Chapter 3: Paying for Health Services
Healthcare Business Basics
CHAPTER 2 Healthcare Business Basics
Concept of a business
Legal forms of business
For-profit versus not-for-profit ownership
Organizational goals
Financial goals
Taxes
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
2 - ‹#›
1
Concept of a Business
A business is an entity that
raises money in the capital markets,
invests these funds in assets (land, buildings, equipment, inventories, and so on),
uses these assets to create products or services, and
sells these products or services to sustain itself.
A pure charity is different. Why?
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Concept of a Business
2 - ‹#›
Legal Forms of Business
There are four major categories of business organization (legal forms of business):
Proprietorship (sole proprietorship)
Partnership
Corporation
Hybrid forms
How much does the organizational form influence the practice of healthcare finance?
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Legal Forms of Business
2 - ‹#›
Proprietorships and Partnerships
Advantages:
Ease of formation
Subject to few regulations
No corporate income taxes
Disadvantages:
Limited life
Difficult to transfer ownership
Unlimited liability
Difficult to raise capital
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Proprietorships and Partnerships
2 - ‹#›
Corporation
Advantages:
Unlimited life
Easy transfer of ownership
Limited liability
Ease of raising capital
Disadvantages:
Cost of formation and reporting
Double (or triple) taxation for investor-owned corporations
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Corporation
2 - ‹#›
Hybrid Gorms of Organization
Limited partnership (LP)
General partners have control
Limited partners are liable only for their initial contribution
Not commonly used by healthcare providers
Limited liability partnership (LLP)
Partners share general business liability
However, partners are liable only for their own malpractice actions
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Hybrid Forms of Organization
2 - ‹#›
Hybrid Forms of Organization (cont.)
Limited liability company (LLC)
Members are taxed like partners
Liability like that of stockholders
Professional corporation (PC) or professional association (PA)
Owners have benefits of incorporation
However, they are still liable for malpractice
Often used by individual clinicians
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Hybrid Forms of Organization (cont.)
2 - ‹#›
Alternative Forms of Ownership
In most industries, the only form of ownership is the investor-owned (for-profit) business.
However, in the health services industry, a significant proportion of businesses, particularly hospitals, are organized as not-for-profit corporations.
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Alternative Forms of Ownership
How much does ownership influence the practice of healthcare finance?
2 - ‹#›
Investor-Owned (For-Profit) Corporations
Investors become owners by purchasing shares of common stock.
Primary market transactions
Initial public offerings (IPOs)
New common stock sales
Secondary market transactions
On exchanges
In the over-the-counter market
Stockholders have:
right of control, and
claim on residual earnings and residual liquidation proceeds.
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Investor-Owned (For-Profit) Corporations
2 - ‹#›
Not-For-Profit Corporations
If a business meets certain requirements, it can qualify as a not-for-profit (nonprofit) corporation.
These corporations:
generally have no shareholders and, hence, do not have a single clientele to which managers are responsible;
receive various tax exemptions; and
can be thought of as being owned by “the community.”
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Not-For-Profit Corporations
2 - ‹#›
Organizational Goals
The primary goal of for-profit corporations is shareholder wealth (stock price) maximization.
The primary goal of not-for-profit corporations is generally expressed in a mission statement, often in terms of service to the community.
What is the primary goal of proprietorships and partnerships?
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Organizational Goals
2 - ‹#›
Stakeholders
All businesses have stakeholders, who are parties that have an interest (often financial) in the business.
Stakeholders include owners (if for profit), managers, employees, suppliers, patients, and even the community at large.
Not-for-profit managers must satisfy all stakeholders.
For-profit managers are primarily concerned with satisfying owners.
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Stakeholders
2 - ‹#›
Discussion Items
What responsibilities do for-profit businesses have to stakeholders other than owners?
Should for-profit businesses behave ethically? If so, why?
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Discussion Items
2 - ‹#›
Financial Goals
The primary financial goal of investor-owned corporations stems from their organizational goal: shareholder wealth (stock price) maximization.
The primary financial goal of not-for-profit corporations is to ensure the financial viability of the organization.
Does the difference in financial goals lead to different behavior?
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Financial Goals
2 - ‹#›
Tax Laws
Some understanding of tax laws is necessary because taxes influence
financing decisions,
the operating cash flows available to an investor-owned business, and
the ability to raise contribution capital.
There are several types of taxes:
Federal, state, and local
Personal versus corporate
Ordinary income versus capital gains
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Tax Laws
2 - ‹#›
Personal Taxes
Individuals pay federal (and perhaps state) taxes on salaries, interest, and other income at rates that can approach 50%. (Capital gains and dividends [in some years] are taxed at lower rates.)
Taxes reduce the amount of useable income. Consider a person paying 40% in taxes who receives $100 in interest:
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Personal Taxes
After-tax amount = Before-tax amount × (1 − T)
= $100 × (1 − .40)
= $100 × .60 = $60
2 - ‹#›
Corporate Taxes
Investor-owned corporations pay federal and state taxes on corporate income at rates that can exceed 40%.
Not-for-profit corporations, for the most part, are not subject to taxation.
Not-for-profit corporations have two additional tax benefits:
Can issue tax-exempt (municipal) bonds
Can receive tax-exempt contributions
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Corporate Taxes
2 - ‹#›
Taxable Versus Muni Bonds
Assume that a for-profit healthcare organization must offer a 10% interest rate on its new bonds.
Jane Green, an individual investor with a 28% tax rate, buys one $1,000 bond. What is the effective (after-tax) annual interest?
AT$ = (.10 × $1,000) × (1 − .28)
= $100 × .72 = $72
AT% = 10% × (1 − .28) = 10% × .72
= 7.2%
Taxable Versus Muni Bonds
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
2 - ‹#›
18
Discussion Items
Assume that a not-for-profit healthcare organization can issue similar-risk municipal bonds with an 8% interest rate. Should Jane buy the not-for-profit bond rather than the for-profit bond?
At what rate on the for-profit bond would Jane be indifferent between the two bonds?
AT% = BT% × (1 − T)
8% = BT% × (1 − .28) = BT% × .72
BT% = 8% ÷ .72 = 11.1%
Discussion
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
2 - ‹#›
19
Discussion Item
Not-for-profit businesses generally are exempt from local property taxes and state and federal income taxes. Should policymakers mandate that not-for-profit healthcare organizations provide indigent (charity care) services equal to the tax benefits received?
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Discussion Item
2 - ‹#›
Conclusion
This concludes our discussion of Chapter 2 (Healthcare Business Basics).
Although not all concepts were discussed, you are responsible for all of the material in the text.
Do you have any questions?
Copyright 2009 Health Administration Press
Conclusion
2 - ‹#›