Discussion Health Promotion: Prevention of Disease W2
Chapter 3
Health Policy and the Delivery System
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA)
� New health care federal reform law signed in 2010 � Largest change in the financing of the American health
care system since Medicare and Medicaid (1965) � Focus on vulnerable populations: affordability,
accessibility, and financing of health care � Designed to reduce number of uninsured persons via
expanding Medicaid and establish subsidies � US Supreme Court upheld the ACA in June 2012 � Likely will change secondary to Trump presidency
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 2
Key Features of PPACA
� PPACA lacks bipartisan support � Change in political landscape may result in
repeal or significant changes � No exclusion for preexisting conditions � Health insurance is mandated for everyone � Marketplace exchange for insurance plans � All policies must cover essential benefits � Medicaid expanded; subsidies available
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 3
Measuring the Nation’s Health
� Health, United States report (annual) Ø Informs policymakers of trends in nation’s health
� Healthy People 2020 Ø 10-year agenda for improving nation’s health Ø Goal is to increase quality and years of healthy life,
and eliminate health disparities � Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) statistics
Ø Morbidity data Ø Compares United States with other countries
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 4
US Health Trends
� Successes in infection, other diseases � Concerns: sedentary lifestyle, obesity, chronic
illness � Health disparities persistent
Ø Contribute to unfavorable US health indicators Ø Compromise progress in world health
� Vulnerable populations due to age, education, language, location
� Rise in suicide and drug poisoning deaths esp involving opioid analgesics
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 5
Historical Role of Women
� Nurses have long tradition of health promotion � Nursing pioneers
Ø Florence Nightingale (Crimean War 1884)—crusaded for nutritious food, cleanliness, sanitation
Ø Lillian Wald (Henry St Settlement—NYC 1883) founded NYC visiting nurses association to provide health services for indigents in tenements
� Through the ensuing decades nurses developed unique role agents for health promotion
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 6
� US Health Care system undergoing changes Ø Sparked by health care reform politics Ø Large organizations involved in forming health policy
� Health and medicine division Ø Previously known as Institute of Medicine (IOM) Ø Research from a systems approach Ø Advisement on safe delivery of health care Ø Health care system (not practitioners) is basic cause
of medical errors
A Safer System
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 7
� Overriding objective is for all people (global) to attain highest possible health
� Current agenda—six goals Promoting development Enhancing partnerships Fostering health security Improving performance Strengthening health systems Harnessing research info
� Budget issues limit achievement of goals � Huge health disparities in developing nations
Global Health World Health Organization
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 8
� Earliest views were holistic, emerging from integrated worldview
� Hygiene incorporated into most religions � Primitive peoples had mystical view of sickness
and cure—tied to religion � During middle-ages widespread epidemic
diseases leading cause of death ( leprosy, plague, smallpox, TB)
Historical Influences Health Care
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 9
� Adequate food supply prolonged life span Ø Transportation enhanced food distribution Ø Technological advances improved food production
� Industrial advances prevented diseases Ø Flush toilet, sewer systems Ø Decrease in typhoid, paratyphoid, gastroenteritis
Historical Industrial Influences
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 10
� Elizabethan poor laws (1601) England Ø Relief for infants, sick, elderly, workhouse laborers
� New Law 1834—harsher philosophy Ø Pauperism in able-bodied workers viewed as moral
failing Ø Suspicious and punitive view of indigence
� Protestant work ethic (rewards work efforts) Ø Philosophy brought to United States by Puritans Ø Influences modern health care—fee-for-service
Historical Socioeconomic Influences
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 11
� Edwin Chadwick—father of public health � Disease viewed as impediment to ability to self-
support (Chadwick’s view) � Public health services and welfare combined
creating a more benevolent view of indigence � Puritan ethic in the United States offered a
harsher view toward indigence and health care � Health and welfare departments continue to
have contradictory approach to poor
Public Health Influences
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 12
� Prior to 20th century infectious diseases (ID) major cause of death
� Scientific advances → Improved health Ø Louis Pasteur—germ theory Ø Joseph Lister—antisepsis
� Innovations: safeguard water, food, and milk supply; sewage systems; urban housing regs
� Antibiotics (1936-1954) decrease in ID � ID death persists in vulnerable populations
Scientific Influences
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 13
Major milestones with effects on health care � New Deal (Great Depression) � Social Security Act 1935
Ø Grants-in-aid for state and local public health Ø Assistance programs: blind, elderly, disabled
� Medicare and Medicaid (1965) � Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act
(2010)
Political and Economic Influences
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 14
Preventative vs Curative Medicine
� Early prevention directed toward individuals Ø Originated in medical practice vs public health Ø Focus was on poor—state welfare programs
� Public health services eventually emerged Ø Focus on societal prevention vs individual cure Ø Immunizations, screenings, education Ø Education and career paths for pubic health vs medical
practitioners remained separate � 1960s emphasis shifted from individual to societal public
health goals � Evolution toward greater government in health care
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 15
Organization of Delivery System
� Huge system: public and private components � Multifaceted and complex interrelationships
Ø Providers and consumers Ø Varied settings: private and public services
� Public sector: nonprofit agencies, government agencies, organized at local, state, and national levels (US Department of Health and Human Services)
� Private sector: for profit services
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 16
Private Sector Independent Practice
� Independent practice—free-market system Ø Fee-for-service; hallmark is choice of provider Ø Managed care health organizations evolved Ø Prevention has gained importance
� Nurse-managed centers Ø Advanced Practice Nurse serve as primary care
providers Ø Multidisciplinary collaborative approach Ø Focus: vulnerable populations
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 17
Private Sector Managed Care
� Managed health care/health maintenance organizations (HMOs)—emerged 1990s Ø Groups of providers, contract with HMOs Ø Comprehensive care for prepaid fee Ø Motivation and goal is to control costs
� Managed care: key elements Ø Control costs, regulate health care utilization Ø PCP gatekeeper to system; coordinate care Ø Payment based on network status: in-network vs out
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 18
Private Sector Health Maintenance Organizations
� Capitation method of payment Ø Provider receives fixed payment per enrollee.
Provider provides all necessary care to enrollee � PCP is gatekeeper
Ø Specialist require referral Ø Members (patients) may have copays Ø Must use network providers
� Medicare Advantage plans are HMO alterative to traditional Medicare
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 19
Private Sector IPAs and ACOs
� Independent practice associations (IPAs) Ø Physician organizations Ø Care for HMO members in private office Ø Several models available
� Accountable Care Organization (ACOs) Ø Key component in Affordable Care Act Ø Not yet in place—Medicare reform Ø Structure will be similar to HMOs Ø Focus is cost-containment
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 20
Private Sector Concierge and Hospitalists
� Concierge medical practices Ø Membership fee for enhanced health care Ø Fewer patients—more time per patient Ø Focus: personalized, holistic care for higher income
individuals • Typical household income—$125,000-$250,000 • Typical patient—age 50 and older
� Hospitalist movement Ø Physicians or APNs who provide comprehensive
hospital care—improved quality and safety of care
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 21
Private Sector POS and HDHPs
� Point-of-service plans (POS) Ø Additional fee for providers outside of network Ø Increases consumer choice
� High Deductible Health Insurance Plans Ø High annual out-of-pocket deduction Ø Suitable for healthy persons—low monthly premium Ø Health Savings Account (HSAs)
• Employer contributions plus pretax deposits allowed • Withdrawals for health-related expenses • In-network providers offer enhanced savings
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 22
Private Sector PPOs
� Preferred Provider Organization—PPO � Key elements
Ø Contracted providers who will deliver member services at prenegotiated rate (discounted)
Ø Extra cost if non-PPO providers used Ø Copays by members required at time of visit Ø Preauthorization required for hospitalization or costly
tests and procedures Ø 52% of employer-sponsored plans are PPOs
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 23
Public Sector Power and Influence
� Source of power—shared federal/state Ø Federal: tax/spend general welfare Ø State: health authority based on 10th Amendment
� Influence of political philosophy Ø Each new administration since 1980s has introduced
new philosophy, bills, or components of health care Ø Most recent legislation: HIPAA (1996) Medicare
Prescription Drug Act (2003) Affordable Care Act (2010), Children’s Health Insurance Program (2015)
� National health care debate
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 24
Public Sector Current/Future Policy
� Current political issues re health care Ø Lack of political consensus—partisan discord Ø Major factors: cost, access, quality Ø Discordant partisan views concerning ACA
� Nurse’s role in health care reform Ø ANA: advocate for single-payer system Ø Focus on primary care, prevention Ø Push for nurses to function to full extent of education and
training—remove barriers Ø Nurses comprise largest segment of health care
workforce—3 million members
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 25
Official Health Care Agencies
Type of Agency
Key Characteristics
Local � Local health department � Direct services to public
State � State health department � Policy, planning, program coordination
Federal � Run by executive and legislative branches— determine health policy
� USHHS—administers policy
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 26
Official Health Care Agencies (Cont.)
Type of Agency/ Personnel
Key Characteristics
Chief Nursing Officer
� Serves in US Public Health Service � Works with US Surgeon General on nursing and public health policy
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA)
� Part of Department of Homeland Security � Disaster-related services � Assists individuals, communities, states
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 27
Official Health Care Agencies (Cont.)
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 28
Type of Agency/ Personnel
Key Characteristics
Military Health System
� Comprehensive medical care for active duty personnel, dependents, retirees � Responds to natural disasters and humanitarian crisis throughout the world � Veteran’s Administration: independent agency under President to provide for veteran care
Wounded warrior care
� Extensive care and rehabilitation to return severely injured soldiers to active duty or transition to VA health system
Health Care Legislation and Agencies
Legislation/ Agencies
Key Information
Americans with Disabilities
� Prohibit job discrimination and require services to people with disabilities
Patient Self- Determination Act
� Advanced directives for health care
Federal Health Information Privacy
� Safeguards security/confidentiality of health information
International- WHO
� Worldwide guidance in promoting world health through standards, programming, and collaboration
Voluntary (not-for- profit) Agencies
� Influence policy/legislation � Philanthropic (nongovernmental)
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 29
American Red Cross
� Volunteer-led humanitarian organization � Congressional charter—officially sanctioned but
no direct government supervision � 700 local chapters, 500,000 volunteers, 35,000
employees � Responds to both small local disasters (house
fire) and large natural disasters � Blood products, health education,
communication for servicemen/families
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 30
Financing Health Care
� Costs Ø Increasing due to multiple factors Ø Less time in system for health promotion
� Sources Ø Federal government (Medicare, Medicaid) Ø State funded programs—Medicaid, CHIP Ø Third-party payment (insurance) Ø Employer provided health plan benefits Ø Independent sources Ø Out-of-pocket: deductibles, copays, health savings accounts Ø Affordable care act subsidies
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 31
Mechanism for Financing
� Independent practice with fee-for-service—physicians, APNs, health care professionals
� Salaried providers—nurses, APNs, physicians Ø Overtime is uncompensated Ø Often leads to burnout from overwork
� Hourly compensation Ø Most hospital and outpatient staff Ø Workers eligible for overtime
� Capitation—flat fee regardless of services used Ø Encourages preventive care to keep people healthy Ø Some individuals make unnecessary visits Ø HMO sponsors and bears risk of illness
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 32
Cost Containment � Cost-containment initiatives
Ø Prospective payment system, limits on provider payments, Medicare Advantage (MA) plans
� Care management Ø Determines and coordinates care Ø Across continuum of health care services Ø Reduce waste, improve quality, control costs
� Managed care issues Ø Quality of care vs cost control Ø PCP as gatekeeper
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 33
Managed Care
� Care management: professional oversees care Ø Coordination of care Ø Insuring quality care Ø Cost containment
� Managed care issues Ø Renewed importance with Affordable Care Act Ø Cost containment Ø Provide high-quality optimum care
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 34
Health Insurance
� Private insurance Ø Traditional insurance companies (BC/BS) Ø PPOs—“brokers” between insurers/providers Ø HMOs—prepayment plans Ø POS—combination of HMOs and PPOs Ø Self-insurance/self-funded
� Public insurance/assistance Ø Medicare Ø Medicaid
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 35
Medicare
� Federal program � Paid through taxes � Finances medical care for:
Ø People over 65 Ø Disabled Ø People with end-stage renal disease Ø Hospice
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 36
Medicare (Cont.)
� Part A Ø Inpatient care in hospitals, skilled nursing facilities, home health
care, hospice � Part B
Ø Supplementary voluntary coverage Ø Pays doctor’s visits
� Part D Ø Pharmaceutical costs—multiple plans available
� Challenges Ø Growth in elderly population Ø Depletion of Medicare resources (trust fund) Ø Uncovered services (glasses, dental, hearing aids)
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 37
Medicaid
� Assistance program managed jointly by federal and state funds
� State-determined eligibility � Costs up to 50% of state budgets—open-ended
program � Benefits vary by state � Available to:
Ø Certain low-income individuals Ø No age requirements Ø Families with children: 5-year lifetime limit
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 38
The Uninsured
� Of all developed countries, the United States has the highest proportion of population with no health insurance
� 2008: 46 million uninsured younger than age 65 � Most uninsured individuals live in families in which there is at least
one full-time worker � Groups at most risk
Ø Persons of Mexican origin Ø Young adults Ø Working uninsured Ø Illegal aliens
� ACA expected to reduce uninsured numbers
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 39
Affordable Care Act and HIPPA
� The Affordable Care Act is expected to reduce the number of uninsured people by 60% Ø Expansion of Medicaid Ø Subsidies to pay health insurance premiums Ø Federal mandate requiring citizens to enroll in an
insurance plan—penalties for noncompliance Ø Provision allowing children to remain on employer family
insurance to age of 26 � Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act
(HIPAA) Ø Provisions for maintaining coverage if lose/leave job
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 40
Unauthorized Immigrants
� 11.3 million illegal aliens in United States (2014) Ø 50% from Mexico Ø Some illegal entry; others overstayed visa Ø Federal law mandates anyone entering ER must be
treated regardless of ability to pay � Illegal aliens are vulnerable population
Ø Indigent but not eligible for Medicare or Medicaid Ø Many do not seek care for fear of deportation
� Immigration reform highly contentious issue
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 41
Health Care in Other Countries
� Canadian health care system Ø Universal coverage; social insurance plan Ø Private plans available for unpaid services Ø Issues: two-tiered system, shortage of providers, delays in service
� German health care system Ø Nearly universal access (87%), but private insurance (10%) pays
providers better Ø Issues: two-tiered system, weakening public system, increased cost
� UK health care system Ø National health insurance—spends least on health care per capita
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 42
Nurse’s Role in Health Policy
� Advocate Ø Individual Ø Justice in health care system
� Participating in policy decision-making Ø Voting Ø Communicating with legislators Ø Running for political office Ø Lobbying though professional organizations
Copyright © 2018, Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved. 43