Assignment 83
1: Introducing Human Resource Management
Dr. Mirna Safi
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
iStock.com/Rawpixel
Introduction
Human Resource Management (HRM) is the term most widely used to describe the activities a business engages in to manage its relationship with employees.
Organizations choose between a range of policies and practices that can assist in achieving this objective, such as how to recruit and select employees and how to pay and reward them.
HR philosophy: The principles that guide how the organization leads, manages, involves, treats and views all its employees, so that it can successfully achieve its business strategy.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
2
Evolution of HRM as an organizational function
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
During the Industrial Revolution in England in the late 19th century, the working conditions of men, women and children were dreadful.
Some enlightened employers, often Quakers, who wanted to improve the working conditions of their employees, providing workplace and family amenities for workers such as lunch rooms, medical care, company magazines, and housing.
The changes during this period to working conditions were driven by not just a welfare agenda, but also a drive to improve productivity.
Industrial welfare
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
F.W. Taylor’s Scientific Management movement focused on developing a systematic approach to the design of jobs and to employment and pay systems.
Allied to these were tight control of workers.
Practices were often met with resistance from workers and their union representatives.
Scientific management
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
Elton Mayo and the ‘Hawthorne Effect’
Experiments in Illinois, USA highlighted an emphasis on personal development, a better understanding of group work and the importance of working conditions as a means of motivating employees, all areas that are covered by the work undertaken by today’s HR function.
Behavioural science
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
HRM today
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
The 1960s and 1970s saw the introduction of a large body of legislation which provided rights for employees.
The 1980s recession led to high unemployment levels and significant competition in the marketplace led to a focus on productivity and ‘excellence’ associated with leading-edge companies.
This led to a shift from traditional manufacturing industries to growth in the service sector and a move towards a 24/7 society and an introduction of non-standard working hours.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
HRM today
8
HRM today
It is important to understand the nature of the employment relationship that exists between employers and employees.
All employment relationships have to be regulated in some form or another so that each side understands its obligations.
Most analyses of the employment relationship focus on the concept of industrial relations.
Traditionally, most HR managers were essentially industrial relations managers where their main responsibility was to negotiate and interact with trade unions.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
HRM today
Decline in both trade union membership and perceived significance of trade unions in managing the employment relationship has meant that managers, acting on behalf of employers, now have a significant amount of control over this relationship.
The open door policy
For this approach to be effective, it is important that employees are seen as assets that can be developed and nurtured, rather than resources to be exploited, and that a partnership exists between management and employees.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
Barney’s VRIO model (1991) - an organization’s employees are its single most important strategic differentiator.
They are:
Valuable
Rare
Inimitable (not easily copied)
Organised
The focus on HR as a strategic contributor to the organization is increasing.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
HRM today
11
Strategic HRM
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
Strategic HRM
The integration between HRM and business strategy is believed to contribute to the effective management of human resources, to an improvement in organisational performance and finally to the success of a particular business .
When referring to strategic HRM we are referring to the linkage between human resource management policies and practices and the strategic objectives of the organization.
In differentiating between strategic HRM and HRM we see that strategic HRM takes a macro level approach within the context of organizational performance, whereas HRM operates at the micro level.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
13
HRM and the business context
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
Internal organizational environment
Organizations are effectively all distinctive. This distinctiveness is created by many different factors, including:
The size and structure of the organization
The sector the organization operates in
The length of time the organization has been operating
Workforce characteristics
The financial health of the organization
Established ‘custom and practice’
The organizational culture
The values and managerial ideology of the senior management team.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
External organizational environment
The external context presents further opportunities and constraints. It is comprised of many different factors, including:
Competition
Technological
Labour market
Legislation and regulation
Ethics.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
Features of HRM
Storey (1989) identified four features of HRM, which he believed differentiate HRM from traditional PM:
HRM is explicitly linked with corporate strategy.
HR focuses on commitment rather than compliance of employees.
Employee commitment is obtained through an integrated approach to HR policies in the areas of rewards, selection, training and appraisal.
HR is not just the domain of specialists in the HR function, rather that HRM is owned by line managers as a means of fostering integration.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
17
HRM policies and practices
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
HRM policies and practices
Given how organizational context will influence the strategic HR choices the business will make, there are many different types of HR policies and practices in which the organization can engage.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
19
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
20
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
Linking HR practices to organizational outcomes
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
Linking HR practices to organizational outcomes
HRM aims to enable everyone in the organization to contribute fully to meeting the organization’s strategic objectives.
The strategy will determine the development of a range of HR policies, setting out principles or guidelines for the various practices within HR.
Some policies will guide very tangible practices e.g. recruitment, pay
While others will guide more intangible practices e.g. motivation and engagement .
Each HR policy should guide a HR practice that creates an organisational behaviour that leads to a desired organizational outcome.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
23
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
24
Structure and role of the HR function
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
Structure and role of the HR function
How the HR function is configured often depends on the organization’s context, needs and preferences.
Specialist roles - often follow the lifecycle of the employee
Generalist roles - where an HR generalist works with a specific group of employees, for example production operators, and handles all the issues related to that group.
HR business partner is seen as a consultant to the organisation, working closely with line managers to ensure that HR practices enable the successful delivery of business strategy.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
26
Structure and role of the HR function
Ulrich et al. (2012) suggest that the following competencies needed are needed in the mix of the HRM function :
Credible activists - deliver promises, trusted by the business, and take action in a positive manner as and when needed by the business.
Capability builders - identify the core processes which will positively impact on the business strategy and then deliver the appropriate HR practices.
Change champions - enable the organisation to respond to the external pressures and pace of change.
Innovators and integrators – use evidence and business insights to continuously develop new HR practices.
Technology - have the skills to leverage available technologies and use HR analytics.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
27
The role of the line manager
The role of the line manager in feeding into the design of HR practices and their implementation and interpretation locally across the organization is critically important (Purcell et al., 2003).
Day-to-day HR practices need to be devolved to line managers in order to allow for faster decision-making that is more in tune with business needs.
The rationale is that the line manager is the person who works most closely with the employee (Whittaker and Marchington 2003, Trullen et al. 2016).
HR provide support and guidance to line managers in these activities which also allows HR the time to move towards aligning the people management agenda with the strategic goals of the organization.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
Theoretical basis of HRM
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
The Michigan model
The Michigan model of HRM stresses the importance of alignment or ‘fit’ between:
the HR strategy and the business strategy (vertical integration or external alignment).
the HR practices themselves (horizontal integration or internal alignment).
Fit can be achieved with a relatively straightforward suite of HR practices:
Selection of the most suitable individuals
Managing performance
Appraising performance and providing feedback
Providing rewards for appropriate performance
Developing employees to meet the needs of the business.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
30
‘Universal’ approach
The Harvard model recognizes the influence that various stakeholders and situational factors have on the development of HR policies and practices (Beer et al., 1984).
The model focusses specifically on how the development of HR practices, incorporating these stakeholder interests and situational factors, will lead to a change in organisational behaviours or the building of organisational capabilities, which in turn, lead to specific organisational outcomes.
The main contribution of this model was to highlight the potential benefits of adopting a ‘soft’ approach to HRM.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
31
The Guest model
David Guest (Guest, 1989) in the UK built upon this model to develop a theory of HRM founded on four key policy propositions that he proposed, if followed, will combine to increase organizational effectiveness.
Strategic integration
High commitment
Flexibility
High quality.
Best achieved through appropriate HRM practices in the areas of:
Change management
Organizational and job design
Recruitment and selection
Appraisal, training and development
HR movement through, up and out of the organization
Reward and communication systems.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
32
Strategic HRM contingency approach
Proponents of this view believe there is no universal answer to the choice of HRM polices and practices. The choice is contingent on the context of the organisation and its business strategy (external fit).
Each organisation can choose a different set of polices and practices, depending on their organisational specific context and strategy.
The adoption of a contingency HRM strategy is then associated with optimised organisational performance, where the effectiveness of individual HR practices is contingent on firm specific strategy.
The most effective way to manage people will depend on issues specific to the organisation, such as industry sector, organisational size and economic conditions.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
33
Strategic HRM universalist approach
Focuses on the existence of one set of HRM ‘best practices’ aimed at creating and enhancing high levels of employee commitment and performance.
These will result in superior levels of organizational performance, regardless of the context in which the organisation operates and the competitive strategy of the firm.
Pfeffer’s (1998) work identified seven practices which result in higher performance:
Recruiting the right people
High wages clearly linked to organisational performance
Employment security
Information sharing
Investment in training and skill development
Self managed teams and decentralised decision making
Reduced status differentials.
© Ronan Carbery & Christine Cross, Human Resource Management, 2nd edition, 2019
34