aviation assignment for MGMT
Chapter 9
Emergency Management and the New Terrorist Threat
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Introducing the Terror Threat
- US attacked on 9/11/01 - spectacular in its methods, and devastating in terms of loss of life and destruction of property
- Every citizen felt its impacts
- Event marked a turning point
- Policies and laws launched at an almost alarming rate to address a seemingly new hazard
- Has had a resounding impact on emergency management, foreign policy, immigration policies and enforcement practices, counter-narcotics programs and policies, and more
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Introduction Continued
- Billions in funding to counter terrorism came after 9/11
- Federal grant programs created to help State, tribal, territorial, and local governments
- Rush to understand
- How terrorism impacted them as a community
- How vulnerable they were
- What needed to be done
- Communities re-examined themselves
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Introduction Continued
- Nation faced terrorism since its founding
- 100s of attacks—bombs, shootings, chemical and biological attacks, physical assaults, more
- Terrorism hazard broad in scope
- Perpetrated by people/organizations with a broad range of types, sizes, and backgrounds
- May or may not have a tangible ideological or philosophical reason for carrying out their attacks
- May be “homegrown” or internationally-based.
- Groups or individuals
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Introduction Continued
- Terrorists have a wide range of weapons and tactics to choose from
- Traditional methods: shootings, bombings, and assault-type attacks
- Weapons of mass destruction (chemical, biological, or radiological weapons)
- Cyberterrorism
- For the EM, terrorism is just one of many hazards that merit attention, and likewise resources
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Introduction Continued
- Many actions can be taken to protect the community from terrorist attacks
- Specific risk in each community
- Emergency manager must look at:
- What actions to take to address the consequences of terrorism
- How to mitigate terrorism or prevent an attack from happening
- Who is responsible
- What is needed to recover
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Differences Between Terrorism and Other Hazards
- Intent—perpetrators try to ensure they are as devastating as possible
- Criminality—adds a new dimension in that additional stakeholders involved
- Laws guiding terrorism prevention and response
- Others
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Changes in EM and
the War on Terror
- EM policy and strategy mirrors the policy agenda
- Efforts sometimes disproportionate to risk (e.g, risk of terrorism vs. risk of hurricane)
- EM focus in the war on terrorism can have many crossover benefits into natural and technological hazards management
- Interoperable communications, credentialing, standardization of incident management protocols, and others created in 9/11 aftermath all have extensive dual-use applications
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Change Continued
- War on terrorism = fundamental change in nationwide EM capacity
- Unprecedented funding resources
- Federal government recognized vital role of state and local first responders
- Creation of the DHS
- Consolidation of federal agencies
- PKEMRA corrected the changes
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
1st Responder Evaluation Cont’d
- Arlington Report
- Declared the response a success
- Showed that responders’ plans and skills worked
- Compiled notable facts about the response
- Contains 235 recommendations and lessons learned
- 2 categories of lessons learned:
- things that worked well and contributed to the overall success of the response
- challenges encountered and overcome by responders that could serve as examples for other jurisdictions in the future
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Terrorism Threat
- Terrorism is a global problem
- From 1969 to 2009, over 38,000 attacks worldwide
- 8% (3000) targeted Americans or American interests
- Almost 5,600 dead, 16,000 injured, billions in damage
- Hazard has existed for centuries
- Many definitions—must take a broad view
- “One man’s terrorist is another’s freedom fighter”
- Earliest recorded examples of organized terrorism launched by the Sicarii in the 1st century BC
- Boston Tea Party could be considered terrorism
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Domestic Terrorists
Groups labeled as domestic terrorist organizations have included:
- The Ku Klux Klan (KKK)
- Anarchists
- Unions
- The Black Panthers
- Weather Underground
- The Army of God
- Earth Liberation Front
- Others
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Lone-Wolf Terrorists
- George Matesky
- Radical leftists Sam Melville and Jane Alpert
- Muharem Kurbegovich
- Ted Kaczynski
- Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Categories of Terrorism
- Nationalist Terrorism
- Religious Terrorism
- State sponsored terrorism
- Left-Wing Terrorism
- Right-Wing Terrorism
- Anarchist Terrorism
- Single Interest Terrorism
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Watershed Terrorism Events
- 1993 World Trade Center Bombing
- Ramzi Yusef
- Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building
- Timothy McVeigh and Terry Nichols
- The Khobar Towers Bombing
- Kenya and Tanzania Embassy Bombings
- USS Cole Bombing
- The September 11th Attacks in New York, Virginia, and Pennsylvania
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
9/11 Attacks
- Required years of planning, many conspirators, and significant funding
- Teams boarded 4 commercial flights, overtook the flight crew, and crashed them into the World Trade Center Towers 1 and 2, the Pentagon, and into a field in Pennsylvania (thwarted attack)
- 2,974 deaths (343 firefighters, 75 police officers)
- 2,337 people were injured
- Catastrophic financial impacts
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
9/11 Attacks Continued
- 1993 WTC bombing credited with reducing the number of casualties
- Response unprecedented
- 55,494 individual victim cases
- 240,417 mental health contacts
- 133,035 health services contacts
- 60 shelters opened, with a population reaching over 3,500
- 101 mass care points of distribution opened
- Over 14 million meals served
- Almost 60,000 disaster workers
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Statutory Frameworks
- Statutory authority / legal frameworks guiding terrorism management a junction between EM and law enforcement evolution of emergency management statutory authority
- Prior to OK City, little crossover
- FEMA moved to DHS – mission shifted
- Today, EMs plan and train for terrorism response and recovery and mitigate risk as well
- DHS is the primary Federal agency responsible
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Early Legislation and Actions
- 1878 passage of the Posse Comitatus Act
- Office of Defense Mobilization
- White House Office of Emergency Preparedness
- 1974 Disaster Relief Act
- 1979 Reorganization Plan Number 3 – FEMA
- 1988 Robert T. Stafford Act
- Federal Response Plan (FRP)
- Public Law 103-160§1704
- Executive Order 12919
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
PDD 39
- First notable counterterrorism action impacting emergency management
- Stated the USG would use all appropriate means to deter, defeat, and respond to all terrorist attacks that occurred on US soil, or to US interests
- Gave DOJ authority to manage the crisis, while FEMA was given consequence management responsibilities
- FEMA chaired a Senior Interagency Group for Training and Preparedness for terrorism events
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
FRERP
- May 996
- Addressed radiological sabotage and terrorism
- Treated the response to events involving radioactive materials as the same whether intentional or accidental
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Nunn-Lugar-Domenici
- Prompted by OK City bombing and Tokyo Sarin gas attack
- Weapons of Mass Destruction focus
- Provided funding to prepare and equip first responders
- Little change in terms of how attacks were prevented and how terrorist organizations were disrupted occurred
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Terrorism Annex to the FRP
- Directly connected to the 1996 bombing at the Olympics in Atlanta, Georgia
- Prior to 1997, nothing dictated terrorism incident roles and responsibilities
- Criminal investigations element of attacks had previously caused several problems in terms of jurisdiction of the attack scene, and who had incident command authority
- Annex gave explicit lines of authority
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
The Three Commissions
- U.S. Commission on National Security/21st Century (USCNS/21) – the Hart-Rudman Commission
- Goal was to design a national security strategy.
- “Road Map for National Security: Imperative for Change”
- The Gilmore Commission
- Produced reports that presented a growing base of knowledge concerning the WMD risk
- The Bremer Commission
- Addressed international terrorism
- Evaluated laws, policies, and practices
- “Countering the Changing Threat of International Terrorism”
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
AG’s 5-Year Interagency Plan
- December 1998
- DOJ project to develop the Attorney General’s Five-Year Interagency Counterterrorism and Technology Crime Plan.
- FBI emerged as the principal counter-terror agency
- Congress intended the plan to serve as a baseline for the coordination of a national strategy and operational capabilities to combat terrorism
- This plan did remove barriers to interagency information sharing
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Stafford Amended
- February 2001—Preparedness Against Domestic Terrorism Act of 2001 passed
- Amended Stafford to include acts of terrorism within its definition of “major disaster”
- Formalized how the Federal disaster support in terrorism incidents would take place
- Authorized FEMA Director to carry out federal emergency preparedness plans and programs
- Established President’s Council on Domestic Preparedness
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
GAO Findings
- Review conducted in late 2000 and early 2001
- Tested whether the nation was prepared to manage the terror threat
- Findings showed it was not
- Report released in March of 2001—“Combating Terrorism: Comments on Counterterrorism Leadership and National Strategy”
- Early September 2001, the GAO released a second report titled “Combating Terrorism: Selected Challenges and Related Recommendations”
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
E.O. 13228
- After 9/11
- Established the Office of Homeland Security within the White House
- Also created the Homeland Security Council
- Tasked with developing and coordinating an effective strategy to prevent or respond to terrorist threats and attacks
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Patriot Act
- Passed with little deliberation, signed 10/26/01
- Granted exceptional powers to investigate suspected terrorism
- The most important provisions of this law are that:
- Promotes information sharing between LE and Intel
- Makes it illegal to knowingly harbor terrorists
- Increases wiretap powers
- Greater power to detain non-U.S. citizens
- Greatly increases US/Canada border protection
- Increases financial reporting requirements
- Increases or eliminates the statute of limitations on most terrorist attacks
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
HS Act of 2002
- To shore up weaknesses and ensure response and recovery connected with prevention/preparedness
- DHS established and given agency-level status
- Massive organizational change—involved over 230,000 federal employees in over 20 agencies
- Established the Homeland Security Council and the Office for State and Local Coordination and Preparedness
- Did not bring together the intelligence agencies
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
9/11 Commission
- Established November of 2002 to study 9/11 understand how and why they happened, and what needed to be done to prevent a future attack
- July 2004—9/11 Commission report released
- Findings included 37 recommendations in three subject areas:
- Attacking terrorists and their organizations
- Preventing the continued growth of Islamist terrorism
- Protecting and preparing for terrorist attacks.
- Congress responded by passing the Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
The Post-Katrina Emergency Management Reform Act
- Signed into law by President Bush 10/4/2006
- To correct the emergency management shortfalls highlighted in the response to Hurricane Katrina
- The Act:
- Established new leadership positions
- Created additional functions that were assumed by FEMA
- Created and reallocated functions to other components within DHS
- Amended the Homeland Security Act in ways that directly and indirectly affect the organization and functions of various entities within DHS
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
DHS
- Office of the Secretary of Homeland Security
- Includes:
- The Privacy Office, the Office of Civil Rights and Civil Liberties, and the Citizenship and Immigration Ombudsman Office
- The Office of the Inspector General
- The Office of Legislative Affairs
- Office of General Counsel
- The Office of Public Affairs
- The Office of Counternarcotics Enforcement
- The Office of Intergovernmental Affairs
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
DHS Advisory Panels/Committees
- The National Infrastructure Advisory Council
- The Homeland Security Science and Technology Advisory Committee
- The Critical Infrastructure Partnership Advisory Council
- The Interagency Coordinating Council on Emergency Preparedness and Individuals with Disabilities
- The Task Force on New Americans
- And The DHS Labor-Management Forum
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Pre-Existing Offices
- US Coast Guard
- US Secret Service
- FEMA
- Federal Law Enforcement Training Center
- Transportation Security Administration
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
New Offices/Directorates
- Directorate for National Protection and Programs
- Directorate for Science and Technology
- US Citizenship and Immigration Services
- US Customs and Border Protection
- Immigration and Customs Enforcement
- Office of Health Affairs
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Other Agencies Involved in HS
- White House
- Department of Agriculture
- Department of Commerce
- Environmental Protection Agency
- Department of Justice
- Department of State
- Department of Defense
- Department of Health and Human Services
- Department of the Treasury
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
Other HS Involvement
- State and Tribal Governments
- Local Governments
- The Private Sector
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.
©2014 Elsevier, Inc.