CDEV 9
Middle Childhood: Psychosocial Development
The Developing Person Through Childhood and Adolescence
Kathleen Stassen Berger | Eleventh Edition
Chapter 13
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
WHAT WILL YOU KNOW?
What helps some children thrive in a difficult family, school, or neighborhood?
Should parents marry, risking divorce, or not marry, and thus avoid divorce?
What can be done to stop a bully?
Why would children lie to adults to protect a friend?
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
The Nature of the Child (part 1)
The middle childhood years are characterized by steady growth, brain maturation, and intellectual advances. Children become more capable and independent and social. Negotiation and compromise become important.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
3
Self-Concept
Social comparison
Tendency to assess oneself against those of other people, especially peers
Contributes to development of realistic, culturally viable self value
Peer relationships
Crucial during middle childhood
Correlated with self-concept
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Tendency to assess one’s abilities, achievements, social status, and other attributes by measuring them against those of other people, especially one’s peers
4
The Nature of the School-Age Children
Erikson’s insights:
Industry versus inferiority
Characterized by tension between productivity and incompetence
Proposes children judge themselves as competent or incompetent, productive or useless, winners or losers
Self-pride dependent on others’ view
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
The Nature of the Child (part 2)
Freud: Latency
Emotional drives are quiet, and unconscious sexual conflicts are submerged.
Children acquire cognitive skills and assimilate cultural values by expanding their world to include teachers, neighbors, peers, club leaders, and coaches.
Sexual energy is channeled into social concerns
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
The Nature of the Child (part 3)
Self-concept
Contains ideas about self that include intelligence, personality, abilities, gender, and ethnic background
Gradually becomes more realistic, specific, and logical
Is dependent on social comparison
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Becomes less optimistic as influences from peer and society are incorporated.
Potential for psychological growth is evident in the advance a child makes in self-concept in middle childhood. However, advance is not automatic—family, culture, and social context affect advancement.
Is dependent on social comparison:
awareness of social prejudices and gender discrimination
increase in materialism
7
A Question
What would you list as signs of psychosocial maturation over the middle childhood years?
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Children responsibly perform specific chores.
Children make decisions about a weekly allowance.
Children can tell time, and they have set times for various activities.
Children have homework, including some assignments over several days.
Children are less often punished than when they were younger.
Children try to conform to peers in clothes, language, and so on.
Children voice preferences about their after-school care, lessons, and activities.
Children are responsible for younger children, pets, and, in some places, work.
Children strive for independence from parents.
Of course, culture is crucial. For example, giving a child an allowance has been typical for middle-class families in developed nations since about 1960. It was rare, or completely absent, in earlier times and other places.
8
Resilience
Resilience
Involves capacity to adapt well to significant adversity and to overcome serious stress
Suggests differential sensitivity
Important components
Resilience is dynamic.
Resilience is a positive adaptation to stress.
Adversity must be significant.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Resilience is dynamic. A person may be resilient at some periods but not at others.
Resilience is a positive adaptation to stress. If rejection by a parent leads a child to establish a closer relationship with another adult, that child is resilient.
Adversity must be significant. Resilient children overcome conditions that overwhelm many of their peers.
Accumulated stresses over time, including minor ones, are more devastating than an isolated major stress.
9
Dominant Ideas About Resilience, 1965–2017
1965: All children have same needs for healthy development.
1985: Factors beyond the family, both in the child and in the community, can harm children.
2005: Focus on strengths, not risks
2012: Genes, family structures, and cultural practices can be either strengths or weaknesses.
2015: Communities are responsible for child resilience.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
See Table 13.2 for additional information
1965: All children have the same needs for healthy development.
1985: Factors beyond the family, both in the child (low birthweight, prenatal alcohol exposure, aggressive temperament) and in the community (poverty, violence), can harm children.
2005: Focus on strengths, not risks. Assets in child (intelligence, personality), family (secure attachment, warmth), community (schools, after-school programs), and nation (income support, health care) are crucial.
2012: Genes, family structures, and cultural practices can be either strengths or weaknesses. Differential sensitivity means identical stressors can benefit one child and harm another.
2015: Communities are responsible for child resilience. Not every child needs help, but every community needs to encourage healthy child development.
10
Dominant Ideas About Resilience—Today
2017
Resilience is seen more broadly as a characteristic of mothers and communities.
Some are quite resilient, which fosters resilience in children.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
See Table 13.1 for additional information.
Current thinking about resilience, with insights from dynamic-systems theory, emphasizes that no one is impervious to past history or current context, and many suffer lifelong harm from early maltreatment. But some weather early storms and a few not only survive but come out stronger.
Sri Lanka children were exposed to war, a tsunami, poverty, deaths of relatives, and relocation.
Accumulated stresses increased pathology and decreased academic achievement
Sierra Leone child soldiers witnessed and often participated in murder, rape, and other traumas.
Recovery was more likely when children were in middle childhood when war occurred; when at least one caregiver survived; when community rejection did not occur; and when daily routine was restored.
U.S. homeless children living in temporary shelters showed delays in every measure of development.
Negative outcomes were buffered by supportive parent who provided affection, hope, and stable routines.
11
Cumulative Stress
Repeated stresses, daily hassles, and multiple traumatic experiences may challenge resilience.
Social context is crucial.
Family as protective buffer
Committed caregiver, especially mother
Daily routine
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Repeated stress:
makes resilience difficult
is more devastating than isolated major stress
includes such things as frequent moves, changes in caregivers, disruption of schooling
12
Cognitive Coping (part 1)
Coping measures reduce impact of repeated stress.
Interpretation of family situation and other circumstances
Development of friends, activities, and skills
Participation in school success and after-school activities
Involvement in community, church, and other programs
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Child’s interpretation of a family situation (poverty, divorce, etc.) impacts how that situation affects him or her.
13
Cognitive Coping (part 2)
Social support and religious faith
Network of supportive relatives is a better buffer than having only one close parent.
Grandparents, teachers, unrelated adults, peers, and pets can lower stress.
Use of religion, which often provides support via adults from the same faith group, has been found to be helpful.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Same Situation, Far Apart: Praying Hands
Differences, even in their clothes and hand positions, are obvious between the Northern Indian girls entering their Hindu school and the West African boy in a Christian church.
But underlying similarities are more important. In every culture, many 8-year-olds are more devout than their elders.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Cognitive Coping (part 3)
Parentification
Occurs when a child acts more like a parent than a child
Happens if the actual parents do not act as caregivers, making a child feel responsible for the entire family
Has effect related to child interpretation of what they do
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Families and Children
Shared and nonshared environments
Genes affect half or more of the variance for almost every trait.
Influence of shared environment (e.g., children raised by the same parents in the same home) shrinks with age
Effect of nonshared environment (e.g., friends or schools) increases
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Thinking about any family—even a happy, wealthy family like this one—makes it apparent that each child’s family experiences differ.
For instance, would you expect the 5-year-old boy to be treated the same way as his two older sisters?
And how about each child’s feelings toward the parents?
Even though the 12-year-olds are twins, one may favor her mother while the other favors her father.
17
Family Function and Family Structure
Family structure
Legal and genetic relationships among relatives living in the same home and includes nuclear family, extended family, stepfamily, and others
Family function
Way a family works to meet the needs of its members
Families provide basic material necessities to encourage learning, to help development of self-respect, to nurture friendships, and to foster harmony and stability.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Needs of Children in Middle Childhood
Families help children
Provide basic physical necessities
Encourage learning
Help development of self-respect
Nurture friendships
Foster harmony and stability
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
19
Continuity and Change
No family always functions perfectly
Children worldwide fare better in families than in other institutions
School-agers value continuity and having fathers at home
Stability challenges occur in military families
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
20
A VIEW FROM SCIENCE Effects of Genes and Environment
Children raised in the same households by the same parents do not necessarily share the same experiences or home environment.
Changes in the family affect every family member differently, depending on age and/or gender.
Most parents respond to each of their children differently.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Diversity of Family Structures (part 1)
Two-Parent Families
Nuclear family
Stepparent family
Adoptive family
Grandparents alone
Two same-sex parents
Single-Parent Families
Single mother-never married
Single mother-divorced, separated, widowed
Single father
Grandparent alone
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
See Table 13.3 for additional information.
22
Diversity of Family Structures (part 2)
More than two-adult families
Extended family
Polygamous family
These may also be included as two-parent or single-parent family categories.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
See Table 13.3 for additional information.
23
Divorce (part 1)
How can these facts be interpreted?
United States leads world in rates of marriage, divorce, and remarriage.
Single, cohabiting, and stepparents sometimes provide good care for their children, but children usually do best living with married parents.
Divorce is a process, not a decree.
Custody disputes and outcomes frequently harm children.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Divorce (part 2)
Insight
Both marriage and personal freedom are idolized. This creates a cultural conflict.
A shrinking middle class impacts the ability to find jobs and support families. This creates a strain on marriages and families.
Some of the greatest effects of divorce come from frequent changes in residence, school, and family members.
Parenting style (e.g., discipline, too much or too little child responsibility, conflict, secrets)
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Connecting Family Structure and Function (part 1)
Two-parent families
Generally function best
Better educational, social, cognitive, and behavioral child outcomes
Mate selection effects and parental alliance
Positive effects beyond childhood
Some reported benefits are correlates
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Structure influences but does not determine function. Which structures make it more likely that the five family functions (necessities, learning, self-respect, friendship, harmony/stability) will occur?
26
Connecting Family Structure and Function (part 2)
Adoptive and same-sex parent families
Typically function well; often better than average nuclear families
Vary tremendously in ability to meet child needs
Stepfamilies
Some function well; positive relationships more easily formed with children under 2; more difficult with teenagers
Solid parental alliance more difficult to form
Child loyalty to parents often undermined by disputes
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
27
Connecting Family Structure and Function (part 3)
Grandparent family (skipped-generation family)
Generally lower income, more health problems, less stability
Often involve grandchildren with health or behavioral problems who are less likely to succeed in school
Receive fewer services for children with special needs
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
28
Connecting Family Structure and Function (part 4)
Single-parent families
On average, structure functions less well for children
Lower income and stability
Stress from multiple roles
Benefit from community support
More common in United States than in many nations
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
No type of two-parent family guarantees good functioning, but the fact that two adults are involved nudge it in the right direction.
29
Family Challenges (part 1)
Two factors increase the likelihood of dysfunction in every structure, ethnic group, and nation:
Low income or poverty
High conflict
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Many families experience both: Financial stress increases conflict and vice versa.
30
Wealth and Poverty
Family income correlates with function and structure.
Low-SES contribute to increased family risk factors.
Any risk factor damages only if it increased parental stress and adult hostility (family-stress model)
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
31
Family Challenges (part 2)
Conflict
Family conflict harms children, especially when adults fight about child rearing.
Fights are more common in stepfamilies, divorced families, and extended families.
Although genes have some effect, conflict itself is the main influence on a child’s well-being.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
32
The Peer Group
Child culture
Particular habits, styles, and values that reflect the set of rules and rituals that characterize children as distinct from adult society
Fashion
Appearance
Peer culture
Attitudes
Independence from adults
Passed down to younger children from slightly older ones
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
The culture of children is not always benign.
Boys in middle childhood are happiest playing outside with equipment designed for work. This wheelbarrow is perfect, especially because at any moment the pusher might tip it.
33
Friendship and Social Acceptance (part 1)
Friendships
In middle childhood, children value personal friendship more than peer acceptance.
Friendships lead to psychosocial growth and provide a buffer against psychopathology.
Gender differences:
Girls talk more and share secrets.
Boys play more active games.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
34
Friendship and Social Acceptance (part 2)
Older children
Demand more of their friends
Change friends less often
Become more upset when a friendship ends
Find it harder to make new friends
Seek friends who share their interests and values
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Popular and Unpopular Children
Popular children in the United States
Kind, trustworthy, cooperative
Athletic, cool, dominant, arrogant, aggressive (around fifth grade)
Unpopular children in the United States
Neglected
Aggressive-rejected
Withdrawn-rejected
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Universally, children seek friends.
Culture and cohort affect popularity.
Neglected children:
neglected by peers, but not actively rejected
ignored, but not shunned
do not enjoy school; but psychologically unharmed
Aggressive-rejected children:
disliked by peers because of antagonistic, confrontational behavior
Withdrawn-rejected children:
disliked by peers because of their timid, withdrawn, and anxious behavior
36
Bullies and Victims
Bullying
Repeated, systematic efforts to inflict harm through physical, verbal, or social attack on a weaker person
Bully-victim
Someone who attacks others and who is attacked as well
Also called a provocative victim because he or she does things that elicit bullying, such as stealing a bully’s pencil
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Types of Bullying
Physical (hitting, pinching, or kicking)
Verbal (teasing, taunting, or name-calling)
Relational (destroying peer acceptance and friendship)
Cyberbullying (using electronic means to harm another)
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Causes and Consequences of Bullying
Causes
Genetic predisposition or brain abnormality
Parenting/caregiving environment
Age, peers
Consequences
Impaired social understanding, lower school achievement, relationship difficulties
Depression
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Can Bullying Be Stopped?
The whole school community must be involved, not just the identified bullies.
Intervention is more effective in the earlier grades.
Evaluation of results is critical.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Research finds that children are better at stopping bullying than adults are, because bystanders are pivotal. Since bullies tend to be low on empathy, they need peers to teach them that their actions are not admired (many bullies believe people admire their aggression).
40
Children’s Moral Values (part 1)
Forces that drive emerging interest in moral issues include:
Child culture
Personal experience
Empathy
Children show a variety of skills in:
Making moral judgments
Differentiating universal principles from conventional norms
Becoming more socially perceptive
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Children’s Moral Values (part 2)
Kohlberg’s levels of moral thought
Stages of morality stem from three levels of moral reasoning with two stages at each level
Preconventional moral reasoning: Emphasizes rewards and punishments
Conventional moral reasoning: Emphasizes social rules
Postconventional moral reasoning: Emphasizes moral principles
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
See Table 13.4 for additional information.
Kohlberg judged moral development not by the answers but by the reasons for the answers.
42
Children’s Moral Values (part 3)
Criticisms of Kohlberg
Pros
Child use of intellectual abilities to justify moral actions was correct.
Cons
Culture and gender differences are ignored.
Differences between child and adult morality are not addressed.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Kohlberg’s levels could be labeled personal (preconventional), communal (conventional), and worldwide (postconventional).
43
What Children Value
Prosocial values among 6- to 11-year-olds
Care for close family members
Cooperate with other children
Do not hurt anyone intentionally
Adult versus peer values
Protect your friends
Do not tell adults what is happening
Conform to peer standards of dress, talk, and behavior
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
As children become more aware of themselves and others in middle childhood, they realize that one person’s values may conflict with another’s. Concrete operational cognition, which gives children the ability to understand and use logic, propels them to think about morality and try to behave ethically.
44
Developing Moral Values
Throughout middle childhood, moral judgment becomes more comprehensive.
Psychological and physical harm, as well as intentions and consequences taken into account
Peer effects on morality (Piaget)
Transition from advocating for retribution to restitution between ages of 8 and 10 years
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
Benefits of Time and Talking
Conversation on a topic may stimulate a process of individual reflection that triggers developmental advances. Raising moral issues and letting children discuss them advances morality.
Copyright © 2018 by Macmillan Learning
The graph on the left shows that most children, immediately after their initial punitive response, became even more likely to seek punishment rather than to repair damage. However, after some time and reflection, they affirmed the response Piaget considered more mature. The graph on the right indicates that children who had talked about the broken window example moved toward restorative justice even in examples they had not heard before, which was not true for those who had not talked about the first story.
46