Strategic Management week 8 Discussion
chapter 12 Corporate Culture and Leadership—Keys to Good Strategy Execution
Arthur A. Thompson The University of Alabama
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
All rights reserved. Not for distribution to non-registrants without permission.
An e-book published and distributed by McGraw Hill Education
Sixth Edition of Strategy: Core Concepts and Analytical Approaches (2020-2021). Arthur A. Thompson, The University of Alabama. Published and distributed by McGraw Hill Education. Image of globe comprised of puzzle pieces with several pieces dislodged and scattered below the globe. Chapter 5 The Five Generic Competitive Strategy Options: Which One to Employ
1
“The biggest levers you’ve got to change a company are strategy, structure, and culture. If I could pick two, I’d pick strategy and culture.”
12–2
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Wayne Leonard former CEO, Entergy
2
“Weak leadership can wreck the soundest strategy; forceful execution of even a poor plan can often bring victory.”
12–3
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Sun Zi ancient Chinese general and philosopher
“Leadership is accomplishing something through other people that wouldn’t have happened if you weren’t there… Leadership is being able to mobilize ideas and values that energize other people… Leaders develop a story line that engages other people.”
12–4
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Noel Tichy,
Professor
“You’ve got to have a vision. You’ve got to have a plan to implement it. Then you’ve got to set the example, develop the principles and values that are important, and get people to buy into it.”
12–5
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Nick Saban, Head Football Coach, The University of Alabama
5
Be able to identify the key features of a company’s corporate culture and appreciate the role of a company’s core values and ethical standards in shaping the corporate culture.
Understand how and why a company’s culture can aid or block the drive for good strategy execution and operating excellence.
Learn the kinds of actions management can take to change a problem corporate culture.
Understand what constitutes effective managerial leadership in achieving superior strategy execution and operating excellence.
12–6
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Chapter 12 Learning Objectives
6
Instilling a Corporate Culture that Promotes Good Strategy Execution
Identifying the Key Features of a Corporate Culture
Cultures Are Often Grounded in Core Value and Ethics
Strong vs. Weak Cultures
Why Cultures Matter to the Strategy Execution Process
Healthy Cultures That Aid Good Strategy Execution
Unhealthy Cultures Impede Good Strategy Execution
Changing a Problem Culture
Leading the Strategy Execution Process
12–7
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Chapter 12 Roadmap
7
Every firm has its own unique culture that is a product of:
The core values and business principles articulated by executives
Its standards of what is ethically acceptable and what is not
The ingrained work practices, beliefs, and behaviors that define “how we do things around here”
Its approach to people management and its style of operating
The “chemistry” and the “personality” that permeates its work environment
Stories told repeatedly to reinforce its values, business practices, and traditions
The specific cultural traits that emerge from a firm’s meshing of these culture-determining factors define its corporate culture
A firm’s culture is its psyche or organizational DNA
A firm’s culture is important because it influences its actions and approaches to conducting its business
There are large variations in the character of company cultures
Instilling a Corporate Culture That Promotes Good Strategy Execution
12–8
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
8
Core Concept
Corporate culture refers to the character of a firm’s internal work climate and psyche—as shaped by its core values, business principles, ethical standards, ingrained beliefs and behaviors, approach to people management, style of operating, and traditions.
12–9
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
9
Identifying the Key Features of a Company’s Corporate Culture
12–10
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Strength of peer pressure to conform and observe norms
Actions and behaviors encouraged and rewarded
Traditions and stories and “how we do things around here”
How the firm treats its stakeholders
A Company’s Corporate Culture
Values, principles, and ethical standards in actual use
Approach to people management and key policies and procedures
Atmosphere and spirit that pervades the firm’s work climate
How managers and employees interact and relate to one another
The values, beliefs, and practices that undergird a firm’s culture can have any of several origins:
A founder or strong executive leaders who articulated them as a set of business principles, the firm’s policies and ways of operating
Exemplary actions of personnel viewed as role models
Evolving consensus about “how we ought to do things around here.”
Over time, these cultural underpinnings take root, become embedded in how the firm conducts its business, and gain widespread acceptance among both managers and employees
Identifying the Key Features of a Company’s Corporate Culture
12–11
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
11
Zealous pursuit of low costs and frugal operating practices
A strong work ethic
Ritualistic headquarters meetings to exchange ideas and review problems
Executives’ commitment to visiting stores, listening to customers, and soliciting suggestions from employees.
12–12
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Example: Corporate Culture at Wal-Mart
Share a common customer-centered goal of developing the best consumer products that make users feel delight, surprise, and connection to each Apple device
Secretive, and highly protective of company-developed technology and know-how.
Creative thinking and inspired solutions are expected from everyone—perfectionists always on the lookout for better ideas.
12–13
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Example: Cultural Traits at Apple
13
Delivering exceptional service to an out-of-the-ordinary customer request is a “heroic” act
Promoting employees noted for their heroic acts and dedication to outstanding service
Motivating salespeople with a commission-based compensation system that enables Nordstrom’s best salespeople to earn more than double what other stores pay
12–14
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Example: Cultural Traits at Nordstrom
Corporate culture is strongly influenced by its dedication to its core values and the bar it sets for ethical behavior.
Accounts for why so many firms have developed a formal values statement and a code of ethics
At some firms stated values/ethics are cosmetic, existing mainly to impress outsiders and help create a positive image.
Stated core values and ethical principles have two culture-building roles:
Fostering a work climate where personnel share common and strongly held convictions about how the firm’s business is to be conducted
Providing personnel with guidance about the manner in which they are to do their jobs
Cultures Are Often Grounded in Core Values and Ethics
12–15
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
15
Strategic Insight
A company’s values statement and code of ethics communicate expectations of how all company personnel should conduct themselves in the workplace.
11–16
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
FIGURE 12.1 The Two Culture-Building Roles of a Company’s Core Values and Ethical Standards
12–17
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Access text alternative for slide image.
17
Screening and selecting new employees that will mesh well with the culture.
Incorporating discussions of the firm’s culture and desired cultural behaviors into employee orientation programs and training courses for managers and employees.
Having senior managers frequently reiterate core values, ethical standards, and the desired cultural behaviors in daily conversations, at company events, and internal communications to employees.
Stressing that line-managers all the way down to first-level supervisors give ongoing attention to explaining the desired cultural traits and behaviors in their areas and why they are important.
Expecting managers at all levels to be cultural role models and exhibit the advocated cultural norms in their own behavior.
Encouraging company personnel to exert strong peer pressure on coworkers to conform to expected cultural norms.
Making the display of cultural norms a factor in evaluating each person’s job performance, granting compensation increases, and deciding who to promote.
Holding periodic ceremonies to honor people who excel in exhibiting and role modeling the desired cultural behaviors.
Ways That Companies Ingrain Cultural Norms and Perpetuate the Culture
12–18
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Cultures evolve because a variety of factors breed a new work climate and new ways of doing things:
Diversification into new businesses
Expansion into foreign countries
Rapid growth that brings an influx of new employees
Merger with or acquisition of another firm
A new CEO who opts to shake things up
A significant change in the company’s direction and/or a big strategy change and/or a sudden decline in sales/profits
12–19
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
The Forces That Cause a Company’s Culture to Evolve
19
Why a Company’s Culture Evolves
Causes of Cultural Change
A new CEO that shakes things up.
Expansion into foreign countries
Diversification into new businesses
Eroding business prospects or big internal changes
Merger or acquisition of another firm
Rapid growth that causes an influx of new employees
12–20
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
It is not unusual for firm to have multiple cultures (or subcultures) with their own values, beliefs, and practices:
Departments
Geographic locations
Business units
Global and multinational firms tend to be multicultural because cross-country organization units have different operating histories and work climates, members who speak different languages, have grown up under different customs and traditions, and have different sets of values and beliefs
Subcultures can clash if:
They embrace conflicting business philosophies
Key executives use different approaches to people management
Differences between a firm’s culture and recently-acquired businesses have not been ironed out
Existence of subcultures does not preclude important areas of commonality and compatibility being established in different countries (or within a subculture)
12–21
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
The Presence of Company Subcultures
21
Strong-Culture Firm
Has deeply rooted widely-shared values, behavioral norms, and operating approaches.
Insists that its values and principles be reflected in the decisions and actions taken by all company personnel.
Weak-Culture Firm
Lacks values and principles that are consistently preached or widely shared.
Has few or no widely-shared traditions, principles, beliefs, values, or behavioral norms.
12–22
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Strong vs. Weak Cultures
Core Concept
In a strong-culture company, culturally approved behaviors and ways of doing things flourish, while culturally disapproved behaviors and work practices get squashed.
12–23
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
23
The dominating presence of deeply-rooted values and operating approaches “regulate” conduct of a firm’s business and its workplace.
In strong culture firms, senior managers
Reiterate business principles and core values to organization members and explain how they relate to its business environment.
Make a conscious effort to display these principles in their own actions and behavior—they walk the talk
Insist that those values and business principles are reflected in the decisions and actions taken by all personnel
Over time, the strong values are widely shared by rank-and-file employees—people who dislike the culture tend to leave
Individuals encounter strong peer pressures from co-workers to observe culturally approved norms and behaviors
12–24
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Strong-Culture Companies
24
A strong corporate culture has a powerful influence on strategy execution (“how we do things around here”) because:
Many personnel are accepting of cultural traditions
There are strong management expectations and co-worker peer pressure to conform to cultural norms
Managers use traditions, beliefs, values, common bonds, and behavioral norms as levers to mobilize commitment to executing the chosen strategy.
Caution: Strong cultures can create a HUGE OBSTACLE to good strategy execution if its behavioral norms conflict with the needed kinds of execution-supportive behaviors.
12–25
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Strong-Culture Companies (continued)
25
A Weak-Culture Firm
Lacks values and principles consistently preached or widely shared
Has few widely revered traditions and evidences few culture-induced norms in its operating practices
Top executives not committed to culture-building, no commitment to particular values and behavioral norms and/or efforts to paint white lines for actions, decisions, and behavior of company personnel
Has a working environment where its personnel feel little co-worker peer pressure to do the right things in particular ways
Breeds no strong allegiance to what the firm stands for or to operating the business in well-defined ways
Cultural weakness can result from entrenched subcultures that block the emergence of a well-defined work climate
12–26
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Weak-Culture Companies
26
When a firm’s culture promotes attitudes, behaviors, and ways of doing things conducive to first-rate strategy execution, the culture
Functions as a valuable ally in the strategy execution process
Adds formidable power to management’s strategy execution efforts
Why so?
Execution-supportive cultural norms, actions, behaviors, and work practices make it easier for managers to win support for doing the things needed to execute strategy proficiently
Culture-induced peer pressures steer personnel into actions and behaviors that aid the cause of good strategy execution
Execution-supportive cultural influences rally personnel to implement needed internal changes by exerting their best efforts to attain execution-critical performance
Why Corporate Cultures Matter to the Strategy Execution Process
12–27
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
27
Core Concept
A culture that encourages actions, behaviors, and work practices conducive to good strategy execution adds significantly to the power and effectiveness of a firm’s strategy execution effort.
12–28
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
28
Strategic Insight
In companies with execution-supportive cultural influences, managers can use the ingrained values, business principles, behavioral norms, and established ways of doing things as levers to mobilize the energy and actions of company personnel squarely behind the drive for good strategy execution.
12–29
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
A culture that clashes with execution-supportive behaviors and work practices poses a dilemma for the firm’s personnel:
Should they be loyal to the culture and traditions of the firm and resist or be indifferent to behaviors and practices that promote better strategy execution?
Should they go along with the strategy execution effort and engage in actions and behaviors that run counter to the culture?
Why Corporate Cultures Matter to the Strategy Execution Process (continued)
12–30
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
30
Strategic Insight
It is in management’s best interest to dedicate considerable effort to establishing a corporate culture that encourages behaviors and work practices conducive to good strategy execution and that marshals organizational energy behind the drive for good strategy execution.
12–31
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
31
Closely aligning culture with requirements for strategy execution merits the full attention of senior executives
Their culture-building objective is to create a work climate and style of operating that mobilizes their personnel squarely behind efforts to execute the firm’s strategy competently.
The more that execution-supportive ways are embedded in the culture, the more the culture automatically steers its members toward execution-supportive behaviors and work practices
Why Corporate Cultures Matter to the Strategy Execution Process (concluded)
12–32
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
32
Strategy execution in a weak culture firm poses big top management challenges because:
There are no ingrained traditions, values, peer pressures, or behavioral norms for managers to rely on in helping align the actions and behavior of employees with the requirements for good strategy execution.
Managers have no strong internal cultural support for their attempts to implement strategic change.
Managers are left with the options of urging employee support for needed changes and using compensation incentives and rules-driven directives to induce execution-supportive actions and behaviors.
12–33
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Trying to Execute Strategy in a Weak-Culture Company
A strong, healthy culture embraces execution-supportive attitudes, behaviors, and work practices.
Two types of cultures that are healthy and supportive of good strategy execution are:
High-performance cultures
Adaptive cultures
Healthy Cultures That Aid Good Strategy Execution
12–34
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
34
The standout traits:
A “can-do” spirit of results-oriented work climate where people do more than is expected to meet or beat stretch objectives
Pride in doing things right
No-excuses accountability
A strong sense of involvement on the part of all personnel
An emphasis on individual initiative and creativity
ALL personnel display high-performance behaviors and a passion for making the firm successful
Such a culture—permeated by a spirit of achievement and constructive pressure to achieve good results—is a valuable contributor to strategy execution and operating excellence
12–35
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
High-Performance Cultures
35
A willingness to accept change, introduce and execute new strategies, and adopt new work practices
Confidence that the firm can deal with new threats and opportunities
A proactive approach to identifying issues, evaluating implications and options, and quickly moving ahead with workable solutions
Receptiveness to risk taking, experimentation, and innovation
Supportive of managers and employees who advocate useful change
Seek out, support, and promote individuals who exercise initiative, spot opportunities, and display the skills to implement them.
Openly evaluate ideas and suggestions, fund initiatives to develop new or better products, and take prudent risks to pursue opportunities
Firms with adaptive cultures thrive on change— driving it, leading it, and capitalizing on it .
12–36
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Traits of Adaptive Cultures
36
Why is change willingly embraced in an adaptive culture as opposed to a condition where organization members are fearful of how change will affect them and thus change-resistant?
Answers lie in the traits of an adaptive culture:
Managers are careful to make sure that any changes in operating practices and behaviors do not compromise core values and long-standing business principles
Managers are careful to make sure that any changes they institute are consistent with the legitimate and best interests of all stakeholders—customers, employees, shareowners, suppliers, and the communities where the company operates
Changes are readily accepted so long as the changes are viewed as fair to all stakeholders and management exhibits a commitment to doing the right thing
12–37
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Change in Adaptive Cultures
37
Strategic Insight
As a firm’s strategy evolves, both a high performance culture and an adaptive culture are valuable allies in the strategy-implementing, strategy-executing process, as compared to cultures that have to be coaxed and cajoled to change.
12–38
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
38
The distinctive characteristic of an unhealthy corporate culture is the presence of counterproductive cultural traits that adversely impact the work climate, company performance, and the success of strategy execution initiatives
Five particularly unhealthy cultural traits are:
Hostility to change
Heavily politicized decision-making
Insular, inwardly-focused thinking
Unethical and greed-driven behaviors
The presence of incompatible subcultures
Unhealthy Cultures That Impede Good Strategy Execution
12–39
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
39
Five Unhealthy Cultures That Impede Good Strategy Execution
Change-resistant cultures
Insular, inwardly focused cultures
Politicized cultures
Incompatible Subcultures
Unethical and greed-driven cultures
12–40
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Undesirable or unhealthy behaviors in change-resistant cultures
Avoiding risks; being cautious and conservative is deemed wiser
Not making bold proposals to pursue emerging opportunities
A lax approach to both product innovation and continuous improvement in performing value chain activities
Following rather than leading market change because:
Being in the forefront of change is too risky
Acting too quickly increases exposure to costly mistakes
Moving later allows careful analysis and learning from missteps of early movers
No enthusiasm for (or opposition to) proposals to do things differently
People who champion new ways of doing things are viewed as a nuisance or troublemaker; more comfortable with “we have done it this way for years”
12–41
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Change-Resistant Cultures
41
Internal politics and political infighting consumes a great deal of organizational energy
Empire-building managers jealously guard their prerogatives
Have their own agendas and operate their work units as autonomous “fiefdoms”
Their positions on issues are aimed at protecting or expanding their turf
Collaboration with other units is viewed with suspicion, and cross-unit cooperation occurs grudgingly
Politically influential executives and/or coalitions among departments with vested interests in a particular outcome shape what actions the firm takes
What’s best for the firm takes a backseat to political maneuvering
Political jockeying detracts from efforts to execute strategy and frustrates personnel who are less political and more inclined to do what is in the firm’s best interests.
12–42
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Politicized Cultures
42
Standout traits and behaviors:
A belief on the part of managers and key employees that they have all the answers or can develop them internally
A neglect of customers and how their needs and expectations are changing.
Confidence in the correctness of how the firm does things and the firm’s skills and capabilities causes managers to discount he merits of what outsiders are doing and see little payoff from studying best-in-class performers.
Insular thinking, internally driven solutions, and a must-be-invented-here mindset permeates a culture of managerial inbreeding and a failure to recruit people who offer fresh thinking and perspectives.
The big risk of insular thinking is underestimating the power of the competitive capabilities of rival firms and overestimating the power of the firm’s own competitive capabilities.
12–43
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Insular, Inwardly Focused Cultures
43
The standout traits and behaviors:
Executives exude
Arrogance, ego, and greed
An “ends-justify-the-means” mentality in pursuing performance targets
Senior managers
Wink at unethical behavior
May cross over the line to unethical (and criminal) behavior themselves
Adopt accounting principles that make financial performance look better than it really is
12–44
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Unethical and Greed-Driven Cultures
44
Subcultures are unhealthy when:
They embrace conflicting business philosophies, approaches to people management, and/or styles of operating
They spawn warring factions within the firm, creating a poisonous atmosphere
They become absorbed in political behaviors with surrounding clashing subcultures that distract personnel from doing the firm’s business while they are jockeying with other subcultures for cultural dominance
They prevent or impede teamwork among various units and block emergence of a collaborative approach to strategy execution
Lack of consensus among subcultures about how to do things results in fragmented or inconsistent approaches to implementing strategic initiatives and limited success in executing the firm’s overall strategy.
12–45
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Incompatible, Clashing Subcultures
45
When a culture is unhealthy or out of sync with actions and behaviors needed to successfully execute the company’s strategy, the culture must be changed as rapidly as can be managed by
Eliminating the unhealthy or dysfunctional or mismatched cultural traits and replacing them with execution-supportive behaviors and work practices
Successful culture change requires decisive, forceful leadership by top executives
The single most visible factor that distinguishes successful culture-change efforts from failed attempts is competent leadership at the top.
Changing a Problem Culture
12–46
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
46
FIGURE 12.2 Changing a Problem Culture
12–47
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
47
Efforts to replace a problem culture are made credible by initiating a series of visible, forceful change actions:
Replace recalcitrant “old culture” executives and managers
Promote advocates of the shift to a different culture who can function as new-culture role models
Appoint outsiders with the desired cultural attributes to high-profile positions
Screen all candidates for new positions carefully, hiring only those who appear to fit in with the new culture
Mandate that all personnel attend culture-training programs
12–48
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Substantive Culture-Changing Actions
48
Ways to change a problem culture:
Design compensation incentives that boost the pay of teams and individuals who display the desired cultural behaviors.
Let word leak out that generous pay raises have been awarded to individuals who have stepped out front, led the adoption of the desired work practices, displayed the new-style behaviors, and achieved pace-setting results.
Revise policies and procedures to better drive cultural change
12–49
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Substantive Culture-Changing Actions (continued)
49
Symbolic actions that top executives can take:
Lead by example—Walk the talk
If the firm is striving to be a low-cost provider, top executives must display frugality in their own actions and minimize executive perks
If the culture change imperative is to be more responsive to customers’ needs and to pleasing customers, then executives must spend time talking with customers
Hold ceremonial events
To praise and honor people who display the desired cultural traits
To celebrate each culture-change success
Appear at employee training programs to stress strategic priorities, values, ethical principles, and cultural norms
12–50
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Symbolic Culture-Changing Actions
Changing a problem culture is not a short-term exercise:
A new culture takes time to emerge and prevail, overnight transformations do not occur.
A new culture can take 2-5 years (maybe longer) to become deeply embedded
The larger the organization and the greater the cultural shift needed to produce an execution-supportive fit, the longer change takes
How Long Does It Take to Change a Problem Culture?
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
12–51
51
12–52
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Leading the Strategy Execution Process
Managing the strategy process is simple enough:
Craft a sound strategic plan, implement it, fully execute it, adjust it as needed, and win!
Leading the strategy execution process is a top-down management activity:
Stay on top of what is happening, monitor progress, remove obstacles to good execution, and decide how to get things done
Use constructive pressure to achieve good results and operating excellence
Push corrective actions to improve strategy execution and achieve the targeted results
52
Requires senior executives to tap into information from a wide range of sources:
Talk with key subordinates
Stay in close contact with key personnel in outlying locations via e-mail and telephone
Attend meetings and quiz presenters and attendees
Review the latest operating results
Watch the competitive reactions of rival firms
Visit with key customers and suppliers to get their perspectives
Practice managing by walking around (MBWA)—learn firsthand how well the strategy execution process is going (gather information by visiting facilities, talking with different personnel at different organization levels, asking lots of questions, listening to concerns and opinions, soliciting ideas)
Staying on Top of How Well Things Are Going
12–53
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
53
Core Concept
Management by walking around (MBWA) is one of the techniques that effective leaders use to stay informed about how well the strategy execution process is progressing and determine whether and when to intervene to help move things along.
MBWA allows managers to see firsthand how well the strategy execution process is proceeding, spot gridlock, learn what obstacles lie in the path of good execution, and start considering what might be done to clear the way for better progress.
12–54
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
54
Mobilizing organizational energy behind the drive for good strategy execution and operating excellence entails nurturing a results-oriented work climate, where performance standards are high and a spirit of achievement is pervasive
The goal is to build a good organizational track record in meeting or beating stretch performance targets
Putting Constructive Pressure on the Organization to Achieve Good Results and Operating Excellence
12–55
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
55
Treating employees as valued partners and contributors in organizational efforts to achieve good business results.
Fostering an esprit de corps that energizes organizational members
Using empowerment to help create a fully engaged workforce
Setting stretch objectives and clearly communicating an expectation that personnel are to give their best in achieving performance targets
Using benchmarking, best practices, business process reengineering, TQM, and Six Sigma to focus attention on internal operating improvements
Using the full range of motivational techniques and compensation incentives to inspire company personnel, nurture a results-oriented work climate, and reward high performance.
Celebrating individual, group, and company successes
Instilling a Spirit of High Achievement Into the Culture
12–56
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
56
Success in initiating corrective actions hinges on:
Accurate analysis of unacceptable performance (correcting flawed strategy execution is different than correcting flawed strategy)
Exercise of good business judgment in deciding when and what corrective adjustments to make
Good implementation of the corrective actions that are initiated
Successful managers get an organization back on track quickly because:
They (and their staffs) are good at discerning what actions to take and in driving them through to a successful conclusion.
Managers who misdiagnose the causes of weak performance or are habitually slow to implement corrective actions that produce better results are candidates for being replaced.
Leading the Process of Making Corrective Adjustments
12–57
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
57
Leading the Process of Making Corrective Adjustments
12–58
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Accurate analysis of the situation
Good business judgment in deciding what actions to take
Good implementation of the corrective actions
Making corrective actions successfully requires:
Leading the Process of Making Corrective Adjustments
Making corrective actions successfully requires:
Accurate analysis of the situation
Good business judgment in deciding what actions to take
Good implementation of the corrective actions
12–59
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Strategic Insight
The process of making corrective adjustments is not about searching for the “right” or “provably correct” way to proceed. It’s about instituting actions deemed likely to result in better strategy execution and improved ability to attain the targeted levels of business performance.
12–60
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
Doing a good job of leading the strategy execution process is not about searching for the “right” way to proceed or for provably “correct” solutions. It is about proceeding in a manner that produces good results, namely proficient strategy execution, progress toward operating excellence, and good business performance.
“Good Results” Are the Best Sign of Effective Leadership
12–61
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
61
In practice, it is hard to separate leading the process of executing strategy from leading the other pieces of the strategy process
Strategy consists of five interrelated and linked tasks requiring continuous fine-tuning and adjustments to strategic visions, objectives, strategies, and implementation/execution approaches to fit ever-changing circumstances
The best tests of good strategic leadership and management are
Whether the firm has a good strategy
Whether the strategy is being competently executed
Whether the enterprise is meeting or beating its performance targets
12–62
Copyright © 2020 by Arthur A. Thompson and Glo-Bus Software, Inc.
A Final Word on Leading the Process of Crafting and Executing Strategy
62
Accessibility Content: Text Alternatives for Images
FIGURE 12.1 The Two Culture-Building Roles of a Company’s Core Values and Ethical Standards, Text Alternate
A company’s stated core values and ethical principles:
Foster a work climate where company personnel share common and strongly held convictions about how the company’s business is to be conducted.
Signal employees that they are expected to:
Display the company’s core values in their actions (do things the right way)
Uphold the company’s ethical standards (do the right thing)
FIGURE 12.2 Changing a Problem Culture, Text Alternate
Step 1: Identify facets of the present culture that are dysfunctional and impede good strategy execution, operating excellence, and the achievement of performance targets.
Step 2: Specify what new actions, behaviors, and work practices should characterize the “new” culture.
Step 3: Talk openly about problems of the present culture and make a persuasive case for how the proposed new actions and behaviors will improve company performance.
Step 4: Follow with visible, forceful actions—both substantive and symbolic—to ingrain a new set of behaviors, operating practices, and cultural norms.
65