Screening and Interviewing external candidates
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
INTERVIEWING JOB APPLICANTS
THE #1 WAY WE CHOOSE PEOPLE TO HIRE
Richard J. Wagner, PhD
Capella University
Updated: February 5, 2016
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
*
WHY WE INTERVIEW PEOPLE
We can judge interpersonal skills.
We believe we are a good judge of people.
It is easy if we do not do it right.
Fit is judged by an interview.
It has always been done this way.
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
*
DO INTERVIEWS WORK?
Validity is often dismal (r = .10 or so).
Reliability across interviews is often very low.
Often no objective measure to assess candidates.
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
*
HOW WE CAN IMPROVE INTERVIEWS
Train the interviewers.
Use a more structured interview.
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
*
TYPES OF INTERVIEWS
Unstructured.
Typical interview.
- No pre-set issues or questions: “Tell me about yourself.”
Structured.
Very reliable and valid.
- All questions are written beforehand.
- Same for all applicants.
- No real interaction.
Semi-structured.
Generally good validity.
- Follows pre-set areas such as education and experience
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
*
BEHAVIORAL INTERVIEWS
Stresses behavior.
Focus on past behaviors .
- (Best predictor of future behavior is past behavior).
Stresses situations.
Based on hypothetical statements of situations you may never encounter.
- (Tell the old fool what he or she wants to hear.)
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
*
OPEN- OR CLOSED-ENDED QUESTIONS
Open-ended:
“Why did you choose accounting for your major?”
- Opportunity to explain or expand on answers.
Closed-ended:
“When did you graduate from college?”
- No chance to explain or expand on answers.
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
*
OTHER TYPES OF INTERVIEWS
Stress interviews.
Group/panel interviews.
Multiple interviews.
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
*
INTERVIEWING BIAS
First impression.
Similar to me.
Halo/horn effect.
General interviewer bias.
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
*
HOW TO CONDUCT A BAD INTERVIEW
Do not prepare in advance.
Do not ask job-related questions.
Talk too much.
Be distracted during the interview.
Arrive late.
Do not listen to the candidate.
© 2013 CAPELLA UNIVERSITY
*
The end