themselves by choosing and pursuing a course of action without external coercion. In health care delivery, it refers to patient empower ment, which undergirds the philosophy of patient-centered care. Autonomy is ensured by obtaining consent for treat ment, explaining the various treatment
alternatives, allowing patients and their families to participate in decision mak ing and selection of treatment options, and treating patients with respect and dignity. Constant tension exists between autonomy and paternalism, the view that someone else must decide what the patient will undergo without the patient's involve ment. Truth-telling requires a caregiver to be honest. This principle often needs to be balanced with nonmaleficence because a tension is created when truth-telling could result in harm to the patient. The principle of confidentiality sometimes becomes a source of conflict when the legal system requires disclosure of patient information. Fidelity means performing one's duty, keeping one's word, and keeping promises.
The principle of beneficence means that hospitals and caregivers have a moral obligation to benefit others. A health ser vices organization is ethically obligated to do all it can to alleviate suffering caused by ill health and injury. This obligation includes providing a certain amount of charity care to the financially needy.
The principle of nonmaleficence means that medical professionals have a moral obligation not to harm others. Of course, many health care interventions, including certain preventive measures such as immu nization, carry risks. Hence, in health care, nonmaleficence requires that the potential benefits from medical treatment suffi ciently outweigh the potential harm.
The principle of justice encompasses fairness and equality. It denounces dis crimination in the delivery of health care.
Legal Rights Legal issues often arise in the areas of patient competency and the patient's right to refuse
treatment. Although the right of mentally competent patients to refuse medical care is well established, the desires of incompetent or comatose patients present ethical chal lenges. Unless such patients have expressed their wishes in advance, family members or legal guardians may end up making decisions regarding sustained medical treatment, or state laws may govern such decisions. Medical and legal experts and family members may differ, often bitterly, on the controversial issue of withdraw ing nutrition and other life support means for dying patients. However, certain legal mechanisms have been established to deal with the issues of patients' rights.
Bill of Rights and Informed Consent The Patient Self-Determination Act of 1990 applies to all health care facilities participating in Medicare or Medicaid. This law requires hospitals and other facil ities to provide all patients, upon admis sion, with information on patients' rights. Most hospitals and other inpatient institu tions have developed a patient's bill of
rights-a document that reflects the law concerning issues such as confidentiality and consent. Other patient rights include the right to make decisions regarding medical care, be informed about diagnosis and treatment, refuse treatment, and for mulate advance directives.
Based on the principle of autonomy, informed consent refers to the patient's right to make an informed choice regard ing medical treatment. The current cli mate in medical ethics supports honest and complete disclosure of medical infor mation. In 1972, the Board of Trustees of
Ethical and Legal Issues in Patient Care 383
the AHA affirmed the document known as the Patient's Bill of Rights, which states that patients have the right to obtain from their physicians complete current infor mation concerning their diagnosis, treat ment, and prognosis, in terms the patients can be reasonably expected to understand (Rosner, 2004). Informed consent is cus tomarily obtained via a signature on pre printed forms and becomes part of the patient's medical record.
Certain principles governing patients' rights are being incorporated into pro vider mindsets and organizational culture within the patient-centered care model. Involving patients in their own treatment, grounding treatment decisions in patients' preferences, and creating a care giving environment in which staff solicit patients' input and meet their needs for informa tion and education collectively promote patient-centered care (Cross, 2004).
Advance Directives Advance directives specify the patient's wishes regarding continuation or with drawal of treatment when the patient lacks decision-making capacity. Advance directives are intended to ensure that the patient's end-of-life wishes are carried out.
Three types of advance directives are in common use: do-not-resuscitate orders, living wills, and durable powers of attorney.
• A do-not-resuscitate order directs medical caregivers not to adminis ter any artificial means to resuscitate the person when his or her heart or breathing stops. It is based on the theory that a patient may pref er to die rather than live when strong odds are against a good quality of
384 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
life after cardiopulmonary resuscita tion, because severe disabilities would likely remain.
• A living will communicates a patient's wishes regarding medical treatment when he or she is unable to make decisions due to terminal illness or incapacitation. The main drawback of a living will is that it is general in nature and does not cover all possible situations.
• A durable power of attorney for health care is a written legal document in which the patient appoints another individual to act as the patient's agent for purposes of health care decision making in the event that the patient is unable or unwilling to make such decisions. Although a durable power of attorney can cover most circum stances, its main drawback is that the appointed person may not act in the same manner in which the patient would have acted had he or she remained competent.
Mechanisms for Ethical Decision Making Many health care organizations, especially large acute care hospitals, have ethics
committees charged with developing guidelines and standards for ethical deci sion making in the delivery of health care (Paris, 1995). Ethics committees are also responsible for resolving issues related to medical ethics. Such committees are multi disciplinary, including physicians, nurses, clergy, social workers, legal experts, ethi cists, and administrators. In some states, such as Texas, ethics committees have
decision-making authority to overrule the patient's or his or her representative's desire to continue life-sustaining treatment when, based on medical judgment, the treatment is not appropriate (Berlin, 2020).
Although physicians and other care givers have moral responsibilities on the clinical side, the health care executive who leads the health services organiza tion must also assume the role of a moral agent. As a moral agent, the manager morally affects and is morally affected by actions taken. Although executives are entrusted with the fiduciary responsibility to act prudently in managing the affairs of the organization, their responsibilities to patients must take precedence.
In governing the affairs of an orga nization, health care executives must recognize that ethics entails much more than simply obeying the law. The law rep resents only the minimum standard of morality established by society. Similarly, health care professionals must recognize that, even though they are bound by the law, they also have a higher calling-one that includes numerous positive duties to patients, to society, and to each other (Darr, 1 99 1 ).
� Summary Hospitals are institutions that engage primarily in the delivery of inpatient acute care services, although many have branched out to provide postacute and outpatient services. In the United States, almshouses and pesthouses first evolved into public hospitals to serve the poor. Subsequently, voluntary hospitals were established to serve all classes of people.
Over time, advances in medical science, improvements in hygiene, and evolution of nursing care transformed hospitals into institutions of medical practice, many of which then became important centers of medical training and research. Since the 1 980s, economic pressures have led many hospitals to consolidate. Health systems that offer a full contin uum of health care services now exist in many locations.
Hospitals in the United States went through an expansion phase in the mid- 20th century that lasted until the mid- 1980s. The Hill-Burton Act of 1 946 was the single greatest factor contributing to the increase in the nation's bed supply. The federal government later played an equally important role in reducing inpatient utili zation by establishing the prospective pay ment system. Some of the key measures of inpatient utilization are discharges, inpa tient days, average length of stay, capacity, average daily census, and occupancy rates. The growth of managed care has also been significant in reducing inpatient utiliza tion. Despite these accomplishments, hospital costs have not abated, and U.S. hospitals are among the most expensive in the world.
Hospitals can be classified in numer ous ways, and the various classification schemes help differentiate one hospital from another. Performance statistics by hospital type can help executives compare their hospital to others in the same cate gory. Although most U.S. hospitals are gen eral community hospitals, various specialty hospitals treat specific types of patients or conditions. Roughly half of all U.S. commu nity hospitals are nonprofit organizations.
Summary 385
In response to controversies surrounding physician-owned specialty hospitals, the Affordable Care Act placed restrictions on their expansion. Yet, these hospitals offer many benefits to patients, especially better quality of care over other hospitals.
Most public and voluntary hospitals are nonprofit organizations; as such, these institutions enjoy some tax advan tages. They are expected to provide community benefits that are equivalent in value to the tax subsidies received; however, many nonprofit hospitals emulate the behavior of their for-profit counterparts. Moreover, evaluation and reporting of community benefits have been inconsistent.
Hospitals are among the most com - plex organizations to manage; they must satisfy numerous external stakeholders and manage a complex internal gov ernance structure. A hospital cannot legally operate unless it is licensed by the state in which it is located. To participate in the Medicare and Medicaid programs, a hospital can voluntarily apply for accreditation by the Joint Commission. Magnet hospitals are recognized for
· their ability to recruit and retain quali fied nurses and to deliver high-quality patient care.
Ethical decision making has been a special area of concern for hospitals. From a medical standpoint, ethical issues often pertain to patient privacy, confiden tiality, informed consent, and end-of-life treatment. The patient's bill of rights and advance directives are two of the legal means to address these issues. Active ethics committees develop policies and standards and deal with ethical issues as they arise.
386 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
� Test Your Understanding
Terminology
academic medical center accreditation advance directives average daily census average length of stay
durable power of attorney ethics committees executive committee general hospital
multihospital system (MHS) occupancy rate patient-centered care patient's bill of rights proprietary hospitals public hospitals
hospital (ALOS)
board of trustees certification
infection control committee informed consent inpatient
quality improvement committee
rehabilitation hospitals rural hospitals short-stay hospital specialty hospitals swing bed
chief of service chief of staff community hospital conditions of participation credentials committee critical access hospital
inpatient day investor-owned hospitals licensure living will long-term care hospitals
(LTCHs) teaching hospital urban hospitals utilization review
(CAH) days of care deemed status
Magnet hospital medical records
committee committee voluntary hospitals discharge
do-not-resuscitate order medical staff committee moral agent
Review Questions
1. What is the difference between inpatient and outpatient services?
2. As hospitals evolved from rudimen tary custodial and quarantine facili ties to their current state, how did their purpose and function change?
3. What were the main factors respon sible for the growth of hospitals until the latter part of the 20th century?
4. Name the main forces that were responsible for hospital downsizing. How did each of these forces affect the decline in inpatient hospital utilization?
5. What is a voluntary hospital? How did voluntary hospitals evolve in the United States?
6. Discuss the role of government in the growth, as well as the decline, of hospitals in the United States.
7. What are inpatient days? What is the significance of this measure?
8. How does hospital utilization vary according to a person's age, gender, and socioeconomic status?
9. Explaill the relationship between hospital demand, employment, exp enditures, and profitability.
10. Discuss the different types of public hospitals and the roles they play in the delivery of health care services in the United States.
1 1. What are some of the differences between private nonprofit and for profit hospitals?
12. What is a long-term care hospital (LTCH)? What role does it play in health care delivery in the United States?
1 3. The table gives some operational statistics for two hospitals located in the same community. Use the table to answer the following questions. a. Calculate the following mea
sures for each hospital (wherever appropriate, calculate the mea sure for each pay type). Discuss the meaning and significance of each measure, and point out the differences between the two hospitals.
Number of beds in operation 320
Total discharges 12,051
Medicare 5,130
Medicaid 3,565
Private insurance 3,356
Total hospital days 72,421
Medicare 36,935
Medicaid 23, 175
Private insurance 12,311
Total inpatient revenues $45,755,000
Dollar value of community $5,000,000 benefits
Test Your Understanding 387
i. Hospital capacity ii. ALOS
iii. Occupancy rate
b. Operationally, which hospital is performing better? Why?
c. Do you think the nonprofit hospital is meeting its com munity benefit obligations in exchange for its tax-exempt status? Explain.
d. Do you think the hospitals have a problem with excess capacity? If so, what would you recommend?
240
9,230
3,876
2, 118
3,236
51,684
26,359
12,921
12,404
$35,800,000
$3,500,000
388 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
14. Why have physicians developed their own specialty hospitals? What are the main criticisms that these hospitals have faced?
15. What criteria does Medicare use to classify a hospital as a rehabilitation hospital?
16. How do you differentiate between a community hospital and a noncom munity hospital?
17. What is a critical access hospital (CAH)? Why was this designation created?
� References Alexander, J. A., et al. 2009. How do system-affil
iated hospitals fare in providing community benefit? Inquiry 46, no. 1: 72-91.
American Hospital Association (AHA). 1990. Hospital
statistics 1990-1991 edition. Chicago, IL: Author. American Hospital Association (AHA). 1994. AHA
guide to the health care field: 1994 edition. Chi cago, IL: Author.
American Hospital Association (AHA). 2011. The
opportunities and challenges for rural hospitals in
an era of health reform. Washington, DC: AHA and Avalere Health.
American Hospital Association (AHA). 2019. Fact sheet: Long-term care hospitals. Available at: https://www.aha.org/system/files/media/file /2019/04/fact-sheet-ltch-0319.pdf. Accessed Au gust 2020.
Appleby, J. 2004, September 30. IRS looking closely at what non-profits pay. USA Today, p. 02b.
Arndt, M., and B. Bigelow. 2006. Toward the cre ation of an institutional logic for the man agement of hospitals: Efficiency in the early nineteen hundreds. Medical Care Research and
Review 63, no. 3: 369-394. Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC).
n.d. Council of Teaching Hospitals and Health
Systems (COTH): Member services and benefits. Available at: https://aamc-orange.global.ssl. fastly.net/production/media/filer_public/f6/a8/ f6a875e5-acf5-442a-87el-f9 lf24c0f3dl/ coth memberservices.pdf. Accessed August 2020.
1 8. What are some of the main differ ences between teaching and non teaching hospitals?
1 9. Discuss some of the issues relative to the tax-exempt status of nonprofit hospitals.
20. Discuss the governance of a modern hospital.
2 1. In the context of hospitals, what are the differences between licensure, certification, and accreditation?
22. What can a hospital do to address some of the difficult ethical problems relative to end-of-life treatment?
Bae, J., et al. 2020. Evaluation of costs and outcomes of physician -owned hospitals across common surgical procedures. American Journal of Sur gery 220, no. 1: 120-126.
Balotsky, E. R. 2005. Is it resources, habit or both: Interpreting twenty years of hospital strategic response to prospective payment. Health Care
Management Review 30, no. 4: 337-346. Berlin, J. 2020. Preserving do no harm: Supreme
Court tosses challenge to medical ethics com - mittee law. Texas Medicine 116, no. 2: 22-23.
Betbeze, P. 2011. Reassessing community benefit. Health Leaders Magazine 14, no. 1: 50.
Bindman, A. B. 2020. Rising prices and health care ((empires:' Journal of the American Medical Asso
ciation 323, no. 9: 815-816. Blavin, F. 2016. Association between the 2014 Med
icaid expansion and US hospital finances. Jour
nal of the American Medical Association 316, no. 14: 1475-1483.
Burns, L. R. , et al. 2015. Is the system really the solu tion? Operating costs in hospital systems. Medi
cal Care Research and Review 72, no. 3: 247-272. Burns, L. R. , et al. 2020. How different governance
models may impact physician-hospital align ment. Health Care Management Review 2: 173-184.
Burrill, S. , and A. Kane. 2017. Chapter 3: Hospital pro.fitmargins: Hospital CEO survey series. Deloitte Development LLC. Available at: https:// www2. deloitte.com/us/en/pages/life-sciences-
and-health-care/ articles/ improve-hospital profit-margins.html. Accessed August 2020.
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). 2018. IRF classification criteria. Available at: https://www.cms.gov/Medicare/Medicare-Fee for-Service-Payment/InpatientRehabFacPPS/ Criteria. Accessed August 2020.
Chen, A. F., et al. 2017. Utilization of total joint arthroplasty in physician-owned specialty hos pitals vs acute care facilities. Journal of Arthro
plasty 32, no. 7: 2060-2064. Chin, V., et al. 2020. A case study in model failure?
COVID-19 daily deaths and ICU bed utilisation predictions in New York state. European Journal
of Epidemiology. 35, no. 8: 733-7 42. Clement, J. P., and K. L. Grazier. 2001. HMO pen
etration: Has it hurt public hospitals? Journal of Health Care Finance 28, no. 1: 25-38.
Congressional Budget Office (CBO). 2006. Non
profit hospitals and the provision of community benefits. Available at: https://www.cbo.gov/ sites/ default/files/ 109th-congress-2005-2006/ reports/12-06-nonprofit.pdf. Accessed August 2020.
Cross, G. M. 2004, November. What does patient
centered care mean for the VA? Forum, Acad emy Health. pp. 1-2, 8.
Darr, K. 1991. Ethics in health services management.
2nd ed. Baltimore, MD: Health Professions Press.
de Cordova, P. B., et al. 2020. Staffing trends in Mag net and non-Magnet hospitals after state legisla tion. Journal of Nursing Care Quality 35, no. 4: 323-328.
DelliFraine, J. L. 2006. Communities with and with out children's hospitals: Where do the sickest children receive care? Hospital Topics 84, no. 3: 19-28.
Ellison, E. C., et al. 2020. The continued urbaniza tion of American surgery: A threat to rural hos pitals. Surgery 169, no. 3: 543-549.
Feldstein, M. 1971. The rising cost of hospital care.
Washington, DC: Information Resource Press. Feldstein, P. J. 1993. Health care economics. 4th ed.
Albany, NY: Delmar Publishers. Freeman, W. J., et al. 2018. Overview of U.S.
hospital stays in 2016: Variation by geo
graphic region, 2012. Statistical Brief #246. Rockville, MD: Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. Available at: https:// www.hcup-us.ahrq.gov/reports/statbriefs/
References 389
sb246-Geographic-Variation-Hospital-Stays. pdf. Accessed August 2020.
Gaskin, D. J., et al. 2019. Measuring nonprofit hos pitals' provision of charity care using IRS and (:MS data. Journal of Healthcare Management 64, no. 5: 293-314.
Ge, B., and G. F. Anderson. 2016. A more detailed understanding of factors associated with hospi tal profitability. Health Affairs 35, no. 5: 889-897.
Giancotti, M., et al. 2017. Efficiency and optimal size of hospitals: Results of a systematic search. PLoS One 12, no. 3: 1-40.
Goodman, C. W., et al. 2020. Charity care character istics and expenditures among US tax-exempt hospitals in 2016. American Journal of Public
Health 110, no. 4: 492-498. Haglund, C. L., and W. L. Dowling. 1993. The hospi
tal. In: Introduction to health services. 4th ed. S. J. Williams and P. R. Torrens, eds. Albany, NY: Delmar Publishers. pp. 135-176.
Hamric, A. B., and L. D. Wocial. 2016. Institutional ethics resources: Creating moral spaces. Hast ings Center Report 46 (suppl): S22-S27.
Harolds, J. A., and L. B. Miller.- 2020. August 11. Quality and safety in healthcare, part LXXVI: The value of Magnet® Hospital recognition. Clinical Nuclear Medicine. 1536-0229, 2020 Aug 11; Publisher: Lippincott; PMID: 32796251.
Health Forum. 2001. AHA guide to the health care
field: 2001-2002 edition. Chicago, IL: Author. Health Forum. 2020. Fast facts on US hospitals.
AHA hospital statistics, 2020 edition. Available at: https://www.aha.org/ system/files/media/file /2020/01 /2020-aha-hospital-fast-facts-new Jan-2020.pdf. Accessed August 2020.
Hilsenrath, P. E. 2006. Osteopathic medicine in transition: Postmortem of the Osteopathic Medical Center of Texas. Journal of the Ameri can Osteopathic Association 106, no. 9: 558-561.
Hollingsworth; J. M., et al. 2010. Physician owner ship of ambulatory surgery centers linked to higher volume of surgeries. Health Affairs 29, no. 4: 683.
Horak, R. V., et al. 2019. Growth and changing char acteristics of pediatric intensive care 2001-2016. Critical Care Medicine 47, no. 8: 1135-1142.
Internal Revenue Service (IRS). 2016. New requirements for 501 ( c) ( 3) hospitals under the Affordable Care Act. Available at: http:// www.irs.gov/Charities-Non-Profits/Charitable Organizations/New-Requirements-for-501 c3
I ; I
390 Chapter 8 Inpatient Facilities and Services
-Hospitals-Under-the-Affordable-Care-Act. Accessed February 2021.
Kacik, A. 2018a. Number of outpatient facilities s_urges as industry values more convenient, affordable care. Modern Healthcare. Avail able at: https://www.modernhealthcare.com/ article/20181220/NEWS/ 181229992/number of-outpatient-facilities-surges-as-industry-val ues-more-convenient-affordable-care. Accessed August 2020.
Kacik, A. 2018b. Flaws in reporting create knowl edge vacuum regarding community benefits. Modern Healthcare 48, no. 48: 20.
Kangovi, S., et al. 2013. Understanding why patients of low socioeconomic status prefer hospitals over ambulatory care. Health Affairs 32, no. 7: 1196-1203.
Keon-Hyung, L., et al. 2009. The association between hospital ownership and technical effi ciency in a managed care environment. Journal of Medical Systems 33: 307-315.
Liang, L., et al. 2020. National inpatient hospital
costs: The most expensive conditions by payer, 2017. Statistical Brief #261. Agency for Health care Research and Quality. Available at: https:// hcup-us.ahrq.gov/reports/ statbriefs/ sb26 l - Most-Expensive-Hospital-Conditions-2017 .j sp. Accessed August 2020.
Lin, G., et al. 2020, June 1. Clinical and economic outcomes of hospital pharmaceutical care: A systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC
Health Services Research 20, no. 1: 487. Mantone, J. 2005. Critical time at rural hospitals.
Modern Healthcare 35, no. 10: 22. Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (Med
PAC). 2006. Report to the Congress: Physician
owned specialty hospitals revisited. Washington, DC: Author.
Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (Med PAC). 20 l 9a. Critical access hospital payment
system. Washington, DC: Author. Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (Med
PAC). 2019b. Hospital acute inpatient services
payment system. Washington, DC: Author. Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (Med
PAC). 2019c. Inpatient rehabilitation facilities
payment system. Washington, DC: Author. Nachega, J. B., et al. 2010. Association of antiretro
viral therapy adherence and health care costs. Annals of Internal Medicine 152, no. 1: 18-25.
National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS). 2002. Health, United States, 2002. Hyattsville, MD: Department of Health and Human Services.
National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS). 2013. Health, United States, 2012. Hyattsville, MD: Department of Health and Human Services.
National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS). 2016. Health, United States, 2015. Hyattsville, MD: Department of Health and Human Services.
National Center for Health Statistics (NCHS). 2018. Health, United States, 2017. Hyattsville, MD: Department of Health and Human Services.
Nudelman, P. M., and L. M. Andrews. 1996. The ((value added" of not-for-profit health plans. New England Journal of Medicine 334, no. 16: 1057-1059.
O'Connell, L., and S. L. Brown. 2003. Do nonprofit HMOs eliminate racial disparities in cardiac care? Journal of Healthcare Finance 30, no. 2: 84-94.
Office of Inspector General. 2003. Trends in urban
hospital closure: 1990-2000. Available at: http:// oig.hhs.gov/ oei/reports/ oei-04-02-00611.pdf. Accessed August 2020.
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). 2019. Health at a glance,
2019: OECD indicators. Available at: https:// www.oecd-ilibrary.org/ docserver I 4dd50c09-en. pdf? expires= 1597784317 &id=id&accname=gu est&checksum=l7 AOC45135450BlOB4E8B807 410CC683. Accessed August 2020.
Ortiz, G. 2019. Predictors of 30-day postdischarge readmission to a multistate national sample of state psychiatric hospitals. Journal for Health
care Quality 41, no. 4: 228-236. Owens, B. 2005. The plight of the not-for-profit.
Journal of Healthcare Management 50, no. 4: 237-250.
Pai, A. B., et al. 2009. Reduced drug use and hos pitalization rates in patients undergoing hemo dialysis
· who received pharmaceutical care: A
2-year, randomized, controlled study. Pharma
cotherapy 29, no. 12: 1433-1440. Pai, D. R., et al. 2017. Does efficiency and quality of
care affect hospital closures? Health Systems 8, no. 1: 17-30.
Paris, M. 1995. The medical staff. In: Health care
administration: Principles, practices, structure, and delivery. 2nd ed. L. F. Wolper, ed. Gaithers burg, MD: Aspen Publishers. pp. 32-46.
Raffel, M. W. 1980. The US health system: Origins and functions. New York, NY: John Wiley and Sons.
Raffel, M. W., and N. K. Raffel. 1994. The US health
system: Origins and functions. 4th ed. Albany, NY: Delmar Publishers.
Roemer, M. I. 1961. Bed supply and hospital utiliza tion: A natural experiment. Hospitals 35, no. 21: 36-42.
Rosner, F. 2004. Informing the patient about a fatal disease: From paternalism to autonomy: The Jewish view. Cancer Investigation 22, no. 6: 949-953.
Sanofi-Aventis/Forte Information Resources. 2019. Public payer digest: Trends in chronic disease management. Managed care digest series. Bridgewater, NJ: Author.
Schneider, J. E., et al. 2007. Effects of specialty hospitals on the financial performance of gen eral hospitals, 1997-2004. Inquiry 44, no. 3: 321-334.
Schroeder, G. D., et al. 2018. The effect of hospital ownership on health care utilization in ortho pedic surgery. Clinical Spine Surgery 31, no. 2: 73-79.
Shoger, T. R. 2011. Commonsense contracts. Trust
ees 64, no. 1: 6-7. Sinay, T. 2005. Cost structure of osteopathic hospi
tals and their local counterparts in the USA: Are
Chapter opener photo: © Fl 1 photo/Shutterstock
References 391
they any different? Social Science and Medicine 60, no. 8: 1805-1814.
Statista. 2020. Number of psychiatric hospitals in the US. in 2018, by operation type. Available at: https:// www.statista.com/statistics/712645/psychiatric hospitals-number-in-the-us-by -operation type/ #statisticContainer. Accessed August 2020.
Stewart, D. A. 1973. The history and status of pro prietary hospitals. Blue Cross Reports-Research Series 9. Chicago, IL: Blue Cross Association.
Teisberg, E. D., et al. 1991. The hospital sector in
1992. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. 2018. Healthcare
jobs and the Great Recession. Available at: https://www.bls.gov/ opub/mlr/2018/article/ healthcare-jobs-and-the-great-recession.htm. Accessed August 2020.
Vogt, W. B., and R. Town. 2006. How has hospital
consolidation affected the price and quality of
hospital care? Princeton, NJ: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
Weil, A. R. 2020. Rural health, behavioral health, and more. Health Affairs 39, no. 6: 919-920.
Wolfson, J., and S. L. Hopes. 1994. What makes tax exempt hospitals special? Healthcare Financial
Management 4, no. 7: 56-60. Worthy, J. C., et al. 2016. Analysis of the community
benefit standard in Texas hospitals. Journal of Healthcare Management 61, no. 2: 94-102.