article 2
Chapter 5
Short-Term and Working Memory
Some Questions to Consider
- Why can we remember a telephone number long enough to place a call, but then we forget it almost immediately?
- How is memory involved in processes such as doing a math problem?
- Do we use the same memory system to remember things we have seen and things we have heard?
What Is Memory?
- Memory: processes involved in retaining, retrieving, and using information about stimuli, images, events, ideas, and skills after the original information is no longer present
- Active any time some past experience has an impact on how you think or behave now or in the future
Modal Model of Memory
- Atkinson and Shiffrin (1968)
- Three different types of memory:
Sensory Memory – Initial stage that holds all incoming information for seconds or fractions of a second
Short-term Memory – Holds five to seven items for about 15 to 20 seconds.
Long-term Memory – Can hold a large amount of information for years or even decades
Modal Model of Memory
*
Modal Model of Memory
- Control processes: active processes that can be controlled by the person
- Rehearsal
- Strategies used to make a stimulus more memorable
- Strategies of attention that help you focus on specific stimuli
- There are many strategies or control processes that we can use to improve our memory.
*
Modal Model of Memory:
Sensory Memory
- Sensory Memory: The retention, for brief periods of time, of the effects of sensory stimulation.
- Information decays very quickly
- Persistence of vision: retention of the perception of light
- Sparkler’s trail of light
- Frames in film
Modal Model of Memory:
Sensory Memory
- Measuring the capacity and duration of sensory memory (Sperling, 1960)
- Array of letters is flashed quickly on a screen
- Participants are asked to report as many as possible
Modal Model of Memory:
Sensory Memory
- For the whole report method, participants were asked to report as many as could be remembered
- They averaged 4.5 out of 12 letters (37.5%)
Modal Model of Memory:
Sensory Memory
- For the partial report method: participants heard tone that told them which row of letters to report
- Average of 3.3 out of 4 letters (82%)
Modal Model of Memory:
Sensory Memory
- In the delayed partial report method: presentation of tone delayed for a fraction of a second after the letters were extinguished
- Performance decreases rapidly
Modal Model of Memory:
Sensory Memory
*
Modal Model of Memory:
Sensory Memory
- Iconic memory: Brief sensory memory of the things that we see
- Responsible for persistence of vision
- Echoic memory: Brief sensory memory of the things that we hear
- Responsible for persistence of sound
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
- Short-term memory
- Stores small amounts of information for a brief duration
- Includes both new information received from the sensory stores and information recalled from long-term memory
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
- Measuring the duration of short-term memory
- Read three letters, then a number
- T, W, N, 12
- Begin counting backwards by threes
- 12, 9, 6, 3, 0, etc.
- After a set time, recall three letters
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
- After three seconds of counting, participants performed at 80%
- After 18 seconds of counting, participants performed at 10%
- This reduction in performance is explained by the existence of decay
- the vanishing of a memory trace due to the passage of time and exposure to competing stimuli
- Short-term memory, when rehearsal is prevented, is about 15-20 seconds
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
*
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
- Proactive interference: occurs when information learned previously interferes with learning new information
- Example: Your native language may make it more difficult to learn and remember a new foreign language
- Retroactive interference: occurs when new learning interferes with remembering old learning
- Example: After you get a new telephone number and use it for a while, you may have difficulty remembering your old phone number
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
- Capacity of short-term memory
- Digit span: how many digits a person can remember
- Typical result: 5-8 items
- Most textbooks say the “magic” number is 7, which is why phone numbers were always 7 digits before we had to add the area code
- But what is an item?
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
- Change detection
- Participants are shown a picture, followed by a blank screen and then a new picture and asked if the original picture had changed.
- The more items there are, the harder it is for people to detect the change.
- This study shows that performance declines after more than 4 boxes are shown.
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
- In other versions, more practical, real-life images are shown.
- As number of items in the picture increases past 4, the accuracy decreases.
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
- Chunking
- small units can be combined into larger meaningful units increasing the amount of information that can be held in short-term memory by grouping related items together
- Phone numbers are separated by the dash, creating chunks of 3-4 numbers that make it easier to remember;
249-619-1958
Placing the dash in the right place or arranging the letters in a more meaningful way can really help!
FB – ICI – A – NB – CIRS = FBI CIA NBC IRS
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
- Ericsson et al. (1980)
- Trained a college student with average memory ability to use chunking
- S.F. had an initial digit span of 7
- After 230 one-hour training sessions, S.F. could remember up to 79 digits by chunking them into meaningful units
Modal Model of Memory:
Short-Term Memory
- Alvarez and Cavanaugh (2004)
- Used colored squares as well as complex objects
- Used the change detection procedure
Modal Model of Memory: Short-Term Memory
*
Working Memory
- Similar concept to short-term memory
- Baddeley and Hitch (1974)
- Working memory
- Limited capacity system for temporary storage and manipulation of information for complex tasks such as comprehension, learning, and reasoning
Working Memory
- Working memory differs from STM
- STM holds information for a brief period of time
- WM is concerned with the processing and manipulation of information that occurs during complex cognition
Working Memory
*
Phonological Loop
- https:// www.youtube.com/watch?v=DxHXJmGH8i8
- Phonological similarity effect
- When letters or words sound similar to each other they are often confused (hatch, latch)
- Word-length effect
- Memory for lists of words is better for short words than for long words
- Takes longer to rehearse long words and to produce them during recall
Phonological Loop
- Articulatory suppression
- Results when a participant is asked to make an irrelevant sound (the, the, the) while trying to remember something.
- Prevents one from rehearsing items to be remembered
- Reduces memory span
- Eliminates word-length effect
- Reduces phonological similarity effect for reading words
Visuospatial Sketch Pad
- Visual imagery
- The creation of visual images in the mind in the absence of a physical visual stimulus
- Mental rotation task (Shepard & Metzler, 1971)
- Tasks that called for greater rotations took longer
Working Memory
- Working Memory is set up to process different types of information simultaneously
- Working memory has trouble when similar types of information are presented at the same time
Working Memory
The Central Executive
- Attention controller
- Focus, divide, switch attention
- Controls suppression of irrelevant information
- Has been studied extensively in patients with frontal lobe damage.
- These patients have a defect called perseveration.
- Perseveration
- Refers to repeatedly performing the same action or thought even if it is not achieving the desired goal
- Participant learns a rule, then the researcher switches the rule and the patient continues with the old rule.
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-vwA9QmJRy8
WM and the Brain:
Individual Differences
- As with every behavior or function, not everyone is the same. There are individual differences between people whereby some people have a low capacity for working memory and others have a high capacity for working memory.
- Vogel et al. (2005)
- Determined participants’ Working Memory and found that people could be separated into two groups.
- High-capacity WM group
- Low-capacity WM group
- Shown either simple or complex stimuli
- Measured ERP responses - the measured brain response that is the direct result of a specific sensory, cognitive, or motor event.
*
WM and the Brain:
Individual Differences
- Vogel et al. (2005)
- Results
- People with a high capacity for working memory were better at ignoring the distractors
- http://phys.org/news/2009-08-beep-oops-video.html
Episodic Buffer
- Backup store that communicates with long-term memory and working memory components
- Holds information longer and has greater capacity than either the phonological loop or visuospatial sketch pad
Episodic Buffer
*
Working Memory and the Brain
- Research has shown that chimpanzees have a remarkable capacity for working memory. The following is an article. Make sure to scroll down to view the video:
- http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2279528/Memory-chimpanzees-far-BETTER-human-study-reveals.html
- The prefrontal cortex responsible for processing incoming visual and auditory information
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ep25ntXtClg
- Primates without a prefrontal cortex have difficulty holding information in working memory
Working Memory and the Brain
- Funahashi et al. (1989)
- Single cell recordings from monkey’s prefrontal cortex during a delay-response task
Working Memory and the Brain
*
Working Memory and the Brain
- Neurons responded when stimulus was flashed in a particular location and during delay
- Information remains available via these neurons for as long as they continue firing
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zsXP8qeFF6A
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hh2Z2hSgFIY